High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22104/2022disposed of

Kunal Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-01-05Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra8 pages

$!%&'&"(

*+ +,

-.(/ -.01 " 2!1'

+++++++ ! & &"(!1'

3!1'.'

4 !

" 2!1'

++++++++ !'6"($!( '

-1&'2

.1& " 2!1'

+++++++ ! & &"(!1'

3!1'.'

4 !

" 2!1'

++++++++ !'6"($!( '

) 7 8 + 4 4 4

7 8 + 4 88

1!'!( ) 1+ 4.(&/ 2$2 4!(&"1 $9"% !

:& 2

1+ ;'25 2$2 $9"% !

+ 1+ 9&($!1 4&(<2 ($2:

$9"% !

+ '+ (&'2 !'2:1&

15(+ 1+ '2";

<<1:/ 4!(&"1 $9"% !

:& 2

1+ .;./ <<1:/ 1+ 1& / $9"% !'

*+ 4 4 + '2// $&'6"'!

=" 2 ="9!

6! & &"('

&''.!'

1&'!$ 2!1!&( 1!

'0!+ "1 %"(9!(&!(%!

#% '

=!&(< 1!#!11!$ #1"0 +

7##"1$=/!

1".6 ".'&(< 1">!% 7 #/" !$ (0!

2&1 "0!'

'& . !$ 4!% "1 ?, 4!% "1 @* 9&//<!

2106.1 .1.<10+

2!5 #&/!$ 615&(< A.'2&(< ?+B+

((!C.1!

D 2!

&1!% "1E+

6.16"1 !$/5

((!C.1!

1!A.!'

? //":

1&'&(< "1&<&(/ 1!'6!% 1!$5 /.(%2!$ %%!6 !$ '.=>!% #./#&/0!( %!1 &( %"($& &"('+

&1!% &"('

'".<2 , 2!

"##&%&/ ;!

"9!1 '& . !$ 4!% "1 ?, 4!% "1 @* .1.<10 %%".( #&/.1!

$!9!/"6 ' 1 $!'6& !

29&(< 1!%!&9!$ 0"1!

2( * %!( 650!( +

%'!

2!5

/1!$5 6&$ 0"1!

2( * %!( ='&% '/!

61&%!

1!'6!% &9!

.(& '+

!'6& !

29&(< 1!%!&9!$ 0".( #&/!$ ' 1 $!9!/"6&(< 61">!% + !( &1!

61">!% /5&(< =11!( !C%!6 ='!0!( #&1'

#/""1 "(!

":!1+ '

1!6"1 4!(&"1 /((!1 "9!1// // =! :!!( * %!( 2".<2 '+

%1"1!'

%"//!% !$ #1"0 6! & &"(!1'+

='&'

91&".'

%"06/&( '

9&$!

+*+

((!C.1!

%(%!//!$ /&%!(%!'

<1( !$ 2!0 %%".( <19!

9&"/ &"('

&(%/.$&(< '.=0& &(< #"1<!$ #=1&% !$ =(;

<.1( !!'

#"1<!$ '&<( .1!'

=(;

"##&%&/'"##&%!1'

=(;

<.1( !!'+

$!%&$!$ =/%;/&'

$!9!/"6!1 %"06(&!'1!'6"($!( '

* & '

$&1!% "1'

'21!2"/$!1'

" 2!1 . 2"1&F!$ '&<( "1&!'

#1"0 <1( &(<

, (!:

/&%!(%!

!9!/"60!( !<./ &"( 1=( 1!'

'2"1 7 2!

% 7+

((!C.1!

? 1!'6"($!( ,4!(&"1 /((!1

!61 0!( .1.<10 &''.!$ &(' 1.% &"('

1!' 1&(&(< * #1"0 %"//!% &(< &(' //0!( '

%21<&(< &( !1!'

6!(/ 5 =/(%!

&(' //0!( '

#1"0 '& . !$ 4!% "1 ?, 4!% "1 @* 4!% "1 , 4!% "1 .1.<10+ !'6"($!( '

* :!1!

1!' 1&(!$ #1"0 %(%!//&(< .(& &// 61">!% %"06/! !$ /&(;!$ 6"/&%5+

!'6"($!( '

* #&/!$ 66/&% &"( 1!9&!:

+*+

((!C.1!

66/&% &"(

&1!% "11!'6"($!( :2!1!=5 :& 2$1!:

+*+

'.=>!% #"//":&(< %"($& &"('

! "

! &

'() !10'

((!C.1!

1!'6"($!( '.=0& !$ .($!1 ;&(< '2// #"//":

/&(;!$ A.!' &"( '2// $$& &"(/ &(' //0!( &// 61"6"1 &"( !

/1!$5 1!%!&9!$ 0$!+

#.1 2!1 .($!1 "";

%(%!// &"( //" 0!( '2// 0$!

&# %(%!// &"(

0$!

'2//

:& 2$1:(+

2!1!# !1 1!'6"($!( ?+B+

&''.!$ @+B+

((!C.1!

//":&(< 1!A.!'

1&'!

"1&<&(/ 1!$5 /.(%2!$ &+!+ 8@B 8, *@ 8,

8 '.=>!% #"//":&(< %"($& &"('

"*& +

"*& ) &06.<(!$+ %2//!(<!

61&01&/5 <1".($ :2&/!

6''&(< ?+B+

1!9&!:!$ ++

:& 2".

<1( &(<

6! & &"(!1'+ 4.%2 0($ !$ %/.'!

% 61"9&'"

$!/'

:& 2 6":!1 1!9&!:

1!$'

,# '

# -.

/ '

0 - .

0 -.

) '

%/.'!

% 61"9&'"

'2// 0"$&#&!$ 1!9!1'!$ "1 %"(#&10!$ .(/!''

61 &!'

%"(%!1(!$ ##"1$!$ 1!'"(=/!

=!&(< 2!1$+

%"( !($!$ 9&$!

$&1!% !$ '2// #"//":

/&(;!$ '2// $$& &"(/ &(' //0!( &// 61"6"1 &"(/ %"(' 1.% &"('

650!( '

1!%!&9!$ %"06/! !$+

&06.<(!$ //":!$ 1&'!

"1&<&(/ 6/(+

61!>.$&%&/ &( !1!'

//" !!'+

6!1'"('

%"(%!1(!$ :& 2&( 0!(&(< %/.'!

% 61"9&'"

:!1!

1!A.&1!$ 2!1$ =!#"1!

6''&(< '.%2 "1$!1+

29&(< <1( !$ 61"9&'&"('

2.'

.('.' &(=/!+ 2!( %'!

%0!

.6 @++ 42+ '2";

<<1:/ 8$+ 4!(&"1 ".('!/ 1&'!$

61!/&0&(15

"=>!% &"( 1!<1$&(< 0&( &(=&/& 5 6! & &"(+ %"( !($!$ &06.<(!$

1!0!$5 66!/

%'!

2!1!# !1 $>".1(!$ 2!1 61 &!'

A.!' &"( 0&( &(=&/& 5 9&!:

? / !1( &9!

' . "15 1!0!$5 61"9&$!$

1+ 2$2 1+ ($2:

66!1&(< 1!'6!% &9!

%'!'

:2&/!

$!(5&(< &06.<(!$ 66!/=/!

%"( !($!$ "(7=/!

4.61!0!

".1 %"('&' !( /5 2!/$ (" :& 2' ($&(< 9&/=&/& 5 / !1( &9!

1!0!$5 &<2 ".1 05 !C!1%&'!

& '

:1& >.1&'$&% &"(

/!'

21!!

%"( &(<!(%&!'

&+!+

& :2!1!

!(#"1%!0!(

.($0!( / &<2 '

'".<2

&& :2!1!

2!1!

9&"/ &"( 61&(%&6/!'

( .1/ >.' &%!

&&& :2!1!

:& 2".

>.1&'$&% &"(+ &06.<(!$ $0& !$/5 29&(< :& 2".

<1( &(< %/!1/5 0($ !$ 1"9&'"

61!'!( 0&( &(=/!

".<2 !( !1 &(!$+

2!5 1!#!11!$ 91&".'

$!%&'&"('

"(7=/!

4.61!0!

".1 + 1+ <<1:/ " 2!1 2($ %"( !($!$ #&1'

6/%!

&06.<(!$ %( !10!$

!9&!:

++ !C!1%&'!

6":!1'

!9&!:

1!#!11!$ '.='!% &"(

, , &('!1 !$

.($!1) -&$./

) !

1<.!$ ' !$

&06.<(!$

& '!/# ++ !C!1%&'!

6":!1'

'.='!% &"(

:!1!

1!A.&1!$ <&9!( =!#"1!

6''&(< "1$!1+

"1!"9!1 66/&% &"( 2!(%!

2!5 :!1!

&( !1!' !$ 61 &!'+

.1 2!1

$&1!% &(< #"//":

/&(;!$ &<("1(%!

#% ./ 6"'& &"( A.!' &"( /.(%2!$ 7##"1$=/!

1".6 ".'&(< "/&%5 ,7 (" &#&!$ 61"9&'&"('

6"/&%5 $"!'

!(9&'<!

/&(;!$ 6/(+

'%2!$./!

61"9&$!$ 6"/&%5+ "6!(

%2(<!

'0!+

3&$!

&06.<(!$

"(/5 %"11!% !$ 66!1'

:& 2".

;&(< &( "

%"('&$!1 &"(

' . "15 6"/&%5+ !

' 1!''!$

66/&% &"(

2!(%!

2!1!

1!A.&1!0!( 2!1 =!#"1!

0"$&#5&(< "(/5 %"11!% !11"1 %1!6 + %'!

66!/=/!

0&( &(=/!+ 1!/!< !$ 9&/ ' . "15 1!0!$5+

/1<!

(.0=!1 $!%&'&"('

"(7=/!

4.61!0!

".1 &<2 ".1 '

1!#!11!$ "+ '+ !'2:1& /!1(!$

&(' 1.% &"('

' !'

1!61!'!( &"( ,+@+ #&/!$ "(!

6!($&(< =!#"1!

15(+

:"./$ %"('&$!1 '&$ 1!61!'!( &"( " 2!1 1!61!'!( &"( 05 #&/!

6''

"1$!1'

2!1!"(+

(5 2"'!

1!61!'!( &"('

:&//

B "1$!1'+

9&!:

#"1!'&$ ' !0!( '+ !'2:1& :!

(!!$ <"

&( "

%"( !( &"('

1&'!$ 8$+ ".('!/+

%%"1$&(</5 $&'6"'!$ <&9&(< /&=!1 5 #&/!

661"61& !

1!61!'!( &"( =!#"1!

?+B++

:"./$ %"('&$!1 '.%2 1!61!'!( &"( 1!61!'!( &"( ,+@+ 6''

661"61& !

"1$!1'

2!1!"( !C6!$& &".'/5+

1!61!'!( &"( :"./$ "6!( '!!;

&( !1&0 $&1!% &"('

6!($&(< #&(/ $&'6"'/ 1!61!'!( &"('+ '0!

:"./$ %"('&$!1!$

& '

":( 0!1& '+

0;!

%/!1 :!

!C61!''!$ "6&(&"( 1!<1$&(< %/&0 61 &!'+

4 4

* ++,

'>;'

2! 2!1 '6!;&(<1!'"(!$

2! 2!1 1!6"1 =/!