High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5878/2015dismissed

The New India Assurance Co Ltd v. Madhu Bala & ORS

2015-12-08Mr. Justice Satpal8 pages

!" #"$%&%'( "$")*"+ ,

-"".'#% &&/+ '$")0 '12!# 00"33 '!

4"+&/& #-/ 3 '#!-"+& "&0'#"'!&

! +"&"'!( +555%#-/,#6$ !"

+!-" 00"33 '! ! "

'&! '! 00" 3 - & *""' %3"# *1 -" ". '#% &&/+ '$" )0 '1 2%)%!"# %)0/8'%'8 . +# # !"# 9

0 &&"#*1!-"3" +'"#!+$$%#"'!3 %)&+%*/' 3,:/+/;&-"!+ -"+"%'

!"++"

"++"#! &!-"<+%*/' 3<.-"+"*1$)0"'& !%'! !-"!/'" , ,= >?- &*""' . +#"#!+"&0'#"'!&!@ ' $$/'! #" !- 5%+%- '#

+%"

$!&, &#"! %3"#%'!-"$3 %)0"!%!%', +"!- !5%+% - '#&%'$"#"$" &"#. &.+;%'8.%!- +1 ' #. 1&" . &"'8 8"#%'+"0 %+.+; !-" +1 ' #. 1&*/&?

=?=99 '

%' !-" +1 ' #. 1& A+;&-0, "-. 3'8.%!-

3. '! 5%'8- '# + - )0 3 ! */! =

0), !-"+ )"$- '%$& ."'! !*+%'8 &0 +" 0 +!& +) !-" &!+", .-"+" &5%+%- '#+") %'"#"'8 8"#%'!-".+;*"%'8#'"*1 -%)/'#"+!-"*/&"&0'#"'!B )%. &%' + &- '#'"83%8"'! ) ''"+.%!-/!"C"+$%&%'8#/"$ +" '#$ /!%'&! +!"#!-"*/&5%+% - '#,.-. &&!%33"'8 8"#%'-%&.+;/'#"+!-"*/&+"$"%6"#

! 3%'D/+%"& '##%"#'!-"&0!

@# !"#

/'#"+5"$!%'&

9 '#E @. &+"8%&!"+"# !3%$"5! !%'

"-. &!)+!")"C )%' !%'+"0+!,C? ,0+6"#!- !-" #%"##/"!!-"%'D/+%"&&/

"+"#%'!-" $$%#"'! 3 %) '!&%".%#. '#!-+""$-%3#+"' !-"#"$" &"# 0+"

"++"# $3 %) 0"!%!%'/'#"+5"$!%'&== '#@ >@ !-"

!+4"-%$3"&$!,9 +8+ '! $)0"'& !%'!!-"!/'"

3 ;-& "$" &"#. &$3 %)"#!*"@ 1" +&3#,")031"# & 0&!"+.%!- +1 ' #. 1&" +'%'8 ,

>?0"+)'!-"

. &!-"&3"*+" #" +'"+ !-" )%31 3 %) . & $'!"&!"# *1 !-" +"&0'#"'!& '&/+ '$" $)0 '1, !; 03" !- ! 0 +! +)!-" $$%#"'!- 6%'8 $$/++"##/"!+ &- '#'"83%8"'! $! !-"#"$" &"#-%)&"3 , $$%#"'!!;03 $"%' .+;&-0,.-%$-%&'! 0/*3%$03 $" )%31 #%# '! &/

"+ '1 %' '$% 3 3&&, !-"+"

+", $3 %) 0"!%!%' *"

#%&)%&&"# 33.%'8%&&/"&."+" + )"#*1!-"3" +'"#+%*/' 3(?

A-"!-"+!-")!+6"-%$3" $$%#"'!# !"#

%& '/!$)" + &- '#'"83%8"'!#+%6%'8 /&

*" +%'8+"8%&!+ !%'=?=99*1 )%. & &%'$"#"$" &"#,+"&0'#"'!F

A-"!-"+!-"+"&0'#"'!?#+%6"+ +"& %#6"-%$3". & '!- 6%'86 3%##+%6%'83%$"'$" !!-"!%)" 33"8"# $$%#"'!F E A-"!-"+!-"0"!%!%'"+& +""'!%!3"#!$)0"'& !%'' $$/'! #" !- 5%+% - '#, %' !-" +"& %# $$%#"'!, &,%'.- ! )/'! '# +).-)F @ "3%"

2" +'"# +%*/' 3 ' $'&%#"+ !%'

$!& '# $%+$/)&! '$"&$'$3/#"#!- !5%+%- '##%"##/"!%'D/+%"&&/

"+"# *1-%)%'!-" $$%#"'!$ /&"##/"!+ &- '#'"83%8"'! $!'!-" 0 +! #+%6"+ !-"

"'#%'8*/& ! 3&/) , ,= >?. & . +#"#*1!-"3" +'"# +%*/' 3 &#"! %3"#*"3.(?

2&& #"0"'#"'$1 , E,= >?

2&& $'&+!%/) ,

2&& &! !"

2&& 36" '#

"$!%'G,

>?" $- !!-+""$-%3#+"' E,

/'"+ 3$- +8"& ,

! 3 , ,= >?

##%!%'. &

+#"#' $$/'! 3&& /!/+"

0+&0"$!&;""0%'8%'6%".!-" $!!- !!-"#"$" &"#5%+%- '#. & @ 1" +&3# !!-"!%)" -%&#" !- '#!-" )%31./3#*""'!%!3"# !+"$"%6" /33& 3 +1 + 0"+%# 1" +&%"!%33!-"#"$" &"# ./3#- 6" !! %'"#!-" 8" % -"- #*""' 3%6"!%' 3 8"

@ !-"#"$" &"#. &.+;"#/! & '#)/3!%03%"+ 9. &, $$+#%'831, 003%"#-"+"%&'#%&0/!"+"8 +#%'8!-"3 &!#+ .' & 3 +1 !-"#"$" &"#%" @,

>?'6%". !-"#"0"'# '!& *"%'8 /+%''/)*"+,#"#/$!%' >@!-. & 003%"#;""0%'8%'6%".

!-"*&"+6 !%' !-"'<*3"5/0+")"/+!%'

9E%6%3

'# ''/ 3#"0"'# '$1. &.+;"#/! & , E, E >?2&& #"0"'# '$1. &.+;"#/! & , E,= >?

.-%3" 0031%'8)/3!%03%"+ 9 2" +'"#$/'&"3 +!-" 00"33 '!6"-")"'!31 +8/"&!- !

!-" %'&/+ '$" $)0 '1 $ ''! *" -"3# 3% *3" & !-" $$%#"'! %' H/"&!%'!;03 $"%' .+;&-0 +1 ' #. 1&.-%$-%& '! 0/*3%$03 $"4"-%$3"%'H/"&!%'. &%'!-".+;&-0 +!-"

0/+0&"& +"0 %+!. &'!+ #.+!-1/+!-"+)+",#"$" &"# $ ''!*"!+" !"#!*"!-%+#0 +!1"%& '")031""'!$6"+"# /'#"+ !-" %'&/+ '$"03%$1-"+"

+", %'&/+ '$" $)0 '1 %& '!

3% *3"!0 1$)0"'& !%'%' '1) ''"+ - 6" -" +# 3" +'"# $/'&"3 + !-" 00"33 '! '# 0"+/&"#!-" %3" ! - & *""' &0"$% %$ 331 '# +%8-!31 $'$3/#"# *1 !-" +%*/' 3!- !)"$- '%$ 3 %3/+" !-"*/&%'H/"&!%'%&'! 33"8"# '"%!-"+0+6"#-"+"$ '*"'#/*! */!!-"+ &- '#'"83%8"'! $!'!-"0 +! !-"#+%6"+ !-"

"'#%'86"-%$3",.-.%!-/!

"C"+$%&%'8#/"$ +" '#$ /!%'! %'#/!.-"!-"+ '1)"$- '%$ . &&!%330+"&"'!/'#"+!-"*#1 !-"*/&!-/8-!%! %!!#+%6"

3 $" $$%#"'!%& #)%!!"#31 .+;&-0 +1 '

#. 1& ."6"+, ! -3# !- ! %'&/+ '$" $)0 '1 %& ! *" *&36"# %!&3% *%3%!1'!-%&8+/'#%&'!D/&!% %"#!%&'!!- !!-"

$$"&&!!-"0+")%&"&. &!! 331* ''"#+6%&%'& 5"$!%'@

* !-"$!$ ''!*"+" #! *&36"!-"%'&/+ '$"$)0 '1

%!&3% *%3%!1 /33 "'$- )* 1%8-/+!%'

"#$$%&'( ! $)*.-%3"+"

"++%'8 !#"

%'%!%' <0/*3%$03 $"</'#"+!-"$!- &-"3# &/'#"+(? I -" #"

%'%!%' I0/*3%$ 03 $"J /'#"+ !-"$! %&, !-"+"

+", .%#" "'/8- ! %'$3/#" '1 03 $" .-%$- )")*"+& 0/*3%$/&" '#!.-%$-!-"1- 6" +%8-!

$$"&&-"+%8-! $$"&&) 1*"0"+)%&&%6",3%)%!"#, +"&!+%$!"#++"8/3 !"#*1+ 3+.+%!!"'0"+)%&&%',*1 !%$;"!&,0 &&"&+* #8"&+'0 1)"'! ""-"/&"

) 1*"+"&!+%$!"#8"'"+ 331+!0 +!%$/3 +0/+0&"+ 0/+0&"&A- !%&'"$"&& +1%&!- !!-"03 $")/&!*" $$"&&%*3"!!-")")*"+& 0/*3%$ '#*" 6 %3 *3" + !-"%+/&","'D1)"'!, 6$ !%'!-"+0/+0&" !%& 3&'"$"&& +1!*" +%')%'#!-"#%&!%'$!%' *"!.""'!-""C0+"&&%'I+%8-! $$"&&J '#I $$"&& & +%8-!J-"3 !!"+"C0+"&&%'#"'!"& 03 $".-"+"!-" )")*"+& 0/*3%$- 6" +%8-! %!&/&" &)")*"+&

0/*3%$ '# & ) !!"+ +%8-!, .-"!-"+ +"8/3 !"#, +"&!+%$!"#+'!-"1$ ''!,-."6"+,*"#"'%"#!-" & %#+%8-!"C$"0!'3"8 38+/'#&'!-"!-"+- '#, .-"+"!-"+"%&'31 +%8-! $$"&&,!-".'"+ !-"

03 $",% -"- 00"'&!*" 0+%6 !".'"+,) 1#"'1!-" $$"&&! '1)")*"+ !-"0/*3%$' '18+/'#.-%$- -"$-&"&'!-"+.+#&%'!-" +)"+$ &"!-"+%8-!

!-")")*"+& !-"0/*3%$!/&"!-"03 $"%&+"&!+%$!"#

= $)0 +"#! !-"%+ +%8-!!/&" %'!-"3 !!"+$ &"-" #"

%'%!%' /'#"+ !-" $! /&"& !-" "C0+"&&%' I+%8-!

$$"&&J & 0%'!"# /! " +3%"+ A- ! %&, !-"+" +", &%8'% %$ '!!'!"%&!- !/'#"+!-"0+"&"'!#"

%'%!%'"6"'

03 $"!-"+%8-!!/&" .-%$-%&+"&!+%$!"#%& 0/*3%$ 03 $"'$"!-%&%&*+'"%')%'#)/$- !-"$'!+6"+&1 + %&"# *"

+" /& +/'# !-" $++"$! )" '%'8 !-"

"C0+"&&%'I0/*3%$03 $"J3&"&%!&"#8" CCC CCC CCC -"3"8%&3 !/+". &$'$"+'"#'!&)/$-.%!-!-" ' !/+" !-"03 $".-"+"!-"6"-%$3"$ /&"&!-" $$%#"'! &.-"+"%!. &3%;"31!#&"'$" 3303 $"&.-"+" !-")")*"+& 0/*3%$ '#>+!-"%+0+0"+!1 +"3%;"31! $)"%'$'! $!.%!-!-"6"-%$3"&$ '3"8%!%) !"31*"& %# !*"%'%!&6%"..-"'!-"3"8%&3 !/+") #"!-"+"3"6 '! 0+6%&%'& + $)0/3&+1 %'&/+ '$" ! .%33 - 6", !-"+"

+",!*"-"3#!- ! 3303 $"&.-"+"!-")")*"+&

0/*3%$- 6" ' $$"&&, +.- !"6"++" &'&,.-"!-"+ & +%8-!+$'!+33"#%' '1) ''"+.- !&"6"+,./3#*" $6"+"#*1!-"#"

%'%!%' I0/*3%$03 $"J%'5"$!%'

@ !-"$!-3#!-"+.%&"./3# +/&!+ !"!-"6"+1 *D"$! !-"& %#- 0!"+ '#!-"$!J '!-" *6"& %#$ &", $$%#"'!%'H/"&!%'- #! ;"' 03 $".%!-%'!-"$)0/'# $!+1'&/+ '$"$)0 '1. &-"3# 3% *3"!0 1$)0"'& !%' /33 "'$- #+ & %8- /+! %' +

"###,"-./- & 3&"C0+"&&"#&%)%3 +6%".& -"+"

+",%'&/+ '$"$)0 '1$ ''!*" *&36"#'!-" *6"& %#8+/'#

5%)%3 +31 3% *%3%!1 *1 !-" %'&/+ '$" $)0 '1 $ ''! *" #"'%"# &%)031 *1 6%+!/" !-" #"$" &"# *"%'8 ' ")031""

+1 ' #. 1& ! %& %'$++"$! ! &/88"&! !- ! !-" 03%$1 %' H/"&!%'./3#$6"+'31!- !")031"",.-%&'#/$!+, +%6"++ %$;"! C )%'"+ !-" 6"-%$3" '##"$" &"# *"%'8''" !-"

*6",%'&/+ '$"$)0 '1$ ''!*"& ##3"#.%!-+"&0'&%*%3%!15%+% - '#. &/'#/*!"#31 '")031"" +1 ' #. 1&*/!-"

. &.+;%'8 +)/'#"+!-"*/&%'H/"&!%''&/$- &%!/ !%', 00"33 '!$ ''!"&$ 0"3% *%3%!1*1 +8/%'8!- !!-"#"$" &"#*"%'8 ' ")031"" +1 ' 6"+')"'! %& '! $6"+"# /'#"+ !-" %'&/+ '$"03%$1

"$%&%'# !"#

E !-"'<*3"5/0+")"/+!

%' 0!

%' %6%3 00" 3 @

E %& '!

003%$ *3"!!-" $!& '#$%+$/)&! '$"& !-"0+"&"'!$ &"'

#$#%&'#(%$ &"&/0+ ,%'&/+ '$"$)0 '1. &'!-"3#3% *3"

+#" !- !-"0"+&'")031"#*1!-"6"-%$3"<&.'"+ & :- 3 &% !-" 6"-%$3" "$" &"# %' !-" & %# $ &" . & -"3# '! ! *" 0 &&"'8"+'!-"

"'#%'86"-%$3" '# /+!-"+)+"%!. &*&"+6"# !- !!-"+". &'!-%'8'+"$+#!&-.!- ! '1 ##%!%' 30+")%/) . &0 %#!$6"+!-"+%&; !-"%'D/+1!;- 3 &%>$'!+ $!+& $!& !-" 0+"&"'! $ &" +" #%

"+"'! '# #%&!%'8/%&- *3"%' &)/$- &!-"#"$" &"#!-/8- '")031""

+1 ' #. 1& . & "'8 8"# %' !-" +"0 %+ !-"

"'#%'8 6"-%$3"!%&#/"!+ &- '#'"83%8"'! $!'!-"0 +! */&#+%6"+ !- ! $$%#"'!. &$ /&"##/"!.-%$-#"$" &"#3&!-%&3% "2% *%3%!1

!-" 00"33 '! $)0 '1 - & *""' +%8-!31 %C"# *1 !-" 3" +'"# +%*/' 3 H/ 331/' $$"0! *3"%&!-"$'!"'!%'!- !H/ '!/)

$)0"'& !%' . +#"# *1 !-" 3" +'"# +%*/' 3 %& 3% *3" ! *" +"#/$"#%' &)/$- &$)0"'& !%' . +#"#!)%'+$-%3#+"'%& "C$"&&%6"+!- !3" +'"#+%*/' 3. &*/'#! . +#!-" )/'! & &&"&&"#*1!-"'<*3"5/0+")"/+!%'!-"$ &" 0

EE%6%3

'#'! 2

5 @ = "+"31 *"$ /&" !-" +%*/' 3 - & %+&! +"

"++"# ! #"$%&%' 0 &/0+ ,%!$ ''!*"-"3#!- !+%*/' 3. &* ++"#

+) . +#%'8 $)0"'& !%' %' !"+)& 2

3 $ &"

&/0+ ! %& !-" #/!1 !-" +%*/' 3& '# /+!& ! "'&/+" #%&0"'& !%' D/&! '#0+0"+$)0"'& !%' !-"+0%'!- &*""' +8/"# '!-" $!/ 3) !+%C & *6",3" +'"#$/'&"3 +!-"

00"33 '! %& /' *3" ! 0%'! /! '1 %33"8 3%!1 + %' %+)%!1 %' !-"

%)0/8'"# . +# # !"#9

,.-%$-$ 33& +%'!"+ "+"'$"*1 !-%&/+! !!-"%'&! '$" !-" 00"33 !")0 '1 '&"H/"'!31,!-%& 00" 3%&#%&)%&&"# )%#!)**

"$")*"+ ,

+,-.

+!&