← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5532/2018dismissed

Raghbir Singh Manak And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2024-09-17Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal9 pages

  

    

%  7 8(9 $%&$'!"( ' ) '* "+%, 4+%,-, # '* "+%, +,+%6+*' ;< %'-'1+*'2;/<  

 !"#$ = $ $'+%, &

+ -'. # = +,>'*+'

,  /    (0, -$ +1" '* ' "+% 4+%,-, $%&$'!"( ' ) '* "+%, 3 (  &

3 (  &45 = $ $'+%,

 !"#$  (2  = +,>'*+'

,

 (  

  (

 

 +

 5!, 



 

 



45 ( *

 !



 !



!



 !

 

"#"$"% %&'&/"000/# &./00$#/#1"63 #1"23

 (



  

") 444  : 

  +

   (

,! !

!    !(-!!  "# 

 * +! +

 

           

 

((

@@

!7(  

!(-!!

!,  ++

  !

 7,!   

   ( ( !! 

(!

   , , ,+    !

7,!   !

     

 (  ( 

(   

 

((  ! ! 

* +   +

 

  

"# "0 0 

  79+

  8 

!(- -!!  +

 ( (9

 

  

")?"0 * +! 

  +

  

"#"$

,

(!   



  ( 

!   +  

   

! !

  + 

 !9 9

 , 

(!

 

   # * !(   ,  

 !( -!!  "#      ,    

"#"$     ;!(- !!@  ,

  ,! 9 9   

   !

!  (  *  

 !

    

     ( ,  (< $0!  < 00! 



"#"$ $    + , ,+!!    !  ! 9

  ! =      

!     !    

   !!+ 

!: 9, 

! !

!  (  &!,



  >!+

9 !   

  ! !+((

%8/"3

@@ )      9 9(!+D& A B



9 9"# + 6 + 

!

B 0 9 , 

,!

! ,+ )1 ! (!+   A  9   9 "# !

 



 ! * 9C9  ,

  (

!

9       !!

( !  9   ( 

  %8/#3  !!

(! 

(!

      !

     9   ,  !

 9        D+ (

( ( %8 /$3 9 ! 8 9

 ,   , 

 ,+  !

 ( &  * 9! (

=

!D  ,  A8  '

&



5  

( (7& (!8!

9

 

(( !

 B9 !    

 (   

   !!        (  (9 (   +  ( ,+ 

  !



   (

((    

(!8 *  

< "F 9 8 (

, (  9( ,!9 

!!



 9 8 B# #1")

  %8 8/0399  9 !!+ +(    9 

(!     9  ! , +  9 (   B !    !!

 9F

8 ( (  (

           

 9 !

(!!   8   (   ( 9  (    + 9  

@<@ 9      9 , 8 

    

 9  +  * ( ( (  ,

  (9(  < 01F

 >!(!+  !  

 !  

 9    7!!

 %8 / 3  B 9  !!

9 ! 8  !  9     

 $1 + ! 9

  !+

 < 01117/  (   9 ! , ,

 ,+   ,!   !  9 

!+  % 8 /63  * ! (   !  9 8 ,9 

")"0 DAA5AAD!

9

9 !+ 9

 +

!

")"09

9

 

& ((

 (

 ,

( !

  + +  



!( -!! < ! ,(

(( (  ,+  

 & ( ((     

  ,  ,+    

       (  ,+   ,!  ! ,F

,+ 

 %8 /2 /"$3

B    

 

 9

 

  

!( 

9,!   < 

((   ,9,  ,( ( B

!(  

"#"$

! 

,(  +<!   "220%       < 3  !  , ( ( '9    "220 %         '3  B , ,     

 < ,!7 !

7 ( ( ,  

!!

@@  

(  !!

7

 9

   ,   < , ,(  

 

<'   ,(  0 %"$3" 

<  3 , ,!! 

  , ! *

!      

 9 !+

9 /

( !

9 

 !! 

 + 9 8 

9

 

(

 (,

!

9

  (!

 ,

 !+  +  ! ,





,   9 <  

)  !

 

 9  , 

!   , ,+ 

)

!

+

,,! 5

E 

(  !  , , 

 ,+   A8 

 '

  ! &  !       

 !   

 &   ! (

= =

!5

(, B  ,  

 ( 

  

) (,!   9 (   , ! ,+  

"#"$ !! ((  ,   !

 ! ,  * , 

,        

(

  !

9

,   9( B  ! ,   



!+

!+

!&!,E 9 ! 

9 #)

. 9 ,   &&*- - !   (

 ./C ! !

@A@     (! +

, 

  B  ,   

 ")1   !+    

!  !    ! 

! ,,+    !+ 9

     9  "1 B 

!+ ! , !

 

" $  ,    

,  !  "2"" 

 A8   '

  ! &  !  

(

+

 !! ,! 9  ( !!(  

    !&  ! 9

9!! , 

   

   9 9

9  ! ,+   !&  !  ""

= 

!

 9 !+  "# B9 9,(,+!

 !    ,  ,+      ,   

 !!(-!

!!  ,     F ! 9

 ,  (  ( < 9( (   ((   9 !!+ + ,(         ,   

"# "0  

 ! F ,  ( 

   !7(  , (

"$ 

 !

!

    (!+

    9   B 9 ,(      !9

  + ( (  !

9

@;@

,   9( B9 ,(  



/+(

(

 

(!9! !,+           !  ,

   <! A <! + 

+    9   ,+    

+  (+

!!

 + ( ( (  =

!! ,(     ,  9!!

!  

  $"

1"

#1"2 ,+ & / D

9

 ,   

 +   (  (    B 9 ,(    !   9  !

  !!     ,   ( 9 !

 , 9 ( 

 & / D

9

  9    ,+   !

7   B 9 ! ,( 

   

#      (



$09!! !   

0  8 &'&

"000

#1"2 , ! ,+   9



( 9 1 #1"2,  !+!

!+ =

!(  



 ,(   ,(

   !

 ") = 

!

      ,(     +

   (

 <! A<! +

+

+(

( 



 , !  ,+  

"#  "$ ,

   & ( 

+/ (/    

'    1) #1"

"2   & 

   

   ( (      

 !( -!!    + (

 G

@ @ < #0  F

 9

 1"

#1"2 !! ! H

   !

 9    $"

1"

#1#1     

 !( -!!  ! <.

.

! ! ( 



 9 

 ( (  9    

 $1 +  =

! ,(

(

  , ,  <.

 "# #1 1##      (

  ,

   "0 1# #1#1 "0 E

  !

!

         

 9 

    

(!!+         





 (

     C!+ 

!(+

(

!  ,

 <! A<! +

+    !  

 < ! A %<!    !

(3    #1"

!+       !(  ,+  

/ !(,+   9

!!+ !



!   ,  9 

,       (+

!

( !!, (,! 

(  !9  C    , ,    ,+ !

!   

"#  "

"$  



 ,+ !

!

!    

 (  !+ , 

 <. +# #1## 9  +( 

( ( !!

+#1#1 !+ B

9



 

 ( 9   +( 9  ( (

!+( !!

!  



@/@   @@ / < 

"#"$  !   

   

" $0

9!!

!  

  $"

1"

#1"2   ,+   & /  D

 9

 , !!      +   ( (   ( !+   

!+    ! & 

$#)"

 #1 "2

  !!

 

     1$ #1"2 (9  , 9 9 (  * 9 ,    9, 

+ !

B   

, 9  (9!!

! 

  $"

1"

#1"2  ,+   & /

 D

 > 

 (      !,!   , 

 

(

&   

!+

( (   

+

 ,!

  !

 

 %

 

9 7   745 (  9    

%'-'1+*'

<  '2;/< .

.

.

 7  .

  ,! I7

I7