High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/752/2014dismissed

M/S A K Precast Concrit Pipe Corp. v. State Of Haryana

2020-02-18Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal6 pages

"#$%&$'()(*+ , -). $'")#*'(#

(/$/"#(* //$00"*# 1 2$#"#$%"3"*" $)/*&$*# + 45 .5

$)$*#+ "*"&6'"#$7%#2$"//$00"*# 1()2"0"87&&07"3"*" 9999999 .57

2$ /$)$*# "//$"0 :*&$ $'#(* ; % #2$ <(#"#(* "*& *'(0("#(*'#7 ==> %)2#7#2$'#!()&($'#$&"8"(*)##2$&$&"#$& ,= ;/"))$&<3#2$&&(#(*"0()#('#:&8$72"*&(8"2&()?())(*8"* "//0('"#(*%(0$&<3#2$"//$00"*#:*&$$'#(*; %#2$'# 2$%"'#)7(*<($%7@2('2"$$A:($&#<$*#('$&%"&B:&('"#(*8 :/*#2$/$)$*#"//$"0"$#2"##2$$)/*&$*#(*6(#$&<(&)%)://03% /(/$)%%:&(?$*)(*)($??7>??7??"*& ?? 2$ "//$00"*#A:#$&#2$0@$)#"#$)@2('2@$$"//6$&<3#2$(82 @$$&

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

DE $/$)$*#"#(6$7"//$"$&<$%$#2$($'#7://0($)()/)"0)7"3"*""*& ):<?(##$&"0$##$*<$2"0%%#2$"//$00"*##2:82@2('2#2$$)/*&$*#@") $A:$)#$&#?"F$#2$$"?$*&?$*#)(*#2$)://03&$&"#$&> ==##2$ %00@(*8$%%$'#+ G"!

'0$"(*#2$)://03&$#2"#?"#$("0()#<$)://0($&<3 "& "*)/# <!

2$/"3?$*#-&"%#)%$"'2'*)(8*?$*#)2:0&<$/"3"<0$"#2"F2( "&( '!

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

%#2$'#%)$##(*8")(&$#2$"%$)"(&"@"& 2:82#2$&$(?/:8*$&(*#2$/$)$*#"//$"0):'2"//0('"#(*@")&()?())$& <3#2$&&(#(*"0()#('#:&8$72"*&(8"2 5$"*$&':*)$0%#2$/"#($)2"6$<$$*2$"&"*&@(#2#2$("<0$ "))()#"*'$#2$$'&2")"0)<$$*/$:)$& *

,! ,#2$:/$?$:#/(*$&"):*&$+ C$"$*#(*"8$$?$*#@(#2#2$"//"'2"&/#$&<3#2$0$"*$& (*80$:&8$2$&()/:#$(*A:$)#(*2"&$):0#$&(*"$")*$&"@"&#() *#")(%#2$"<(#"#2")*#"//$'("#$&#2$$6(&$*'$2$"<(#"#2")

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

#2")<$$*/(*$&<3#2():##2"#@2$*(#'?$)#)$##(*8")(&$ %"*"@"&:*&$#2$/:<0('/0('38:*&7(#@:0&?$"*#2"##2$"@"& )2:0&)2'F#2$'*)'($*'$%#2$:#"*&@:0&*#(*'0:&$@2"##2$ :##2(*F)():*B:)#*#2$%"'#)%#2$'")$)$$F(*8#):<)#(#:#$(#)6($@% #2"# % #2$ "<(#"# # & @2"# (# '*)(&$) # <$ GB:)#('$H D

7 !; =+ ! (6! E!

2$"//"'2"&/#$&<3#2$0$"*$&&&(#(*"0()#('#:&8$7 2"*&(8"2@")7#2:)7'$'#(**#8$##(*8(*##2$"'#%$"//$'("#(*8#2$ $6(&$*'$")#2$%()#"//$00"#$':#%?"#("0':#&$'$$*"<(#"#()" '2)$*:&8$<3#2$/"#($)"*&(#()*0(?(#$&/""?$#$)'"*#2$"@"&<$ (*#$%$$&@(#2

=,=!;,+

=,=! >>EID 6 7 >!=

,+ > E"*&! " # 6 $$

!;=+ !; (6!+

! <5 E!H *

% & & ' $ (%) = !;>#2$:/$?$:#2$0&#2"#+ G= *#2$'")$%))'("#$:(0&$) ):/"!7#2():#2"&"*''")(*# '*)(&$(*&$#"(0#2$B:()&('#(*%#2$:##(*#$%$$@(#2#2$"@"& /"))$& <3 #2$ <(#"# (* $J$'()$ % /@$) :*&$ )$'#(*; % #2$ <(#"#(*'#*#2$"%$)"(&&$'()(*7#2():#2")'*)(&$$&#2$0(?(#) %/@$%#2$:##(*#$%$$@(#2#2$"<(#"0"@"&#()<)$6$&"*& 2$0&#2"#*03@2$*#2$"@"&()(*'*%0('#@(#2#2$/:<0('/0('3(**&("7#2$ :#@:0&<$B:)#(%($&(*(*#$%$(*8@(#2#2$"<(#"0"@"&*#2$"%$)"(& &$'()(*7#2():#'*)(&$$&&(%%$$*#2$"&)%K/:<0('/0('3(**&("K @2('27(*#$"0("7(*'0:&$)/"#$*#(00$8"0(#3%#$$%$(*8)$'#(*, ;!%#2$ <(#"#(*'#"*&"%#$'*)(&$(*8#2$&$'()(*)%#2():#(*#2$'")$) %#

% *

) $ +,--./ 00010+$ 00,2003/"*&& * $(%% !

&% ) $ ,-0,+3/&&+/4,-5+,-0,/63-. +$ 73276/7(#()<)$6$&"*&2$0&#2"#"*"<(#"0#(<:*"0?:)#&$'(&$(* "''&"*'$@(#2#2$#$?)%#2$'*#"'#7<:#(%"*"<(#"#'*)#:$)"#$? %#2$'*#"'#(*"$")*"<0$?"**$7(#@(00*#?$"*#2"##2$"@"&'"*<$ )$#")(&$*#2()8:*&#()%:#2$<)$6$&"*&2$0&#2"#'*)#:'#(*%#2$ #$?)%"'*#"'#()/(?"(03%"*"<(#"##&$'(&$:*0$))#2$"<(#"# '*)#:$)#2$'*#"'#(*):'2"@"3#2"#(#':0&<$)"(&#<$)?$#2(*8#2"# *%"(?

(*&$&$")*"<0$/$)*':0&&#()%:#2$<)$6$&<3#2() :#(*#2$"%$)"(&&$'()(*(*/""8"/2;;#2"#@2$*"':#()"//03(*8 #2$K/:<0('/0('3K#$)##"*"<(#"#(*"@"&7(#&$)*#"'#")"':#% "//$"0"*&'*)$A:$*#03$)%%"'#'"**#<$'$'#$&/))(<0$6($@<3 #2$"<(#"#*%"'#)2")*$'$))"(03#/"))?:)#$")#2$"<(#"#()#2$ :0#(?"#$?")#$%#2$A:"*#(#3"*&A:"0(#3%$6(&$*'$#<$$0($&:/*@2$* 2$&$0(6$)2()"<(#"0"@"&#()%:#2$<)$6$&#2"##2:)"*"@"&<")$&* 0(##0$$6(&$*'$*$6(&$*'$@2('2&$)*#?$"):$:/(*A:"0(#3#"#"(*$& 0$8"0?

D E * # ! "

!; #2$:/$?$:#<)$6$&+ ,#()*$'$))"3#$%$##2$)$##0$&0"@*#2$)'/$%$'#(*);

%#2$'#*#2()'")$@$"$'*'$*$&@(#2#2$/(*#")#@2$#2$"*"<(#"0 "@"&'"*<$)$#")(&$%<$(*8(*'*%0('#@(#2#2$/:<0('/0('3%*&("* "<(#"0"@"&'"*<$)$#")(&$(%(#()'*#"3# "!%:*&"?$*#"0/0('3% *&("*0"@7 <!#2$(*#$$)#%*&("7 '!B:)#('$?"0(#3 &

! " 8 ) +0997/$$0 .77! "#$*# (00$8"0(#3@")"&&$&##2$"<6$#2$$8:*&)(*:("! $ ) +,--3/64-600$8"0(#3?:)#8##2$#%#2$?"##$"*&(*'")$#2$ (00$8"0(#3()%#(6("0*"#:$(#'"**#<$2$0&#2"##2$"@"&()"8"(*)##2$/:<0(' /0('3#@")%:#2$<)$6$&(*#2$)"(&B:&8?$*# :("! $

):/"!!#2"#"*"@"&':0&"0)<$)$#")(&$(%(#()):*%"("*&:*$")*"<0$ #2"#(#)2'F)#2$'*)'($*'$%#2$:#* $% #;

& % )+,--1/031-(#@")2$0&#2"#"*"@"&'"*<$ (*#$%$$&@(#2<3#2$:#:*&$$'#(*;

%#2$'#@2$*(#()'*#"3#+ "!):<)#"*#(6$/6()(*)%0"@I <!/6()(*)%#2$ ==>'#I '!"8"(*)##2$#$?)%#2$$)/$'#(6$'*#"'#I &!/"#$*#03(00$8"0I $!/$B:&('("0##2$(82#)%#2$/"#($) 2$%:*&"?$*#"0/0('3%*&("@")$J/0"(*$&(*:("<

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

$*#"0/0('3%*&("*0"@ 2():#%:#2$<)$6$&#2"##2$"@"&%#2$<(#"0(<:*"0()/$*# '2"00$*8$@2$*#2$"<(#"#)%"(0#&"@"*(*%$$*'$@2('2:82##<$ &"@*(%#2$32"&&"@*"*(*%$$*'$@2('2*#2$%"'$%(#():*#$*"<0$ $):0#(*8(*?()'"("8$%B:)#('$2$:#2")#2$/@$#?&(%3#2$ %%$*&(*8/"#%#2$"@"&(*'")$(#())$6$"<0$%?#2$$)#"''&(*8##2$ )"(&B:&8?$*# C$)#$*$'5#& ):/"!!

=2$0(?(#%$J$'()$%/@$<3:#):*&$$'#(*; %#2$ '#2")<$$*'?/$2$*)(6$03&$"0#@(#2<3:)#('$ "(?"*(*#2$'")$%

$% )+,-06/3795"'F% B:&('("0 "//"'27 6(0"#(* %/(*'(/0$) %*"#:"0B:)#('$7 /$6$)(#3 "*& /"#$*#(00$8"0(#32"6$<$$*(&$*#(%($&")8:*&)%(*#$%$$*'$@(#2"*"@"& %#2$<(#"#2$$)#('#(*)/0"'$&*#2$$J$'()$%/@$%":# :*&$$'#(*;

%#2$'#2"6$<$$*"*"03M$&"*&$*:?$"#$&(*))'("#$& :(0&$) ):/"!@2('2"$")%00@)+ "!2$:#:*&$$'#(*;

!%#2$'#7&$)*#"'#")":#%"//$"0 @2(0$ "//03(*8 #2$ 8:*& % K/:<0(' /0('3K # "* "<(#"0 "@"& "*& '*)$A:$*#03$)%%"'#'"**#<$'$'#$& <!/))(<0$6($@<3#2$"<(#"#*%"'#)2")*$'$))"(03#/"))?:)#$") #2$<(#"#()#2$)0$B:&8$%#2$A:"*#(#3"*&A:"0(#3%#2$$6(&$*'$ '!*):%%('($*'3%$6(&$*'$'"**#<$"8:*&%(*#$%$$*'$<3#2$:#

$$J"?(*"#(*%#2$%"'#)#%(*&:#@2$#2$"&(%%$$*#&$'()(*'"*<$ "(6$&"#()(?/$?())(<0$:*&$$'#(*;

!%#2$'# &!*"@"&'"*<$)$#")(&$*03(%(#)2'F)#2$'*)'($*'$%#2$:# $!00$8"0(#3?:)#8##2$#%#2$?"##$"*&'"**#<$%"#(6("0*"#:$ %(*#$%$$*'$<3":#$")*"<0$'*)#:'#(*%#2$#$?)%#2$

DE '*#"'#<3#2$"<(#"#'"**#<$(*#$%$$&@(#2<3#2$:#% '*)#:'#(*()@(#2(*#2$B:()&('#(*%#2$<(#"#$*'$7*(*#$%$$*'$ ()@""*#$& %!%#2$$"$#@/))(<0$(*#$/$#"#(*)%#2$#$?)%#2$'*#"'#7#2$ "<(#"#4)(*#$/$#"#(*2")#<$"''$/#$&"*&#2$:#:*&$$'#(*;

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

*03@$$*03):82##<$)://0($&<3#2$ "//$00"*# C2$*):'2)://03@")*#?"&$#2$"//$00"*#@")()):$&*#('$(* /:):"*'$#@2('2 :/#"7":#2()$&$/$)$*#"#(6$%#2$"//$00"*#7 "//$"$&<$%$#2$($'#7://0($)()/)"0)7"3"*""*&):<?(##$&" @(##$*'??:*('"#(**<$2"0%%#2$"//$00"*##2:82@2('2#2$%00@(*8 #2$$"?$*&?$*#)(*#2$"%$)"(&)://03&$&"#$&> ==@$$):82#+ G"!

'0$"(*#2$)://03&$#2"#?"#$("0()#<$)://0($&<3 "& "*)/# <!

2$/"3?$*#-&"%#)%$"'2'*)(8*?$*#)2:0&<$/"3"<0$"#2"F2( "&( '!

2$$0(6$3/$(&%?"*:"37 ==>#/(07 ==>(*$6$*03)/$"& :#?"**$)2:0&<$"00@$&H 2$$)/*&$*#"''$/#$&#2$"//$00"*#4)"<6$$A:$)#"*&2"*&$& 6$#"%$)"(& :/#""*"?$*&$&)://03&$&"#$& ==@2('2 @")%)://03%/(/$)?$"):(*8??"*&>??*#$?)(*'0:&(*8#2$ "<6$A:#$&"?$*&$&#$?) @$6$7(*)/(#$%#2$)"?$*)://0($)@$$

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

#$("0@")/0"'$&*#2$$'&<3#2$"//$00"*##2"#&:$# (*"'#(**#2$"//$00"*#4)/"##2$$)/*&$*#&(&*#):%%$0))@2('22"&<$$* '0"(?$&<3#2$$)/*&$*##2"##2$'0"(?2"&*#<$$*?"&$<3#2$$)/*&$*# ")/$"8$$&#$?) 2"# <$(*8 )7 #2() :# %(*&) #2"# #2$ (?/:8*$& "@"& # <$ $")*"<0$"*&#2"#(#&$)*#'*#"6$*$"*3):<)#"*#(6$/6()(*%0"@ )2'F)#2$'*)'(:)%#2$:#'*#"6$*$)#2$#$?)%#2$"8$$?$*# <$#@$$*#2$/"#($) *6($@%#2$"<6$7#2$"@"&"*&#2$&$:*&$'2"00$*8$@""*# *(*#$%$$*'$ ()?

, D .5E )2"?)2$ C2$#2$)/$"F(*8-$")*$& + $)- C2$#2$$/#"<0$ +$)-