High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5925/2015allowed

Bhateri Devi v. Sangeeta Devi And ANR

2015-10-29Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh14 pages

!"#$%$ &'( (

!

"

#

$ !" %& %'

(%)* +$ , -"$ . / 0+$ +$ 1"2 (*34

)5&% $" "+0

1 6 )2"$ "" $" 0 " #

1"2+0 "" " "

& "

*

"

$ $"

# +0"

" " "$ " + )% %& (%)% # +00 )5 %* (%)( # " + 0"

" 0$ + +

+ " " 0 "$ 0 ""!"$+

7%) %'

(%)(

+$ " "+ $ 0 +$"$""++ """0 " +

8 # + $+$ 1

2+ ""+ $ " "

# 0" "" $"""

" 0$"0" 0" $""" 00 + "

" +

)

$" $ 1

29 +$""0" + 0 + 0" + "" + $ $ # +0 " 9 "$""

# $+0 " 0+$.:

!

"

#

# 0 "

" # 1 29" "+ 1 2 4( / 7" 4;

# +

*

0+9 9" $ 0 "+

$ 0 +$. # . +0

" 9 0" " 1"2 $ <::

<

"

$

$" " /0

+"+0 + - 0 !" +$ .

+ +$ ""

#.0 $0" . 0+$ "

1"2 " = " 0 5%>: $++$"+ 4( $"

"" 7

$

0' 00

)* %%%>: " " "9" $ +"+$

+""+$ "

$

%) %'

(%)(

"$ 0" # 8 " $"

$+?"$+$0$0%) %'

(%)( @9 ) $ $

+. " 0 $ +0+ = +"

0"+

!" +$ . " 8 " $"" 00" )A$

#.+ 0

00 00"0 = "$

$ 0"" %) %'

(%)(

0 $ $

+ 0" . $

!" +$ . = +"0"1"2 $

="? "0 + 0+$ " + $

# ""

$$ " # $$ 0 # 0 $ " 0 0 "$"+!0$" 0 0 " 0 """+"

0 " #0@9 )+ + +$ ++ 9 0 $" " $ +?"$ #

9"$0

0 " @9 ) " 0

#"

, "@9 ) + " 0@9 )

0 0 = "$ 9 $ " $ 0 !"0 "" " = 0

@9 ) + "0 9 +$ 8 "

$ $+?"$ 0$ # +" " +$ 00" %) %'

(%)(0 0+$)A$0 " 0 + +$ 00

4

# +$ + 0 $" # "

0 #80 " +9" 9

"

- = $ +0"" # 0$0 0+$)A$ #

+ <::

< " $ =+0 " $ "+ + +"$0 ""+++ + " $

. $ $00$ "$+$ 0 # "!+

0+9

" $" + $+$ " $0" " " 08 = 0" 0 " "

$ $" 0 ++$

1"28 " $

9 0 @9 ) = 0 "+$

0+$ 0+$9 0 " + "" +

/0 " "$ 0 0 09 + 0 # 0 +$ 0 :9" 0 0

$ "%) %'

(%)(" @9 )

$"0@9 )+ 9+ $0@9 ) ?0++ +$

" + 9" $ 0+"

"+ 4( " @9 ) + 9 ? 0+ +$ . 0

90 "

! 3B!

/ $ "

" "0 +@9 ) #8 0 0@9 )+

00 0

" $

" - @9 ) # "9 @9 ) #" $"

$@9 )09 " 0 0+ 9 0@9 ) #

$ "@9 ) #

"+

9" $0@9 ) C

" 0 " @9 )+

00

@9 ) " " # @9 )" 8 "

$:0"$0 $ 0

$ 0 #"0 + "8" # :

0"$

"0$0+0 #+ "01+2 $1"$ $2":0+

00 :0 = + 9 $ " 8 $ "

$ :0"$""+

"

@9 ) +

+

9"$ 0 "

" "$+ $ 7"+ " $

0 7 + (%)(! "0 # "$

0@9 ) ? " $" $$

.

+$ +" " $ + #

$ 0!"" """

"

$ $ +$ .0

" " ""

#<"$ +$.

"

0 =

. "+8 #

+0 0+$ +. # 0"

" $ 0"

+$

#+.8 0 " 0 $ = 0 8 0$ + 0 0 > 0 .

"$+ +" + 0$ 0" = " " 00$ /9

$" "$ / "$ <" # 0"

.(D %& (%)* 4 9

+$" +" 0 + $ # 0 "

$ "$+ 0 "+0. "

) 40 " +$ "00"0 E""

C " 0 0 0 0 + + " $ "$"$ $ #"" " 0

1"2$ # 000$ = $

" 0+ "" 0

$ #+$ +$" $ #""$++8

<::

<"

/0 " "+ +

"" 4 0"

0 +9 @9 4)> 0 0 0 + "$ #"" "+""++ "$0 +

*

+$ $ 0+ "$ 0

+ +$$""$ #

$+00:0 " =

"0+ $ 0+$

0 $"$ +"$1" "2 4+ "$ "+

"

$0" $ ""+" 0 " $ 0++

+0 = 0+ 0$" $ +$.0

- "

" +0 .//

0 / # 123 ( $%

&