← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1640/2013dismissed

Budh Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-12-226 pages



     



 



 !"#  $%&'

' ()(% *)&+)"))"( %&'

, ,- *.

,/0*10, *.

,/0*1*,*2 &%'%"( & )3%"%& )"456)(%4

&( %)77%33)"( & %%7) )8)"4394*)&+)")4

&&%'7"%"('( &8!(! )#456)(%4

&&%'7"%"(' (: ;;;

    !'!"(&)-6 &()77%)3 "%&3) '%< ( %%((%&')(%"( )'

=%%" !3%)#)!"'(( %&%&)(%

7)''%=+( %3%)&"%!"#3% / #%!'>!''!"#( %?&!(7%(!(!"2 

 !3%=+( % )77%33)"(6 )33%"#!"#( %&%&)(%

@""%A &%-:7)''%=+ ( %!5!'!")3)")3

!6%&B)"( %&%&)(% C

""%A &%- 7)''%=+( % 7%&!"(%"!"#)")3

!6%& %)77%33)"( )')3' 6 )33%"#%( %&%&)(% C

7)''%=+( %3%)&"%!"#3%/ #%4 ? %&%=+( %&%5!%?)773!6)(!",  

 !3%=+ !>?)'

)3'!'>!''%   # ( %&%!'%3)+ C )+'!" !3!"#( %)77%)3)"( % )77%33)"( )' !3%)773!6)(!" @ -

 &6""!"# ( %')!%3)+4+%(?% )5% %)&3%)&"%6 "'%3 &( %7)&(!%'">%&!('

)" )5%#"%( & # ( %!>7 #"%&%&7)''%=+( %3%)&"%!"#3% / #%4)'?%33)'( %&%&'7)''%=+( %6)")3) ( &!(!%'  %!'7 (%!"( %7&%'%"(6)'%!'&%#)&!"#&%'(&)(!" ) &'%0"%&%6(!"  ( %*)&+)"))")3)"

&)!")#%  6(4  @:

  %&%!") (%&  &% %&&%  (  )'  D( %  6(.4  ( %  6)")3 ( &!(!%' )5%=%%"%>7?%&%(&%'(&%)%>3!' %?)(%&6 &'%"

)")773!6)(!" !3%=+( %)##&!%5%7%&'""( %!"'()"(6)'%4( %7&!5)(% &%'7"%"('>5%)")773!6)(!"=% &%( % =!5!'!")3)")3

!6%&4 )33%#!"#  ( )(  ( %  )77%33)"(  )'  !33%#)33+  %>3!' %  ( %  %A!'(!"#  ?)(%& 6 &'%4( & # ? !6 ( %+?%&%!&&!#)(!"#( %!& !%3')"7&)+%( )(( % &'%=%&%&%(=%&%'(&%"!(!)33+45!%&%& )(% :

C""%A &%- 4( %')!)773!6)(!"?)'!'>!''%=+( %  =!5!'!")3)")3

!6%&4"( %#& "( )(( %%>3!' %?)(%& 6 &'%  %'  "(  )33  "%&  ( %  % !"!(!"    (%>7&)&+  ?)(%&  6 &'%4 ( %&% &%4( %')>%6)""(=%&%&%(=%&%'(&%")77%)3 !3%=+( % 7&!5)(%  &%'7"%"('4  ( %  !5!'!")3  )")3  

!6%&  5!%  &%&  )(%

@ @

C  ""%A &%  -   '%(  )'!%  ( %  ')!  &%&  )"  &%&%  & &%'(&)(!" ( %%>3!' %?)(%&6 &'%4) (%&6>!"#(( %6"63 '!"

-- ( )(!"( %7 =3!' %'6 %>%4( %7&7'%"%? (3%(, @-)=&) !'(&!= (&+?)'' ?"(=%6>73%(% %)(()!3 &>3!"E%?)(%& 6 &'%')"?)'' ?"(=%!"& ""!"#6"!(!")"!(?)' %3( )( ?!(  (3!"E!"#?)(%&6 &'%''73!((!"#?)'"(7''!=3% %&% &%4( % &'%?)'%''%"(!)3 &!&&!#)(!")"( %')>% )'(=% &%'(&%6"(%"(!" ( %)77%33)"(( )("?)(%&6 &'%?)'%A!'(!"# =% &%  %>3!(!"  ?)'  "%#)(%  )"  !(  ?)'  %3  ( )( ( %  )77%33)"(  )' >!'%&)=3+ )!3%(7&5%( %')! )6(  %)=5%')!&%&?)'6 )33%"#%=+( %)77%33)"(=% &% ( %   7%&!"(%"!"#  )")3  

!6%&4  ?   5!%  &%&  )(%  

@ ""%A &%- &%>)"%( %>)((%&=)6E(( %!5!'!")3)")3

!6%& ?!( )!&%6(!"( )(( %7)&(!%'>)+=% %)&)#)!")"( %6)'%=%%6!% &%' ) (%&6"

6(!"#( %'!(%!"'7%6(!" %&%) (%&4( %!5!'!")3)")3 

!6%&5!%&%&)(%

@""%A &%-:4) (%&6"

6(!"#'7( !"'7%6(!"4>)!"()!"%( %&%&&%&)(% @ @

C %)=5%')!

)6(?)')

!&>%=+( % 7%&!"(%"!"#)")3

!6%&5!%&%& )(% C

""%A &%-4? !3%='%&5!"#)' "%&-  

     

   

      

                  

       

   

 

 

   

   



      !

  "

    #  $              %   

  

  #   %    

    



    !

 "

    #  $   

  &'()''*   + 2 !3%  !'>!''!"#  ( %  ?&!(  7%(!(!"  !3%  =+  ( %  )77%33)"(  )#)!"'(  ( % &%')!&%&' ( %!5!'!")3)")3

!6%&)"( % 7%&!"(%"!"# )")3

!6%&4( %3%)&"%!"#3%/ #%)

!&>%( %) &%')!5!%?()E%"=+ ( %6)")3) ( &!(!%'4? !3%='%&5!"#)' "%&-     

   #

    

  

  

  

    

      

      

    

        

"

  

 

     

   

     #     ,-&.# 

  

 

$         

    #

  

       

       

 

  

 

  



  

        

     

     

          

   

  #       

  

     

 

   

   

 

    

      

    

                      

+ %)&"%6 "'%3 &( %)77%33)"((  # 6 3"(7!"( (

)"+8 &!'!6(!")3%&&&&7%&5%&'!(+!"( %&%&'7)''%=+( %6)")3 ( &!(!%'4= (  %)&# %( )( ( %7&!5)(%&%'7"%"('?%&% )5!"# )" )3(%&")(!5%?)(%&6 &'%)5)!3)=3%(!&&!#)(%( %!& !%3'4( %&% &%4( %&%?)'

"  8 '(!

!6)(!"  &  ( %  6)")3  ) ( &!(!%'  (  &%&  &%'(&)(!"    ( % &'% !')&# >%"(?)')3'&)!'%=% &%( %3%)&"% !"#3%/ #%2 !3%&%8%6(!"#( !'6"(%"(!"4( %3%)&"%!"#3%/ #% ='%&5%( )()5)!3)=!3!(+ )")3(%&")(%?)(%&6 &'%6)""(=%)")='3 (% =)&(( %&%'(&)(!" )%>3!' %?)(%&6 &'%(%7%"' 7" )6('

)"6!&6 >'()"6%' %)6 6)'%" &5!%?4( !'6"(%"(!" )'&!# (3+=%%"

&%8%6(%=+( %3%)&"%!"#3%/ #%0"%&( %7&5!'!"' ( %6(4" 7%&'" )')&!# (&3!=%&(+(%>3!' )"%A!'(!"#?)(%&6 &'% )"+ 7%&'"%>3!' %''

6 ?)(%&6 &'%4( %)##&!%5%7%&'" )')&!# ((#%( !(&%'(&%=+>5!"#)")773!6)(!"=% &%( %6)")3) ( &!(!%' )7%&'"

)''>%#& '%?!( &%#)&()"%A!'(!"#?)(%&6 &'%4& %?)"('( )( ( %')>%'  3=%6 )"#%&63'%4&!(')3!#">%"(=%6 )"#%4 % )' 3!=%&(+(>5%(( %6)")3) ( &!(!%' &( %')>%4= ( % )'"&!# (( %>3!' ( %%A!'(!"#?)(%&6 &'% !>'%3 4>%&%3+"( %#& "( )(( % )##&!%5%7%&'">)+!&&!#)(% !' !%3' &>)")3(%&")(%?)(%&6 &'%"

&  7!"!"4  (  >)!"()!"  ( %  !'6!73!"%  !"  ( %  !%3'4  "  =+ 6)"  =% 7%&>!((%(%>3!' )"%A!'(!"#?)(%&6 &'% !>'%3 *%6)")5)!3 !'

&%>%+=% &%( %6)")3) ( &!(!%'"( %7&%'%"(6)'%4) )6( )'

=%%"&%6&%=+( %6)")3) ( &!(!%'( )()"%A!'(!"#?)(%&6 &'%?)'

- - %>3!' %=+( %)77%33)"(4? !6 ?)'&%&%(=%&%'(&%=+( %6)")3 ( &!(!%') (%&7&5!!"#)"77&( "!(+  %)&!"#(=( ( %7)&(!%' % %'(!")'(? %( %&)?)(%&6 &'%?)'%A!'(!"#&"(!')F %'(!"

)6(4? !6  )'(=%%6!%=+( %6)")3) ( &!(!%'"6%( %6)")3 ( &!(!%' )5%&%6&%) )6(4( %')>%%'"(&%F !&%)"+ !"(%& %&%"6%%!( %&!"( %?&!(8 &!'!6(!" ( !'6 &(&!"( %%((%&'

)(%"(77%)3 2%"( !")"+!33%#)3!(+!"( %='%&5)(!"&%6&%=+( % 3%)&"%!"#3%/ #%(( %%

%6(( )(!"5!%? ( %7 &% )6( &%6&%=+( %6)")3) ( &!(!%'?!( &%#)&(%>3!(!" ( %%A!'(!"# ?)(%&6 &'%4( %+ )5%&!# (3+&%&% &&%'(&)(!" ( %%>3!' % ?)(%&6 &'% "5!%? ( %)=5%4?%"( !")"+>%&!(!"( %!"'()"( )77%)3)"( %')>%!'4)66&!"#3+4!'>!''% !  "

  #$#%&#' ( ! )"

"8