High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5930/2015dismissed

Sukhwinder Singh v. Baljinder Singh And ORS

2015-09-098 pages

!" #"$%&%'()"*!"+,"- .

)/012%'#"-)%'31 **"44 '!

5"-&/&

46%'#"-)%'31 '#!1"-& "&*'#"'!&

)/012%'#"-)%'31 **"44 '!

5"-&/&

&2%'#"-)%'31 '#!1"-& "&*'#"'!&

)/012%'#"-)%'31 **"44 '!

5"-&/& 7 01 )%'31 '#!1"-& "&*'#"'!&

! -"&"'!( - ) !2 4% .)"'%-#8$ !"2%!1 -) 4%4) ,40.#8$ !"

-!1" **"44 '! ! " &

. '#

-"! 0"'/* !3"!1"- -1" -%'3 &!1":"+ ' !"/! '"+!-8"1%$/4 -

$$%#"'! 21%$1 !0 *4 $" ' !1" %'!"-8"'%'3 '%31!

;

1-""$4 %+*"!%!%'&1 #,""'*-"

"--"#,:

!1"$4 %+ '!&;%'6/-"#%'!1"& %# $$%#"'!21%$12"-"#"$%#"#8%#" &"* - !" 2 -# "8"' # !" %"

< * &&"# ,: 4" -'"# !- $$%#"'! 4 %+& -%,/' 4. )) 3 -. 1 4% 1"-"%' !"- -"

"--"#! &!1"=-%,/' 4= -"&"'! **" 4&1 8",""'*-"

"--"#,:!1"2'"- !1"

"'#%'38"1%$4"%"$ '!"-," -%'3"3%&!- !%' >

> >?<@ &*"-!1"$ &" !1"$4 %+ '!&. 44!1-"" !1"+%" 46%'#"- )%'31. &2%'#"-)%'31 '#7 01 )%'31A )1 ')%'312"-" *-$""#%'3!8%44 3" $14%0 4 ''!1"- # -+1 4%'!1"%- +!-$:$4"' '%'!"-8"'%'3'%31!

'# <

,/!

+%#'%31!1"%-+!-$:$4"2 & ! &42&*""#'!1" 4"

!&%#" !1"- #1":2"-","%'3 442"#,: 42%'#"-)%'31 '#1 ')%'31' &"* - !"+!-$:$4"B1"'!1":-" $1"# 7 '#- ' $120 '# 2"-" %' !1" *-$"&& $-&&%'3 !1" & +".

$ '!"- ," -%'3 "3%&!- !%' >

> >?<@ #-%8%'3 ! 1%31 &*""# '#%' - &1 '#'"34%3"'!+ ''"-,:%!&#-%8"-CD/4#""* )%'31 --%8"# -+D1 - -&%#" '#&!-/$0 3 %'&!!1"%-+!-$:$4" 44!1-"" !1"+%" 46%'#"-)%'31. &2%'#"-)%'31 '#7 01 )%'31A)1 ')%'31 "44'!1"- #1":2"-"! 0"'!)-%/-/ -0-%&1 ') 1%,&*%! 4.)1 ' -+21"-"7 01 )%'312 & -"

"--"#!.1 '#%3 -144 !1"+-"$"%8"#&"-%/&%'6/-%"& .E2 &-"3%&!"-"#'!1"&! !"+"'! 42%'#"-)%'31 '

%'6/-"#":"2%!'"&& !1"& %# $$%#"'! 44!1"!1-""%'6/-"# %4"#&"* - !"*"!%!%'&/'#"-)"$!%'

@@ !- 5"1%$4"& $!. ?? *- :%'3 - $+*"'& !%' '

$$/'! #%& ,%4%!:&/

"-"#,:!1"+ &2"44 &4&& " -'%'3.

+"#%$ 4"E*"'&"&"!$ **"44 '!>-"&*'#"'! )/012%'#"- )%'31 2'"- !1"

$ '!"-$'!"&!"#!1"$4 %+*"!%!%',: %4%'3 6%'!2-%!!"'&! !"+"'!

4'32%!1!1"#-%8"-.#"':%'3!1"$$/--"'$" !1" $$%#"'!!2 & *4" #"# !1 ! 4&" $-%+%' 4 $ &" 1 # ,""' %4"# '4: ! $4 %+ $+*"'& !%') %#2-%!!"'&! !"+"'!2 & #+%!!"#4:'!&%3'"#,: !1"& %#-"&*'#"'!&"!%!%'&2"-" 4&$'!"&!"#,:!1"%'&/- '$" $+* ':*4" #%'3!1 ! * -! -+!1" $!!1 !!1"%'&/- '$"$8"- 2 &'!8 4%# !!1"!%+" $$%#"'!.#-%8"- !1"

"'#%'38"1%$4"

2 &'!1 8%'3 8 4%# '#"

"$!%8"4%$"'$"'"%!1"-2 &!1"-" 8 4%# *"-+%!- %!'"&&$"-!% %$ !" !!1"!%+" 44"3"# $$%#"'! 7" -'"#-%,/' 4 - +"#!1" 442%'3%&&/"&(> B1"!1"-!1"$4 %+ '! 46%'#"-)%'31-"$"%8"#%'6/-%"& %' - #&%#" $$%#"'!$ /&"##/"!!1"- &1 '# '"34%3"'! #-%8%'3 ,: -"&*'#"'! 21%4" #-%8%'3 8"1%$4"," -%'3 >

> >?<@ F

B1"!1"-!1"$4 %+ '!%&"'!%!4"#!$+*"'& !%'.% & !21 !- !" '# -+21+F

B1"!1"-!1"$4 %+*"!%!%'%&+ %'! %' ,4"F < B1"!1"-!1"$4 %+ '!1 &'$ /&" $!%'! %4"!1"

*"!%!%'F B1"!1"-!1"#-%8"- !1"

"'#%'38"1%$4"2 &'!

14#%'38 4%# '#"

"$!%8"#-%8%'34%$"'$"F @ "4%"

B-%!!"'&! !"+"'! %4"#',"1 4 !1" **"44 '!>2'"- '##-%8"->D/4#""*)%'312 &'!! 0"'%'!$'&%#"- !%' &%!2 & '!&%3'"#,: ': !1"+

< ' **-"$% !%' !1" "8%#"'$" ' -"$-#. 4" -'"# -%,/' 4$'$4/#"#!1 ! 44!1"!1-""$4 %+ '!&1 #-"$"%8"#%'6/-%"& %'!1"- #&%#" $$%#"'!$ /&"##/"!- &1 '#'"34%3"'!#-%8%'3

!1"

"'#%'3$ '!"-,:-"&*'#"'!CD/4#""*)%'31+*"'& !%' 2 &

-#"#! 44!1"!1-""$4 %+ '!& &/'#"-(>

46%'#"-)%'314 %+ '!>-"&*'#"'!%'

&2%'#"-)%'314 %+ '!>-"&*'#"'!%'

@.?G ;> 7 01 )%'31A)1 ')%'314 %+ '!> -"&*'#"'!%'

?. <.

;> 7 01 )%'31A)1 ')%'31&/

"-"# +*/! !%' 1%& -%31!4"3 &2"44 &+/4!%*4"%'6/-%"&'!1" $".":".1" # '#!1"- * -!& !1",#:.21%$1%&*-8"#'-"$-#!%& /-!1"-*-8"#!1 !

1" -"+ %'"# ,"#-%##"' - ,/! &%E +'!1& & *"- #%& ,%4%!: $"-!% %$ !" E %' &" <;

&/,6"$!

+ !!"-

7 01 )%'31&/

"-"#*"-+ '"'!

#%& ,%4%!:!!1""E!"'! @ H &*-8"#,:B - +"&1D/+ - 7 01 )%'312 & 8"3"! ,4"8"'#-/'$!%' 4#%& ,%4%!: !1%& $4 %+ '!2 & &&"&&"# &

H"2 & G:" -&4# !!1"!%+"

$$%#"'!.!1"-"

-". ' ##%!%' H !1"%'$+"2 & 2 -#"#.

0%'31%&%'$+"!," G.

;>*"-+'!1.+/4!%*4%"- G2 & **4%"#!1 &,""'1"4#!1 !!1" **"44 '!,"%'3!1"2'"- !1"

8"1%$4" %& 4% ,4" ! * : $+*"'& !%' & !1" $$%#"'! 1 & ,""' $ /&"#' $$/'! - &1 '#'"34%3"'!#-%8%'3 !1"

"'#%'3 8"1%$4",:1%&#-%8"->-"&*'#"'!D/4#""*)%'31 '&/- '$"$+* ':2 & ,&48"# %!&4% ,%4%!:'!1"

3-/'#!1 !!1"

"'#%'38"1%$4"2 &%'&/-"#2" <

,/!!1" $$%#"'!%'!1%&$ &"$$/--"# !

+%'!1"%'!"-8"'%'3'%31!

'# <

33-%"8"# -+!1"& %# %'#%'321"-",:!1"%'&/- '$"$+* ':1 & ,""' ,&48"# %!&4% ,%4%!:.*-"&"'! **" 4&1 8",""'*-" "--"#,:

!1"2'"- !1"

"'#%'38"1%$4" 7" -'"# $/'&"4 8"1"+"'!4: -3/"& !1 ! 2-%!!"' &! !"+"'! %4"#',"1 4 !1" **"44 '!;2'"-1 &,""'2-'34:

%3'-"#1"-%,/' 4$/4#'!1 8"%3'-"#!1"2-%!!"'&! !"+"'! ! !1"!%+" -3/+"'!&;* &&%'3 !1"-#"- !%& /-!1"-&/,+%!!"# !1 !%'&/- '$"$+* ':$/4#'!," ,&48"# %!&4% ,%4%!: &!1"

$$%#"'!%'I/"&!%'%&'!*-8"#!1 8"$$/--"# !"-+%#'%31!

7" -'"# $/'&"4 - !1" **"44 '! /-!1"- -3/"& !1 !

4" -'"#-%,/' 41 &3-&&4:"--"#%''!! 0%'3'!" !1" $!!1 !

!1"-"2"-"!1-""*"-&'&-%#%'3!1"+!-$:$4" !!1"!%+" 44"3"# $$%#"'! 1"-"

-". $'!-%,/!-: '"34%3"'$" ' !1" * -! !1"

%'6/-"#%& ** -"'!'!1" $" %! 1 8"1" -#4" -'"#$/'&"4 -!1" **"44 '!& '#3'"

!1-/31!1" %4"& !%&'!#%&*/!"#!1 !!1"2-%!!"'&! !"+"'!.21%$12 & &/,+%!!"#. #"&'! ," - !1"&%3' !/-"& !1" **"44 '! ! 2 & &%3'"#'4:,:!1"$/'&"4 -!1" **"44 '!'!1%&&%!/ !%'.4" -'"# -%,/' 41 &-%31!4:,&"-8"#!1 !& %#2-%!!"'&! !"+"'!$ ''!," ! 0"'%'!$'&%#"- !%'!%& /-!1"-,&"-8"#,:!1"-%,/' 4.!1 !

"8"' %' !1%& 2-%!!"' &! !"+"'!. !1" **"44 '! 1 & #"'%"# !1"

@ $$/--"'$" !1%& $$%#"'! "&*'#"'!2'"-*-"&"'! **"44 '! '##-%8"-'"8"- &!"**"#%'!!1"2%!'"&&,E!-",/!-"E*4 %'!1" 44"3 !%'& & 4"8"44"# %' !1" $4 %+ *"!%!%' & *"- !1" . %! %& &*"$% %$ 44:

+"'!%'"#!1 !!1" $$%#"'!!0*4 $" !

+%#'%31!'!1"

%'!"-8"'%'3'%31!

'# <

1" **"44 '!$ ''!

#"-%8" ':,"'"

%! -++"'!%' !1" $$%#"'!!1 8"! 0"'*4 $"

! ,/!

+%#'%31!'!1"& %## !"&1%&%&&&*"$% %$ 44:%'

8%"2 !1" $!!1 !!1" **"44 '!#%#'! %4"2-%!!"'&! !"+"'! &*"- *-8%&%'& 4 2"'"%!1"-4"# ':"8%#"'$"!*-8"!1 !!1" $$%#"'! %'I/"&!%'#%#'!$$/- !"-

+%#'%31! '!1"

%'!"-8"'%'3'%31!

'# <

,/!$$/--"#*-%- !1"-"!*-8"!1%& &*"$!.&*"$% %$"8%#"'$"&1/4#1 8",""'

4"# ! %& %'#""# 44 $%/& -3/+"'! - %&"# ' ,"1 4 !1"

**"44 '!!1 !'$"!1"2-%!!"'&! !"+"'! !1" **"44 '!2 &'!

,"%'3! 0"'%'!$'&%#"- !%'!1"-"2 &'I/"&!%' 1 8%'34"# ':"8%#"'$"!%&'!#%&*/!"#!1 !!1"2-%!!"'&! !"+"'!2 & %4"# !

!1" %'%!% 4 &! 3" 1"-"

!"-. **"44 '! #%# '! ! 0" ': &!"*& 21 !&"8"-!4" #"8%#"'$" ! ':*%'! !%+"*-%-!!1"* &&%'3 !1"%+*/3'"# 2 -#14#!1 !!1" **"44 '!$/4#'!%' ': $ &"1 8"4"#"8%#"'$"%'8%"2 !1"/'&%3'"#2-%!!"'&! !"+"'!.

!1/&.!1"+ !!"-&1/4#,"-"+ '#"# !!1%&&! 3"2/4#%'#""#," !- 8"&!: 6/&!%$"21"-"!1" **"44 '!%&

-#"#,"'"

%! 1%&2'

2-'3 "-/& 4 !1"3-/'#& *-"&"'! **" 4&-"8" 4!1 !!1"

3-/'# 2-%!!"'&! !"+"'!1 8%'3,""'2-'34:-"6"$!"#1 &'!

"8"',""'- %&"#.!1"-"

-".*- :"-',"1 4 !1" **"44 '!!1 !

!1"+ !!"-&1/4#,"-"+ '#"#,"

-"!1"-%,/' 4 !!1%&&! 3"%& $4" -4: /'!"' ,4" '# /' $$"*! ,4" )! '# ! 0"' %' !1" *-"&"'! **" 4%&!1 !!1"%'&/- '$"*4%$: !1"8"1%$4"2 &8 4%#/*!%44

1/-&'

'#!1"2'"-1 #- 44:%'

-+"#!1"

%'&/- '$"$+* ':!%&&/"$8"-'!" !1"&/,&"I/"'!:" -'

!1" 442%'3# : '&"I/"'!4:.#'! %'# ':%'

%-+%!:-%44"3 4%!:%'!1"

%'#%'3-"!/-'"#,:!1"-%,/' 4-"3 -#%'3!1"4% ,%4%!:%'!1%&$ &" )%+%4 -4:.$'!"'!%' !1" **"44 '!!1 !!1"$4 %+ '!& -"3/%4!: $'!-%,/!-:'"34%3"'$"%&#"8%# ':+"-%!-%*4"

-%#%'3 !1"+!-$:$4"2/4#-"'#"-!1"$4 %+ '!&4% ,4" --"I/%&%!"

$!%'/'#"-!1"!-5"1%$4"&$!*-8"$'!-%,/!-:'"34%3"'$" %!%&%'$/+,"'!/*'!1"* -!:& 44"3%'3!*-8"!1 ! $$%#"'!%' I/"&!%' 2 & $ /&"# ' $$/'! & %# 8%4 !%' !1" !- 5"1%$4"&$!1"-"$ ',"'*-"&/+*!%'%'-"&*"$!!$'!-%,/!-: '"34%3"'$" %' &/$1 $ &"&. "&*"$% 44: 21"' - &1 '# '"34%3"'! #-%8%'3 !1"-"&*'#"'!>#-%8"-1 &,""'*-8"#'-"$-#!%&'! #"'%"#!1 !!1"& %##-%8"- $"#$-%+%' 4*-$""#%'3&**"44 '!%'

!1%&$ &"1 &'!4"# ':"8%#"'$"21 !&"8"-!*-8"$'!-%,/!-: '"34%3"'$" !1 &,""'-%31!4:,&"-8"#,:!1"-%,/' 4!1 !"8"'%' !1" 2-%!!"' &! !"+"'!. 21%$1 !1"-2%&" $ ''! ," ! 0"' %'! $'&%#"- !%'.!1"$ &" !1" **"44 '!%& #"'% 4 !1" $$%#"'! 1"-"

-". %'#%'3 ' !1%& $/'! %& 4& $--"$! %' !1" $!& '# $%-$/+&! '$"& !1"$ &"

7" -'"#$/'&"4 -!1" **"44 '!%&/' ,4"!*%'!/!

':%44"3 4%!:.%'

%-+%!:-*"-8"-&%!:%'!1"I/ '!/+ $+*"'& !%'

2 -#"# ! 44 !1" !1-"" $4 %+ '!& 1"-" %& ' 3-/'# - ':

-"#/$!%'!1"-"%' '&"I/"'!4:.,"%'3#"8%# ':+"-%!. 44!1"!1-""

**" 4& -"#%&+%&&"# #$%!#&& )"*!"+,"- .

'()* -!&