High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5934/2015dismissed

National Insurance Co Ltd v. Laltesh & ORS

2026-01-31Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma34 pages

!"# $% & '

(

)* $+ !$%$,%-.%* & '

(

)* $+ /0$)#1%2

(

& 3 4 5'

5 5 5

" ! #$

%&%

! '() **** 5 5

# + , !

" % -.-./-#.

! #001#'-!

#233,

+ , %4! 5+ , 67% ,8

% , # $ ! ##-----18"% 9.):

!!; ,

5 5 / & !! ! -#-#/-#'; , 4 7"% <4 7%

! " !

, " " =8)-8$23- > % " , ?

% @!

% ,

A % , " " =8 $38)2). % , # "" !

! ; ,

#, 8 !%; ,

% <% @? = % "

% !

! < "= B=% <

, <

-/-#/-#'+ % " C '-/-#/-#' /.2$$.$-'8 #30- % " " # =

$ D !

,!" % ! !

' "

! + , !

!%"

! "

# $

' # $()* +,+-#

/ % 01 0 1 1..

) 1

.() 2 / 3

.() + ( 4 )

! "

0 ! @" "

+ , %

! ##-----18"% 9 .):

!!; , 8

% , =

5 555 4

545 5 . ! 8

+ ,

@ "" "!!!" = !

, "" !

% !"" %

, "=8)-8$23-=!

% , + , "

% 3 !

-#-#/-#' < " , & !=6,

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $./)%6 4*#'

!)%)6 5*71' %!! E " " !

"#-:

, !

" & !=6,

) 1%)

) .1% ! '

*1*1$%!

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $./)%6 4*#'

%!'8 + !

, %+ ! ,%% , !1

2 ! # $8

!"! , "" ,

% " , ,

! ,

, !!!"

"" ! !

, !

, "" % , ,

% E !"! + , " ! !!" "" ! ! =!

! % % , % #- ! ') "

!% ## ! !

% !

% ,

#/ &! " !

! % -.-./-#)

, + , , $'

' ' 0

.201 1

5%( $ 3 .267

01 /82 "

# 9 : 1 % 9 : 1

# $( +8;

( ),*8 & ; <

( :0

= & & ;

# 9 : $9

# :

1 1 1 0 = $ 0 # $()* +,+-# # $ 7 > "

# 1 0 7 1

7 0

# & ; % 1 = $

0 .

3 $ !

# $ # 1 5%( 2 / /823 .20 /-,0))- )827%.;

. $ & 9

1 #3 . # 1

3 .67

# ?

0./"

@ 07 7 @ 0 "

& % ;

0 $ #

9 "

& %;

0$ 1 ! &0

1 #3# #

# # 1

(

$A# $ ; ,%:);

)!6)%) 1% ):, )%# $*7!

< '

5,=7>1%#!

51%27 )%# $*7!

(

1"10 ?

' ;

# 3 .8,01 1 1 1

& ; 9 :

3 .8*0 =

3 .8,

&<( 3 .)8 '

% 3 .,1 1 #

1 1

' "

# % 0 &<( & ;

' ' # #

# !

# $()* +,+-# "

# % &

? ; ' 00

, $' 8 )%# & % 0)1.

*1*1$% $'

*1*0# 5.*'4)0* 7 <! , 5)*6) )!=) 7 )%# $*7! &

' <

1 , $

8 # ( ,08886 '

1 10

/ )#

/ ) # ! '

# #

' 0 "

# 9 : ! $1

# 1 ( 28886 '

.&( 3 ' 1 1 # ) < C

( ,8886 '0

) 0

, '

# 3 .8,1 "

# 1 , '0

# 0 ,

9' ' 0

< 01 "

# 01

1 #3 .) "

# 1 8 ? & 0

@ # 1 # ( ,08886 '

1 '

1 1 $10# , 1

# ' !

/82 7 #

( +8886

3 '0 ( +8886

?' % 0 ,

1 31

'0! 1

#11 31

0 +8

# #

1 '$A# ; %

5.*'

5)!0) <!.) <! ,

!)% /$!* $!/$!)*1$%

<4 # D % 1 #

0 1 #0

+8E

01 # 1 # 128 9

# 01

4 #

34: ' # )8E 1 28+8 ' # 01 +8 '0

# 1 1 3

91 0 :01

# 3

' '$A# 7 3; 5)%*$ 7

"1 < '

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $./)%6

41.1*# )%# $*7!

54 @; ?

5 1%

1"10 //)0 $'

9 $+

)!1 1%2 $,* $+

$' ? $+

#-1## $%

# D

C F 1 1 1

0 0;1

# 3

% 10 1 #

1 6

1 1

0 01

' # %

#1 7 0 1

1 1 3 6 ' 1 '0 3

; = 6

#1 0 #

;

%C =1 # 1 7 0 1 6 G

= # # #

# 0 # #

1 #

# % 30

# 3

1 # %

0 #

# 1 #

0 # #0# 0## 0 '0 1 1

C F0;

1 # 1 #

1 > 1

31 ( 0

1 # #

1 31 1

)8 6# #

' % 1 , '0 1 1

B A 9 : +8E

# #

1 #( /+886 % 1

0 ( -+886 9( +8886 H ( /+886:( ,808886

' '# 00 1 1

C A 9 :01#

# /)0 #6) '0

( I8088869,80888)80888: ' 7 # 1 ,

1 1

1# $A# ;%

C A 9 :

* #

7 0

( I808883*J80*808886:

' '

< 01 1

( 808886 '

( 808886

3 K

' % 1

# 1D 5!'

)# ,%#!

>71-7

).$,%* >)!## .$,%* #

#-3----18 / + ( F

#----18 $

#----18 4 & '

A ' '0

( 088088869( :

% 0)1.

*1*1$% $'

*1*0# 7)!

7)%# )%# )%$*7!

<! , 5)*6) )!=) 7 )%# $*7! D (' < 0

1 // $ 1

# ( 808886 $

# $1 =

0 .

1 /82// /82

( /08808886 $10

# $

! $ #

# $ #

3 ?

! 9' 0

! $ &<(0 0 # #

## $

?' '0

& ; 1 1

# ( 808886 0#

1 3

1 '0 0 #

1 1

# ' /8) %

0 #1 ( +8886

3 '0

6 ( +8886 ' .*

3 .8,1

L 7$ #0 # 1 #0 1

0 G 0 3

# 0 0 0 B( 0 '0

1 0

(

0 ( +088869( +08886M):

1 ' '

# 1 #

'0 #

' ' 0

0 0 ?

. 0=

.2 1 # 3 .+ 3 .88 ( /I0+)*60 # ; 0 (

# 3 .83 .8- ( /)02886

B 0 (>

67 =

0 .

# 3 .83 .*( +80+86 ?

# 3 ./83 ./,( +08+86 7 # #

( 08+02,*6 1 ' 7 =

0 .

& 1

/82 / /82 '0

! 0

( +08886 1

( +8886

( +88861 % 1

! 5!'

)# ,%#!

>71-7

).$,%* >)!## .$,%* # ; ( 08+02,*6> 3 / < ( +08886 $ .

( +08886 ' ; ( +08886 ) ; ( +08886

4 '

88?A

' '0

( 02+02,* 9( :

# ! % 0)1.

*1*1$% %$' $+

*1*0#

)6) 7)%# )%# )%$*7!

<! , 5)*6) )!=) 7 )%# $*7! D ' <

1 /8 $

/ # ( ,08886 '

? # ! '

% #

1 0

' 0 %9 : ! $1

# 1 ( 28886 '

.&( 3 ' 1 1 # ( ,8886 '0

) 0

/8 '

% 3 .,1 %1 /8 '0

# 0 /8 9' ' 0

; 0 %0 1

1 #3 .- %1 / ? & 0

@ # 1 # ( ,08886 '

1 '

1 1 $10# /8

# ' !

/82 7

1 ( +8886

3 '0 ( +8886 ?' % 0 /8

'0 1 1

1# $A#

5.*'

5)!0) <!.)

,/!) 5)%*$ 7

,/!)0

+8E 1 #( /+886 %

0 ( -+886 ( ,808886 ' ' $A# ; %

5)!0) <!.)B-)

,/!) D 1 1 #

0 1

% # 0

0+8

3 0 #

# 1 1 0 #

0 1 #

9: #

'0+8 1 # 3 # +8 #

' '0 # 1 1

1 5)!0) <!.)B -)

,/!) # 1

# +8E '0 # 1

( 2+08886 ' 103! 1

# $%B;0 127 $,!* $+ ,%:);

)!6)%) )* 7)%#12)!7 $'

( ?

*1*0# 5)"1*!1 )%# )%$*7!

< '

:%#!

)%# )%$*7!

#-1## $%

1 $A# $ ; # D

B 9 :

8, /88 .

9 : - 8/ /8 13

C 9 :

+ 82 /88,1 #

% ;

# ?$A# 1"

C 9 : # # ; .

9 :

B 9 :00%

C 9 : .

9 :

# ' #

4 ' ; 0 1 /8 '0

1 1

1# $A#

0 5)!0) <!.)B -) 9 :0 '5'5$.)%)*7)% )%# $*7! B -) 9 : 1

1# $A# $ ;,%:);

)!6)%) )* 7)%#12)!7 1% 5)"1*!1 )%# )%$*7!B -) 9 :0

* #

7 0

( *0808886 9( 2+08886 M *:

' '

( 808886 0 7 ' % 1

# 1D 5!'

)# ,%#!

>71-7 ).$,%* )>)!## .$,%* # <

( *080888 88 / 3

' 0

( 80888 88 4 & '?8

' '0

( *0/8088869( < '1

' :

3 .1 1 /2 / /88, 1

/) / /82 0 '

/82 '0

0 1

! 7

3 ./ 1 1 / 1 1 )

3 ( '0 ) # 0 1

'0 /

)

) 4 #$

! " % + , " %

%8 !"

"" "! !!" 8 , " " =8$38)2). ,

# 4 7 ! !!" 8 #' !

-#-#/-#' C % " , !

! 8%

, " % %

! !C

"" !

!!!" + " !C !

, !

, ! " #) +8%

, "% F A8$%

" , E ! "

= !

8 % ," ""

"!<

B ,"

,< "

8F "

= !

! #0

A8/; !

! # ! " %

, " %8

C , " "8 , !" !!!" ! ! "" "

, , "

" , # ! %

,F , , , "

! " #. " , ! 8

, "" !

% "

% ! #3 ! , "" , ! !

",! + , E

, "" % !

, !"

! "

,+=6,

1*76) ! '

%!)0 % ,!)%- $'

4*#' 54C 5'??

E %

, ""

+ ,

, #2 G % ! , ""

E ! !! !" " """

"" ,

, ! "

"" % ,

/- % ! ! ""

" !"

, + ,

! "" " <

! + ! !

" !! /# "% ,! "

,!!H

E !

% , + , "

F //

! + ,

! , @" " %" !

! %

" ! ,

/$ !

" !

% " , #2

+ + ,

! " !#3% % %,=6,

/' =% + ,

% "!

!)-: %!%%

, E < " % !

" ,'-:)-: /) , !

! ! %

% , =6, F

! !

( ! /0 %!!

, ,

5!'

)# $./% )*1$% >)!## #

)---18 /

9'- /---184'-:!)---7 $ B

#1$ /$$$184.---I#1$7 '

+ '00.184.---H/$$$7 ) )0--'184'00.I#/7

#3 .

B #--3-./184)0--'I#37

!G #)---18 GF

#)---18 #-

! '----18F/

'----18F# #/----18 $*)0 $./% )*1$% '

8?8 9 A .$,%* >)!## ;6 *7

!1;,%)0 '

A %7)%-# ).$,%* '?8 9 A

8?8

5 55 4 /. +! 8 " !

>7*7!

*7 )>)!# /) # ;6 *7 !1;,%)0 -)% ;

%7)%-# 1% )%

9 )//)0 /!+!!# ;6 *7 1% ,!)%- -$./)%68 >7% *7 -0)1.)%* 7)"

%$* +10# )%6 -!$ $;:-*1$% $!

-!$ )//)0'

/3 + E ! ,! 8;

" & !$%3;0 5,/!.

$,!* 1% 5,!=7) ! '

5)%*$ 7 ! '8

( 5 (9'+ !

# < '

3 2>>/8, N =

% ; < 0/8, ;;< ?/O

# $ ;" ?#

0? 7 # 5 7

/+I2/8I01# *7 127 $,!*8 "% *7$,27 )2!# >1*7 *7 *)%# $+ *7 )//00)%* *7)* :, * -$./% )*1$% ).$,%* $,27* *$ ;

8?89(

,/ +$!*6%1% 0)=7 127*6+1"

*7$, )%# *7!

7,%#!# "%*6 1D $%068 7$>"!8 #-01%# *$ 2!)%* %7)%-.%* .!06 $% *7 2!$,%# *7)* *7 )//00)%* 7)# +)10# *$ +10 -!$ )//)0'

/ %$>8 1* >00 **0# *7)* 1% *7 .)**!

$+ 1% ,!)%- -0)1.

-$./% )*1$% 1% !+!%- *$ *7 .$*$!

)--1#%*8 *7 -$,!* 7$,0# %$* *)= 76/!*-7%1-)0 )//!$)-7 )%# % ,!

*7)* :, * -$./% )*1$% )>)!## *$ *7 )++-*# /! $% $!

*7 -0)1.)%* '

) ! ,0*8 > .$#1+6 *7 $!#!

/) # ;6 *7 127 $,!*

(2,0*+0)-I9( >

> > :01 # $ ; 2 '

1 # .

0 0 P

? /2 %!, !% ,F

% <

, , " ! , !

8, $- +

< " 8 , % <

! !

%, $%3;0 5,/!.

$,!* 1% )2)//) "'

,!,#)6)0 51%27 !

5 9'

C>8)3$'8/-#0 7 !1%*)0 % ,!)%- $./)%6 41.1*# < '

5.*'

)*7!1

"1 )%# $*7! #/-2/-/) %

J' ;

(0 ).)*) )%# $*7!

)//6 )%# $*7! 0 /, 8+ /8/201 3

8-;.; 1 M<%( ));.;0 1D>

4< <55 <4 8

8-D>.17

; Q9: #

# #0

; 1Q :

9#: R 9:

R 9:

! #

9/: #

; 1

# # ;;

!#!

E4 ,0 $+ *7 $# $+ 1"10 !$-#,!8

?& '

$>!

$+ $,!* $+ //)0 Q'7

; 1

1 #

! 0 1

#3 # ;1

01 # > 11

# 3 0

D N. 7

;

)+7 # 1 ; 1

O /* MMM MMM MMM , 7 8-;;

.0,8* 1 17

;07

; 1

# # ; ;

0 &C 7,** #

0 #

# 7

/8/+ MMM MMM MMM 45 /I '7

; #1

1 0 1 8- 1 M<% ( ));;

.0,8*

1 #

! 0 1

#3 # ; 1

# /- & #

6 >

7 1 1

# ?

0 # ;

1 # 6 '"

0 0 0

# 0

0 ;

' #

# /* '; # 1

%I)>7 II &C 70,** S 8- 1 M<%( ));.;

00 7

; 0 1

01 ; 1 1 '0 8- M<%( ));.;0 7

; 1 >

7 >

# '

; /, # 7

; 1 I)>7

II&C 70,**

4 ) % #

# #

> % ;

! 0

;! 0

0 # >

2 %3

10 ; #

&C 70 ,**01 #

1 ' ;

# >

+ 7 0 0

0 ;

₹ ?8 A < 4 6

/ I % 1 # $F# ; F'

).6) "'

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $'

4*#'8

1"10 & 7 ;

' # 1 4 # %#

; 1 1 3 0 # 0

4 $/ ! ,=6,

)!) 51%27

7)!)

)%:)!) < '

576).

51%27 <)!.)

9('<)001 )%# *7!

<5'

).10 )%#, 5*)* !)% /$!* $!/$!)*1$%

5,/!.

$,!* )

92: !

!!"! !

K $$ +8

! "% %+ , % !% !

++ , !

! "%

! #/

% -.-./-#.+ # / !

+ , $' E ," !

#1 .1 # $) + ! /)---18 , !

! , !

$0 " 4 7! !

5 5

(

A @"18 @"

A ,

L 1