Rajasri Bhattacharyya v. Central Administrative Tribunal Chandigarh & ORS











 

 





!
"# $
!
%&'
()*+

,
"# 

$-$&
.$$%.$//$

 0&1& .
$
2*&$
+1$,
(%
#,
.$23$.
4
.&

&)2&




 !"#$%&
!"'(#&%%



 !"#$%&
!&% ))))

&'

5& $32)
$&,
2%$, !
.
)

66666







































&% *" #

.
%.$3

.
)&
7
)
&

.
7
2& 2$2

#

"#
$2
#"

"#
891&
:#
4
:

;;
22
+/
. $
2*&$
+1$,
.$23$.
%.
8!
&.
<=; 2&*&&3

  " ">"""#?> "# $2

  " ">#" @> "#?

&)%/

5& $32)
$&,
$2
%1&
!
.
)
&1+*2 .$
.
)
.$2
)$&&2
.
5 (%
8%.*&/;
!*
$%1$

&/


.
/$
#AAA
$2

.
/$
""B
7$&
$7$22
7.
.

23
+/
$2$)1
&/
(.
7C2
$&
&$%.
&&%$
$
& &1,
DC$$
!*
""B:

""

$2
.$!
$&
(
*&$
$

5 ,
.$23$.
!*
""

:

"##

@


.
/$
"#",
&)2
 ,
7.%.
&
$
&1
!

5%+$
%.3/
85;,
(%
@A:,
.$23$.,
%$1&2

$

 )1+%$
!
!3
1)
$1&
)&&
!
(%&&
.
),
+3 !1/
3+,
$))2
!
.
&$*
.13.
))
%.$
(.
%2
$ %$

!
7

1/,
"#"
$2
)$%)$2

.
7
.2 
@#

"#",
+1
!*$
&1
!
.
&%
7$&

)1+&.2

. /$
"##,
&)2
 
$3$
%$1&2
$
$2&*
!
$1& (%!%
)&&
2
2&*
 #"> "##
.
):$))%$ $&
$))2
!
&1%.
)&
$2
&.
7$&
72

)1&1$%

.
%$ 
2$2

"#@
&&12

.,
+1
$3$

!*$
&1
7$&
)1+&.2 
2$

%*+,
"#@,
&)2&
&&12
$))*
&

&* !
.
%$22$&
7.1
!*$/
)1+&.3
*>&%
&
. !*$
&13.
12
.
3.

!*$
%
$2
.$
. 7
!73
31$&

.
&%
)%&&
$2
7': $;

.
(%
**
7$&

))
+1
7$&
3$E +;

.
(%
**
2
%1
!!
*$C&
7.1 .$3
$/
9)%
-1&2%E %;

.
)$$*&
$2
+/
.
(%
** 7
$&
7.1
-1&2%E 2;

3$&
B
)&&,
@
%$22$&
7
&.&2
! 7
$2
7
.$))2

7
2$/&E ;

.
7$&

!*$
)1+%$
!
.
*
&E !;

5$C&
7

$&&32
12
2!!
.$2&E 3;

5*+&
!
.
(%
**
7

)22 &)$$
*$C&
$7$2
&.E ?


.&
)&
7
!1/
$3$2
+!
.
,
+1
. &$*
.$
1&/
+
-%2
+/
$&&33
$&&,
7.%.
7 1-1&!2

$7
 
!$%,
.
&)2&
!$2

)$%

%2
$/
%)/
! .
!*$/
)1+&.2
*
&,
.1&,
.

&%
)%&&
7$&

$ %$2&
*$
.
7$&

$&)$%/
.

)%&&
!

+ &%
$%C2
.
$))%$+/
!
$&)$%/
$2
)12%,
.!, .
2&
12
%.$3
$
$+

+
&:$&2


.$
.$2
.
$2
%1&
!
.
),
$))$&2 .
)$)
+C
$2
$
!
.
7
.$
.
&

!%
$2
*

. &1+*&&&
!
.
$2
%1&
!
.
)
.
$!*2 %&
7
!12
+/
.
2)$*

&
2$2
)/
!2
+! .
,
7.

7$&
&$2
.$
.
(%
**
%21%2
. &%
)%&&

$%%2$%
7.
(
(%&
%1*
$2 &&&&*
*
1&,
""#
8
&.
< ""#
1&=;
$&
$&
+/ 3
&
7
%$
!
&%
!
.
%$22$&
$&
)
&$2
1&

.
&$2
&%
)%&&
7$&

%.$32
+/
.
$))%$
.
+! $))/3

)1&1$

.
$2&*
 #"> "##



. 3$
))%$ .
$))%$:)
&%12

*$C&
1
!
*$9*1*
!

"
$2
.
&1
!
.
&%
)%&&
7$&
2&)$/2

.
7+&
! .
&)2:&1
.
$))%$
$3
7.
@
.
%$22$& )$%)$2

.
&%
)%&&

)1&1$%

.
$2&*  #"> "##
$2
.
$*
!
.
$))%$:)
7$&

%**22


.
*$C:&.&
!$F2
+/
.
(%
**
.$
$$2/ +
*$2
$$$+

.
$))%$

.
)*$/
G1&
.$
7
$&&
!
%&2$

7 !
.
$!*2
!$%1$
*$9
&
$&

7..
$
)&,
7.
.$& )$%)$2

.
&%
)%&&,
%$
%.$3
.
3+/
!
. &1%%&&!1
%$22$&
$2
.
&%
)%&&
.
$&7

. $!*2
*$

.$&
+
3$2
+/
.
-123*
22
+/
. )9
1

,-,.& ./ 0  

$/- ., -,

3 

4 ./.($,./6,2, 7, 8 3 .*9:$/1 
/
,.

.

4;4* 7.

.$&
+
.2
.$
7.
$
%$22$
$C&
)$

. &%
)%&&,
%$
1
$12
$2
G1&
.
&$*
/
&% )%&& 
.
&$C
!
+/,
$
)
!
.
-123*
8&1)$;
& )21%2
.
+7':

 

      



    

  

 

         

 
   !  "

#$%&'()**
+
#



     ,    - .

  /       *                

0

1     !  "

1     ,      *

,

    

 #   

    2 *   ,  

    3 

     *



   ,  2    ,   

 *

4 5    #  *  6$** 
%#
( 7
8  # #    

            

      , 

   ,            ,  

             

#  ,         

                   

   

 

     *

2

      ,    

                  ,     2    #      

 

  

    

       

 

         * 9" 0 *  #1 4%
&*:
#   



;  

 #                             



   

           ,      

  ,          

 6$1 4):#%( 7%

                  ,    ,   

     

     ,   #         7 ' 9"  .;<#$%%
()**+'#    ,    ,  /   6$** %)#% 7%/        # 

              



   

 ,     

    #     ,      ,    



# ,   ,  ,     !  

    

 ,                                   ,  9 ,      *

    

              

   

  

#       

                   = , 

          



  

  ,   ,  



   #    

  

  

  

           #

 # , 

 

           ,  # 

 

,

    

        *

  

   =0   1 <  #

 %+' **:+
#  ,  , /     .



 *  

             3    



      

  3                  3 #  2 *          

  > & 9 <   /#$:??(:**
&'#  *              

,  6$**
+#'( 7'8       2 *   

    

     

  %@  ,       

#            

    #    A

       

#                         5     2 *   1  ::'  *

        

     

    ,    *

              



    2 *     , 

      7 + 4 * 1. #$:?)(**)?%#    /   *      

   6$**):?#:( 7:        ,  5   

# 

,   ,       

     

         ,             #    

    

          , /         .



  B  /   2 * 





  ,      ,  

7


.
)&
%$&,
.
7$&

7
&
.
1
22
 )&%+
.$
.
%$22$&
1*+3
*
.$
.%
%$
+
%$2

.
(%
**
%&22
.
$))*
!
/

%$22$&, 7.
&%12
*
.$
BH
*$C&,
7.%.
7$&
.
%2

.
*$C& $7$22
+/
.
(%
**

.
7
7

& &$&!$%,
7.%.
%&&2
!
9)&
$2
$1&
.
%1$ )&&
$2
.
1&
&.$

:$))%$
.
&%
)%&&
1
$2 1&&
$/
3$3
3$/

*$$!2&
.$
+
$+12,
7.%.
$ %&)%11&/
$+&
. #"

.

$&
!12
.$
$%.
**+
!
.
(% **
.$2
$&&32
*$C&

$%.
%$22$&
2)2/
+/ *$$3
.
))
%2

.
$))%$
.$2

&%12
.
G1$!/3 *$C&
$2
7$&
!$
+.2
.
&%2
%$22$&
$2

&.%*3&
 3+/
!
.
&%2
%$22$&
.$2
+
)2
1

##


&
$
*$
!
%%2%
.$
$%.

!
.
&%2 %$22$&
7C3

$
$2.%
%$)$%/

.
&)2
&1
%12 &%1
*
.$
BH
*$C&,
.!,

&
!12

+

11&1$
 .
)
22

&1%%2

:$3$3
.
*$
+/
!3
.
7 $&
&.
%12

)
1
$/

$))$

%2
.
7 $))%$
7$&
!2
:$3$3
.
*$,
7.%.
&

)*&&+
 7
!
.
    %12
1
+/
.
I+
(1)*
1





 
     

     

            

!"# $%&  '##
.
$
)$$3$).
!
.
-123*
$2& $&
12':

 AA4    -   

      , 

     ,

 

             

  ,  

,  1     

   

  -   5   * # (     )   



*+    $ !!#& ,  ,!"

   6        



  #    "    *          

 

,

 

   

   ,  

  

 

,   = 

  ,  

#             



                  , 

     , 

       

,

,

  

                

  1      

    

    5         ,  3       3     #  

        3  

AA #

&
$
1)&.
!
1
!23&,
7
2

!2
$/
3$/
 )&/

.
*)132
2&
.
&$*
%$
+
!$12 &1$/, .
7
)
&
2&*&&2

8"'(#&%% :  9&% :

"#0<!

 "#0<!

$ 1 * ,2 .3 3 3 .1 ,= >? ,.

- '

.?

3 3  ,6

'

.?