High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5973/2015dismissed

National Insurance Company Ltd v. Mehar Chand & ORS

2026-01-31Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma33 pages

!"# $% & '

(

)* $+ !$%$,%-.%* & '

(

)* $+ /0$)#1%2

(

& 4 5 6'

6 6 6

# !$%$ &' (((( 6 6

# ) *

" $ +,+,&+#,

! #--.#/+ #011*

) *

$2 3) * 45 $ *6

$ * .

# # /7 /01.6"$ 8,79

* .

6 6 & % +#+#&+#/ ; * 2 5 "$ :2 5 $

* " " <67+6'01+ = $ " !* >

$ ?

$ !*

@ $ * " " <6 '1!6707, $ * # ""

; *

#* 6 $; *

$ :$ ?> < $ "

! :

"< A<$

* :

+&+#&+#/) $ " B /+&+#&+#/ ! &,0 '','+/6 #1-+ $ " " # ! <

' C

* " $

/ "

) * $"

! "

# $

' # $()* +,+-#

/ % 01 0 1 1..

) 1

.() 2 / 3

.() 5.

Relief. "

- ?" "

) * $

# /7 +++.6"$ 8,79

* 6 6

$ * <

3 6 666 5

656 6 , 6

) *

? "" " " <

* ""

$ "" $

* "<67+6'01+<

$ * ) * "

$ 1

+#+#&+#/ :

" * % <4*!

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $./)%7 5*#'

!)%)7 6*81' $ D " "

"#+9

" % <4*!

) 1%)

) .1% ! '

*1*1$%!

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $./)%7 5*#'

%!'9 )

* $) *$$ * .

0 #6

" * "" *

$ " * *

* "

* "" $ * *

$ D " ) * " " "" <

$ $ * $ #+ &' "

$ ##

$ *

#& % "

$ +,+,&+#7

* ) * , $'

' ' 0

.201 1

4%( $ 3 .256

01 /72 "

# 8 9 1 % 8 9 1

# $( +7:

( ),*7 & : ;

( 90

< & & :

# 8 9 $8

# 9

1 1 1 0 < $ 0 # $()* +,+-# # $ 6 = "

# 1 0 6 1

6 0

# & : % 1 < $

0 .

3 $ !

# $ # 1 4%( 2 / /723 .20 /-,0))- )726%.:

. $ & 8

1 #3 . # 1

3 .56

# >

0./"

06 6 ? 0 "

& % :

0 $ #

& %:

0$ 1 ! &0

1 #3# #

# # 1

(

$@# $ : ,%:);

)!7)%) 1% ):, )%# $*8!

< '

6,=8>1%#!

61%28 )%# $*8!

( 3

1"10 ?

' :

;

# 3 .7,01 1 1 1

& : 8 9

3 .7*0 <

3 .7,

&;( 3 .)7 '

% 3 .,1 1 #

1 1

' "

# % 0 &;( & :

' ' # #

# !

# $()* +,+-# "

# % &

? : ' 00

, $' 9 )%# 3& % 0)1.

*1*1$% $'

*1*0# 6.*'5)0* 8 <! , 6)*7) )!=) 8 )%# $*8! &

3' ;

1 , $

7 # ( ,07775 '

1 10

/ )#

/ ) # ! '

# #

' 0 "

# 8 9 ! $1

# 1 ( 27775 '

.&( 3 ' 1 1 # ) ;

( ,7775 '0

) 0

, '

# 3 .7,1 "

# 1 , '0

# 0 ,

' ' 0

;

01 "

# 01

1 #3 .) "

# 1 7 > & 0

? # 1 # ( ,07775 '

1 '

1 1 $10# , 1

# ' !

/72 6 #

( +7775

3 '0 ( +7775

?' % 0 ,

1 31

'0! 1

#11 31

0 +7

# #

1 '$@# : %

6.*'

6)!0) <!.) <! ,

!)% /$!* $!/$!)*1$%

<5 # C % 1 #

0 1 #0

+7D

01 # 1 # 127 8

# 01

E #

3E9 ' # )7D 1 27+7 ' # 01 +7 '0

# 1 1 3

81 0 901

# 3

' '$@# 6 3: 6)%*$ 8

"1 < '

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $./)%7

51.1*# )%# $*8!

65 @; 3?

6 1%

1"10 //)0 $'

)!1 1%2 $,* $+

$' 33? $+

#-1## $%

# C

B F 1 1 1

0 0:1

# 3

% 10 1 #

1 5

1 1

0 01

' # %

#1 6 0 1

1 1 3 5 ' 1 '0 3

: < 5

#1 0 #

%B <1 # 1 6 0 1 5 G

< # # #

# 0 # #

1 #

# % 30

# 3

1 # %

0 #

# 1 #

0 # #0# 0## 0 '0 1 1

B F0:

1 # 1 #

1 = 1

31 ( 0

1 # #

1 31 1

)7 5# #

' % 1 , '0 1 1

A @ 8 9 +7D

# #

1 #( /+775 % 1

0 ( -+775 8( +7775 H ( /+7759( ,707775

' '# 00 1 1

B @ 8 901#

# /)0 #5) '0

( I7077758,70777)707779 ' 6 # 1 ,

1 1

1# $@# :%

B @ 8 9

* #

6 0

( I707773*J70*7077759 ' '

;

01 1

( 707775 '

( 707775

3 K

3 3' % 1

# 1C 6!'

)# ,%#!

>81-8

).$,%* >)!## .$,%* #

#+ 1+ +++.6 & ) F E

#+ +++.6 '

#+ +++.6 5 & '

A ' '0

( 077077758( % 0)1.

*1*1$% $'

*1*0# 8)!

8)%# )%# )%$*8!

<! , 6)*7) )!=) 8 )%# $*8! C (' ; 0

1 // $ 1

# ( 707775 $

# $1 <

0 .

1 /72// /72

( /07707775 $10

# $

! $ #

# $ #

3 >

! ' 0

! $ &;(0 0 # #

## $

?' '0

& : 1 1

# ( 707775 0#

1 3

1 '0 0 #

1 1

# ' /7) %

0 #1 ( +7775

3 '0

5 ( +7775 ' .*

3 .7,1

L 6$ #0 # 1 #0 1

0 G 0 3

# 0 0 0 A( 0 '0

1 0

(

0 ( +077758( +07775M)9 1 ' '

# 1 #

'0 #

' ' 0

0 0 >

. 0<

.2 1 # 3 .+ 3 .77 ( /I0+)*50 # : 0 (

# 3 .73 .7- ( /)02775

A 0 (=

56 <

0 .

# 3 .73 .*( +70+75 >

# 3 ./73 ./,( +07+75 6 # #

( 07+02,*5 1 ' 6 <

0 .

& 1

/72 / /72 '0

! 0

( +07775 1

( +7775

( +77751 % 1

! 6!'

)# ,%#!

>81-8

).$,%* >)!## .$,%* # : ( 07+02,*5= 3 & ; ( +07775 ' .

( +07775 / : ( +07775 7 : ( +07775

5 '

9393?A

' '0

( 02+02,* 8( 9

# ! % 0)1.

*1*1$% %$' $+

*1*0#

)7) 8)%# )%# )%$*8!

<! , 6)*7) )!=) 8 )%# $*8! C 3' ;

1 /7 $

/ # ( ,07775 '

? # ! '

% #

1 0

' 0 %8 9 ! $1

# 1 ( 27775 '

.&( 3 ' 1 1 # ( ,7775 '0

) 0

/7 '

% 3 .,1 %1 /7 '0

# 0 /7 ' ' 0

: 0 %0 1

1 #3 .- %1 / > & 0

? # 1 # ( ,07775 '

1 '

1 1 $10# /7

# ' !

/72 6

1 ( +7775

3 '0 ( +7775 ?' % 0 /7

'0 1 1

1# $@#

6.*'

6)!0) <!.)

,/!) 6)%*$ 8

,/!)0

+7D 1 #( /+775 %

0 ( -+775 ( ,707775 ' ' $@# : %

6)!0) <!.)B-)

,/!) C 1 1 #

0 1

% # 0

0+7

3 0 #

# 1 1 0 #

0 1 #

89 #

'0+7 1 # 3 # +7 #

' '0 # 1 1

1 6)!0) <!.)B -)

,/!) # 1

# +7D '0 # 1

( 2+07775 ' 103! 1

# $%B;0 128 $,!* $+ ,%:);

)!7)%) )* 8)%#12)!8 $'

( ?

*1*0# 6)"1*!1 )%# )%$*8!

< '

:%#!

)%# )%$*8!

#-1## $%

1 $@# $ : # C

A 8

7, /77 .

8 9 - 7/ /7 13

B 8 9

+ 72 /77,1 #

% :

# >$@# 1"

B 8 9 # # : .

8 9

A 8 900%

B 8 9 .

8 9

# ' #

E 3 ' : 0 1 /7 '0

1 1

1# $@#

0 6)!0) <!.)B -) 8 '6'6$.)%)*8)% )%# $*8! B -) 8 9 1

1# $@# $ :,%:);

)!7)%) )* 8)%#12)!8 1% 6)"1*!1 )%# )%$*8!B -) 8 90

* #

6 0

( *0707775 8( 2+07775 M *9 3' '

( 707775 0 6 33' % 1

# 1C 6!'

)# ,%#!

>81-8 ).$,%* )>)!## .$,%* # ;

( *070777 77 & 3

' 0

( 70777 77 5 & '?9

3' '0

( *0/7077758( ;

' 3('

3 .1 1 /2 / /77, 1

/) / /72 0 '

/72 '0

0 1

! 6

3 ./ 1 1 / 1 1 )

3 ( '0 ) # 0 1

'0 /

)

) E #'

" $ ) * " $

$6 "

"" " " 6 * " " <6'1!6707, *

# 2 5 " 6 #/

+#+#&+#/ B $ " *

!* !" $ $

" ) " B

* * " #7 )6$

!* !"$ E @6'

" * D "

6 $ *" ""

" :

A *"

*: "

6E "

@6&;

# " $

* " $6

B * " "6 * " " "" "

* * "

" * # $

*E * *

" #, " * 6

* ""

$ "

$ #1 * "" *

"* ) * D

* "" $ * "

*)<4*!

1*87) ! '

%!)0 % ,!)%- $'

5*#' 65C 6'??3

D $

* ""

) *

* #0 G $ * ""

" " """

"" *

* "

"" $ *

&+ $ ""

" "

* ) *

"" " :

)

&# "$ * "

* H

$ * ) * "

E &&

$ $ .

*< $ >

?< $!< $ $ $ ##&+#/ &&#&+#/

* ) * " $

$ <$

" * $ $

$ ,+ +++.6

* $ * ) * @

6 66 5 &' ) 6 "

>8*8!

*8 )>)!# /) # ;7 *8 !1;,%)0 -)% ;

%8)%-# 1% )% )//)0 /!+!!# ;7 *8 1% ,!)%- -$./)%79 >8% *8 -0)1.)%* 8)"

%$* +10# )%7 -!$ $;:-*1$% $!

-!$ )//)0'

( &/ ) D * 6;

" % $%4;0 6,/!.

$,!* 1% 6,!=8) ! '

6)%*$ 8 ! '9

( 6 3(')

# ; '

3 2==/7, N <

% : ; 0/7, ::;

>/O

# $ :" >#

0> 6 # 4 6

/+I2/7I01# *8 128 $,!*9 "% *8$,28 )2!# >1*8 *8 *)%# $+ *8 )//00)%* *8)* :, * -$./% )*1$% ).$,%* $,28* *$ ;

39?9(

,/ +$!*7%1% 0)=8 128*7+1"

*8$, )%# *8!

8,%#!# "%*7 1D $%079 8$>"!9 #-01%# *$ 2!)%* %8)%-.%* .!07 $% *8 2!$,%# *8)* *8 )//00)%* 8)# +)10# *$ +10 -!$ )//)0'

/ %$>9 1* >00 **0# *8)* 1% *8 .)**!

$+ 1% ,!)%- -0)1.

-$./% )*1$% 1% !+!%- *$ *8 .$*$!

)--1#%*9 *8 -$,!* 8$,0# %$* *)= 87/!*-8%1-)0 )//!$)-8 )%# % ,!

*8)* :, * -$./% )*1$% )>)!## *$ *8 )++-*# /! $% $!

*8 -0)1.)%* '

) ! ,0*9 > .$#1+7 *8 $!#!

/) # ;7 *8 128 $,!*

(2,0*+0)-I8( =

= = 901 # $ : 2 '

1 # .

0 0 P

&7 $ * $ *E

$ :

* * " *

6* &- )

" 6 * $ :

$* $%4;0 6,/!.

$,!* 1% )2)//) "'

,!,#)7)0 61%28 !

6 3'

B=671'/6&+#- 8 !1%*)0 % ,!)%- $./)%7 51.1*# < '

6.*'

)*8!1

"1 )%# $*8! #&+0&+&7 $

&1 I' :

(0 ).)*) )%# $*8!

)//7 )%# $*8! 0 /, 7+ /7/201 3

7-:.: 1 M;%( )):.:0 1C=

5< <66 <5 9

7-C=.16

: Q89 #

# #0

: 1Q 9

R 8#9 R

? 89

R 89

! #

8/9 #

: 1

# # ::

!#!

E5 ,0 $+ *8 $# $+ 1"10 !$-#,!9

?& '

$>!

$+ $,!* $+ //)0 Q'6

: 1

1 #

! 0 1

#3 # :1

01 # = 11

# 3 0

C N. 6

)+6 # 1 : 1

O /* MMM MMM MMM , 6 7-::

.0,7* 1 16

:06

: 1

# # : :

0 &B 6,** #

0 #

# 6

/7/+ MMM MMM MMM 56 /I '6

: #1

1 0 1 7- 1 M;% ( ))::

.0,7*

1 #

! 0 1

#3 # : 1

# /- & #

5 =

6 1 1

# >

0 # :

1 # 5 '"

0 0 0

# 0

0 :

' #

# /* ': # 1

%I)=6 II &B 60,** S 7- 1 M;%( )):.:

00 6

: 0 1

01 : 1 1 '0 7- M;%( )):.:0 6

: 1 =

6 =

# '

: /, # 6

: 1 I)=6

II&B 60,**

E ) % #

# #

= % :

! 0

:! 0

0 # =

2 %3

10 : #

&B 60 ,**01 #

1 ' :

# =

+ 6 0 0

0 :

₹ ?9 A ; E 5

/ I % 1 # $F# : F'

).7) "'

)*1$%)0 % ,!)%- $'

5*#'9

1"10 3 & 6 :

' # 1 E # %#

: 1 1 3 0 # 0

E &0 ! *<4* !

)!) 61%28

8)!)

)%:)!) < '

687).

61%28 <)!.)

('<)001 )%# *8!

<6'

).10 )%#, 6*)* !)% /$!* $!/$!)*1$%

6,/!.

$,!* )

9 "

809 "

J '+ )6

"$ $) * $ $ )) *

$ +,+,&+#,) .

) * '# D *"

#1 .1 # '& ) &7 +++.6 *

* '' " 2

6 6

(

@ ?".6 ?"

!?"

@ *

K .