High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6003/2015allowed

Bhago Devi & ORS v. Ninder Kumar & ORS

2018-12-17Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan5 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* +

* -. /0/

1$($)#* 1/ 2')%("3%4&"#$ 1 1 "15')%$1/')623%4&"#$ 1#2$"77$88")#( (0")%")""82#1"3%4&"#$ 11$(7)%$)#

!"# 2$"9"1%%"#$%

:37"(($%;<#2$#1&&'%$)# 8"'5(1';=)"83>"'#2"8 1;1$4'#<3-#2$1';=)"8-2"(;$$)"(("'8$%;< #2$8$6"82$'1( /2"5."8($$?')6$)2")&$5$)# &57$)("#')"9"1%$% =)%$1/$&#') #2$#10$2'&8$(&#3 @,, 1(21#3-#2$&#- 2$"77$88")#("1$#2$9'%9")%#9()( /2"5."82$ %1'4$1 ")#$1;$"1')61$6'(#1"#') @A @2$1$')"

#$1 1$ $11$% # "( -#2$

$)%')6 4$2'&8$-3 9)$1 ")% #2$ ')(=1$13 '$3 28"5")%"8"5/$)$1"8)(=1")&$57")<.#% #2$

$)%')6 4$2'&8$ 2"4$;$$)"11"<$%"(1$(7)%$)#( # 1$(7$&#'4$8<')#2$ "77$"8 2$ "&#()$&$(("1< 1"%B=%'&"#') #2$71$($)#"77$"8"1$ #2"#)

3"#";=# : 3/2"5."8"8)69'#22'(9'

2"6 $4'")%)$72$9/"#7"89"(6')6)"5#1&<&8$#9"1%(4'88"6$ 2"#"B1" )#2$'19"<3#2$'15#1&<&8$9"( 2'#;<"1"(28<")% )$68'6$)#8<%1'4$)

$)%')64$2'&8$("1$(=8# #2$'57"&#3/2"5."8 (=(#"')$%61'$4=(')B=1'$(")%9"(#"?$)#/"1"(9"#''((')(7'#"83

$29"392$1$#2$%&#1%$&8"1$%2'5%$"% ,%"#$%

9"(1$6'(#$1$%"# 8'&$/#"#')3 $29" &8"'57$#'#')=)%$1/$&#') #2$&#9"( '8$%2$ 1';=)"83"

#$1&)('%$1')6#2$ "&#(")%"771$&'"#')6#2$$4'%$)&$"%%=&$%3 2$8%#2"#"&&'%$)#&&=11$%%=$#&)#1';=#1<)$68'6$)&$ #2$

$)%')6 4$2'&8$")%#2$%1'4$1 #2$5#1&<&8$2$&)#1';=#1<)$68'6$)&$9"( 2$8%')#2$1"#' @ * 3'$#2$

$)%')64$2'&8$9"(2$8%@ C8'";8$ 1 &"=(')6#2$"&&'%$)#2$%1'4$139)$1")%#2$')(=1$1 #2$

$)%')6 4$2'&8$9$1$2$8%B')#8<")%($4$1"88<8'";8$#7"<#2$&57$)("#')2$ 1';=)"8&"8&=8"#$%&57$)("#')##2$#=)$ 33 DA")%#2$ &8"'5")#(9$1$2$8%8'";8$#1$&$'4$")"5=)# 3@ 3 DA"8)69'#2 ')#$1$(#E@C7$1"))=5 )#2$&8"'57$#'#')3'#9"(78$"%$%#2"##2$%$&$"($%9"( $"1)')63 DA7$15)#23"(2$9"(")"61'&=8#=1'(#")%"%"'1< "15$1 )#2$#2$12")%3"$89 4$1#<.')$&"1% 1(21#3- .&"1%- #2$ %$&$"($% 9"( "8( 71%=&$% ;$ 1$ #2$ 1';=)"8 2$ 1';=)"83 "

#$1 &)('%$1')6#2$ "&#(2$8%#2"# )1$8'";8$$4'%$)&$9"( 71%=&$%9'#2 1$6"1%#&&=7"#')")%#2$5)#28<$"1)')6 #2$%$&$"($%3#2$1';=)"8 $F="#$%#2$%$&$"($%9'#2")=)(?'88$%8";=1$1")%"(($(($%#2$')&5$E :3 DA7$15)#2G 1%%$%=&#')9"(5"%$ $H7$)($(G5=8#'78'$1 9"("778'$% 3+3 DA9$1$"9"1%$%=)%$1&)4$)#')"82$"%(3 92'&2')&8=%$% 3 3 DA 84$")%"

$&#')

$"1%8$"1)$%&=)($8 1#2$7"1#'$(")%7$1=($%#2$7"7$1 ;?")%#2$1$8$4")#%&=5$)#(71%=&$%;<#2$5 .$"1)$%&=)($8 1#2$"77$88")#(&)#$)%(#2"##2$1';=)"8 $11$%')"(($((')6#2$5)#28<$"1)')6 #2$%$&$"($%"(:3 DA3"('#'( $4$)8$((#2")#2$5')'5=59"6$( 1"(?'88$%8";=1$12$&)#$)#')'( #2"##2$5)#28<')&5$ #2$%$&$"($%(2=8%;$"(($(($%"(7$1#2$ 5')'5=59"6$(71$4"8$)#')#2$/#"#$"##2$#'5$ "&&'%$)#2$61'$4")&$ 1"'($%'(#2"#) =#=1$71(7$&#(2"4$;$$)"9"1%$% .$"1)$%&=)($8 1#2$')(=1$1%$ $)%(#2$"9"1%/2$"16=$( #2"##2$ .&"1%71%=&$%;<#2$"77$88")#('#($8 (29(#2"##2$$"1)')6 #2$%$&$"($%9"(5$"61$")%#2$1';=)"81'62#8<"(($(($%:3 DA"( 2'( 5)#28< $"1)')6 /2$ =1#2$1 (=;5'##( #2"# #2$ "5=)# =)%$1 &)4$)#')"82$"%((2=8%;$(#1'&#8<"9"1%$%"(7$1%$&'(')( #2$ /=71$5$=1#')

$% &'

( &

3 )*+,%-+-,")%)"5=)#(2=8%;$"9"1%$%

84$")%"

$&#') 2$1$'()%'(7=#$;$#9$$)#2$7"1#'$(9'#21$6"1%##2$ "&# #2"##2$%$&$"($%9"(: <$"1(8%"##2$#'5$ "&&'%$)#G 1%%$%=&#') 5"%$ $H7$)($(")%5=8#'78'$1 "778'$%;<#2$1';=)"8 2$"77$88")#( "'8$%#(=;(#")#'"#$#2$5)#28<$"1)')6 #2$ %$&$"($%3')(=&2&'1&=5(#")&$(3#2$("

$(#<"1%(#'&?'(#1$8<=7)#2$ 5')'5=59"6$(71$4"8$)#')#2$/#"#$"##2$#'5$ "&&'%$)#2$%$&$"($% '( #1$"#$% "( ") =)(?'88$% 8";=1$1 ")% 5')'5=5 9"6$( 1 =)(?'88$% 8";=1$1"##2$#'5$ "&&'%$)#9$1$:3@+DA7$15)#2')#2$/#"#$

"1<")"2$("5$"1$1=)%$%

#3 DA7$15)#2 1#2$7=17($ &"8&=8"#')6#2$&57$)("#')

: "4')6%=$1$6"1%##2$%$&'(')( #2$/=71$5$=1#') ( & . &"($ (=71" ")% / "

$ % &'

!)*+0#)('10* ")%&)('%$1')6#2$ "&##2"##2$ %$&$"($%9"(: <$"1(8%3 C =#=1$71(7$&#("1$"9"1%$% (#2$F=")#=5 &57$)("#')'(;$')61$A4'('#$%3'#9=8% ;$"77171'"#$#2"##2$"5=)#("9"1%$%=)%$1&)4$)#')"82$"%("1$5"%$ ')&)()")&$9'#2#2$%$&'(') #2$/=71$5$=1#') ( & . &"($(=71"2$"77$88")#("1$$)#'#8$%# 3 DA$"&2 1 =)$1"8 $H7$)($(")% $(#"#$: 3 DA'("9"1%$%##2$9'%9 18(( &)(1#'=5"5=)#&");$"9"1%$% 84$")%"

$&#') ) 4'$9 #2$ ";4$ %'(&=((')3 #2$ &57$)("#') '( 1$A &"8&=8"#$%"(=)%$1*

)#28<')&5$ #2$%$&$"($%"(($(($% 3 DA

C =#=1$71(7$&#( DA /=;#"8 3 DA

1%%$%=&#') $H7$)($( 3 , DA )#28<%$7$)%$)&< :3 +DA ))="8%$7$)%$)&< 3 :DA 778<')65=8#'78'$1 - - +3 3 DA =)$1"8$H7$)($( 3 DA .(( $(#"#$ 3 DA .(( &)(1#'=5#9'%9 : 3 DA 1")%#"8 ,3 3 DA /')&$ C &)#1';=#1< )$68'6$)&$ 9"( "##1';=#$% # #2$ %$&$"($%32$)&$3#2$"9"1%%"#$%

:'(5%'

'$%##2$$H#$)##2"# ')(#$"% 3@ 3 DA3#2$&8"'5")#("1$2$8%$)#'#8$%#&57$)("#')

+3 ,3 :DA 2$&8"'5")#((2"88;$$)#'#8$%##2$$)2")&$%"5=)#"8)6 9'#2')#$1$(#E+C7$1"))=5 15#2$%"#$ '8')6 &8"'57$#'#')#'88

1$"8'("#') #2$"5=)# 2$"77$"8'(7"1#8<"889$%')#2$"

1$("'%#$15( !

# 2

, 5?

I2$#2$1(7$"?')6D1$"()$%* !$(D I2$#2$11$71#";8$* !$(D