← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4791/2023dismissed

Sanjay Khurana v. Shanta Yadav And Another

2025-08-20Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain10 pages



        

  !"#"

$%&'&( )$*+,-./$  &&&&&&

"

"

/ /#.# )-$  0$ 

- /# &&&&&&

#1 2% 342 & ) , 

 



  !"



$ %& $



 ''''

,5&6 /78 ( ) 

 

 * ++ , 

  (-((.

/* +&, 0"

)

1%&&,$#  /





,#

#+* +"&

2(.. ++#  ,

$

+ 

3 +

  + 



,     

&+

&



,   

 $  

,  

&

   

 +  4&

 # ,

$ 

&



,  

 $  ++ ,+& &

5 

&

 

  "&

+  (.(.. 

$

&

 +

 (3(.. +

$ 



,#

#+

+

, 

+  

/    $

   4&

    

 

 #   ,

+ 

6

#

/

   &,  * +&, 0"

)

1%&&,$++# 

,

$+ + 

$ &

  *&

+



 

/

6 +*&  7

 



,#

#+

&, +

 

+   /   $

 /&

  

+  

/   $

 

++ &

*&

+ &/$

 

 

+

+   / 

 

  + /

#

&

,  

,,

+ 

*&

+  + &



+#+ # /"&  $ *&

 

   

       

&/$

 ,

+ 

, 

& 

$ 8 99777:&+ (**/





 

++ + 

$

 6

&  



 ,

++#



#

&



,$+  

&+

 ++# 



,#

#+ 

+ 

 ; 

  &

+ 

,   

 

 

/

6 +*& <  &/$



&,  #

 (-((.



3((.

&  8  77:&+ ((**#

 

   .(.3   8  (.3.3   

  +   #

8 (.3.3

&  8  99979:&+ ( # ++#  ,

$ 

+#

   /

..3 6    (=.-.3

   

# +

 

    (>.-.3#

& 

+



+  &/$

&

&/ ?&

<  +

& &,$

/*



 !!"

+  #$% 

     &

 '     (..#



,,

5  

+

 

+ # 

#

:

....@  

,

$

+ 

 !&

&/$



+#+ #

 

  

 

/+ 

7

 "&  $ /  

,  /<

  

++ /   &  # + / &

/+ 

#



+ 

# ,



+

#*&

= 7   &

+

  &++,

&,

 

 -   

 

+

++/ 

& 8 99777:&+ (031**#

  &   @ A031

@ 01

$&

 +/  $ $+   

0/1

  

++#







&/  @$



  + $

 $   &  

  

  ,



#$ &

 &

+



&/  @ $

 &

 &

+ $C >    8   99777  :&+  (031   

 *  #



  /"&  $ *&

 

   

       &++ &

++#



+# @ A((7 8 3:&+ (0310/1#  

&

   

 ,&    ++#

, 



$

7

#

D

   #

8  #

,&

+& 0/1$&

/ D &  $,

D#

+& 01

$&

/ 

$  & 

+& 01

$+    + 

+,&

$E

 ##

# D

+& 0/1

&+/  

# F$+    F +& 01*& , #  



++##

#+$

&

 

  &  

  /+& 01"

 

    #     +       #

 D$+    

, &  +& 01:&+ 0(1 &/@&+ 031#  

 +/ &





&   +& 0/1

D

D ( GG GG GG (3 

8 3:&+ (* + & *

   G

 

 $$  +# 

+   

  

+ 

/

&   &/@ &+ 031

/     #

/

$

G 

/ +& ,

$&   &/@&+ 0(1

$ 

 &++  

$

   



, 

 *&   ,

,  G

   

&$

 &



, 

 ,

   &  

  2

&/

,

+  

, 

&/@&+ 031:&+ (

 



 

/& &  



 / G 

/

&

 &$

6

+ ,

  + 

$

 G 





+  $



&/@&+ 031

#+



   0(1#  

$&

 +/   $ $+   

#  

   

 ,&    ++#

, 





&/  $





+ $*+& 0/1 &/@&+ 031

$

$&

/ 

/&



,& ++#





$ + $

+ $

6



, 

& $ &  





*  



 

++ + 

$

+&



/





& +

,

6

/ $ ++

$ 

  

 8 3:&+ 0(1



, 

+ %

   +  

&     #&+   &+

&

&+



    ,



&

   +   $  +    &+

 

,   

 +

, 



, &



/

&

/ +#%

#

#+

+ 

+ 

$+  &+

&+$





 

 6

++  

++ &

&+

+

$

 #

& 

$  #

 / 

8  3  :&+  (031  * +   &  *    G 

  



 # 

+   +  

!

 

  

  # 

 #

#+     

 

++  

++

,  &+

,  &/+

$   *&

  

 /+   

$ 

 #+, &$&+



+#  &



 +



+

C

(. $ # ,

  /"&  $ *&

$  (

)

  *

    && 

  

 + ,-

./ /   &   @ A(.7 H" 

 8 H + 8 ...031 :*:0* +1(> 0...1"**-

+

& 

/ 

/&

 G

  A$+     C    A

 ,& C  /   ,

+ 

 

6 &, + $+

$ 

  

 

/+

, 

 A$+     C  

C &

/ 

   /  / +&

 &, /& 

*& 

+  /  #



+ $/

+

+  

+ $ 



+ ,

$

 

B

+ &  8 99777:&+ (031**

$&

/ 

/&

A$+   A

CA4$+   C

   $

 / /

:&+  &  & #

  " 

 -.  **     +&

  



&   &

 ,

 $

@

 

 +&  

+ &



A4$+   C$&

/ , + / +$ 

 & 

  

 

$ 



+ 

/



 ((7 8 99777:&+ (0310/1#  

&

   

 ,&    ++#

, 



$

7

#

C

   #

8  #

,&

+& 0/1$&

/ A &  $,

C#

+& 01

$&

/ 

$  & 

+& 01

$+    + 

+,&

$E

 

   #  #

 #  A

 

,& C

+& 0/1

&+/  

# I$+   J +& 01*& , #  



++##

#+$

&

  &  

  /+& 01"

#   +   #

A$+  

, &  +& 01:&+ 0(1 &/@&+ 031#  

 +/ &





&   +& 0/1

A

C ((

+

&

*



!!"

+  #$% 

     &

 '    (../   &   @ A(7

 

$

+



 $ ,

 

, /+  &

+

@

 6   #

 

&  +    &

+ 

  /  

 *&

 #

+ 

++ , 

 , $

  ++  6  *&

&/$

$ /+  &

+

# ++6

  

 

+

,    

   /



$ 

$

 

  $ 

+&



  

+ 

&

 #&+/ &



,+

#

,

 (3 7

  

, 

  8   99777  :&+  3  ** 

 

  6  



#

#+

&+  /

+ ;  &

+

 , 

# &+  < 

,  



# ++6

/  6 +*&

  

    +

 / 

 

   



 # ,

7 / /

$

&,

@

 &+  $  

  &

+ 

&+   + 

# ++ & /

$

+ 7

  

+*&

$$

++ ,+

@



+ 

(  



$

+/

& /&,

 

/+  &

  

 2( 

& &

 



,  /

# 

 ...2

#

& 

((..6

   ((..6



&

 #  

           (3..  

+#    /

2(,

 

++#  ... (  6

  

 #   +  

    

(3..6 &,

$

& &

&,   >.(. 

,/

  



#  

     #

$   

 

  &/$

 

&

&

++

/

+*& /& ++# /

++  #

 

   

  

     + /  +    +   

+ 

$

 $ 

$

+ 

  6   

+    $ /+  

  GGGC (  

/  



 ++#



$&

$

, 

8 99777:&+ (031**

+ ,

+ 

/ 

/&  +/  $ $+   

  

++#







&/  $





+ $ (3

&

+

$+

&  $

+  

/   $



$

6

/



&

8 99777:&+ (031017

&,

 

/  

+

, 

 &  #&+/ &



++#   + /"&  $  *&

     0

 &  &



#&+++

$/

&  8 99777 :&+ (0310/17  ' "&  $ *& &

,,

,  ,&+ 

+<

  

+

 &  # ++/ &

&

+



  

  

 

 #   +   / 

  

#+

 (-((.#

 #

  

   + #

"



 &

 7

 $ *& 

$

6

&+ / &

6 +*& 

,++# 

+ 

,  ( $

/  & +

 

 +  

+



,

&,    &/ ?&

 /   +   

    + 

&/$

&

$  < $ 

&  8  77:&+ ((** 

,  

$ # 

 

$ 

 + 

 

 

+

    

#  /+ ,   

+

    

  

<  

, +   



+  (  #/ 



 

  

 

$ 

   /

 ,8    &'&(    )



,  !

:

/+  2