← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5062/2016allowed

Rakesh Kumar v. Pinki And ORS

2019-03-14Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan11 pages

        



 

  

 !

"# $!%&'&"() *+*  ,!'- ./01 ****22!33( 4!1'/'

&(,& ($ " -!1'

****!'2"($!( '



 

  

    

      

 

      

 !" 

     #

!

 $ %     &

''''

45 

*

13 ( )   * +

,+ & -.  / %(- %-  01(- 12 -  -. )    3  - "  "     4 &* 5#&+  0    1 "12-" "" -. .% 

)  % ! && 

*660112

( %  "%  "

" +6 ,+ #

 ") %) ""%



8   (3- ""   4 &* 5#&+0 1"12"

"

) "

) "" (")  -" . "".   "   % " 

%-   

9:

) "   %) ! && ( (-  "    "    )    """ " ()")  -  .%  (: /% .)  -% -.

 .% "  )  " " "  " ("       )" )  ")""

: " (-  " -.)   "        "          )   "   ""

("-.(- )"

 -.  .   - : % ")   )-;

" 

  ) )    -;    )  "" "   % "  8 

((- ) " )     )  "  "  ""

 )  "  ) "

+ (   ) ) "-"

 -. %< , ) -(-    ")%  ) ""8 

% "

(        )       -     .

%               -.  )      )" %%!

5 - (!-   %% -) 

     

   

   !     "# $% & '    !# (      )!  !#   "  !# ($ %&   "#  ! (   * +  %"&   !    ! !    !#   , !   "$ %-&$ %& . # "# ( # "  "#   !      "# /#  # !   .  # !!#    !#  "#  .

      0   !" !+ %& .     "# /#  # !.   !" 0 0  "#  .       0   !" !+ 10   !#   " $ % &  0 "#  !    .          !#     !#   !  "#  !#   !  "# /#  "#    !# .          !#     "# .   23   ) !  -4 % 

-4&  !       "# /#     !#$

 %& ..  0.  0  %"&     !" 0 0 ..      0   , . 3   0  %&     . . ".    0  %&  0 #  "#

5,! $ 6   0  "   "#       "# /#  # !   .  # !!#    !#  "    0 "  "#   0         0   !" ! (.   ! (    /   !!# (   . (    !" !              (        !" !

%-& "/   !0  "$ % &  !#       "$ % &  0 # "#   !  #  !   (.

   #$ %& 0  !0  ) %"&     "# + %"&  !   .  # !!#    !#     ! , + 10  # !#    ( #   "#     # "            " 

0   ! 

             ,!#   !# (0  

%4&  !#  "   

   !!   )!       "#   

0   ! "# (  !#  

       !"   .  !" !  #  "/  (  !#     #  !" +  

   !   # " !"  

 

% & 2  0   "#    

 !0   )!       

( "#  !#   (  !"     ( 0 #   ,!#   !  0#   0   #     .. #  (   0  (  0    " .     #    70  # !"

%8& 9(. #.   # (     ".     .  !#       " "    #  !    ! !    !#  !  # "# (  !# !!  0      !     !

   %  &  

  

   !     "# $ % & '    !# (      )!  !#   "  !# ($ %&

%"&   !    ! !    !#   , !   "$ %-&$ %& . # "# ( # "  "#   !      "# /#  # ! .

(   .    !0    0   .  # !!#    !#  "#  .       0   !" !+ %&

:

;;;;

;;;;;

% ! !!& :!

50 20-202%1") "                1  )     1 .1 !%/  !  " #   $    "%  &'(()*+,(-=) "

  %% ** !

5 "    !  " #  .

/0%&'((1*1+ *2/+'-3  ' !   %!&  )     !0   8% &     4   ( 

% &         !      <    #   !0 ( 3    !      

  (  #      .  (   .    !0 ".

   . 0 =    !  )         ( " "  !#  !  !     "# /#     (   .    !0 ( ".    . 0    '

      



 ,  !#  >    > 

 "# ( ,! /#  # !   .   " "#  ,! /#  # ! . (   .    !0    0    "  !         

  0  ( !  .0   ,!  # !  (  0   (   .    !0 ".    0 ? "/    ) >     3    

  (   .    !0    0   !!  "#   ' 1# '   "       .    ( "# (#   !        ! (      "  ! . ". .0   (        !      

      "       

6  ".    "/   .      !0       

       ,! . (   .    !0    0 ( (    !$, ,! /#  # !    #   !    !$,. 

=     #     . (  ". (  (! 

 3.   !#      0     . 0  (   .    !0 ".    . 0 (  0  (     (   .   !0    

 "# /# ? /.    )  !      "   0  " #     !. /.   ?"  (     @. ) .#      !!  (

'      (  " "  !#.

 !   (  .    !0  ".    . 0 (  0  (     (  .   !0   

 # "# /# :

; ;;;;;;;;;;;;

% ! !!& (  !%  /  "           

%% **    %%)   - .%    -. )" ""  %%)  %   %  .            )      "    

 ) ""

 !%/ 4  / " #    "

/56 "  % &'((3*'+1

7 "

1 0 2  '        !      

   

   !0   

( !  !    (   .    !0      .  (   .    !0 ( ( " 0 "#  !#    !   . 0  (      .  !0   "#    ( !  !. !# . !. ( (   !        (    # !  ( !   ,   "      .#  !! :

$/  /" #     "

%

 % &'((-*'+*2/+71)"



1 0 2   > 1/ 0 2  2 0       !  .

? #     "    (    (  . !.    ,     !0(   !#       "    

? "            .   !0     !0 

% & ( 0  !  0 ( !      $,   ( (    "   ?" ?   (  (  "/       !! (  ! ( (  !#.  .  "     12- 128 12> 12  12

 12 -     ". 

  ( !3    (  . ( ( ".

   

. 0    !      ?#     "

 . !.    "0    !#  "#  !#      !    "#  ?"  # (  (   . 0.   0      

? 0(   (   "#  @ " !  )  %   #  %!&  (  2 $6  $ #  %!&    . "#  $/. <   !,  

/56 " # 

%!&

2 .  

         

     "#   %  &    ( ! <#        ( (   . (   .    !0    0 ? "#   (   0     !#  "#           #  (   .    !0    0 "   ! ?   1      0 "   ( # ! .  

( 0  ! ( ( 0.   . .  # !# (0 '

 (    (  #  1   #          ,! # !   "  %&  ) %"&  "$  % & 

( 0   (   .    !0 "  !. (  .  (

? "0     "#  )    %!&  (     A  (  !# (0 " !

%->& ' 0(   .   0 !0     0$$0  4  (    !   .   ( # ! 

   " " 0. .   ,  ( # 0 "      !#

B!.  0(  !0 

  (    !    !0    / # # "#   (   0  .  0   # !. 0.   . 0   (  " "  

'   %!&   "   "$ ) %&  ) %"&  "$ % & 

   !3  "# ( # "  "#  (   0  !     "# /#  # !   .  # !!#    !#  "#  .      0   !" ! 6   (  !. #. 0  !# !   0.  3   !. 0.   0 ? !   0(       ( # 0   !#    (   .    !0   # !.    . 0 (    (  (

'        !     

   

   !0   

( !  !    (   .    !0      .  (   .    !0 (  " 0 "#  !#    !   . 0  (      .  !0   "#    ( !  !. !# . !. ( (   !         (    # !  ( !   ,   "      .#  !! :

?   0( (    .

 6"

  0 !

/2"% 

0"

%-CC8$4&

C % ) &

'  .  "0  "#  @ " !  ) "# . !0 

      ( # ! .     (  0  ! ( ( 0.  . .  # !# " ( #   (  .    !0   "0  0 0# "     ( #.  .   

. 0  (  0        !!    !  "#   #  (         !! :

:   %%!

5  % . - - .%      -.    )      "           " ")"  ( )   * +

,+ &)"

 -. .

% % ) :     "      .     .   -     .   %    )



,+ *

45  "

  2 !3.E F 2 !" F