High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19846/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Sujender Singh Hooda And Another

2024-11-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!" #$%$!&'

#$%&'(()% %*%( +

(' )*( ++

+ ,

)*( + ++ + ( -!,./0 #)1 -23145,6 71

9 # .2:1 /!21 :15,6 718

;;;;

+ ,

- *2

!-22 1 3 +

52+

,15 + 1/ 8

2 - 1, 8 2

,1, <

&5 1 +1, ./ 2 41

, :,

7 * .!

,532 ./2741: 8

2- ,1.4/+

31144 3,

/ #012!.&3

> , ,1

181 82142!

-27 82 6752 7!

,2 ,1.4/ 8 ? + () 1 , 31 ,721 -,8

: 67

2: 8,721 -52 ,1.4/311,@ A8

48./2#,714B , < *2,1.4/4: 741: 82

31 >7, ./2 :+ !2

/52!

,212!+ 1,1.4/

31 2 1

. -1-- 161,./

8:41 / 67 +

84, 8 1++14 ,1, C

% 36 521:31 >7,./2++441 ::6,

,1,

*2 18 52 !-2

84, 7

, 1++14,1, "

5.!21:2114 . >7,./2 ++441 ::6,

,1,

C 4 -1-- 6,5

84,5.8

2 41

, :,

7 * .!

14 7

,5 32 ./ 2 71 1 72144 - 218

1, >7

*21,5.71: 3,6,

,1,<

*2 + 16+1 821,

= 17,2 18

%&%'(%&)

" #

&%&((%&*+ 4 -1-- 6,8

:218

1+1,!+

2$!+ 1&5./241

, :,

7* .!

147

,52

< +

8 ,12184,2 1-1 2 1 3 +

2 &" 2 &# %!"4$%!.2 " B8

7, - :1D1 88761,>!,71

2+ 3 +

5 1!8!411 78

, : -322

2.8144: 81 /,16E61 /::. 82,8 +

45.!+ 2. -

44, 21 :/5,+12 14 1-5!+

2.7 : - 4,511::. 827 :.11 ,8 71.42: 5 21: :1 -!

,7,5/2 1++ !+

52!+ 4: 2 7. -7

!1.4 . 2 7

- 14

. -7

!1.4 :1-- 161,

. 1 :41 6752!17F! ,58

:52+ 7+4

2 2>!,-: ,./2%

?.4+= 5 714, 1 $% & % "

5 +

, ' () * & ( + *2 461 +1 11+2 8 2 1, 6 ,7 1 = 17, 2 18 (,

" "

- . /01

" "

" 2

(%3 "

4 5 6 &,)(7

$288/5

&9:0 /0

8 "

" ;5 ' <5 &*/0=

/0> /

/5 ,0 /"08 "

;5 &*/0= /"08

" ?

" " ?

" ;&*/0= /"08 "

" @ A

;&*/0=B /"08 @ A

288 7C @ /@ 0 (%%( D 74 . C

6 7

9) ,

76 1, -$& 821.

6= 17,+ 7+45 2 !-2+ ,4/,741 52132 1,1.4/.7 : 14,!+

/::. 827 :.11 ,8 71.42: 51 ,3272

2 = 8

5 2 !+

5 2 !-2 1 / !72 ,1.4, ::. . 614,, 8

:2 :/5.!/ 2

.1- ,2. 8 8,1.4/+

24521- : 8,1.4/+

1 / ::. 827 :.11 ,8 71.42: 532 : 14,

32 1 ,1.4/ 1 F!1 !: 8

5 .! :+ 164/

1 ,741 1

: 2 #,714 B ,5 71 ,,4/

7 -2121,11 ,,1.4/. -1

.7 : -1-- 161,./:41 67*21,,741 1

: > ,./24 5 6 &,)(7 $288/5

&9:0 !

52 !-22 1+ !:+

1- , "2F2"2 ,+2/7141 ,: 142142 81 /::. 82 ,8 71.42: 7

,5+7144/32 121- 82 .7 : -

44,52

,1.

!2.7 : -. 321 /,1#

52 !-22 2 14 18!

!:+

5 21 32 1 / ,

2 5 2! 77!

!.F! 4/5 2 ./ 2 1, 21++ - 8 ,

- 81 /,15 .+ !:, .1F!4 82

- 67 1 1 ::. 8 2 ,8 7 1.42: :+ 164/52

6 -2

, 3: F!1. 8 $!+ 1&"2F2"27

,5.! ,

2:+4 / 51 ,

71521,

! :1 !

,721 -,52 !+

52741:1 .7 : 4, 76,1.4/+

51442817 , 7 7!:1 7 1 ,1 2

8 67 ./ 2

,51 .74 4/7 ! G,52!8

,741 -322 2

81 /,16E627

,51F!4F!1

8 :41 / 67 1 ,9

2 1: . - 1-- 161, ./

. 1 :41 67

B211:1/52 :14 8

218!

7+4$&21/2 71 ., 14 8,1.4/+

,5.!

4/!+

0 1&2: 8177+1 7 827

, :41 / 675 :

-.7 : - 7

,,./2#,714 , 616 2 . - . 32 1 ,1 3272 36 5.7 :7

74!,, ./

-2:

8 : 4, .& / 8!

2 85 :1/ 14

!.F! 4/.7 :7

74!,,./2#,714B ,5

1 8

8 :41 / 67

. 1 :41 675 21:. -1

- 14,1 !

582:,714 +

2 4,212,17 !4,

216. ,7,

:,714=1: 1

827

,. :1,52!+

2.7 : - 4, 6752 !+

52 1:344

.,:, 2161 ,!

- 675/ 2 !1

$!+ 1&52#,714B , 12 1

74!, - < #

514 ,741 , !+ 1521:1 ,1

2#,714B , 8 32-!,4 41,, 21+

82H)!, #,714$#41 /

IH( 4: 0 ) 14 7+4H *2 8

521 .

3, : ,322 : 21.

6+ 7+45322 12: 8 4: 82+

2 :/52!18 1+ 4: /:,714=1: 1

. -:1, "22"214252!1

.71: 7

,,1.

:,1. -2:1 ,9

322 :

.71:1++ ,, 2121,,131 1,

:1 1-#

514

., : ,58

:2817121 ,5322 2 1 71!14 =! 2 !+

82,151 ,9

52!+ 2

44: 82+

1D - +4175 "22" 2 176

./ 2: :41 67532 ./52 :1/7

74!,212

2,1.! 311F!4 82 - 67 2 :/ ,1!72311 .!1.4

.71:1-- 161,./2 :41 67 C 1,,

514 .-12 ,8

,5322 2#,714B ,5,, 144/+

7, :1D1 ,14, 761 7, 14727D5+1 7!41 4/1++ 1 - 2 1,6 82,152

!-2:+4 /: 81 8 :,714 72 F!5 2! !

64 - 2 .4 7D 721 - 7 7

32 8

:5 2,1.71: 7,#

5821, :+4 /: 814!41 4/52 ./:1/.7 :7

74!,,F!1 !+

2 852!!.F! 21++ 4: 1D +4175 31

- 14.! 3,

:41 67.,. -1

: -1-- 161, ./+

:1 7 8:41 67

4/582!+ 1:+4 /, 72 F!121- 81++ 4: 1D -+41752!./2 #,714B ,7

,541, 17

74!

5212 1

:1 7, 7 81 /,15.!/21,,

:1 ,1

2. -2 4: 81 /+

4 21 :/5 16/

7!41 4/2!.F! 176,7

9 !+

2 85 ,!

-27 8

8:41 675.!3 !4, 1!

144/ 41, 13447

74!

./2#,714B ,521176 !+

.! .71: 7, 8

: 1 8876 71!14 - 7 7

32 ./2 3 !4,., 14 8,1.4/+

% 36 5

3 21, ,16 52 , .= 17 -27

82 +

51.71: 7

,,./2

41:,714.

, ,-!!, ,. /01 21$!3 4,#$ 1!1441

2+ 821.4/32 677

3 1.4/ .!1.4

67$J9& -- 161, ./ 67$J9&

7, 32 67 1

971!9+7 87 7

1 , + , 67 $J9& $1&

/ / 1 $& $4,& K $ & J( , 721 ,! ,1,

"< 1

91!9+7877

1 ,+ , 670 8,1.4'!

< 324+ , +171

1<B521 ,-1 2

5 ,6,!14 21 6, +171

4/*2

74 :1 71

8 9 1 4, 19%9+ 67% 752,1.4/7

, , " 1, - 82 7

, 6142112: 82 1++ 4: 1D -+417

.71::1, :

82+ 7+4$!+ 1&,741 ,./2%

?.4+= 71 4,1$% & % "

'5)./2#,714 ,521 :,132722 36 5,,

.,2+

5 : 4, 2 :/5,,:1D+ 4: /

- 8 5 2 ,741 1

8 413 >!,-: $!+ 1& 21 ./2 1+ !:+

212 7!

- 821,,1 311F!4 8

8 675 .816 1.4/ , 3,6162

*2 !-2 2 1, + !:+

.!1.4.!2

! 41,6, 7 .!21,+ !:+

.71: 71 !+

2 +

% 36 5 2 1, 71 6, 1,,!7 -,721 - -

!6162

5 8

7 - 4/

.! -21,+ !:+

5.! 1!

144/14 ,,711

,!/14 !+

2#,714B ,5 -1-48 2 ,16 1 2 -5 2

!-2 :+4 /: 8 2 1 8 .4 7D 721

- 7 71!14 7

72 F!$&5 32 ./ :1/ .71:

164,212

- 82,1

21 :/+

45 .71: 7,8

:1 7, 14- 781:4/2

./3114 .1, 2:,714 +

521 2,1.!8

13448

:, 1

3117

- 14,1 ,.71: 2 1-- 161,./

.71:1 :41 / 67 % 36 51 1, - 8 +

$!+ 1&5,74 2121 . 7

,, 1 /+,8

:1 ,

216. 7

,, 2 = $!+ 1& 1,4/5 7

6, 7 .! 2 !:+

$!+ 1&21. 4,./2+

52 ./52 7

1 -6

3-21- 2 +

82:,714.

,5 1 = 17, $!+ 1&

+7!

!4/5 2 ./

7 , 7 71 . 1- 2!+ 144

:, 1

5.,2 ./2

82,171

.1, .1F!4 81 7, 14- 7 81:4/2

4/5 .,741 1 8

8:41 67 1,,

5 .,741

.1 .!1.4

: -1-- 161,./

8:41 67 ./2+

52 !-21,2 212,1$&

77!

,324 67.71:+

:,./2,8 7+

1+171 15.! 72

=+ :1 ,1 2

461 -!41

53272:1D2

- 82,1$& 1 +171 15

.-18!

F!4211!725?

-,,

1 8

8:41 67

.71:1-- 161, ./

82:41 67 7

F! 752417D 821, =+ :1 ,1 2 -!41

5 , 7

1 2

74!,5216 82

- 821,,1$&!+

2! 77!

, 1+171 152 ./521,

- 1 . ,741 , .7 : 1-- 161, ./

. 1

8:41 67

5 7 : 82>!,-: ,./2 += 5 714,16

" # ?

& ,

*+ 7 32 51,741 1

:1, 2 = 5212. 8 8

, - 885 21 : , 3, 27

,!41 4/14 2 !

1 ,81.4 -2 .71: 6, 2 +

2 D - F!1 2 1++

, - 88. -:1, 2816

(6 3 7 2 ,741 1

8 413 :1,

,7$!+ 1&:1D21,,741 1

.1 =+ !41

8413 :52 ./52=+ !41

8413 :51:1, 6 ,7 $!+ 1&14 :1D22 !

,. 8616 2 ,8 7 +

4 7

,5 5 5 14 4 2

,52! 11 /:D2- - 82 , 3: 1 :1,2 !

51 ,21

5 28!447 :+4: 51+4 !

5.,

+76 82.1 581 /5 8,41/1 ,4172

*2 8

5 2 - - 8 2 . 8 8 2 1++

, - 885 : 826 ,7$!+ 1& ,./2* .!

,514 ,

!88 8

:1 /44-14/1 , . !+24,

$& / 23 2!"4$%!.2

< 18 :1252 8 ,

: 23 +

,32 . 61

6521:,:,

*2:+!- ,

51+1,./241

,* .!

,5:1 1 ,1 ,188 :,

C + , 814

-32144+ , -1++471

$&581 / 5+

+ ,

5+ + (6

'L 22 +1D -9 1

, J9

22 +

1.4 J9