High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6117/2015dismissed

Kamlesh And ORS v. Vijay Singh And ORS

2017-11-13Lok Adalat Bench - 34 pages

"#$%"%&' (

)"*"&+'

)%$+,-./)01/)./ %2#/+" ) ) /%/2 %2#/+" )+1"/33"44/&+* )5/4$+/)6 %2#/+" ))"*3&%"&+(7&*-)/&#"

1" 3)"*"&+ /33"/4 $* /6/$&*+ +1" /8/)% %/+"%

3/**"% 9: +)##$%"&+*4/$.*)$9-&/4 "8/)$ ) *1)+ ;+1"

)$9-&/4; & <=

= /%/&5/4/6"%= :"/)*."+8$+1/.+) 2"1$#-4/)/##$%"&+"8/*%)$2$&6+1".+)#:#4"9"/)$&6)"6$*+)/+$& 7(7

1"*/$%.+)#:#4"8/*9/&6"%9:/+)-#>9"/)$&6 )"6$*+)/+$& 7( 7= )*1)+ ;+1"

"&%$&62"1$#4"*/ )"*-4+ +1" /##$%"&+ /%/& 5/4 *-

")"% 6)$"2-* $&?-)$"* /&% *-##-.9"%+$&?-)$"*&1$*8/:++1"1*3$+/4 %/+"% <=

=8/*)"6$*+")"%/+4$#"0+/+$&$+:"8/)$ 1"4"6/41"$)* +1"%"#"/*"% $4"%/#4/$.3"+$+$&-&%") 0"#+$& +1"+)@"1$#4"*#+ <!! )*1)+ ;+1"#+; 1")$9-&/4/ +")#&*$%")$&6+1""2$%"&#"/&%8$+&"**"* /8/)%"%/*-. *< =

A7/4&68$+1$&+")"*+BC3")/&&-.

1" /.-&+ /8/)%"% $&#4-%"* / *-. * (

A7 +8/)%* #&2"&+$&/41"/%* 1/2"1"/)%4"/)&"%#-&*"4 )+1"3/)+$"*/&%3")-*"%+1"

3/3")79> 1")"$*&%$*3-+"&+1" /#+ +1"#/*"8$+1)"6/)%+ $&242"."&+ +1"

"&%$&62"1$#4"/&%+1")/*1/&%&"64$6"&+%)$2$&6 +1"

"&%$&62"1$#4" 5"/)&"% #-&*"4 ) +1" /33"44/&+* /)6-"* +1/+ +1"

#.3"&*/+$&/8/)%"%9:+1")$9-&/4$*&+1"48")*$%"1"$&#." /**"**"% *

A73").&+1 $*/4*&+1"48")*$%"/*+1"%"#"/*"% 8/*/*>$44"%./*&/&%8/*"/)&$&6* !

A73").&+1 5"/)&"% #-&*"4 ) +1" &*-)/&#" #.3/&: )"*$*+"% +1" "&1/&#"."&+/&%)/+1")/)6-"*+1/++1"/.-&+/8/)%"%$*&+1"1$61") *$%"$*6)$"2/&#"$*+1/+* (

A71/*9""&/8/)%"%-&%")+1"

#&2"&+$&/41"/%*" -)+1")#&+"&%"%+1/++1"#4/$./&+*8")"&+ /94"+3)2"+1""/)&$&6 +1"%"#"/*"% 1"#4/$.8/*./%"+1/++1"%"#"/*"%8/*/*>$44"%./*& /&%8/*"/)&$&6* !

A73").&+11")"8/*&"2$%"&#"3)%-#"% 9"

)"+1")$9-&/4+*-9*+/&+$/+"+1"*/$%#4/$.&/9*"&#" /&:*-#1 ./+")$/4 +1"6-"**8)>1/*+9"+1")" )#.3-+$&6+1"#.3"&*/+$& &" +1"*/ "*+:/)%*+$#>/2/$4/94"8$+1+1")$9-&/4+)"4:-3&8/* +1".$&$.-.8/6"*3)"2/4"&+/++1"+$." /##$%"&+1"/##$%"&+ ##-))"%& <=

=/&%+1".&+14:8/6"* )-&7*>$44"%4/9-)")/+ +1/++$."8/**= A7/&%+1")$9-&/41/*/4)"/%:9""&+/>"&$&+ #&*$%")/+$&+1".&+14:$&#." +1"%"#"/*"%/+*

A7&*-#1

( *$+-/+$& &6)$"2/&#"#/&9")/$*"%9:+1"/33"44/&+* *3")4/+"*+%"#$*$& +1"&;94"3"D-)+$&#/*"

%"#$%"%&(

$+1/*9""&1"4%+1/+/&/.-&+ *

A7 -&%")#&2"&+$&/41"/%*1/*+9"/8/)%"%*

A7 )4**

"*+/+" *

A7 ) -&")/4"D3"&*"* /&%*=

A7 )#&*)+$-. &+1"3)"*"&+#/*" /*-. *

A71/*9""&/8/)%"%

)4** #&*)+$-. *

A7 ) -&")/4"D3"&*"*/&%*

)4** "*+/+"0$&#"+1"$&#." +1"%"#"/*"%/**"**"%8/*&+1"

6-"**78)> $+8-4%&+9"/33)3)$/+"+)"%-#"+1"#.3"&*/+$& /8/)%"%9:+1")$9-&/4314%$&6+1"/8/)%3/**"%9:+1")$9-&/4 +1"/.-&+ #&2"&+$&/41"/%*8-4%#.3"&*/+"$&/))$2$&6/+?-*+ /&%)"/*&/94"/.-&+ )4** %"3"&%"&#:1-61$+./:&+1/2"

9""&3)2"%&)"#)%+1/+1"8/*/*>$44"%./*&9-+*-#1/#4/$.8/* ./%" & *-#1 #$)#-.*+/&#"* *$&#" +1" .&+14: "/)&$&6 / -&*>$44"% 4/9-") 1/* 9""& +/>"& +1" "D#"** /.-&+ /8/)%"% ) #&2"&+$&/41"/%*8-4%9"/#.3"&*/+):/.-&+ )#/4#-4/+$&6+1"

4** %"3"&%"&#: 1"3"D-)+$&#/*"

(0<!1/*1"4%/*-&%")'7 E !F1"&8" $&%+1/+-&%")&"1"/% )"/*&/94"/.-&+ 1/*9""&/8/)%"%/&%-&%")/&+1")1"/% &+1$&61/*9""& /8/)%"%+1-61$+*1-4%1/2"9""&*/8/)%"%/&%/++1" */."+$." 8"&+$#"+1/+"2"&+-/4 $6-)" +1"/8/)%

= #.3"&*/+$&3/:/94"++1"#4/$./&+*/33"/)*+9"?-*+/&% )"/*&/94"+1"&$&*-#1"2"&+-/4$+: 8"%&+#&*$%")$+ 3)3")+$&+") ")"$&*-#1/8/)%$&-)/33"44/+"?-)$*%$#+$& -&%"))+$#4" ( +1"&*+$+-+$&&+1")8)%* $ 9:

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

J *%

F1"+1")*3"/>$&6A)"/*&"% "*A F1"+1")"3)+/94"

"*A