High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7730/2014allowed

Jaswinder v. Sanjay Kumar & ORS

2019-05-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

""## $!% &'()%*!+!

," -!

&%*.%"/0/ !+""##

*"&/0!

&'($!*/0 !!"1

.2+%+!/0!

$2+%+!/0 !!"1

4!#( / + + ! + "!5#*6 !&+ 7!(/89%(!/ !&+18!/-#&+/!)%!%7+!+ 9!%8+ #* " %! & ::/ / + !

$+#/ ;;8!" &'()%*!6!0!/+% )%*!6 !<==%!2*"(>*6%!! *!(#9!8!8!1 ?,, +!!!!! +80+#/#*8*"+%,

"!+0!+"!5#* + !%!8!*0##8@8!++%&+18!/ -#&+/!)%!%7+!!##8089#+ !7+ 5!A+9%: "

* +++'%!&%8! B8+4!8 88+#+!/+## %!"1 &'()%*!!08+*!(#0!( +8+"!+8#8*!88+ !8 +!++!7+ 5!+"!5#*/!%#+ "!5#*!0!%'%!+#8+!8+#8 !%!A+8 !&8+/9!+!+"!5#* +!!0+" +%*9!+8 0+#A+!+&'()%*!!0!#8 ++ *!(# + # + "A + + "! 7 2?2 &++9!* +!+ !!!>1-?"#/)%!%7+!A+ !*#=, +!8!+C% #8 !8+#*/++", ;/5+ !*/*/!"!/"#

98"%+#*"/##++! !" ""! # ! * ' ! *+9#9(!"1 / +!!" 1 6%!*"(+#"! !*

=+' !*#9(!"1 / +( 7 %" 0!% "!#*!( 9' 8 + + #*+#%#+#*"A++#* " 9!*'!'!!("!

*!/%+!"+(+9%9( !"1 +#!08!+8#8*!/!+! +0!(0#0*+*!(#C%+ ,%8+!*8##8+#*"/%+ !""!(!*#+#*"

," 1 6 %! *"( ! *+#!0!%#8#9'*!(8+ C%%9*8+#0!+9"%%" !!#*(!*+ !8!" !8%+ !"/+*!(#C% 98"# +%(0# 0!08# =+/%+!"#"!(!

*#+#*"

+ "#8 + "!/ ## 8 % ! !*

B++!+*!0+# %* !+8#8!08*!(#9!8!8! 1 ?,, !09(&'()%*!!"1 D--

B++!+!"!0!!0+# +08 0#!08#+*##8D-,

B++!+"!#*"% '%!%9(+*+!D=/ +

*%!* +*D--

4++"!#0%""!+!!"0 #*

=!!"!0+/+"!5#*8+ *!!-B 9E*8!

- 4+!#-B !

, > !(-B

+ +! +/ !" 1 ! 0"(!08# !7/"(!8!!

!74"(%!"#( !72/ +!!"1 !0+##+FE , "(%!"#( FE ,

! +!8 #! %# ! + "!/ + #* " *9(+@!9%#0 ! / ++#+#*88!0++#""#9!+ 2%!/ ++ %!"/ +"%""! +!%8+%# =+0+!#!%#!+"!988 +!%8++!!=++ !C%%9# #9#9 @+ @!9%# + % + #* *#( ! + !++*! !"!+"#!"!E( !0#!*+!"!%!& 2! - /!%C +"#!8!8*'%!>1-?"#/ )%!%7+!+! E"# +(+"#

!!*+#*5'%!+*( ;

++!%C !0+"#A+!*+"!%# *"! !!!!*#/*% + !8! %*9! + *!(# #! ! !!8*A+ !%!8+!E*+ + >, "!"!2?2&++9/ +!+*( #!*+%* "( >,FE -:"#!! 9("!5#*+*#+ 8++ !*#8##( E*2?2&++9 ;

!* +!+ !!! >1-?"#/)%!%7+!/+%8+ *+ >,+ "!!0'%!! +*!(#9% + 0#0* *!(# 9#+ 9( + "!9(#88080 *!!

++ 8++*+@!9%# +#+%8+"! +#*!8!%*9!+*!(# 9( 8 !9%8 ! E* 9(+ #* >! %# ! + !" 1 6 %! *"( + !!! %+!(

" +! 9!0++%"!00#0*!+8#8 !08+80+#+#* @+!9("% +%+"!"#

? 0!+/+#*+%%##(+!8+ %"!"#%"+* &*+#* !

: +!"!0%#!0!+ ++ 79(+*+#*" %!+!*!/+=, +!8! + #!8!9!09(+@!9%##/ *+ >,+"!+!0'%!! ++*!(# @+!!/+'%8* *+#"+!"(*!

? 0!/=++@!9%#%!#(! %# ++0%9(+#**(+ #* ! +%('%9#! !+08 !0'%!+ *" +"! +"%#9%9 @+! !!+*0#0 0+#+ !8#( =+*/++!"++ 0!80+#*"8+!E* ##

,"1 6&'()%*!+""!+ 9E !9%+0%9(+#* @+!!/+0 9!%8+#9(+#*+8!9%+%#+09 9#0!+!+!'88!08! +! %++8+@!9%#%1 !0!+%0%!+"!5#* 8 + !" +#8 + *! 0+# %*!+8#8!08+8 0+#!09(&'()%*!6!"1

1 *8%1 @+%"!08+% %"!"1 6%!*"(9%+#9!8 (0!!"!0+% "+"(!08#

"#!! !7 1*" *%**+ !#!*+/ ++"%!"!#(%+# + ++#C%+9%!"1

9(+!++*!89!%*

@+%+%!*"(+#+!8+%"! "#%" @+@!9%#+ !8#(808+%'% 9((8++*+9*!%/ +!

&*#!#( +!8!%1 /+@!9%#!!!*808 (8++%+#9*!% 1 0 +880%1 /"!0 + + !" 1 %+! + 9( !08 + 80+# +++#*+%!'%! ##+ +!!" !0!/ !%!*"(!#9# "(*"+"!5#* 1 +C%+ C%%* @+#*+"!00!!* -

?"#/)%!%7+!+ 8+ !8;(!*# C!2++%!'%! ++"# !""#AE!( E*+ !%!#!#(#9!8+#8!%! #!#*###%!8+#8A+! !%!+!8+#8+ +!8, / 5 4##FE -+!*"!!"#"

FE -+9#(!+ 89#('%!9

@+#*5"! !+0FE -B 5/ +++ +"## ++""!8-B ++++ "*!+, ;/5+!*/*/+"#

; +!8/"#!"! *!*% (9"++ !78089#0!!8 , /5"!*+9%'%!++%!+%8# * -B !

- 4+!#/ !+" &%!8/ - ?"#/ )%!%7+!+E*++%!

## &'

( " #

)

# ) #

# $%#

" -. /01

#1#1#

23$*#

$% 23$ -B!

, > !(/&! #!/2?2&++9 ++

+#8 +!

%7+)%*!/ # &%"! !

+% &+!*/ "%( 20# &%!8 )%!%7+!+E*" !7!/(! *#/ ! 0##8 )%!/ ! )%!%7+! + # "+(#9#( 9 G!9%"!%* !!*0*!8+7' ?+"!0+9#( !%9( *9!4!#%8+*FE -

9(-B!

- 4+!#/!+"&%!8/ -

?"#/)%!%7+!/%*, / 5 +!8!*+'%! 9(+!+"# *!**7 #8+0!( %#+0##+*#9##/!"%!+* &* +9##5!"8 # +! * * +* ! "%!+ +%!!( +% 78 ! % 9##5!" &* *%9 !+#* !%%!*#E" # @+!!/=*"!"!""!"! !%* ,

/5+"!5#* !*#E"

!8!"#/"!%!8'%! "#!!#("!"!!0!( = !%*,

/5 %!++

)"80 +"!+"#H%! '%!+#* %#+08++"#!## %" !*#/%*, / 5 !+*% !"!

@+#*+08%!'%!!C%!+#" %!8 + "! + +"#H + 88 +"#!## %"!* %*, / 5!8#( !+""##5#*+!

=*(0 !8+%*9!'%!%!9( +#*/"!+"#H/0!(%#C%(+ "%!8%!89("!%!8'%!(!C%!8#8 +"#H/%!8!## %"!* )"80 + !%*+/= !%*, /5%!

@+"!5#*089#0!!8%* , /5"!*+%%!8'%!/+*8+ +09 !7!!9#* = !%*, /5 %!++#*

@+#*%'%!%!9(+* %# 99# #7/!%!+%#"!!+ %* , /5 !+*%#*# E"#

>!%#!+#*+!!!%+!( !!

# $

! % & ' !

()*+ , , -**./0 9(+ "E2%! +!+"E2%!+# "!*!! ! *""!*9#(##

!"!*9#(%" G, >7+

9#(90 G%"G, #7+

9#(%":G,

#7+

09#(%" G,

#7+

09#(90 G, :#7+

@++#*0!9(0%#( +!%9#( G%"G/*%, #7+ 8!*" @+!!/= !*" , #7+%!++ @+%+#*"*%, /:

/5 !8#(/+""#" @+ !+""# *", /:

/5 +!I

!*+#8#*"##%#!#H9 +"+!%8+%! !#*"(9#9(##++! !"'#(0!##(

4!'

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#