Rajan Singla v. General Public And Others
!"# ! $
%&!"# ' &!"#
%!"#
( )
& '$ *+, ( *( -
" !)./
0 " 12 &
#
&&# $
& '$ 3
4
))*)(/"
67(2
( &
' $ # , &
5 ))*)(
( , $ #
$ ! ,
& 9)):
$
3 : -
&& & '$
3
4, , # ! ,
&
5 ))*)( ,
&!;,
, & -
& ' $ ,
&
< "7):+!
4'! 7)! &
& ))))9/"
67)2"
5 !
"7):+!
4'! 7)! &
= $
#
! ! ,
$ $
& , > 7
, 8
'
!, 5
"7! - / & 2 <
37 # $! ?4, ! & !
&& @(
$
)@(
, , $ =
@(
$
# $ $
, &8 5 ))*)(6 $
(
5 6
,
,
&$ 3"! "# !
3! "
$3"!"# !
3! -
3 & '$ ))))9
! , # # $ $ # !
(!
,
$
& )9))+ ,
$ ! )9))+
6 "
6 7 -, #
3!& *+ -
" !). 0
# A 1/"
672 "
!&! # /"
6 7+2
,
#
&
#
#
#! "
! &
)7 67 # ()) /"
6 7.2 8 ,
& , $
(
"
&
& , &
6 "
679 +
, 6&
"
!& # @ &
6 "
67))B
,
!
3 " , "
, 6&
57 57(
#$ & $ & #
6
9 5 #$
6
))*)("
, , , (::
# , #
#
/ 2 *( "
$,
<$ ! !
B& $ # & , 6
)!@7
& !
$
3
- # , ! "
! ! # ::: &
, , " # & ,
, # "
! & & ,
,
,
5 , $ # , # &
(
, &
&
6
5 ))*)( * C#
!
( # , , & )9.:
$
5 /"
67(2, & $ & 6 $ !& '$ # $ #
,
$&
$6 5 /"
67(2
# ! ,
C# #
( # , , &
)7 $ #
9)):
$ ,
5 " $! "
):)
3
# .),
, ' C65)@) $ 5 ))*)(,
, ' C65)@/
,
,
3 &, 2 4
(
$
,
76&
# ,
( , &
6 5 ))*)(
$!
76&
,
,
;
8 ):)
, 7
!
"
#
$%&
'
(
) * +
,-,*,* #
./0 /" "
1
"
"
"
2
1
) * + "
3/"
3/"
)41 4 "
) * + "
/
,5*,+
"
&
,+,+*,* " # ,67 "
%& 89
" $%&
+5 " 37:
1 # 34 9 ;
9"
< 3**,,* ) 6-,+-+7-+-5= 4 " ,-,*,* ./0
,5*,+ ./0* !"#$#%&' (&) *++% )(!,% -! -(#) !."- &%/ "+-."%+/ >///00!"-.%#-1$#2+% %2? 7,*,*@ 9 # "
! , ,
,
5 !,
C65)@)
, 7 !!4;
84
+5 $ %& " 37:
1 # 9 ;
6 9"
< 3 **,,*
)"
6-,+-+7-+-5=
";
" " 6 4"
1
" 1 $"# 0 1 $ 1 A
B
BC D *,+ * (&--(+)&#/3#'',&)/"&4-+/*1(.*(&)((&%/ "!"& /2!5&-+ 6.".$"&7 &- -(+ #%)-".5-#!%) !4 &%/ #% 0"+)+%5+ !4 &-+ " 8"+7 (&%9+" 1%$(&' (&- -(+
! 5!%-+%-)!4)&#/3#''/&-+/ :
;,+"+/.'1"+&/-!!2+" &%/+ 0'&#%+/-!-(++)-&-!"*1("!"& ; (&- -(+ )&#/ 3#'' ,&) )#$%+/ *1 -(+ +)-&-!" #% 71 0"+)+%5+ &%/ #% -(+ 0"+)+%5+ !4 ( "!"& *+#%$ -(+ !-(+" --+)-#%$ 3#-%+)) -(+"+#% ,(! &')! &00+%/+/ (#) )#$%&-."+!%-(+)&#/3#''#%710"+)+%5+(&-0+")!%&''1 )&, -(+ +)-&-!" &00+%/#%$ (#) )#$%&-."+ !% -(+ )&#/ 3#'' /&-+/ :
;)&1-(&--(+)#$%#%$!4-(+3#'',&)/!%+ 2!'.%-&"#'1,#-(!.-&%15!+"5#!%&%/#%4.''5!%)5#!.)%+)) *1-(++)-&-!"&4-+""+&/#%$&%/.%/+")-&%/#%$#-)5!%-+%-) )&1-(&--(++)-&-!",&)#%)!.%/7#%/&%/5&0&*'+ !47&9#%$/+5#)#!%)&--(+-#7+!4)#$%#%$-(+)&#/3#'')&1 -(&--(++ +5.-#!%!4-(+3#'',&)/!%+!.-!4-(++)-&-!" ) 4"++,#''&%/2!'#-#!% (&- (&/ &00+%/+/ 71 )#$%&-."+ &) &% &--+)-#%$ ,#-%+))!%-(+)&#/3#''/&-+/ :
;#%-(+0"+)+%5+!4 -(+ +)-&-!" &%/ #% -(+ 0"+)+%5+ !4 !-(+" --+)-#%$ 3#-%+)) #+ ( "!"& ,(+% #- ,&) 0"+)+%-+/ 4!" "+$#)-"&-#!% *+4!"+.*+$#)-"&"6.".$"&7 < (&- -(+ .*+$#)-"&" 6.".$"&7 "+&/ !2+" &%/ + 0'&#%+/ -(+ 5!%-+%-) !4 3#'' /&-+/ :
; -! -(+ +)-&-!"&%/-!-(+&--+)-#%$,#-%+))+)
1 "#
"
"#
3% "
"
"#
1 "# 5 4 "
1 $"#
"
" /
=
/ " 4
/
" #,
, "
$ ,
,
))*)(6 $& '$ $
3 "!"# !&- 5 , $# 6
$3" ,
$
"
>
3"!,
5
-, $'
,
5 # $!, $
8 # "
&$ #
5 ))*)( -, # $ # ).)):
3 "!
,
5 ! , $
3 7)):73--7:,
$
6 5 . D& # &
# , && !
6
5 ))*)( $ #
5
& & '$ ;
& #
$ $ #!
( $ #
& $ #
$&
, 8 !
$ ,
))*)(!
) B
! , #
#$ $
&
$
3# $,
& 5
=
3 !
B& $
& $
& B& $ < 3
=+*&*"&-&&(&+)-&7+%-&"18+-#-#!% !
;> !4
/+5#/+/!%
;" & ,
,
! 8 & $
, $
,
,
B& $ < 3! $ ,
5 B # &,
6
)!@7-
! B& $ < 3 '
#
*( " &
# $
, & )!@7! !
! 8 , #
@ &
B& $ < 3, #
# , #
*(/2 " - , $
#
! ! ! , 3
,
8 # &
, 7 * " %
"
&
' ?8"+'#7#%&"1*@+5-#!% !,(#)8+-#-#!%&% +8"!5++/+/3(+%=+5+&)+/ +)#/#%$-(&%+%/.-)#/+(+."#)/#5-#!%%/ 8"!0+"-1 (!,% % 5(+/.'+ ) ')! #-.&-+/ - .-)#/+(+."#)/#5-#!%8'+&)++"#41%/8+-#-#!%!
+55+0-+/A"!7+)-&7+%-&"1+$#)-"&"B + "
$ E
/ %, ,,,03 4 " 7 "
*5+
4
-* 63
B*5+ !%5'.)#2+%+)) !4 0"!*&-+ !" '+--+") !4 &/7#%#)-"&-#!%
"
"
""
"
"
"
"
" 6 8"!2#/+/ -(&- 0"!*&-+) &%/ '+--+") !4 &/7#%#)-"&-#!% $"&%-+/ AC*1&#$(!."-!" C ;
D " /
&
D D
"
/ )(&''.%'+))!-(+",#)+/#"+5-+/*1-(+$"&%-(&2+'#9+ +44+5--("!.$(!.--(+!-(+"-&-+)B /// /// /// (&2+(+&"/-(+'+&"%+/!.%)+'&00+&"#%$!%*+(&'4 !4-(+8+-#-#!%+"&%/&')!5!%)#/+"+/-(+0"!2#)#!%)!4)+5-#!%
:;!4-(+%/#&%.55+))#!%5-> &7)&-#)4#+/-(&-#% -(+4&5-)!4-(+0"+)+%-5&)+-(+0"+'#7#%&"1!*@+5-#!%"&#)+/ *1-(++)-&7+%-&"1+$#)-"&"#)"+C.#"+/-!*+!2+"".'+/- #)5'+&"4"!7-(+&*!2+-(&-)#%5+-(+2&'.+!4-(+0"!0+"-1 ,(#5( #) )#-.&-+/!.-)#/+-(+-&-+!4&(&"&)(-"&#)7!"+ -(&% )
D -(+ =#)-"#5- ./$+ (&%+ ,!.'/ %!- (&2+
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
01
"
&
@ ))
! & & % '< 3
"#2&).*"&7&%#&%
&'&@#&%/!-(+")2) #'!8 8%! !4
/+5#/+/!%
,
# 5 ,
B
&, 8 3% '
,
, # 5 ):)))
) - #/(# .9&' 2) 6+%+"&' 8.*'#5
:#2#'<>>3
B
3'
3 , ,
!
#
# , #
* " ! 3 3 ,
#
3 # ,
)( -
, &
&
&! ! 3 6
#&, #
&<,#!
# $
<$ !
B& $
& )!@7! !
3 , #
#
*( "
3, #
& ): %
# , # & !
,
$
5 ))*)(6 $& '$ )
! $!
# , # #$%&
'() * ;F"
'
@ E @; E @;