High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5038/2010allowed

Mahender Singh v. Vir Bhan Etc.

2016-01-13Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh13 pages

!"#

$% "!!

"##$$

% &' !

# ("" # $$## )* $$'"+%& ,

"# ,

("" "+%& "%$* # "&,

$% "!!& -"# ##$"* &"+%& #*)"$ .%& /"' #& " ##$ $ *) # & " +%& 0 1#*)"$2!$.%& 3 !42" 5" 6% &"%

$*)"##$$7#$

-" $! #$ "# ##$ " %5"* % # 3 4'' # $ & 5$ 8"' 18" #

+ * ") 99 90-"$' &&'"#

% 1 " %*"2" % ":

7&% $##$ 1 99*#

99$$$ # &$)$05$ $ 5$$ 703 4 8"' 1 8" /" % +/" %$ $ 1 !$ 09 99 7' #"'"$ 1 ' +%' && )%5"* :% $& "##$$6%05$ $ $$& 8$$ 70 $ ' #"" & & ' & *#" :% $ 1999; '$& " # "$$&"$

&&*) 999; % " !

" " %5"*

$).& $$%'" # ! ##$9 9991 #

$$5$ $%

$ &15$1 $ 5"'0 71 8" '""'& 9 99 # *

%$00 999 6%05$ $%

5$ 5"' 15" '"%)#

$$ "$ :%*).& $00*&"

&" "##$$ # $"'

% "& $$;!

"$ # '""#

'5 "$ )*$* "$':%

"##$$ 1999-"##$$" &" $

"%$<" % " "$$& *$) " % $% "##$$ $"%"%*& # $)!$% "#% # 2% # "# & ' # &:# -" ! )*'"# $

& $$'& %*)"$ $2%

!" # $ %%%&'(( ! ) "" $* $% %%+ ,

&'(( * - !.

,, &'(( " ) .. &'(/ # . &'(/ 0

&'(/

-*$""$ "##$$: % 2" ( 3(4 =&" ( 3( 4 &"

2" 3( 4"" $ ## "'*:(0 - *%! "##$$ # ! #) 99 >?(7 #"#) $09 99 >?(7/ #) $0 99 >:(72 5

0 -" $2% "!&" %$ "# ## #$&!%

% 0 "##$$'" %'*

%%%"##$$" &"% 6% "% "##$$' $00 999 3>: 4'$ *'"% *&" &" "##$$' *$$ @$&&& !*)"+%& #*)" $2% /" ##

"##$ -"##$$2% !' &## 0 "+%&

'"" & *)"$ $ 2% #"##$ # "+%& #*)" $2% "% "##$$' * *)"$&"$ 10 1999 >:

*&$$&$'" $00 999

>: $&$*&" &" *""# <'! " # ' $ * " ' @$& '""+%& #*)"##$$ 2% "##$$##$* "2% 2%$ "##$$"% &" % " :

&% %5"* $ ##$ 1 99 5/5&#

$$ 5$ $ * &5" 7708"' 18"

#" + * ") 9

9##$'$$'*)" A% .%& 99 ! >: B " *

& *)"2% :%$

& 05$ $% 5" 770 /" % +/"!$09 99 >:0 $ 1 :%$ # &05$ $% 5" 770 " ##$$!$ 10 1999 >: #% %

& $$ 199 >:.& " %5"*

"%* $##$ 5%&%991 5& #

$ $ & 5$ 5"'0 7 1 5" 5$ &1 5$1 $%" !% !$$&2" )-"$ 2" 5" /"' *$&& %5"* '""' $$' *)"A% .%& /"' ! 9 99

>:1.& " ##$ #

$$$ &5" 770 "'#

$$$ 5" % *

# '" #

" $ )* & %

" " ! 99 ; &% '"

!" ".& '#

*)2% $$$ "

5" 7703 4 "' #$$ $ 5" 770 #! $00 999 >: "% )$

*) .& 6% 5" % * *& %# " &" " ##$$'"#% "05$ $% 5" 770

*"$ %5"* !$ 10 1999>: " %* *)%$ "##$$" "2% ##$

& !

*)5&

"$$!$0 99 >:(72

"$" "$ ):"%" &"$$ 5$

$*$&& %5"* "$&" #

& "

! 99 >: -* &" " %$"! ) $0 99 >:(72:%*) % # 05$ $ %5"* '" $'

# $ 8$$ 3 4 3 4 ; % " &% " $ 0 :% 993>:(724# 5" 7703 4

# '""#

'& "$ * 5 &C "$ " % " $ ) :"%"#

& ! 99 >: 2%$ # " ) "%## "+%& #*)"##$$2% '""%* " "$ )$ 5$ $*$&&" ! $09 990 99

/"" "" &"$$" 05$

$*$&& %5"* "##$$!$ 10 1999 >: !"* & $$ 199 # #%*)"##$$ 2%$" $&$%""##$ $*) 5&#

$$$*$&&" '

*$% &$ .& " !' " ! "<% )A% "# 9 3" "94@ "#% # ""

+%&

1 <D*$"%# 2%

+%& ""

"<&"

2% ! "

# $ %% &

'( ;"!" %$ "# # %" -"%*$6% $''"" +%

) ) .) ) +1

) 1

)

2 3

$ %%# (0&

- 7 4 ) , ) )

6 ) + 1

6. "% * $0 %%0 "0$ $ %%0,56 (!

56 /89.

& " %5"* $##$

5 / 5& #

$$ $ & 5$ 5" 770 $$'*)"A% .%& /"' ! 993>:4-" # % #

&" $$"$*$&&" "

$)'" "$$&)# # & " $ -"6%'""' : ) ) . .))

) 9 2

; :.4&: "% "' ## *"&! ; ; :3%# 4 <D*$"%# 2% 'C

" "%$!$) 34 "9 '" " %" $ 0 " 2%$ ;'""#

) "* : -"<D*$2% # "#6%'"'%$ "##D'"" " &% % &"$ " '"%" &&"2% !$) %" "$$&"& %"""$&$&% "

!' 34 9 ; # 9 " * ! *)"#:2% $$' <% -.. . :: . ) : ):& - 7 )

, . .1 .

= 7 , . .

>;2 ..) . %# ,

, 6 9 / ( ) . )

)

9 .

. ) 6 & - = - ..

.). , .. , . ) , ) . ) ,9 ?

) . ... 9 .

9 .

. 044 . ... 9 ) > :: . ): ):

-.6 . . 044, ):

.:,: .: : .).) : -

))

)

), 6.

. ) , . 1.) .

).) )

. .)

, . 1 ,. . ) . @ ,.. ) . .) ) .. . " . 0;2 ., .

. . 044 ;"" $) $*)

# $09 99 0 9 10 1999 :%*)% "!*"$$&-" %"*#

*)"##$$"$$&$00 999 :%*).& "%* $) ""%* &% "! "$$& $&$)!$) 99#*)"A% .%& /"'<D*$"%# 2% # "& $$)

"$""' D D $) D "$ D;

D"* D "' D*D " " D*

" D# # ) # ) '"! ;

" " '"$$)

" ! " $!&'"" " *)! % %%$% &*'"

" " " "$ #%:$%!$)" & %"$5% " " * **" "

*& &C% $&% !$$)*"$

"&% " " ! "$$&!$) "' &% $$& 5$ $ 5" 770 *"$*) ) "

$ ##$ 5& #

$$ $ # " 5" % * *)! % %%$% &*'"

" " ; )* !

" ""##$ $*).& 5&#

$$ 5$ $% $ &15$1 $ 5"' 170 5"' 8$%" $ 5" 770 $"+ * ") 99 90 3>:4;"!' ; %*$# "

#" ' #$$$ &

5$ # '"" $':%

/"% +/" # !$09 99 " $ 10 1999 " * :% ##$$6%05$ $" -"* &"2% "6%'""

% ":"%" %" )$$ 5$ $*):%& $09 990 99 # 05$$" # -"##$$2% '"$"$& # *" : " $ 0 993>:(724#$ & $'%$$!

%*" $$ 5" 4 3 4$ &05$ $": 05$ #-"$ "%&" 5

"##$1 99 $*)

5& #

" 99 # " ##$ *% '! #

*)) 2% $$$ & 5" % * %*+

$0 993>:(724-" '%$ "!*

" %&"#

$$ 5$

$*$&&" '"% )# 5" % *

*% " !%$) " &% *) %$ "

#'%$"!*' " )* # '! #

$$$ 5" % * %*+

"$:% 99 " #*" )" "$ ):"%" %" )7#

$$$ & 5$ 5" 770*):%& $0 99 $ 0 99':%*) '"%) #

*) #2% $';"!' ;"! ""$" & "##$$2% "

"$ ):"%" %" )& *)"2% ! 99*)') :% '$:%")

99 %*$ .& " %&"#

$$5$ $% $ &15$1 $'"# 5"'0 7 1 5" 5 %$ "+ * ") 99 903>:4'%$ 5!" "$'

5" % * " " 5" 703 4 #'" #

"$ )* & .& '! #

*)" 2% $$ 5" 770 5"'0 5" "' #:%$00

999 3>: 4B" ) $ 10 1999 3>: 4 :% *) % !' & $$ 199 3>:4 " ##$$ ' &"$) !$$) :%*) "##$$'"" #

& " *)"2% ! 99 ;"!' *)%$ "##$$ %$*$*# -" & *)" ##$$2% " %$ ##$ &

! $% % "$&$ %$%

$) &"# #! %" "+%& #*)" ##$$2% *$$'%$*$* ; !' " *! *" " 6%

%$ ' "##$$& # %$ " ##$ # " +%&

#*)"$ .%& /"' " " $2% '""

%&"%-"% $*) "##$$ 35" $4 .%& .% )

"* *