← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6171/2015allowed

Amarjit Kaur @ Rimpy And ORS v. Satpal And ORS

2019-01-31Mr. Justice B.S. Walia6 pages



    

 &' "'())!*+  , -.)&/ 0-1 ),23 !"&4'- 522'66 !& 7'-0 8 &2 6 !"&4'-  5 '2!"'!& 

*  9:  88;:

-''!&* -8 -! 6 <"=( &' -&4' 22'66 !& -,)&/0!"- <"=( &' --'2!"'!&+> !0- !(',2 !3 ???   

     

-&4'-' !  -','!&)!'")!&4' 226)( &)!<&4' ,') 66@'"'6 3 A" 3)! )6)!B &4' 22' 6)(!"!'"0C.'(&& 66 .0&'D('2&)! 

   EF &)(' ,&)!&(!&'&)!B-'2!"'!&+!63 EF -,)&/0!"- <"=( &'<@4@ 2-''!&)!0-&< (('2&'" !&)('!C'4 6  -'2!"'!&+ !"-'G0'&'" -&4'( '&C'& H'!02

&'- 60!(4 C-' H )!-"'- & '! C6' 4), & B ='- &4' 2 2'-CH !" & ""-' -B0,'!& E+F ((-")!B63<( ')& H'!02 -4' -)!B &'-60!(4C-' H !" @)&4&4' )& !(' (0!'6 -&4'2 -&)'<4 ='B!'='-&4' @ -" !" 4 ='(!)"'-'"&4')-0C,))!

EF

EAF 22' 64 C''! )6'"C3&4'@)"@ !"&@,)!-(4)6"-'!  B)-8)!B4@4")'")! ,&-='4)(06 - (()"'!&!

 A EF

- 3'- ) - '!4 !(','!&   (,2'! &)!     <+<

@ -"'"&&4' 22'66 !& !"2 -'!&#)'-'2!"'!&A !"% "'(' '" EF :' !'"&-(()"'!&6 ),-)C0! 6<:0"4) ! #4'-')! &'- -'

'--'"& J&4'-)C0! 69%C3& H)!B)!& ((0!&&4' B' &4'"'(' '"  + 3' - !" &-' &)!B 4),  ',)H)66'" @-H'-< ''" 4) )!(,'  <

I2'-,!&4< 226)'",06&)26)'-  !"C3, H)!B"'"0(&)! IA&4

-,&4')!(,' &4'"'(' '"&@ -"4)2'-! 6'D2'!'<C')"'<C3 @ -")!B<

I! ((0!& 6=' !"

'(&)!<<

I! ((0!& 20 6(!-&)0,< !"<

I! ((0!& 0!'- 6 'D2'!'< @ -"'"&& 6(,2'! &)!  <+<

I 6!B@)&4)!&'-'&1 K2'- !!0, F :' -!'" (0!'6 - &4' 22'66 !& (!&'!" &4 & &4' 22' 6 )

6) C6'&C' 66@'"< @ -",") )'" !"(,2'! &)!2 3 C6''!4 !('"C3 @ -")!B 0&0-' 2-2'(&< C')"'< 22-2-) &' (,2'! &)! 0!"'- &4' (!='!&)! 64' "! ((0!& 20 6 !"2 -'!& 6(!-&)0,  6 22-2-) &'(,2'! &)!! ((0!& '& &' ELF :' -!'"(0!'6 --'2!"'!&+4  )-63!&22'"&4' "")&)!   A K   &4' '& C6)4'" )!(,'   &4' "'(' '" &@ -" 2-2'(&@4)6'(,20&)!B(,2'! &)!)! ((-" !('@)&4&4'"'())! !9C6'&4'802-','0-&)!!

 #  $% &  $ ! '( ) &  !*   ' !*    + , --  

  @'='-< 4'4  (!&'!"'"&4 &! ,0!&)2 3 C6'! ((0!& 6=' !"

'(&)!

E+F

')"'< @ -" <

I! ((0!& 0!'- 6'D2'!'@ 6) C6'&C' ( 6'""@!&<

I EF  4 =' (!)"'-'" &4' 0C,))!   6' -!'" (0!'6 - &4' 2 -&)'2'-2 - B- 24#)=% &4'"'())! !9C6'&4'802-',' 0-&)! - ! 38'&4)9( '#802- % )!('&4'"'(' '"@ '6 ',263'" !"6'&4 !A 3' -  B'<&4'-'

-'<A K &4''& C6)4'")!(,' "'(' '",)!0&4'& D(,2!'!&)&C'& H'!)!& ((0!&&@ -" 2-2'(&@4)6'(,20&)!B&4'(,2'! &)! E F  :)H'@)'<  2'- 2 - B- 24  #=)))%   &4' "'())!  !9C6'&4'802-','0-&)! - ! 38'&4)9( '#802- %<&4' 22'66 !& -' '!&)&6'" &  <

I ! ((0!&  0!'- 6 'D2'!' !"  <

I ! ((0!& '& &' ((-")!B63<  0,    <

I @ -"'" ! ((0!&  

0!'- 6 'D2'!' ) ( 6'""@! &  <

I @4)6' ! ,0!&    <

I @ -"'"! ((0!& 6=' !"

'(&)!)4'6"&C'!& 2 3 C6' EF  :)H'@)'< &4' @)"@   &4' "'(' '" ) 4'6" '!&)&6'" &   A

I ! ((0!&   6   20 6 (!-&)0, )! ((-" !(' @)&4

- ! 38'&4)9( '#802- %@4'-'  2'-2 - B- 24L  &4'"'())! !9C6'&4'802-','0-&)!.$ /

  #   !' (  "-$0*"* "-$ '!*   1 ,-- 222< 0, A

I)2 3 C6'&' (4 &4'(4)6"-'! &4'"'(' '"! ((0!& 6   2 -'!& 6 (!-&)0, 8)!('< &4' "'(' '" 6' & C'4)!" &@ ,)!- (4)6"-'!<&4'-'

-'< 2 -& -,0, A

I2 3 C6'&&4'@)"@ "'(' '"! ((0!& 20 6(!-&)0,<L

I)2 3 C6'& &4'&@,)!-(4)6"-'!! ((0!& 2 -'!& 6(!-&)0,@'='-<

EAF

! (,2'! &)! ) 2 3 C6' & &4' &4'- #)' -'2!"'!& A% !" &4' ,&4'- #)' -'2!"'!& %   &4' "'(' '" ! ((0!&   6  )6) 6 (!-&)0,)!=)'@ &4'"'())!)! B, '!'- 6!0- !(',2 !3 :&"9( '#802- %)!('&4'"'(' '"@ , --)'" EF 

('" @)&4 &4' -','!&)!'" 2)&)!< 6' -!'" (0!'6 - -'2!"'!&+>!0- !(',2 !3(!&'!"'"&4 &)!=)'@ 0C'G0'!& "'())!   !9C6' &4' 802-',' 0-& )! 3 $ 4 (   ' !*  ( !

 # $% &!' '!*    -- 1 @ -" (,2'! &)!! ((0!& 20 6I2 -'!& 6(!-&)0,)! &4' ( '   @)"@ !" &@ ,)!- (4)6"-'! ) 6) C6' & C' -'&-)(&'" &   <

I ! &4' 6)B4&   &4' 2)&)!  !&'" C='< (,2'! &)! ! ((0!&   6   20 6 !" 2 -'!& 6 (!-&)0, & &4' @)"@ !" &@ ,)!-(4)6"-'! &4'"'(' '")-'&-)(&'"&<

I E+F  :' -!'" (0!'6 - &4' 22'66 !& -'6)'" 02! &4' "'())!  !9C6'&4'802-','0-&)!"

!4 ( (3 5&)6!*   1  78 '@4'-' (()"'!&@   A A !"- &' )!&'-'&@  @ -"'" 1 K 2'- !!0,  ! &4' C )   &4'  ,'< 6' -!'" (0!'6 (!&'!" &4 & &4' (,2'! &)! ) 6) C6' & C' 2 )" 6!B @)&4 )!&'-'&  1 K 2'- !!0, :' -!'" 0!'6 - -'2!"'!& +!0- !(' ,2 !3!&4'&4'-4 !"22'&4')!&'-'&(6 ),'" EAF   4 =' (!)"'-'" &4' 0C,))!   6' -!'" (0!'6 - &4' 2 -&)' !" , &4'=)'@&4 &)!('&4' (()"'!&)!&4')!& !&( ') 6 &4'3' - A @ )!80!)& '=)9( '#802- %"'()"'"C3!9C6'&4' 802-',' 0-&< &4'-'

-'< )& @06" C' )! &4' )&!'   &4)!B &4 & (,2'! &)!C'2 )" 6!B@)&4)!&'-'&1 K2'- !!0,

EF

EF  ! &4' 6)B4&   &4' 2)&)!  !&'" C='< &4' 22'66 !&  !" 2 -'!& &4' "'(' '" #)'

&4'- > -'2!"'!& A  !" ,&4'- > -'2!"'!& % -' 4'6" '!&)&6'" & &4' 66@)!B (,2'! &)!*  8 ' $"

!   ' $"

!   ' 9&  9&!* :

9"

 !* "

!  !(,' 





-2'(& )6 K 

IM A





INA

+ & 6 !(,' MLA

''" A 06&)26)'- 226)'"   IA&4 

IM IA&4 LA

IM  '"0(&)! #&@ -" 



2'-! 6 'D2'!'  "'(' '"%  '2'!"'!(3#!!0 6% #

I

I% #LA

I

I%M MA

I#2'- +

I#2'-,!&4% ,!&4% !" !" #A

ID%M #+

ID%M  A<

I#!!0 663%  <

I#!!0 663% A<

IDM  <

IDM

 ,2'! &)! L<

<+A<

@ -"'" C3 2263)!B ,06&)26)'-  <

I : L :   :=' !"

'(&)!  : (!-&)0,  <

 A

I#@)"@% A

I#&' (4 &4'(4)6"-'! "'(' '")'  L

I%& 6M <

'&-)(&'"& 

EF

 <

I)!=)'@ "'())! !9C6' &4'802-','0-&)! 7),6 '=)9( '  

0!'- 6D2'!' <

 <

 : & &' :  <



&' )!&'-'& K2'- !!0,

K2'- !!0, :!    2

;    ,

; EF  ((-")!B63<  B )!&(,2'! &)!  <+<

I @ -"'" C3&4'-)C0! 6<&4' 22'66 !& !"2 -'!&#)'-'2!"'!&A !"% &4' "'(' '" -' 4'6" '!&)&6'" & (,2'! &)!       ,

; 6!B @)&4 )!&'-'&1 K2'- !!0,!&4''!4 !('" ,0!&@)&4'

'(& -,&4'" &' (6 ),2'&)&)!&)66" &' 2 3,'!&<6'2 3,'!&<)  !3<, "'' -6)'- &'-

)-&, H)!B2 3,'!& (,2'! &)!! ((0!& 20 6I2 -'!& 6 (!-&)0, & &4' @)"@ !" &@ ,)!- (4)6"-'!   &4' "'(' '" 22-&)!,'!&   &4' (,2'! &)! 4 66 C' , "' )! ((-" !(' @)&4 &4' - &)&)206 &'")!&4' @ -"2 '"C3&4'6' -!'"-)C0! 6 E F  ''"6' & ,'!&)!< &4' !0- !(' ,2 !3 4 66 "'"0(& )!(,' & D 6) C)6)&3< )  !3< G0  0&0-' 2-2'(& )! ((-" !(' @)&4 &4' "'())!)! - ! 38'&4)9( '#02- % ELF  ((-")!B63< 22' 6 ) 66@'" C3 ,") 3)!B @ -"  " &'" L A  2 '" C3 &4' :' -!'" -)C0! 6 & &4' 'D&'!&  !&'" C=' #8;:%  +  ,)&  ;4'&4'-2' H)!BI-' !'" * 'I 2. ;4'&4'--'2-& C6' * 'I