Ranbir Singh v. R.K. Goel And ORS
! " #$ %&$'() * # ) "
)+ ,-,
./ 0, , 1 2-- 3"
+1- -
+-
!"#$% &' () %$) *)$$ &- +.
4,
)5
+ +1 +
2,6-
1 "+5
+ -
+-
+++ $) *)$$ ,&
-+ +1-0 , 07
+1+1, +,- ,8 +1 9 8 +-
+ :
-- 07 +1 #,4, ' ' ),4,-,
; 1,
,+,
),-+, + ' 5 ; 1, - +,47 (, +-+1++1- + +< 0, , 1
=,+18&6-1 1
#1
,6&-1 -,+ 8 +,
-+, +1-
+<
8 ,- +1, +,- 8+1-1 - 8, + +1 +7
8,- , $ ,+ (>>> -,+ 2 18
,
" ,-;,8,+ 5#1
,1 5 ; 1,
&- + +4 +1+11 +6 -1
+ 8+1
+-, +17::?+8
+17 @A< -1 -0-B +7,
- A<-1
7=- 7 +1+= , +,-1 +6
-1 1
+ &, +,- +1++17=,
-
+18,--&- + +=- 7
1,-0-, -- + 0+, ,
8+1 ,# +,
5; 1,
-, +1 +, ,+7
+1 8 -
+<
,
8+C ,+-5+1
0,-+ + 1,--+0,-1
)
+-= 7 ,4, 8+1, +,-=1, 1+17=
--
+-=5 +1-5 0 +
-, 8 + +1
+1 + 8,-- , +,
=- 8 07 +1 , +,- + )+7 ,
& , 5%
+&, +,-=
-+,
,+1-,+-+1-
+-
-,-+ -
+<
+-=1, 7, +1 ,8 +1 +-=-+1 +1, +,- , +1+,
-1,
+ + 0+= +1 +,- + =- , +1+ +1 , +,-=4,
-+1,+ +- 1=-5+1-5
B-+,
,
-, +1+ + ,+-1 40
,-- 07 +18
+, ,+7 =- - 8 +1 +, ,+7
+1-
+- +=- 0, ,
+18,-- % =, ,---=8 .< D1+1 +1 , +, ,- +,+ 8
E&&
@ D1+1+1-,+,-
+8, +, 0E&) @ , ; +, # +
-, +,
+1 +-
, 8-+
-
+1 4,
+1+ +1 , +,-1 , 4+1+,
-1,
+ 0+= +1+,- 1 5+1-,+=- ,-8,-- =- 07 +1 - + + F 0, , 1
=,+1 8 &6-1 1 1, , +, #1
,6&-1
+,8 +1+,# + ,-,
;
,+,
--,
- ' 5 ; 1,
-, , +1
,-8,-- +1-85,
8,++1, &- + +F
1, , 1
1- +1, -+ + 1 , +1,8 9 8 +-( +1+1
+1, +,-14
+ 1 +1,-# + +,-, 8 07
- +1 -
+- +1+
+1 -, -1 -1-0 1
407+1, +,-<8&6-1 1
#1
,6&-1 ;
- +1 +418 +7-+1+ ,+,-
--7
8 +74,
+ 4+
7
+1 -+ -5, +,<
1, , 1 8,
+1
8,- 8,--,+= +1-1 -
+10-,- +
::?&- +-,+=-, +17@ +,- +1+
+1 +,-
707+1 +, ,+70,- 0+- 07+1+1
0,-!C&+ & ,+ +,- 7 07+1 +,-, +1 !C&?@5 +, ,+70,--=- ;
# , 7
+1 - +,, + ,-- 07 +1 ,
?
# +,
1-+--,-,
+1+-+,8
7 )D3"
7 4 +1 +G- - ;
- +1 =1, , + , 4,+ !C)D 07 3 "
7 -08,+- +1+
+1, +,< +1-
+0 ,-+ 5+1 5
+1+ +,- 51,- +,+
4 B+1+ =
+0 ,- ---- =,+1 +
-+
-- = -,
+19 8
+1
G0 8# +,
:/:
? ## @5
?
8# +#--:5 -. / 0122 .. !3 @ ## , & :@
! " @ ## , & / ;
- +1-
+-=1,+, +1 48 +- +1
- +1 +-08,+-+1++1 - ,, -+
+1 -
+<
+ =- +1+ +1 , +,
=,+1 +1-=- 4,
+1 +7-+ +- ;
+-0 =14
9 8 +-
+10-,- +1 4,
+1,-
, +
,-
9 8
G0 8# +, ! # $ % &' #
! ##@-=- ! ( ! ##,4, 5 ! & :/:
!
$ )**'
##,4,
@:?
141
- +1+,-
+1 1 +1
5 =1, 1 =- B,-,+,
5 =,+1 +1, 0 --,-+
( +1+1
+-0 =14+ + ,
,
+1+, +,1-, -+0,-1+1+,
-1,
+ +0+= +1, +,
+- +,-
, +1+ +1,-
8 ++ 4+1 +8 +
7(+1+-,+ 875, +,=- 0+
4 +1 + ,+-=1, = ++1
+
+07+1-
+-,
+1
7 +1 !C&?@,-
4,+ +1, +, 1-8
+ 0 +6 + 0 4,
+
+ 07 +1 -
+- !C- &5 &@
&?
,- , +,
- 7 8 + +1 , 1 ,-
-8 + 07
, ,A , + 1- 0 - ,, 7 1 07 +1 = +# ++1+.
1- +1,-1 =-+1++1 ,8 +1 +-,-
+10-,- +
750+
-
=1 - -
+1 +
7 =- + 1- 0 C8, 07 +1 +- + 4 +1
7
+5 + ,+
, # +,
1-0
+1,
? ### //51,-;
-1,
G0 '-+, 385' & 90
7 ,1# +5#1
,11-1 +1+ +, -- +,+-14+ 0 1 +1+ +1 ,- +,
-1,
+ +
--,7, 4-+1C,-+
+ +, +1 8 - 7 , 8-+ +, 4,
-1 =, +1+- 1
+ +=-, C,-+
++1
B,- +1+
+1 ,88 40 +7 -1 0 07+ +, 1,- ,+75-- 15
78 + +,-+1 0-4 +10 4-, 8 ++1+ 4,
0++ 07 4,
+1,-
-
+1
5
+ ,+
- 1 -,++,
5
,
0
+1+ +1,-+,
-1,
+ +0+= +1 +,-
+1- -- 5+1&, +,-14, 4 7 + ,+
5=1-5+17 ,8 +1,
+10-,- +
7
5+17 14, 4
+1,+1++17,
+1-,+ +7-+ + CCC CCC CCC 1,-
8
+1,+, + +1+
7 1 +1 , +, 1-
+, ,+7 0,-5 +1
0,-
,
8 +C + - 0+ +1-
8 +-
-
, ++1++1-++ +1-,+ +7
+1+1
0,-5+1 +7 801-
+0 8
-- 15
+0
=,+1+1-,+ +7 ,8,75+1+
8 C !C&:+ !C&/+, + 0, , 1
-
, + 7 +7 80 ,8, ,- +1 -,+,
+, + +1 +1
8 +- - - 15 +1-
8 +-
+0
=,+1+1-,+ +7
45 , ###?@@5,+ 1-0 1 07 & 90
7 ,1# ++1++,
5, +,+7
, -1 =, +1
-- +1, +,5 ,+
8 +-
+1-
+0
-,4
+1, +,5=1-5, +1 - 1
5+1 +7 801-
+0 8
+1
8 +-
07+1, +,
+1 -,+ +7I
+,
7, ,8,+7, +1-,
-,
,4 + 07+1
,+,
),-+, +' 5; 1, ;
- +1 +1-418 +7 +1+4 ,1,-
4+1 +7-+ +,-
-+0,-1 51
+0 ,- ---- C +,
-- = , 8 +,- 78,-
8,-
,4 4,= +1 + +1+ +1 , +, 1- 0 0 + 4 +1 0-,-A
+,
+-
=1, 1 1 -+ 1,- -
- 1 -,++,
5 ,
+ 0 + 1,8 + + 1,-
B+1 = +1 +7 1,- # + , !+ - - 1- - ,, 71 +1++1,
+0 , -++1+
= ) ,-,
+1
G0 8# +,
+
- - =
+0, 0, +1, -+ - +1 -
+1++1,-
,-+ +1+,+ +1
+< -
+ 4+1 8,- 8,--
+ - - +1, +,1 , +1-,+, 1,-+,+-=-
4+1 ,-+ ,
&, +,, +1-, - , 41,-+,+0+=-
0,
+7 )
+, +1+ -1 - , 4,+-+,+ 4+1
,-+
5 +1 5 ,+ ,- , +1 -, , 8-+
- +1+
+1, +,=- =1,4, +1B-+,
+,+
+1 - + - +1 ,- 0- +7
,-+ +1+,+ +1-
+F
+
/
G0 8 # + , !+ - - 1- 0-4 +1+
-- =,--+,-, +18 8 ,1+- +1+,- +
07+1
8+
+ %,
- +1 ,1# + )1,, , -.
"
.
5:// )'?= 5=1, -
. J/ 1C--,
-K
-- =G5K
- =G
K
-+ =G140
+ 1 07- , +1 ,-,
- +
0 4 =1, 1 -7 +1+ +1 -++
4
-
, =
+ 0
,-+0 K ,07G07+1+ = +6, =, 1,-
= 1
- +1- C--,
-5 1 =45 8 +1-8+1, <9 +8 + 8-++
701 07
-+
+ =#75K
-- =G K
- =G515-,878 +1+-
, -++
+ 0 9 =,+1 +
+ = 14, +
1,-,1+-B+1+
= =5 +1,- K
--G K
-G
,+,
,- -+,-, +18 8 ++1,1+- +1+,- +
07
+
8+ 9,-
+
-
+8++=1 0 1++1
+
+ +
0+1 = ,
8 + 1,-,1++ 9 ++1-
=
0+1 -
=1 ,- - 1++ 09 5,
4 +1
= 89 1,8D1+1+1
,- 8 + ,1+
47
,1+ ,
, -+
,-
5 ,-
8 1
-B
D1+ ,-
:
,8 + +,-+1+, ,+14 +,+,-
0 +1
+
+1
+ +-
,+ +1+ ,-
+1 5+1K08, ,88GB,8 K
--G K
-G == -+
-+,-, -
-+ == 140 +6
+1,-
+C+5=1 +7 1-
+ -6, +,48 7- 1- ,
,+,-, -++,
-5 ,++1
-7+1++1 +1+78-+
=, -+,++
+ = 1,-,1+-,5 +6, 0 6- 8+1, 8+1,-++7=1 1 -,+ =75
5+,- 1+,85+1
+1, +1
8-+ + ,
7=7E
= +1, 6
+
74 +5+1K
-+
=G -+,+,
-+
- -+,-, =1 9 ,
+8, +,
,-8 =,+1 + +1,-+ +7G- +,4
1-5, +1- -5 +1, +,G-,+ 86 + -
-
+8 +1+,+-
-B + --+,
- +1-, +=
8-= 140
0 1+0 +=,+1 +
-+ =J 3, , 4,= +1 +-
, 8-+
- -
,- -- 0 45
- +1 +,- 0+
+ 7B-+,
=8 1---0-+ +,B-+,
==1, 870 , 4
-, +,
+1,--
8 9 8 +-=-
9 8 +-
+ ,+,
-, +,
+14,
#
-B +75
+ ,
7 , ,8,+75 ,,+7 4-,+7, +1,8 9 8 +-
+ :
-- 07+1 #,4,' ' ),4,-,
; 1,
,+,
),-+, + ' 5 ; 1, - +,475=1, 1= = + 7, +
07+1,-# + &- +,-5
-B +75 ,-8,-- $/2*/
-+5 & +-