Msk Projects India Ltd v. State Of Punjab & ORS

 



  




























 








!"#
$ 
% &&''  (") 

!) #*
 
"






+&        

   ,--"
"&""

''
.&&"
/0
*
''.



#)1/ 
2


3
*
" ""

"&""
"

2
4 5
,--"
-
#)1/ 
-)'
*
"&"

-
1
2 !" 

"
/"
!"6-7
8
 
 '
9)
!"6-7
8

"
%'
:-)- 7
8
 
80
-

7
8
"
&&''  "
;
-7
'
8
< "'7
!) #* ==== 
 

3-
&&'' 
-
-'' 17
-
""


 

7 &
*0
 '
"
>)17
:- 1"-7
.-"*0
*# 
' "

5

"*"
 
: '
7


?
-" "
 *
" ""

@-
@
*0
-


!) #*
1 
-
."


 

7
&)"&"'0
-8
*
 
8
'"

? 

7 "8
*0
-/

 

7
-8
*


 
-
."


 

 5

" "
*0
-
3-"
"*""7
-
*
)&-' "
/"
!"6-7
'"


) '
&&" 1

*-'



&&'' 
)*/
-
*# 

-
*-

-
"&  A
." B

/
*""7

 7
.
"*""
-
18
."


 

7
.--
/'0
-
*
"8
*0
-


 

.-"
*# 
-
*
'

5 


*0 

&')
5 0
3-
 '
"
>)1
-
"" )'0
6
   "
-
&"

'/
"/
 5


-
."
18

*0
-
-"
"*""7
.-"*0
-
-
18
-
 

-
."


 


$
-
 B7
-
-
".

 

-
:)"

 
 


1 
*0
-
!" 1
"*""
 
 -"
"*""7 .--
"
-)
 

     



 !

"

# $ "

 &



''

(      * +  , '

  '

' 

  !

"

# $ "    (

''

'     '

- *  ,   



.

 

  !

"

# $ "     

 ( &

&(

'

'

%





"

$ / $0  

 *      

 "

# $ " $0%    

&

'

'

% &

1

 &  

.

  02   '& &&

 30

  

& &    

  &   

4  '&       

  !

"

# $ "   



'2 (

'( 

  !

"

/ "

$ / '

/  5

 $   556  '

 & & '7

&(

  

  !

"

# $ "



''   &

  %8

0%,0 $(!



4    

& 9:, #:)  '   (&

  ' %, ;

,   

  !

"

/  "

$ /

/  

  !

"

# $ "    

'' &

&

'  "(  &

.

 ,    &   

  

 8& 

.

   !

/  ;

 $   55- < ,  '

  & 

/  ;

 $   55- 

&(

    & (





  /  /  !

/  ;

 $   55- = $
&)") 

-
 "/  
*"8 7

& )'/ &"1"&-

-
."7
.--
"
-)
55 ,  '   9 6(  9 '   02   '& &&

 30 &

 &  ,   ( '&

  &&

     &  .

   

( & (  '

  & (  &&(   ( '& &&   '

'&

  +> 

 

 

'

 & (

  



    ( '&



( & ( '

 ,   



&



 & (

  





 &&

'&

  



     & ( '7

.







& (  && 3 .



   

 '  

   

&& 

  

  ,    



&  &  /

&

    &  = ;
)"-"
)*/
-7
&" 1

-
 "/  
 
 

7
-
"*""
-
*
." 1
'"

-
-"
"*""


/6
)11 
.-
"1"

-
" 
."

-


*
'" 
-
/ -

8/*"


3-
""&  
"
-
&"

- &&"
*67
"
-
6

*"80

  
"
"&")
-"

4 '

  "3 "/?

2  4!

@ AA /  $  $   %7&

 B  ;5+

$' B  , /

2 9& '

, &   , 9 / , &  2 $

  & / 2 C0

$



 '

:,  



9 /  %    &





 &  & &   

' 

  '

 ' '

' "/? & 9:,  ' (    ' .

(  & & 

9:,!

'  '(  ?(



   '7 (

    

   

 "(  @

& 

 



'

$'    + "

 

6D@@/)E  7  "/?

$'&(

  ( 

 ' 

  9 $ 6

  F

(



/!

+ <   9  * +  D C

$&( 

'&'   /

 $  /

G ' " 9  #/ 9$ #:# * / / (  $ 

7

4

&

,7  %' ;*+   "

 # $ " G ' $

  9 2 

$

     A / 05 $ -    9 / 2 C0 '

"/?

2  B /

2

  , 

  '    (

/& ) * +   

 (

  8' (

 

'

(

 '

 (  (

''   '( 

1   , &    '7 .

    

?(  '  (

   

 &  '

 

(

 '

6

  F

 ( /30

/!

4 '

  6&  2  @

* '   G ' (C "/?

2  4!

@ %  , 9  9& :

, &  , 9  /

, &  2

$ ,  "

 # $ " G ' $

  9 2 

$

     A / 5 $ 9

  4  '  

  (

(

      * + 

'  - *   8&     ' 





1 &  

( 

.

 &   02   '& &&

 30   



 

  & & 

.

 (

& (  '  (

 '   



  (

1 

 F

  ' '  (

   (

  '  (

    &  

'

(

   

.

 (

7(  '  (

 ' 

(   



 (



(

( '  + '    &    (

   '7 '(   &      "

$ / $0   (

( 

  (  (

& F

 ( /30

/!= $
)&&"

-
   7
-
-
"'
)&
8
9 - #)1/ 

-
; @*'
'-
;1-
:)"
" "

# '

4 B "3 '   5 %4 9 

  
-
'/

.)'
"C")
"/
-

.-
."

1 
*0
-
/#"0 "*""
 
-
&0

-"
."
-
'"0
*
"8
*0
- *#"7
'/
.)'
"
"/
-"
 

"/
-


." 1 
*0
-
/ "0
"*"" ;
)"-"
)*/7
-

-"

-

-
*# 
." /
*""7
-
/&)1 
""
'
)

"
"/
''1'0
 
&"8"0

"
-
" 
-
."

-
/ "0
"*""



*
)&-'
 -)7
-
/&)1 
""


) *'

-
0

'.
;
-

   " ""

-
&"8


5

-
 ,-"

-
-"
- 7
"
;
-7
'
8 < "'
!) #*
)*/
-

&"
-
&"8

)*





5

-
7
-
"*"'
."
 1
-
&'

-
"*"
-

* "/ 

" 
.-
'.

'
&"8
) "



- 
 7
-" "
."
-''
*
/

-8
/

-
&'
;

)"-"
)*/
-
&'

"*" 7
"/
-
&")'

-
&" 1 
-
"*"
3"*) '
-
*

:- 1"-7
.-"
"/
- &")'

-
."
18
*0
-
#"0
"*" 7

-
*
1 
 '-
 7
-" "7
/


) *'

-
0

'. D8
'"
B"
)&"


"8'
-
  


-
" 
."
 7
-" "7

.
''0
) ."

-
  


-
" 
."
8AA8
-
 '
."
3-
*# 
."
.-

'/

-
/
-8
*
'7
"/
-


"&

- / "0
."

 5


3-"


''1'0
 
&"8"0

- /&)1 
""
 7
-" "


."" 
 0
 "

" 
 
 ''0 &"0
-
&&'
-)'
*
/
.-
B/&'"0
 $
-8
-"
'"


) '
"
-
&"
 
&&"
- &&"
*6 
&"
-
"
 
)''
)

-
<8"

/ 


$ 
(
C
/
 
-"
)&"7

"

*'
-
-
'/

.)'
*1
"/
-

.-
-
."
-
*
1 
*0
-
/#"0 "*""
$
.)'
*
&

" "
-
"'8 
&"1"&-7
.--
" -) E , '



  

 



    8&  '( "

 $ '

,  ! "

,  (' ( '

& "

 ?

' && "2 (  '( "



"

,  (' ( ' &    G

(  ,   "

 ? 







 

4 &  & -

'2 (

   & &

 /

   

    '   6 &  "

 "

,  (' (  '   '   '( "

 ?    '

8&   ( '7  4 ' 

'   '   8 '2 (  '2 (

  "

 ?  &  (    '

 

      '7 



' % 

&  

'2 (     "

?   ' ( * /&'   ,  && &

&

 /  ;<

- 9 '  

 '2 (   G

(  /  ;

55-   ' 

&

&

.

    '

       

' %  

7 55- / 0  !

/  ;   

  &   '  

% & 0   !

  



'2 (

 ''

    

    



' 

 '



/  ;
'&    &

(





'2 (

''

  

   



'





' (

 '2 ( 

,    

  '2 (



' (  

 ( @ 



& 

 &

'

   & A

 D 55A!

4 & -0+5

  

C I4

  

 '      '

  ' 

'2 (

  %( ''

         '(    

 I &I , 

&  ' ( 

'

&

   '( 



 '

   '

& (  &&   I D8
"/
-
&")'

-
*#
& 7


.-" "

*'
-
*# 
-8
*
'
"/
-


"&

- 8.

/ "0
"
-
6

*"807
-


-
&&'
 "&")
-"

%&& 

 /  ;<

 $   55-

  

         -  

 & <   & 

   '  (

 (

      &

2

 &



 



'

 &

'



& %

 

&& &   

&

 '  ' &  & &   + ;   

'



&  

2 



'

 &       

.

   %

(  && &        $

'

 &





' 



 = 3-
 "/  

.)'
'
""*'
 ')

-
*# 
-8
*
'
*0 

&')
5
07

&"8


'/

 ?5


&&'0

&" 1
"
&"8
) "


5

-

 7
-" "

/0
8.7
 '
"
>)1
)1-
 -8
6
 "/  
7
.-'
' 1
.-
*# 
D8

&"

-
&"8


5?

-
7
-
."7
) '7
-'' 1
.-

-
&""*
&"
-''
*


"
) "
-
:

:8'
!")"


-
/
/

"



.

"

-
:)"
3-
/&)1 
""
' )

"
"/
''07
"
-
" 7
-
/ "0
8.

-
 1' "*""



*
/

+)'

:)"

-
&" 

/#"0
8. $
8.

-
 "/  

 
")/ 7
$
/


-
8.
-
/&)1 
""


) *'
 7
-" "7
-
/


  -"*0

 &&'

" 1'0
''.
 
-
/#"0
8.

- "*""
$$

&"
-
."

 



)&-' 3-
&&'' 
.)'
*

'*"0

'/
-
)  )CB)

-
."

" 
.-
'. !"#$" % 
  &