High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1924/2013dismissed

Chuhar Singh & ORS v. Financial Commissioner Appeals -I Pb , Chd & ORS

2015-10-09Mr. Justice Hemant Gupta,Mr. Justice J.S. Narang2 pages

!"# "$"% & '& ( ( !"")!*++!((!"& ,,&*(- "./0 "$!# "$% & ( 1 1- 2341562761 2341562'1262 &(&"% 8"!"# 0&"! $9)%&08!%

1, !0$9)%&0

% &,,&**"%( 4

*0:0 "./0

&(,"$&"%(% ".&&9"$!%"$ 4*/! 7 + !"!0$9)%&(0

&(,"$&"%(;0<"$ === * !(!"% -) %,,&* "$& * (&> % &&%%& (%&"% ( /&&" !*&$#!"(%% & $& $%&$ ;

,((&$/?% &*& "&$!"#*& $#&0$!(+!((!"#% &8 !%,&%!%!"@

!*&$/?% & ,,&**"%(0) **&"#!"#% & $& , %!%!"$%&$

,((&$/?% & ((!(%"%**&)% (%: $&04*)

08 !) (/&&"

% & , &*$/?

% & **&)% 0 4*)

"$ % & !"")!* ++!((!"& ,,&*(-0 "./09!$& $& ($%&$

;"$<

0 &(,&)%!9&*? @& 9& & $*& "&$) "(&* % &, %!&("$ 9&#"& DASS NAROTAM 2015.10.19 12:52 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document

- - % # % &!+, #"&$ $& ,((&$/?% &*& "&$!"#*&5 $#&(8&**( % & $& (,((&$/?% &1&9&"

& % !%!&( "% &*(%$%& & !"#0!&&,%&+/& A0

0% &*& "&$ ) "(&* % &,,&**"%( !(&$% &"*?)"%&"%!"% %!"% &, %!%!"0" ,((#&8(, 9!$&$%"& % &4*)B( *"$**%%&$%% &,,&**"%( !) &( *%&$!"%# &%!".

(%!)&"% &(!$)"%&"%!"0*& "&$) "(&*

&(,"$&"%(;0<"$ ( # %%!+&%9& !

?% !( )%"$% 9& !"(% )%!"(8!% &# $%, 9!$!"#,((#&%% &,,&**"%(!"% &(!$ 4*)B $?0*& "&$) "(&* &(,"$&"%(;0<"$ (,*)&$ " &) $),? .+/"$! % &?&

A- *"#8!% !) $&,!)%(% %$.!"!"#%B!**<CC 0% &*"$ % &,,&**"%(!( (!% %&$0)+, !(!"#!"B!**

CC;C 08 !) (,((#&"$% & ,,&**"%()",, ) % &4*)B *"$**%%&$%% &+% # % !(B!** "

+/& "9!&8 % &(&$) +&"%(,*)&$" &) $08&$"% !"$"?

+& !%!"% &)"%&"%!" !(&$/?% &*& "&$) "(&* % &,,&**"%((!"

9!&8% &,,&**"%( 9&,((#&%B!**<CC % # B!**

CC;C +& !%!(+!((&$ ! "

#$%&' ( !) "

"$.

DASS NAROTAM 2015.10.19 12:52 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document