Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. M/S Svasca Industries Ltd. And ANR










 

 

 




 !

!"#$#%&
" '!(


)

*


+$)#%
(,%
#-.#
/# (%
#01
2 3*
#$( 44!..% /!($5$

6$
78$"
%35$ (#!$
%3#
2 3*
!.)#*
9:
; 
#..
7 %!
!.)#*

 )5(
3
/#..0!
#( ).
.<.*
#$ (#"
(#3'3

% )!(  !$4%3!% $   

   !"

#$  =)! )!(
!4( !($

.".
44!($
1,
'!
..<!3

$!!
)!
-5301!% >  
'!
(!!((!3

)!
!4( !($
(
% > ? =)! )!(
)!
-5301!%
$)5.3
'!
(!4( !3
#%
)!
#0!$ >

(!$!% &

$7%#
3%*
38" !* (
)!
44!..% 

($)<%#
.<(*
38" !* (
(!$4%3!%
 @@@@@







































 !"

%&' )!
44!..%
#$
#%
44!.
0#%$
)!
#1450%!3
(3!(
3 !3 ?*
<)!(!',
)!
'-!" #%$
#.!3
5%3!(
7!" #%
?9

)!
('# ( #% %3
%"#.# #%
" *
AA
(
$)(
BAA
" C
(
$! #%0D$#3!
)!

('# ( #%
<(3
3 !3
:*
)$
'!!%
3#$1#$$!3

$7%#
3%*
.!(%!3
"5%$!.
44!(#%0
%
'!).

)! 44!..%
$5'1# $
)

)!
'-!" #%0
5(
)$
"11# !3
#..!0.# ,
%3 4!(8!($# ,
#%
%
38!( #%0

..
)!
'-!" #%$
%3*
)!(!(!*
)!(!
)$ '!!%
1#$"((#0!

-5$ #"!
$
)!
%.,
(!1!3,
(
)!
44!..%
<$

(#$!

)!
'-!" #%$
$
!%8#$0!3
5%3!(
7!" #%
?9

AA
" 
7)!
5( )!( $5'1# $
)
)!
('# ( (
)$
"11# !3
%
#..!0.# ,
#%
%
$$#0%#%0
%, (!$%$
(
(!-!" #%0
)!
"5% !(
".#1
%3
( )!(
)$
" !3
#%

1$
'#$ %3
4( #.
1%%!(
7)!
5( )!(
$5'1# $
)
#
#$

#
"$!
(
(!1%3
$
)! '-!" #%0
5(
)$
"11# !3
#..!0.# ,
#%
3#$")(0#%0
# $
35 ,
7)!
)$ 3(<%
)!
 !% #%

)#$
5(

%51!(5$
.! ($
!E")%0!3
'! <!!%
)! $544.#!(
%3
)!
44!..%

$)<
)
)!
$544.#!(
<$
%!0.#0!%
#% 3!.#8!(#%0
)!
1 !(#.
%
#1!
%3*
)!(!(!*
)!
#01
#14$!3
)! 4!%. ,
".5$! 
)8!
)!(3
)!
.!(%!3
"5%$!.
(
)!
44!..%
%3
44(#$!3 )!
44!(
'+ )!
('# ( (*
#%
1,
8#!<*
)$
$$#0%!3
"0!%
(!$%$
( 3!"#%#%0
)!
"5% !(
".#1
/#$DD8#$
)!
0(% #%0

)!
".#1

)! $544.#!(*
)!

('# ( (
)$
((#8!3


#%3#%0
)
#%
"$!
)!(!
<$
3!!"
#%
)!
(%$(1!($*
)!
$1!
)8!
%
'!!%
(!18!3
(1
)!
4."! 
#%$ .. #%*
15")
.!$$*
)!,
(!
$ #..
.,#%0
#%
)!
"5$ 3,

)!
44!..%  )!
44!..%
"5.3
)8!
#$$5!3

3!'#
% !
8#$DD8#$
)!
3!!" #8! (%$(1!($
%3
0
)!
$1!
#%$4!" 3
(1
%
!E4!(
%3
)!(! !(
50) 
)8!
"..!3
54%
)!
$544.#!(

(!4."!
)!
$1!*
)<!8!(*
%
$5") !E!("#$!
)$
'!!%
3%!
)!
(3!($
)8!
'!!%
4$$!3
15")
'!(!
)! #14$# #%

4!%. ,
%3*
)!(!(!*
#%
1,
8#!<*
$5")
"

44!..%
<$ 4(!1 5(!
)!
'-!" #%0
5(
)$
'!!%
!%-#%!3
54%
%
'.#0 #%
 3!"#3!
)!
'-!" #%$
$ (#" .,
$
4!(
)!
4(1! ($
.#3
3<%
#%
7!" #%
?9 
AA
" 
)!
'-!" #%$
% #"!3
'8!*
#%
1,
8#!<*
3#3
%
..
<# )#% )!
(!1!% #%!3
4(1!

($
$
)!,
<!(!
0!%!(.
#%
% 5(!
)!

( ('# ( (*
<)#.!
(!-!" #%0
)!
"5% !(
".#1*
08!
)!
..<#%0
(!$%$&D B


   
             









!

"

                       #  
 $  %!&

  #  

#           '

()(!

)*!

  

  

 +          

 , 

"

    

  


   ()-(!

(!.



/ /

  

 

#$

 

 0'1-(!

.       '2-( !

-13  

'

(22) 2    

#  ,

, ,

   


    
    4.567  0839    

 1:;5

1

10#5

/   3 ,       

  

  

    

      ,   +  

 <

 (

 , 

 ,  4.56 7  083 9  



 

         

"

,  / $ 


"



/ (  6  



 4

     

 6   

   



 ,  
 

+ 

) 
  (!2()

 ,6



  6 

  "

 

   



(         + 

  #   
      6 


 

#6  

    )

    2   (                 !1

 0



)3=

,

# 

  , ,   ,

   

#    +



   

    

  



     

,6     6  

 8    

 '-(1 (! 2 

 

      



 ) <

(

1   <

(

)

  ,  ,

,

>   $ 

  

    6           !  

 

 

 ,

     #,

 



8  ,        

    ' ()(11!.       , (

 

( '!(- (-). 

 


,( 

 

   '-(1 (! 2      ,  


 #   #    4                             

     


+      #  

#           #  



  



       
#  

 

+ ( ,   

  
  (!-(!)222

 11 02   !

 3%!&

  "

 



   


     

  

#  , /

  

  



 #

  

 ((  (

#

   
       / 

,

       

       #,  

   

 




  

6 

=6  





  , 
 

/    

5    

     
  (   ( + ?


#$
%<

$! .!3
.<
)
#%
<)
"#("51$ %"!$
)!
<(3
)$ 
'!
#% !(!(!3
<# )
)!
F5!$ #%*
<)#")
#$
%<
(#$!3
#%
)! (!1!% #%!3
44!.*
)$
.(!3,
'!!%
%$<!(!3
',
)!
%G'.!
754(!1! 5(
#%
" !%

-5301!% $*
<)!(!#%
#
)$
'!!%
.#3
3<%
)
5% #.
%3 5%.!$$
)!
<(3
$5!($
(1
#..!0.# ,
$
$  5 (#.,
4(!$"(#'!3
5%3!( 7!" #%
?9

)!
" *
)!
$1!
"%%
'!
#% !(!(!3
<# )
%
)#$
"% !E
 #% !%3

(!!(
)!
-5301!% $

%G'.!
754(!1!
5(
#%
**+,&-. /,'0.%* 1* #.'2, #.3.'45.6- /-2%,-7 

 (

 )8 &60 &30&7& &** 6-.%-&,65.6- -0 1*

 59,6.* 



 8: %
)!
(!1!% #%!3
-5301!% *
)!
%G'.!
754(!1!
5(
)3
"5..!3

5
)!
( #
3!"#3!%3#
',
).3#%0
)
5% #.
%3
5%.!$$
)!(!
#$
!((( 44(!%
%
)!
"!

(!"(3
(
)!
('# ( (
)$
%
..<!3
$  5 (, .!0.
4$# #%*
#
#$
%.,
#%
)!$!
"#("51$ %"!$
#
<5.3
'!
-5$ ##!3 #% !(!(#%0
<# )
)!
<(3
)!
#0)
5(
$)5.3
%
"
$

5(
 44!.
%3
(!44(#$!
)!
1 !(#.6!8#3!%"!
%3
!1'(+!3
%

4 )
', $5'$ # 5 #%0
# $
<%
8#!<
#%
$544(

)!
('# ( (G$
8#!<

#$
%
)! "$!

)!
44!..%
)
)!
<(3
#$
0#%$
)!
45'.#"
4.#",
(
)$ 8#. !3
)!
4(#%"#4.!$

-53#"#.
44(")*
15")
.!$$
0#%$
)!
$  5 ! %3
 )!(
4(8#$#%$

7!" #%
?9

)!
" 
)!
('# ( (
)$
3!.
<# ) )!
3#$45 !
<)#")
<$
"% !14. !3
%3
<$
<# )#%
# $
$"4!
)!
4( #!$
 )!
)3
4( #"#4 !3
#%
)!
4("!!3#%0$
%3
<!(!
0#8!%
4(4!(
% #"!
% %.

,
<# )
(!0(3

)!
44#% 1!%

)!
('# ( (
'5
8#HDD8#H 4("!!3#%0$
%
1,
8#!<*
)!
<(3

)!
('# ( (
3!$
%
$5!(
(1 %,
#..!0.# ,
#%
$
15")
$
)!
('# ( (*
<)
#$
!E4!( *
)$
3!.
<# )
)! 1 !(
%3
3!"#3!3
)!
".#1

(!$4!" #8!
".#1% $

)!

4( #!$

)!  %
1,
8#!<*
)!
<(3
(!3
$

<).!
#$
-5$ *
#(
%3 (!$%'.!


#$
%<

$! 3
.<
)
)!
('# ( (
#$
)!
$.!
-530!
 F5.# ,
%3
F5% # ,

)!
!8#3!%"!
'!(!
)#1
%3
3!"#3!
%
)!
'$#$
 )!
8#.'.!
!8#3!%"! 
3
%
#%3
%,
#..!0.# ,
%3
4!(8!($# ,
#%
)!
#1450%!3 (3!(
)!
44!.
#$
""(3#%0.,
3#$1#$$!3 +-9.

 !  %&5.*2

#$