Sunandha Dutta @ Veena Dutta v. Kumari Shanti Dutta Memorial And Educational Trust And ORS


  
      






 


 


 



    


 

 
  


 
 
!

 

!" # #
   

 #
$%


#  
#&'
 
#(
& 

 
#  
#&'
#(
& 


 
  '
#(



"   

 
 
 '
#(
& 

 
 )
*'
#(



+,

-'
.
 
/
! 
+0
1 2

(3 
 
 '
#(


 
+4

&
  '
#(




3 '
#(


 
+,,
















( 

"
 
+,0
 "


& 
( 


56765755 + 


+,5

,-
1 " 
( 2




   $   , 8 


(

"  



 70,7575,
1#

9
 02'
&$%
 
#   
  
*'

!&
 

%

.,
%
$%

+,

/'
1

"   2


:  
#""



3 
 
 
5/7657,4
1#

9
 ,2 5 ;




"   
1  
+5
$
  
 
82
$ 


+,

/
1"  
$
  
 
82'

 

 

 
 
"

3   '



"   
 
"

+,7

,0 1 
$
 
 
82'
& 
 
(

  

 
 
  
1"  
+,
$
  
 
82
& 
"
$%

8 
'

   '
 "(  
" 
  
   

"$ 


#
 

,0765777
&
9
 
 


$(
""    

 
$ 


 (
$ )  
""   
 




  
 


& 



"  '
$%



 
" " '
(

"   
 
< 
!8

1


 '

" 
$%
;!

2'
 
+,7'
(

 
 
 
  
 
 


 

'
& 


 +6,.

& '
!& '
 
%
$
  







  
 

 '
 

$ )
 '

$




1"  
+,2


6 ; 







 
 

 "   
 

  '

 
 
8
 



  ( 
3 
 


5/7657,4
1#

9
 ,2

=


$% 




+,

/
 
:  
#""
1#

9
 
%

.,
% '
" 
$%

""  
1#

9
 52
   
-


;   
#'
,/06'
 
"

 
 
 
"



%

"   
 

 

" 
1#

9
 >

 -2'
 
"" 

""  

 
 '



  $  %


""   
 

)

9" %
 

 '
& 

"%


 



> =


$%




 
#""
8'

 

 
 %





%'
& 

 %
 
&
 
&
( 
3  
"  

"
(%


"

"   





?


 @

"(   A

  

""
& 

%
" 

;



9"

$%

""

+,

/
 
%


""

%'



  '

"   
 




  A
+
,

/

  

&

$
 '

 
%
 


 '

 

 

""
& 

%
" 

    '

 %
 
 
 (
"
;




"   




 
#""
8
 

 

(


9"

 ( '
& 


$ 
 

?


 @ -









;


 


""

+
,

/  $%
   

%

0>
%
"

.,
%
  ""  



%'
 




 
" #





'




 
#""
8'

" 
$ ( 

""
 

 $ 

?


 @

  

""
$% 

   
" '
 
 

% 



 

&

   
 $ 
$%
$ 
3   " 
< 


$(
  '

""




 
" 


= ""


  

'




 "   
"
 
"
#%&' () #*+,% &-&(.&/ %0'1,% ".

0.

2.

+*'+ '3 +/*( (+/ +0 4  #
  0


 %'





+
,

/'

'
""


" 
'
 

 
#"" 8

 %
&

""   
 

%'

  

&
""

3  
( 
$
"  


 
 
$%
"  

" 

"

 
 " (
( '


  

 


" 
 
  


=







%
"

$%


$




&
 '
 ( %
$%





 

 




$  


"$ 

'
& 
 % "  




4











;






 
#""
8  %
 

%'
$ 
:  
8

#""'
&
"   $
 (

 
"" %

" 
 
 

=



   
&
3   %
"


 


$

& 

<  
 '

"%



 


"  
$ 
 

 = ""

 
  

'






  "
3  
"  
 

1/(0(5 (+/ 0.

2.

#(0') &2* (+/ 0.

$ 

  

*2*6 77B
80*.%(+ (6 (+/ 0.

2.

%&
'55*..*'+&0$ '%9(: *2*.*'+$ '%9(: (+/ 0.

 
*2

4B .%( %(99(-%(0)&& 2.

(+(,*+,
'55*99&& '3 (,%1+(9%;10 (3(0 -(/&5< (+/ 9%&0. 4  #

= B
+/0( (+/ *.%0(

0.

2.

#9(9& '3 *%(0

0.

  #
4B
(0<(+( #9(9& ,0*-16910&

(0:&9*+, '(0/ (+/ +'9%&0 2.

#15&0 #*+,% (+/ +0
44= 


7  B
 
0.

#(0') (+/ 9%&0. 2.

#% (6)&&9 #*+,% (+/ (+'9%&0  4  

*2*6 

. =
(
 (




$



  




"  
 



 
& 

3  
  

9 
$%

 
:  
#""
8






%




  


8

 
-
 ;    '
#
,/06
"( 


"$  %


9"

 %'


 

%

 
%



" 
%
$ $


& 

"$
9" '
&



 '
%

 
" 

$
 


 % 9" 

C 

8
"

9" '





"  (
9 

   '
%



$
 $'

 


( 
3    '
 

9 

  
""

&%
 $
 '

$ %

"( 

<



  '
&

:  
#""
8






% /


&

   
 

"$ 
" %

!
    


 

 %

 


"  '
%

 




" 


 

%
  '
$
)
 
%
""%


" %
  


8


3 

 "
$& "  

( 
$  
3  




  

 

 


%
""%

D&('


" " 

%

"" 

8

&%
 $
'

( 
3   

'


$


?


 @
""
 
-
 ;   
#
,/06'

$




? $

@'



(  
$  
3  

=

9"
 
$%

 
""


8
 
)



 


"



"
  %
%'

8
 
&
 


 


 

= 

 $
 

"

%
&
 
$%
 "%
 $%


 

)



'

8






" 


9" 

,7 =

 '
; 
#""
8
3

9"


$%

+
,

/


%


""'
 

$ 

" 
 
& '
&
 
$%
&



 
&
 (



&

$
 
 

D&('

 
#""
8
$ (

 
+
,

/ '
&

 
  


9

(%
 
(  %






  "

" 

""
$% 

" 

    '

$
 (

"" %

 



  
; 
#""
8
 $ (

(

" 
 
+,

/
&
  '
%



$
&
'

 
  
""
& 
 



  

,,


8



( &


%

.,
%



$



$
 
%'
&



  
""'

" %'
&

"" 





"


"
+
,
/


""
$% 

" 

    
=


 '
&

+,

/
 


$ '


  



&) 
 
'
 
 
  


"$ 


!

&
"
+
,

/'
(

 

"
 
 

'
% (

"" %

 " 

 
"
 


  
""

$%

" 
 


   
"  '
 
%

 $
  
 

 
  



:'

8


 ( &

& $  
3  
 
 


 

"  



'



"(  ,5 +&'

&
$
"




3  
" 

$%






"   
=
#%&' () #*+,%

.1;0($

&
%

>4/
% 

""



 
! 
8'


 
E  


9"

 %


""
)
$%

" 
&


   

 
 

""'

"" 
 


"   
C  % (
3  
" '
D @$
#"9
8
$ (
  
9 

 (
 
&
 $




 '

+,

/'

"
  


1/(0(5 (+/ 0.

(0<(+( #9(9& ,0*-16910& (0:&9*+, '(0/ (+/ +'9%&0 .1;0($
$
  '

&
$ (

&



:  
""'

 
  $
 

$
 (

" 

%
= 0.

#(0') (+/

9%&0.
1 "2

8 
$ 
 

%

>>4
% '




 



  '



 


 


%
=

80*.%(+ (6 (+/ 0.

.1;0(
 %

( 


 

 





%

>->
%  =
'

+/0( (+/ *.%0(

0.

.1;0($

%

04/

&
 
$% $ ( 

   

&



"( 





$  

3  
,6 :




$('

8

 





3  
  
9 
$%

 
:  
#"" 8

E  '

(
"  
$%
 



,>  
  
""   2'

 %'

 
  
 %

  

 

 (10(2 #'0'9 Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No