High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5149/2010dismissed

Jagjit Singh v. Preet Mohinder And ORS

2016-08-31Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"##$%&%'()*)&"+, - !*.%"%'*/ 00#11!'"

2#3&)&

3##" /%'4#3"/#3& #&0'4#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

3#&#'"( 3!'4/),45$!"#, 3"/#!00#11!'" 3!3#&/ !36/!7!3,45$!"#, 33#&0'4#'"&,89 ::::: *)+%,'

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

/!44#0&#4"/!"!""/#"%<##@#$)"%'"/#?%11,/#>!&+=#!3&14,%'

#&&#'$#)3.%"%'*/>!&*%5%'*/%<>37)3.%"%'*/%&''##1&#6)" /)&6!'4 3#<B!"!,"/#6#'#%$%!3="/#?%11#)3"/#3&)6<%"&"/!" 3<"/#$'"#'"&"/#?%11,%"!00#!3&"/!"%"/!&6##'03#0!3#4!""/# 4%3#$"%' !7&/% %'*/ !'4, "/#3#3#, "/# &)&0%$%)& $%3$)<&"!'$# 035#4""/#/%1",6)""/#)3"&6#1>/!5#'"!003#$%!"#4"/#&!<#!'4, "/#3#3#,"/#3#%&%11#*!1%"=!'40#35#3&%"=%'"/#%<0)*'#4.)4*<#'"&!'4, "/)&,)3*#&"/%&)3"33<)1!"%'"/#&)6&"!'"%!1C)#&"%'&1!>!& $)11#4)"%'"/#<#<3!'4)<!00#!1

#3 $'"3!, 3!3#&/ !36/!7!3, 1#!3'#4 $)'&#1 3 3#&0'4#'"&,8!'49&)6<%"&"/!""/#030#3"=%'4%&0)"#%&<!31!& !'4+&!3&!/%!'4/#3/)&6!'44%#41'*"%<#6!$7,%#,03%3""/#&)%" !'4&/#%&"!7%'*$!3#/!'4%$!00#44!)*/"#3 !'.%"A!)3!1&!00#!3#4 !'4%1#4"/#>3%""#'&"!"#<#'"!4<%""#4&$3%6%'*"/#?%115#'01!%'"%, %'$3&&;#@!<%'!"%',!4<%""#4"/#&%*'!")3#& !3!<.%"A!)3!'4 !'.%"

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

3"/#3#*%'*3#!&'&,4'"%'"#'4"4%#3>%"/"/# %'4%'*&3#'4#3#46=6"/"/#)3"&6#1>*3)'43%'"#3#3#'$#, <)$/1#&&&)6&"!'"%!1C)#&"%'1!>!3%&#&34#"#3<%'!"%'6="/%&)3" 00#!1&"!'4&4%&<%&&#4 01/,2 *)+%

304 '(-.& +414056 70

807

+414 19!

807