Balbir Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS.
! "
# $
% " "
&'(!( %
& )( " %
&! ' %
* +,* - -
-& .
+,* - ,, ! "#$ %&#'(&) &*+ ,-&./ 0/&#) &*+ ,-& &0&% &&(+ ,-& 1/ 23245678 86 9:;3 &/)&+ ,-& 1/ 23 2456 <8 =6 9:;& 456 :9796 9:;3 0 &*+
* + &#&&./ 4/&/&+ + &#&& /&.&*+ ,-&1 //& &,+ ,-& 1 >245678 86 9:;3 ????
-
-& .
/ : - &** / . 23 2 &3+ ,*, -((
@1*&.+" +&1(-((/A+/+ /#&&(&"*" - /!/&-((, -
/&01",#+/1&-145678 86 9:;& &0/1 - !/&-,#
/!//&. +/ 23&01 @&/!1A6:9+&"-&( & "#/4((+ !& ,+A-!/ .1 -4* & - = 1/ &%&" * ! 24* & &
,1&!(&3-+:8=;2/&11/-&** & /B4* &-+:8=;B3" /#&*&01/@&/!1 A6::+&"-&( & "#/ /* &6-(64* &
11-+ &&+A-!/ . - :2 31/ B4* &-+:8=;B =
/ -* & & / mohal --
-((- &- & 1-& 2A 6:3+ ./-/ "-&( <9 999 "@*#+ / 4* & ,#4((.&- 797 99:1*- A6 +/& 4* & ,#4(( (
/,&*&1*& +///&1A&- (& Land owned by the proprietors 16 Anna Cultivable land of the Gram Panchayat 12 Anna Drar and Nalas 8 Anna Pahar 4 Anna 7
/ &1 -* & -/( .& "*/ :>9> 99; & &1 / /&! 1 "%- / -/( .& &- C&-- ;9< 9:92A6=3/(&0!1 A6=+/ -16 &!.&& & .& -( * 1(:99 9:: :9 9:: / & 6 &!
!
- !&&A &A671* "#A6 >+./-//!/(" // - !*&-/ - :2:31/B4* &-+:8=;D+"&
&/&/ &!!, 1(A6>+ 1&#&
&*, /&!&*&*#+ (1/-/(16
&! A 6>+ .& *, 1( ::9> 9::
79> 9::+ / / & /* -- .,+ "@*# & &* 1 !& & / "( & -( *&2A6<3/ - &*14* &1
* !+ &#&&+&**!!//&:79&-1 &-/&#&*&
,&* & 99-/&"&1 / ,& & >
A6<+/ - &*14* & ./*A-! . -= &-+ :8=;B+(& & -./"#/,&*&1/ &-/&#&*&
. "6(& " /&11 &-/&#&*& /
,& &+&(& /-* & - !+".&&* & 2A6;3 < !&A6;+(1/&!!, 1* .
"&! :;>: 1 9:
& / & . A68"-&( / &, 1A68 A&- /&1 "..In view of above, this writ petition is allowed and the order under challenge dated 22.8.2012 (Annexure P8) stands quashed. The Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon Division, Gurgaon upon whom powers of the Government have been conferred under Section 42 of the Act is directed to take up the matter afresh and pass an appropriate order after affording effective opportunity of
" hearing to both the parties. Both the parties are directed to appear before the above said officer on 29.7.2013. The Commissioner will serve notice upon the other rightholders also who are likely to be affected.." ; &-/&",(& (& "#/4+ / - 4* & & A 6:9+ ./"# / (& / lis /-* &11--- +./(& A6::*&*#"/A6:9& 6::"-( &&* "1/4
0
1 0$$234 53674323434
890 1 334 50436 4:2#5
;# 8 &- 1&-(/&A6>+(&
6&&* &/&-1/&!!, A6>.&
&.(1- :2:31/B4* &-+:8=;B
,./1+"-(A&- /&1+/"#!,/ & A&/(&!-/&**! /!/&&
&* ,"! 1 /&!&*&*#+&-@ 1&*# & --*,# "21.
- (1) The Consolidation Officer shall, after obtaining the advice of the landowners of the estate or estates concerned, carry out repartition in accordance with the scheme of consolidation of holdings confirmed under section 20, and the boundaries of the holdings as demarcated shall be shown on the shajra which shall be published in the prescribed manner in the estate or estates concerned."
:9 ,+ ./ / & A 6> &* "-&( ( *( & A- /!/ &
"-(!
*, /&/* -- /1+"",*#/ & *,# 1 .& (& *# &1 /
& 1
' - "-(!(& (1-
& -+:8=;B ::
/!/&1/
&1- &0! *&-+/ A-&"*% -, +/ -14* & &/.// (&1-= 1/E4* &-+ :8=;D+ -&**#+.//&" -*& &**-/) !( (& "#/4 -&* & B
!
"
# $% & '( ) )) * +, -
# B ./ %%% . '
(/ * *,& &&!& /./1A&-
/&1+/&/A-!1% -"#/&#&/# -- + & ( *& "1 /(+ - = 1 / E4* &-+:8=;D&/*( --1&/(-&* -*-&*& C-&1&-* & &/+"./ -/-* & &/-& A-&"*.// "-&!&/1& &/"#/&/* -- 46.
We, therefore, have no hesitation in recording that it is beyond debate that, if a question arises, before an officer exercising power under the Consolidation Act, regarding any right, title or interest in "Shamilat Deh" "vested" or deemed to have vested in a Gram Panchayat, a Consolidation Officer, the State or its delegate exercising plenary power under Section 42 of the Act, are not empowered, while examining the correctness of any scheme prepared during consolidation or order passed thereunder to record a finding on such a question of title or to hold that land is or is not "Shamilat Deh" and as a consequence whether any right, title or interest vests or does not vest in the Gram Panchayat. 0 (1
+
1 ) 2
2
+
3+
(( *
< 4 "
2
+
!
5
6
7% 7
((
+
! 5 ( 7* ( "
( '
'
) 2+( -
(("
(
5
+) 5 ,+
where there is none, as opposed to a mere erroneous exercise of jurisdiction or may, at best be construed to be an order passed by a tribunal of limited jurisdiction, in the exercise of its limited powers to correct errors in the scheme or orders passed during consolidation and nothing more. The latter conclusion would require a degree of explanation." :
/1+./"",*#/% -6 &.
/--* -* &-/(+/&,*1/"!
&# , ,&*& ,&*& 1 / -, &1/&/* -- +& +1/ &(&-/&#& -- +" &,*1(6&**(231*& "!(& -,*# / & /* -- " / &( &-/&#&-- +&/A-&"*+/"#/&/# -( *& - = 1 / B4* & -+ :8=;B *&*#+ /"# / A-! 1 % - , / &
-,#"#/ -&/&(- "1/( -= &-+:8=;B+/.&,&
.//,-1*&-01% -&*( .(/!/(+ //&& (-/*& % -&/& ( : (&*#+ &* ./ / ,&* *# A-&"* % -+ / (!- 1 / 23 2 &3+ A *& /% !(2 &3&/"A-&"**&*# "#/4,*4-- /1+/ &, 1/ , - 2 &3+ & (& "# / 4+ / *& ! / -
) 4* & /!/ A 6:9+/-(&0& 1 (& + / 4* & 11- -- + ./&1B / 4* & 11-(& /( ! A6::+/&
-*& " -&(+/ -*&&1*&.(& 0=06 -4 56>$08#209 := /&&(&#+&1/
&1- &0! *&- (1-
&-+:8=;B& /& &11/&!!, 1(A6>+(&0!&-/&**! /+ /"# ./ &-@ " ! & --*, 11- *&*#.//&1B&11 .(& &** / & /* -- + -*, 1 / &( &-/&#& -- 4@*#+ / -/&**! 1&*F -* & -/(+/.&&(&"*",0 /!//(&0!1& *!&**#1( 2A6:93" "#/-6@&**#1( 2A6::3+"/ ./1+&(& (1& , -(& "#/445 :;>:1 9:
+, -./1 1&2 &3+ -&(/ -*&&1*&.(& 0=06-4 56+$08#209 :7
/& -&*#A1&- -&(/
-*&&1*&.(& 0=06-4 56+$08#209"&&* !&1/&#(& &-* - >1/ B4* &-+:8=;B+ ,./1&A&- /&1+ &(-/ &+ /"# / -/&**! " ! & --*, -* &-/(+/&"&"*#,& ,0 +& +/& + /& .1,-&&1&1/-/( "-(!/ B , &/*#/& ,(+ /!/ (&0! & &
/./ 1-&+ ./&1B
% / / "@ -/( @ " & +
"*/ & -1( "&-- &-.// ,1/ B4* &-+:8=;B-/.//& ,(.&/ * #1A-!&"* .,0,&#/&* 1&*F -* &-/(+//!/&1-&"-(! "# + ./&1 & 1/ -* & -/(+ / .& @ " &.+"*#&1-&"-(! "#/ & ,(+&/16"!!/ mohal -- 6 -* & &+/&+ & /-"!(& &**/ &
&# ,+//1&*F -* &-/( "-( (& .,+ ./ &
&*# / 1-& "#/& ,(+//1 -,*#,&#! -&-**!/&-* &-/( .//&# 1-& "#/& ,(&/16"!!/ mohal -- 6-* &+//!/& /-"!
(& &**/*,&&# , "6% 2
'
' )% 8 A scheme ·for the consolidation of holdings confirmed under this Act may, at any time, be varied or revoked by the authority which confirms it subject to any order of the State Government that may be made in relation thereto and subsequent scheme may be prepared, published and confirmed in accordance with the provisions of this Act." :> -@-+/ 2 &3./-/ prima facie+ ,&#& ,0/1&*F -* &-/(&-1*-./ - >1/B4* &-+:8=;B& &@ " @&/ & &
( :< @*+/. -- & /( !
&@&/ & & /! /&/#&(& ! & 1 / ,&* *# A-&"* % - "# / &
&/ :; 1 &! / 4 * (&0 -& ",&23 &!& / &/ A-! % - -= &-+:8=;B ,+/4 &* * (&0 -& --, ",&23 ,6&6, / 4**--- +A-!% - /%&"**&! 4(( & 2!*&3 -+ :8>: / & --, ",&23&& $6 :3 *#+/&/,&! -= 1/ B4* &-+:8=;B&@ "& /!/(& &1 *&.-& *& 0=06-4 56+$08#209" &%
&*,/% !(1, & "#/4
&
&/&/-( *&-23/(& && -* /% !( &/"-&1/*&-01 0.* ! ** &!23 1 / &/ -( *& -= &-+:8=;B /1+/
&* 4/1-/ ,(1%&"& &#&&+&
- 1/./ & &&+ / ,&*! / (" 1 -/&**! , -+ ./-/ "-&( - "# / &/ -( *& - = 1 / B4* & -+ :8=;B+ -&**#./-/, -& /-& (&1 % !((& &#"#/4 /& &&"-**- &
"( "1/4"1' ) "
,+/4/&&*-*#- /&/ 4**--- (&0!&*"/, -& -<& C -::1/%&"**&!4(( & 2!*&3-+:8>:+/!/&@ "1&(! &&1(/- *& !1/*!&-- +& + ./&1/#&@ " (!/*!&-- + &
- / &
, - / + ./+ /
-/&!!"-(-&/*!&-- +"#/ & -(&6& +/*& !!%- =3
/4**--- &&*"&!( /
- **&! 11 (&-& /!//&/23 /1
!/."A
/&
**&&/-- +./* &*!.// &
*-&1- !/ *&#&&*1(*&!+ /- *& !&/# (!/*!&--
&
-/, - -/&!!/ :8
/1+ / 4 &* /
&* 4/1 -&#+,23+ -,*#/&1%&"& / &1 &#&&++/&&!&( & /&/ -( *& -= &-+:8=;B+" & - /&&!&( & /4**-&
**&/-( *& /%&"**&!4(( & 2!*&3-+:8>:
9
/&!"( & " "-( *
./.(/1( &#& ./&(&/4 "-(!(& &&11 &,"."#/--
: / 232 &3+*' ) "
,
-
&1(&/+/41 (/. 23 & + ./ / &", ",&23+ / &( & &**. / ( ! &@&/ & &
.,+ / 4 , *"# / &!!, ,& -- &-- / *!&**#
("*( (1Parkash Singh>$08#209" *&,*"#/& ,(+/1.**1( &
&!"*&&1-&(1- >1/ B4* &-+:8=;B
= -/(&-&23*1/&," - +/+&** / !&
*-&23+1&#+&*& 23 1 8-
-& .
8,, 9 % " "
0&,!/ 5// &0!C&
$ C 5// &"* $ C