Shiv Chopra v. State Of Punjab
!"# $%&%!'()*+*
( ,- * ...
!
" # $ %
&&&&& ../ * 0
! "# $%$$% #&&'()&%$() '&%& *%
*&*&*+ ,+
-
&+"
&.
/
/
& / 0 0
&1
-,
0 %%$%$
!2(2(3$3($&24+
0
%3%$ !2(2(3##($
0 %$$ !2(2(%%**#($ ,
/
( /
/ / ,,
-
& /
4
,,
/
4 5 , +
,
/
,
")(3*(+(3 2 4 6 )
4 )(3*+('%%, 4
)
4
/
")('7(%%$$ 8
/ &
/
/ ) & ! ,
9
0
& ,
" ,,
! 6 $%$$% %3 / 0 :
& &
4
,
,
!"'
#$$% &#&*$3& *(*( *+ ,+&
-
/
0 #$$
!2(2(*$'+: (*& !"$' $$#$% '()&$% % &
-
&
0 $$%$
+
5 & + "
+: (3 ! "# $$3$% $ &
-
6&&
/
&, &/ ( & ,
&24,+
&1
-,
&
+
;
-
0 0
0 +: ('(%$ 0
& &
(
6
&/
&
& !*&$$$<( 0 0 , , & 0
4
,&/0 & , ( & ,
&24,+
&1
-,
&
+
;
-
0 0
0 %3%$&%%$%$&%$$
$$*$ 0
+: ('(%$ * 0
3 +,
& $%$$% %3 / 0 :
/ !
&
0
.
+
&
= &, &/ (
& ,
&24,+
&1
-,
&
+
;
-
0 0
0 %3%$&%%$%$&%$$ $$*$ 0
' &/ ,, ,
&
/ & ,
& 0
<9
'
( # # !
!!
!!
!
#!
!
) *
+$ , -- ---.
/ ( (
/ /!
!
( /! !
..
232& )/ 0
1 02 3 4 1 3 4