Nafe Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Another
!" #"$%&%'(
")%'*+ '#!+",& -- "!%!%'",& .& )! !" ,/ ' '# '!+", -- "&0'#"'!& ( 12 ) ) 3
!"" #"$% & '( )!"* !
45%,)"+, 6 !78 , 9:
+"!"" ",- "."% / "% 0 "* 12
*" " ,- ,
,3342 %" "" "%5" &"" 6%%% 0 "%! "*""* /" .!." ,-
7 8 9 :"3
!"$" !! / %"% ;2%%0*" *"*". <* " .!."2 .!%"
! " = " "% *" 6%
/ " $" "/" ./ .!." /$!"$"" $" ( " " % .(0 + %".".
/> " *% %*% (." "% "% %" 5$"0 "%( !!%
"*$" > ! ""*!!( "*%"
%"/("* ./(%*%(.+ " "% "!
%" /$$!" "*% "% "%.( "( ' /% ." *" !"%""!
/( .!." ."* $" "%*% 0 $%%'$ "."%"!
"%(" .% %($!""! ". " ! 0
+ "."% "
0 ! "(%*+ %$! "/ !
". !
".8.!
". " % "* !%( "."% '$ . " "% "!
" %" $!" ..% " "."%! +
%*%(.!%(.!"% %" /$$!"<$" ) "* ".! "!
0 "( %*".""."?# "%% ""% %" /$$ "/(!
"*"+ "."%%$"0 "*" *$" !""!
*"?"*"!" "!% %( 2"%*%(.%! " *"?"* .!." /$$" "."%"!
" "8! ! """" *+" " %(! " .! "* "*"% / !." .! "* !!%% ""%* '$ /(" ( ! " /% !"(<$" *"" .!."/$!" < "%(</ "+" "%%(
! "/
2"%+%.
! "/ " 2@
8""*"2$"." ".". .)"*8""*
/%"*"* $ .%"" !
/"* *"? " "$ %*" % .+" "0 " %)"* /( " *"? .!."/$!" "!
# ."" "( ! ! "/ "."% "%<+"% /!." %/( !! "/
! ' " )"* ",-/( '"* # / / $" %(!" "."% "!
$ %%$(/
" "." "."%"%" "$ ! % /%
<" $ % % 0 "( %*+
.."/(!" % "* .""" 0 ""*
" "%!$$"%8 ""*
" !$ /!."/ .!."5")$"
" % "* %($!" ! / % "*! "( " % "* "* ""% % %"
"*""%% !!(/( 8"* ".." % %"
< / !." / .!."@8 !/ ."*
" ( %%
%/!."/ .!."/( " !
/ *"$ %" % !""!
"
!."./ .!."!"$ %!%(" ) ! 0 "% /( / "*.""" "."% " "" "" .""" "."%> "
,
""?%!" )"*/!%( ! / > " (."$ %%$(/"" " "% < .!."/$!"" *"? ""? ." . .." "% (. .""" > " % 0
$" " "(!."/ .!." 'A/% !. .!%( %"
"%*%!"" *"?"* .!.""*"
!"/ B3 +!"".* ./ " " / .." !$ '"* "0 "* "."%! "*12 .!%""8 " ""> "" """" "
!$*" "."% .! "*
" 2!$" $"!%" $" ( %".""/ "/8 "" $"* "%"* " !$ "?<7"9 > " 7""9! / ! ( 2$ !$0 "."%! "* .!%"12.(/8 "$
" ". %""!
$ %! " . *( /! "/'$ / 8 " !$
'"* .
* * "( ". '" "
.%! "(
%").
! "( / ""*%(0 * " ". " ".A ."%(
%"!
!" " " ".! "( "."%%( ( .!."/$ " ".
"%"
! "% %") " !"
.." /(!
/%" $"%$)"*" ! "( < ! " ( /" 0 "* "."%! "*" % "*
# "."% "* $%."*%(!.""*%( " "% % "
"* !
! 0 "* !"
%%(
""* . .. "% " "% . "% " "% !"! %") "
""* .".(%"*$( ."%("!
$$*"/" %%(!" !%" !" % " ""! 2" *(
3 '"* .(0 "."%! "*"
"" "$ / .!."/$
" ".
!"/"%"( " "" ./%) " " "."% $ %!
* !!"!> " 8."> " $ %/ "./( "* "."% !"
%% .!% %. .!."$" " ".2$ '"* .
" $"$ %/ " (" > " " $" "."%! "* " " "."%! "*$ % . / ! %$!"%. .!." /$ " ".$*$ > " " "!!!" "."% "!
"
$/ "79 " "
"." '"* %% / $%% $"" " "" "0 "."%! "*C + ! %% " ( 8 !" "*/ ' " "$ ! " = " "%*"
6%
."!
3
! /(" %
%!
!$ %/ /( )!"*! "* %" 2$"%%/"" > " "
%. /$!"" !
"*%( !!"""%%$ +12
*" " ,- ,
,3342 %" "" "%5" &"" 6% %% 0 "%! "* ""* /(0 0 !!"" /" .!."" /$!" ) 3
!)"*; D; !/% D;