← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6326/2015disposed of

Vishnu And ORS v. Blr Pvt Ltd And ORS

2023-01-23Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages



             

   !" "#$%$&'  ($%)&* &+!)",% -.."// &!% 0",%*% 1,$0 !"1$2$!"+ &+!)",% -"%.&+"&!% , 2'

&34/"5,*%!$#"67 /$  ,"%"&!' 5,($%) / ,89+0# !" ,!)" .."// &!%

&" ,,"%.&+"&! %: 5,*&$! $&9+0# !" ,,"%.&+"&!   ;;; 67 /$ 9<, /=  , >", $& !)" $&%! &! .." / $% , 2+$ $# !$&   ? ,+ + !"+. %%"+4>!)"/" ,&"+5!,##$+"&!%/ $2 ,$4*& /9  ,& /  &+ "&) &#"2"&!   #2."&% !$& ? ,+"+ % /% !)" $&!","%! . > 4/"  1" ,&"+#*&%"/#&!"&+%!) !!)"+"#" %"+? % )*%"?$ "9 >" ,%  8" &+/"

!4")$&+!?%&% &+&"+ *8)!",  1" ,&"+ ,$4*& /4>!," !$&8!)"+"#" %"+ %)*%"?$ " &+ ! @$&8&!$& /$&#2" % A.",2&!)9 ../$"+2*/!$./$",  &+!)","4> %%"%%"+#2."&% !$& % 9B 9A9 ? ,+"+%9A !? ,+% *&", /"C."&%"% &+!! /#2."&% !$& %9 9A /&8 ?$!)$&!","%!DBE.", &&*2  1" ,&"+ #*&%"/ #&!"&+% !) ! !)" &!$& / $&#2"   !)" +"#" %"+$%,"F*$,"+!4"! @"& !%GA.",2&!)$&0$"? !)" +"#$%$&   !)$% &34/" *,! $& H  

  

39

        9 /" ,&"+ #*&%"/ , !)" ,"%.&+"&! &%*, &#"

2. &>) %,"

",,"+!!)"+"#$%$& &34/"!)"6*.,"2"*,!$& H    

    

3

9!#&!"&+!) !!)"$&#2" !)"+"#" %"+ )*%"?$ "<!)","$&= 8"+ >" ,%? % %%"%%"+ !%A.",2&!)$& ,"%."#!   +" !)  $&F*"%!$&   !)" )*%"?$ " !)","$& $& & ##$+"&! & "/"0 &!"C!, #! !)"% 2"$%,".,+*#"+ %*&+",' !"   #

$ % " %  

 "% "#

 & '() * $ "  "  $ % "( !" $*    " &   "    % )+"

(( '(,)   * # -*   "  $# *#  % 

   '(,,)( % "  "   ,

 % & 

 . " * , " / ##   $

/ ## " %

  &

0  " #%

 % " %$ #1 

" *&

0 % " "

# 

# "  #1 & "  &1  $ 

% "

" 

 "# " " **##  "## &   #  % **  "  % +2

   " # %   $ 

% -*  # 1 0  ( . "%  " # $*   *1&#  " **## 

" %  **#  '(,3,)4(   #"+?$!)!)" ,"2"&!$&"++"#$%$&9/" ,&"+#*&%"/ , !)" .."// &!%#&!"&+%!) !$&0$"? !)"+"#$%$&$&H    # %"<%*., =9!)"&!$& /$&#2" !)"+"#" %"+4"! @"& !%A .",2&!) &+$&0$"? !)"+"#" %"+4"$&8>" ,%  8"9E !)" &!$& /$&#2"4"#*&!"+ ,?,@$&8*!!)" *!*,".,%."#!%. > 4/" $& !",2%   !)" +"#$%$&  &34/" !)" 6*.,"2" *,! $& !$& / &%*, &#" 2. &> 1!+ 0",%*% , & > 6"!)$ &+ !)",%9 G<=  <$0$/= B &+ $& 0$"?   !)"," 4"$&8 !),"" +"."&+"&!%9 +"+*#!$&  A ,+ !)"$&#2"4"2 +" ,?,@$&8*!+"."&+"&#>$&0$"? !)"

+"#$%$&$&      <%*., = &+            3

( G 1" ,&"+ #*&%"/ *,!)", #&!"&+% !) ! & 2*&! ) % 4""& ? ,+"+& ##*&! /%% . ,"&! /#&%,!$*2##,+$&8/>9!),"" .."// &!%#/ $2 &!% ,""&!$!/"+!%9A" #)$"%9 9A& ##*&! /%% . ,"&! /#&%,!$*2$& ##,+ &#"?$!)!)"+"#$%$&$& H!   "      # 

     $    9 + '

' 

# 555 &+H%      

H  &    ' &  

9 

( I 1" ,&"+#*&%"/ *,!)",#&!"&+%!) ! % 8 $&%! 1 2*&! ? ,+"+& ##*&! /%% "%! !"9% 9A$%/$ 4/"!4" ? ,+"+9 4"%$+"% % 8 $&%!%9A ? ,+"+& ##*&! *&", /"C."&%"%9 % 9A$%/$ 4/"!4" ? ,+"+ B

)"#/ $2 ,!," !$&8!)"&!$& /$&#2" !)"+"#" %"+9 , !"   +"+*#!$& !? ,+% .",%& / "C."&%"%   +"#" %"+9 #/ $2 , #&%,!$*29 *!*," .,%."#!%9 #2."&% !$& !? ,+% /%%   "%! !" &+

*&", /"C."&%"%$%&!+$%.*!"+4>/" ,&"+#*&%"/ ,,"%.&+"&!     ) 0"#&%$+","+!)"%*42$%%$&% /" ,&"+#*&%"/   +2$!!"+/>9 !)" $&#2"   !)" +"#" %"+ ? % ! @"& % %

9A.", &&*2?)"," % %.",!)"+"#$%$&$&H      <%*., =9 !)" % 2" $% /$ 4/" ! 4" ! @"& % % 9A .", &&*2 /!)*8)9 & +"+*#!$& ? % 2 +" & ##*&!   .",%& / "C."&%"%  +"#" %"+>"! %.",. , 8, .)  !)"+"#$%$&$&H     <%*., =9+"+*#!$&!? ,+%.",%& /"C."&%"%) %!4"2 +"?)$#) % .", !)" +"#$%$& $&        <%*., = &+      <%*., =$&!)"# %" !),""+"."&+ &!%?,@%*!!A ,+*,!)", %

.",!)"+"#$%$&$&H!  "  #

# # %"<%*., = &+H  &    ' &  

# %"<%*., =9!)" #)$/+,"& !)"+"#" %"+ ,""&!$!/"+!. ,"&! /#&%,!$*2D%9A " #)9!! /%9 9A?)$/" %.",!)"+"#$%$&$&     # %" <%*., =9 !)" 2*&! & ##*&!   /%%   "%! !" $% ! 4" . $+ D % 9A .", 2&!) /$@"?$%" $& !)" # %"  *&", / "C."&%"% ##,+$&8/>9 %.",!)"+$%#*%%$& 40"9!)"+"! $/% 0 ,$*%)" +% #2."&% !$& ? ,+"+ 4> !)" 5 9  ,& / 9 % ?"// % 2*&! %%"%%"+4>!)$%*,!9 %?"// %!)"!! /#2."&% !$&. > 4/"?,@% *! %*&+",'   

       *.""%

     *.""%  &#2"

.", &&*2

.", &&*2  *!*,".,%."#!%

$/ E  9AJ K

AL

A

"+*#!$& !? ,+% .",%& / "C."&%"%  +"#" %"+

1 A ,+

 J  L A  5*/!$./$", ../$"+  

! / 2*&! ? ,+"+

9B 9A 9I9A !? ,+% +"."&+"&#> ./*% *!*," .,%."#!%

1%% "%! !"

1 9A G 1%%  . ,"&! / #&%,!$*2

1 9 9A I 10" &+

"#!$&

1

1 B *&", /"C."&%"% 9A 9A  &!","%! BE.", &&*2 BE.", &&*2 

! / %9 9A % 9B9A   ##,+$&8/>9$&!)"/$8)! !)".%$!$&&!"+ 40"9? ,++ !"+  . %%"+ 4> !)" /" ,&"+ 5 9  ,& / 9 ? ,+$&8 #2."&% !$& %9 9A$%2+$ $"+ &+#2."&% !$&. > 4/"$%

"&) &#"+ ! % 9B9A  ##,+$&8/>9 #2."&% !$& 4" . $+ !", +"+*#!$&8 !)" #2."&% !$& /," +> . $+ % /% 4> 2 @$&8 ,"F*$%$!" +"+*#!$&& ##*&! $&#2"! C$& ##,+ &#"?$!)/ ?   .." /

* %$&!)" ,"% $+!",2%    

  6'7 "8 ."" */

0) 

:); ."" *&# :);