Beant Kaur & ORS. v. Union Of India

DHARAM VIR 2019.05.23 13:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

    
      

  


 








 








 

 

  

!  "

 

 ! "#
$%
%





! #
#%
%



& '

"

  #  $%&'

()*+,+-./ (
)*#


,

-


.
/ '&

+0

1
23

43
.#
(2%
.*
% .*%


*


 (
#0%

2*

44%


# 


%
*



#


"
-



43
.#
(2
%
,5

4
"

+&

 43
%
,%
6*

3
#

 +
76
 









4

4
 6



,

+
4

4
*
23

*

( (2

#

#



* *


#0

&#) "*%
4
4

.2




#3%
2

 /

+&
)
89%
*4



*
$#
"* 

,

+
#
7%

2

#
4
**

4

)

 

(4
#
6
4

23


 
)3 

#
%
4



24
"#2 
)
43
"%


3

4
#
 





(
$%


#%
 #

" !%
)%



23
4
3*



'




 #%

"
!%
)%


##


$ % )
(
$







23  
 %
4
43
6%

3
%


#
 

/6
#2
4

(
$




#3
##2





#2



#2
 


(3



 
**

 #
  


23 

(
&43


#

23

*


4
# 
6

*


4


 
3
4


 

"

:;

4
"

+&


43
%
,





4



  *
<

6
23

43


6
4 

 






4
#

 

)

2

3
 *
4


)

3 2
2

#23



23
#




4
#3 **

( %

3
4
#

#

#
 4







*

(2
#

4*
 =


4

2 
*





#

> =

*



4

#2

"

:;:

;

4
"

+&


43
>

 

=

:;
0


:;


>



(




%
2*
4%
4

6
 *


23

(2

(
(2

#


#

 3
 
*

=

%
 

44


%


 3&4



6
4






<%




=
$#
"*%
4




 


*%

#

7
43
"
23



 
2


*
4

2

)3%
4%

 =
$#%
4


#3


#3



4% 



#3



43
"

7


,

+
#
$
23
2
4


4
3
 




6

2

#
(3
2
 
/

+&
)
89%
2

#

2
23
 

.
 ?3

23

#3%
4

2
2* 

23

#0
#%

4


 
=
$#
"*
2



@



 #)
"*
2

#


7




(%
 (2

#





#3



43

=







4

3
23%
3
 
 

#
4




6
43



3 

A
6

4*








 



***
4
3*

 
#
#%


 46


4
'

43







 #2

2






 
*

4%


$








#
2




#) "*%
4






 #





A 


3

4
6




4
 &#)
"*
4


#
(
3

2* 
$






A
#

$


 **

9*



3

4
4 #2*
4

*
(
$



6
43
 
#

##
4
#%
4%



64
 

4

##

4
6

23

$





4





(2
4

 
4
 


=




3





4

* 4
2*
6
43
23


%

**
'

% 4

6
"*%
A
.2%
$ %
)%
4
##
 9#

.
4 




#*
)*# 

'






4
3*
**
 3


6

    
2



6 



%






#
 









26
6


# 4


4
6
2



4
3*
2
 %
4%


4
%






 6
#

3


=

.
?
2
 3
%

4



#



4

 2

4
*
26


#3



2


 
3

4*

(
(2



*
 
#2


*


?

#
*
1
4 4


2
9

 '

2

 
#%

(2

#
 



#3


4
3





#


%



#
 

%

4


2 
#


'

4 
3


#

= %



2


6
4 
2?3

-



26*

 

#9%

.
 

#








7







#* )*#


* 


%


6
 2

#



23

$ %

4


 
(2

#






4



  *
8




?3

23

#3
 
2

 

%

%





4 
2
6
23
=
2 

(2
4





 3
64




2

4
#
2


 2

*

4
4%

#3
3

#

 

=
2



@

#)
"*
4 
9

4
2*



7

7

*


&43
 #3


#*
)*#
23
6*



 #3

=
#3

2
23



?3 
23

#3
%
%



2
#


6
4 


,

(
.





=
 %

44


%




#3



*


&#)
"*


43
"
 7

)

2
(3

4
#
43 6
#
7

4
43
"
(

 
23
= &$#
"*%
4





7 23
2





4
#
6
4 4






23
23

$
(*

'
 




4
3*
2

6


 

   2











6
 
#
(%


2
#

3

6
4
 
    

4



?


#%

4 




#







 6
!
#

2
*
23

(2


'%




%







6
#



 
26
6







#
23
3*
 


6
#

3


4


2
 



#

2



#3


  #3

4%


*


#
%

 #3

2
4
43
"

6






'





#






6%
 

2


*

6



#
4
 2
9%


%
4





/4%


#3
 '


4
3%

 2

23

(2

#*
)*#%

4

 9

6
*
2




>
'

2 
 %


2
#
23

(2


6
 

#3
**


*

6
4
#


##*


4
4
*



?%

9#% 4


B
4
#
6%
4
4



,

+%
4
#
2




2



 >
=






44

 %
4




*
<*
"2



4 % 




2 

43

4
6


6
23 ##*





#*
4


>
(


 

2





4






 #3

4*




#

*

4*



4
2




2
 3





(*





4
#

6


 2



 
*
**
%

9#%
4
 

6

4
4



#
#3%
 
6
2*

4#

4





 

2*




>
8

!

 

3*






6
4

23
#23 


 '

%




.
 ?3

23
 #3
4

=
$#
"*
2



@
 
#)
"*
2



7
2



64
 

4


*

2

=
9#* 



**
3


#0 
&9#
#%
4

*

23

.
 ?3 4
2
2

*

#3

=

2 
 (2
4
2

?








?3

23

#3



#)
"*
4
6
4

2





 
4


(
$

6
#

 ##

?*
2



#
26
 
?*
 

23
4



43
6
A4%

.


?3
#3


  






4 #

23
4



43
6

# #3%
4

$
4
*


*

(
$


2 

43
"
'3

 <


2

 *

8



#



4
6
23

 < 



#
26
 
?*
23
#%

4
 

#

3
64
=


4

# 

23
#23




4
#

%


#33

(

2

9
8
#



.
 ?3% 

2




2




4 

2
#


4



 
*%
3%


4 

6
%
43
*





#

 




>

*




2




2 #



4


6
> 

*
@*


A*
.

C-3- 

-)3& 45 ,&%&6&.3 +43D
:<'
 - 1







;%
 





4


  





? 


#
4
#3
6
%

4

2



 


%
4

4
#

%
4

9 
#3
2

4
#*

 


 

 

 #*




#

 


*

2
# 


%






*




4









   



2
6
23
=


#3
2 
 (2


3
23
4

9




 ?*
4


4

#



 
#

6
#
43
/4

?

4

 
#

#
#

>




2 #
2






 


%
 

4


#




 
* #


#
#


4
#

*
 2






2
23
2%
 

#3 2 

(2

4

23



?

3

23
 #3


6
4




#

23

 
(%


#

#3

%
 (2

##



*


4



 
* '

#
*
2
2%

.

:;


43

,%
%
 %

#0
4
2



3 #
# /4

?
4
2
&
4

2
 #
#>
'



%
#3

# 2



"



43



4

:.#;
%

4
 +
76
A4% 
9
.%


#
2



C-3- 

-)3& 45 3-& +43#8  2 $/ $343'/ 0%


6

4



 *
*


2*

2 
%

#
4 4
2
2




4%


*


#
4 
2





*4

%
4
2 ?

2



#0
8

E

# 

4





 

,

+


3 #
#

6

2
 +
76%

#
4
 3 2






#
4
4
2
2
3%
  %  
##



"




  
%
4 

5%
4

 ,
76 

 
  3-& +43 $5(9%&/

9
.




4 #

4
2




#

4 23

(2
A4%




%




4

 (2

#




&
( #
#

2*
4
23





.% %






2*
6


 
*3%


%

4


 




AF2
"#
.%

#0
4
2

 #

#




 ,
76
*4


E 
2

#









3#


 
#


#0



%



4


#* )*#


 
9

?


%
4%
 
4
2

4


$ "

  /

&%:;

#  7    

=
6*0 G =
2 G