High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5333/2016disposed of

Mandeep Singh v. Avtar Singh

2019-12-17Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal7 pages

## $%& '% !"

( )%

% (* "&+#,'

%"##

% "-% %,'

%"% ....

/"##! " % # " 0 % ! -%

1 02" %/#34%0&#, /"!%" -"%02 " 0 & 5&%&02% 6#37'% !",3 %'"&#% "

1 8

4"4%0&#-%(

67,#"%&% &&% 3 (

,67

: 3&&%% ( , , 67 ;

# "#"2 ( ,67 4% % < (

67 0#2 (

,67 4" "#36% "

1 8 0 & 3,"-!

!% 3)50='%2,/"!%" "

'##!4"

&,%(&!% 3 %2# >""%"% $%+/"

-+,)"7$?, "#,%0%!

/;787@78

3 % 3" A# !%&+!3 %2# " #3 %&#, "# ! -" 3 %2### " % %'% &5&% ;-+ /'#;

#,)"7$?, "# % 3"%%%% )B?,/"!%""%%% / 33 ;

#,/"3% ;%2 %!% "& (

#+"

4"###"-%3'%3 %%8 "#3# %#'<%% 3%#2%8,% ## - <<4"#3"3#% 0# %"5&% "-%&+% 4"#3"3## " % # '%"'"### - '%"% &5&% 4"%

"0 ##23#"% #2 <% 2" %3 #3 << 4"4%0&#%3& " ## -! >""%"

1 8%&#! 5&% #3 &%% & %" !#! %'! '"#

/;787@78

02 %

C)) >""%"#3# % "5&%&%02"3", ,

-"<% 3-"

3C)(

% '","% 6#3%" - 0 < <3 % *" B&7)>, # %, B ;, %,/"!%";%5 !"7)> , %, @0#"3A%",)50='%2 %0& ' " % 6#3, ## <3"3#- / &# %"##- &#%!&"! " 4%0&# &

%0&!%"!#!-"#%'! "##! !'"#"%&# #&% %3%#

% %%!"%',"% %,"3320 4

0%! "

3 " , %!& " ?( - # ! ! &+ -% %0 & 3 " "##" 0D&"%3# ?&%"%%!&"33 02"% 0 %"4%0&#% 3%#%&#% %"%'% D&3%#%&#%% %"?(, "% %,"3 2 - %"2 %%# ?%!& -"'"3"! "4%0&# &

&,# %!% #0# 03 "%&03 302 &#"%3 2

% *"B&,#3&%0#2 "<

:0& "4%0&#"-% !#2& #0#2 :-% &&%# 3 "& (

,6702<!0 3 %&&%% ?&%"%%!&"

! "4%0&# &

%%3, ## - 02"4%0&#%& / &# %%! " % , " %%2, " & %! "4%0&# &

# 3

?"'"% &# %"%,%&"%0

+ % % A %'%! "&03 302 &# %" %,% "'- '%3%%8 "-%36%#2#02"##,"" " % &5&%3 %'"&#% ("%, #20%%"%% 3""##-%"

#2"" &#2"% # % # '%"'"# &5&% 4"% -% <3#!"0&

&""0#"#?(-# ! & 3 "

#2!"## ?" #&!# % <3 , "% -&!! " ## -! ?-% ! &!!"?- 3!% 3*"%% -%/"!%"%

% 3/"!%" *"%%-% ! &!! "?-%'!323 %2# -% ! %&+ "% 4"&!! % !

# !-2 % '"

+#0& ## 0-3 %2#%'02

5&%%%'02"## @'"?(-# !-"

%&#% " !% / &# %"##"#

&2#% <3 '% !"-""!' #!"+#!""%"#%0&!%"!#!

%'% " !'"# %% %"% %0& %2!#! "5&%"3# &'! ?(, "##-& %#"

&!"" "'0D&02 "%3#/ &% / &# %"##% %- 3'! 02 ! &% 3 2 "% '77 '%'% % %"?(0&3#2,"% - % -" " % '% % % " ?(, "% %, " ## %''!"% ;"# # & "3 2 !"0!'%32'77'3

"#365&% ?"!'%&3,? 2% %%! "4%0&#&"

#!# "#3" "%&# %"!#!%'! !'"#02 "##

4"0%!"/ &% D&&3 02 "4%0&# % *"B&)>-<3 % '0#2 &%02"'30#2%@< )

4"3#0 % 0#2 "&

%#'<%% 33 2 % *"B&,% ## - 4"% %&3$ ("-""

%!"# -%#30-"&#%%3 '3-"

&#D&!!% #!"% %%! %!"#! 3 %32 %3 "2# 0#2

:, @< ) " 0#2 %&02"3#0 %-""0%32 !&% "%330% "3#0 % ; -## 00# %& ? & &!"32 "%!""5 ;-##&#2 %&!

4"& #0#2 ;%5 !"7)> , - % 3 )50 ='%2 " % '""5&%-- %+! &%2B&%-""='%2

#20#< -% 3

8 ; ""% %

80&"% "!" 3 "-"< - !%0& " 5&%"'!&%0#2 4+! % "3 2

% *"B& &#-"3 ;%5 !",& # 0#2 "5&%"##0+

:"-##0# #

&&% 3-"

&0 &&%% %!#2,# 3 & 0#2 "<

:02#2!

3&##% 3 (

,67 ,8

<< <

: 4"4%0&#"-%(

,67 -%0#2 "#3"0-%# &&% 302#2!3&##% 3"

, " # -" %!% 0#2

;

-'%,"-%(

,67 %# 3 # 4"4%0&#" -%2 %%'

# 3&%!"% %3 % '%2 4"#3-%( ,67"%!% 4"#3 -%( ,67 %&%! 4"&3 ( ,67 % "

# "#"2(

67 %% % < %3 # ( 1, ,67 02 " 4%0&# %& " < (

,1867

E1, , 4"##"##0# % '%"< 3 &,#%2,02#!% %# 0 %" 4%0&#

%" %!

!% ,"#%#2## -" %%3

" >""%% %0#