← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21894/2022allowed

Naresh Kumar Goyal v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-05-14Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri15 pages

       

 

 

  

!"# $% &#'()($*+  , ,  - . 

/ ,,,#"("($*#0 1-- - 

 



-

,,,#)2$*&#*")  + 3 / ,

-

- -  

   

    



  

  

!

"

#    %

&

'

   

$ 

 (   )

****

- - 4

0!5 6    

  +      ,  %

&

-  

   



'     ,  %

& .  ,(

( /

'     

   1123114 " 5

.+ 



 

 +

  +   6) 8/ 079    %

   



  

.

 + + 

:+     + ;

  + , 

  

   + 3  



+    

 

     %6 6& 1607

+   < 0=> 

  

?

 + 

6& 161&  "     166663  )

 /

@  " +   +  

%

'    

 + ,  ) ,   )

  

+  +

+  



  

  ,  )



,

 



 

&

  +   

 + ,  )  "    +



  6& 161& ,   166663    )  



 

)

' ,  

.+  % .

"



@   .

5



 "

7 

. ,

 07=2

   077)

 %

,  

 

(   %

,;

 



!

  

  

 

  6% 6%

   

  %6 6&

 +

+ 

A 

 

 +  160=





++ 

+



:+





  +  

+  B

, 

 / %

+  B  

 +

 :+

   +   ;

 +

' 



 160=

'  

  

.  

+  3 

B

B  

 . 

;



 



+     

'   

+ +  +  :+

   

+  B   

+  B   +  

 

:+ + 

      %6 6& 

  

+ 

  

+

       

+  

 +

,     

 



+

 

,

 + 

C 

+

  

, 

,( 

 

"

  : 

+ + 

:+

5 



   

         

 %

&   +    

 +   

   1611



 

      %

&

.         + 

  0%=20173

  

  44)6&63  +  10200273 6= 161%

=

@   

 + , , 

(   + 

+     

    



,   

 , ,(    

  +     

,



(   + 



-

 ( +  "   

 

  

 !"#

 + 



@   

 + , , 

  +

    "A 0&)=)1611 

"

  "    %

  +

  .+   

 + .    



      

        

  .  

 ,    +  8/ 079

 

. 

 +

        

    







"

  : 

+ + 

:+



+

   



 +

 ,

,

     

;

 

  

+   

  

    ,

  

:+

;

  



 ++





"

  : 

 , 

. 



 +

 

 

 .     ,

  :







" D/ 



 







"

 

8 : 

;

 ,



 

 

@   

 + ,

,  

  (   + 

+  

:+ 

+  B

;



A  + / %

 +  / 07  ,  

  :+

+ 

+  B





+  B       .   + 

 

 

 

  

   +

:+     

+  B

 

 

, / 

 ,



 

 

 

  + 

?       %

&

,  

     ,   

 ,   +  ,

 

:+

  

+  B





"

  : 

;





6   +  8/ 079

 

@ 

  ,

  

  : 

    +   

" D/   

+    +  , 

,   

 

"

  : 

  

  ++

:+ 

0%

@   

 + ,  )

 /

@  " +  ,

  

0&

       

0)

5



.+

   %

'  %



 +

 

 

' D/     

  :

 

 +   6) 8/ 079         

 ,+  

  

;

 ,+

 

+  B ,

 ,+   



;



  +   

   / % 

  

+  B

 .   

+

 

 

 

' 

 +  +

 +

+ 



 ( , 

    

 



 ,     %6 6&

 ;

  

  



+  

' 



+   

+  B  +  :+ ,

  .   

 

+  B

  +    



+  ' 

   E+ 

  +

    .+    / 07   

 .+ 

      

"

  : 

+ + 

:+

 

   



 +

' "    

     

:+ + 

 

  

  



+  

   ,    

 ++  

D   E+ 

 +     

     

@     %

&

,  

 



   

,

 

+  

5

 

 

  

    

  

   +  3 

   

     

/

 3

        + 

   

"

  : 

     +    



 . 

 

' + 



+ 

   %66 " 5     

 +  



F, 

 " 

.

 0740

"

 ( + $ %& 

 #&   '



(  , 



, 

 , +



- 

+

   %0809 " 5



  &&  " 5  +  , 

"

+

   %66 " 5



- 

+

'   

( +  

 G%0

 

                  

 )*

+



,-  . '!"#    

  

  

       

 

  





     

 

   

  

 

         

   

     

!

       "

   



 







   

 "

  #



     

     

             

  

        

 

  

 



 

 

    

 

 

     



     

    

    



     



 

 



    



$

      %

  

       & '         % 









   

  

   

 

 

    

 

  

      



    & #





 

    

  

 

   (

 

  

 

  

  

      (

  





 

    

  

   

   ) 

  

    

   

           

 

 

  

            

$

  

  

$

   

   

 %

 

    

 

 

  

 

   

  



 

 

    

      

!

       "

           

   





 

*+  

 &  / +    &   & 

 !0 !  

  

 

   ,

 ,

,,

   



   $

-

./0.101  *.0.1    

   

    



  

,



   



,

0=

' 

H, 

 " 



  ( +   1  % 



1&  )2 &  

  '('



'(  +   

 + 

,  +  + + 

 =

( +

 

 23 #

     

  



      -  

   

  



  

   ! 

   

   4& )(  5    # 8 0./3*1 .

& *9:

 %  4- 4 

(     



   

 ;

2.3         



  

   

  



 -



     < #

  

 $

     &   

< #

 

             

       

      

   

< ./ = 

 

< =    



 

< =       

(

< #  

(



 

  

          < =



( 

    

 



       

 

  +9     

  



   



  

  





    

   

    

 

    

 



            

   4( )     &     5  ./>.

0+1 & **9

  

      

        

  

       "



     

  "

 

    

 



 #



      

  



    ?

   #

     

 

   

 

    



  

 



      

          



  

   

           





  &     -    #  &

./>@ 0+1 & .A

7 #

 

    

 

  

 

  2A  

  

  (  

     

 



   

 - *99!-    

  #  .@     

   

               



B 

  2A - *99!-    

  #  



;

2((0

  &

3 3

+

+   &+    4 !

) 

   



      A



      

 

    

  

  





   -  

     



       



  

 

 

  - *99!-    

  # 

        (      

   

  

         

 

     A

F, 

 " 

% 2  )  1 &    

 5 

  +.4

/,$ 

 '( 

6 , +    

"



 +

+



( +  

 G7

   



 

   

  

         



        

         

 

 

  

  

 

           

    )

  





 



  

    



 

    





 06;

-7 2$ 152'(( (

!82 & &5          '(( (  

 8     / +    9 2#7 4'(

!6 . + /%  )2 '( (

($ 4 &&  7 

&7  -   :'( 

6I

'

  + 

   

"

  : 

+ + 

:+  

+  + 

,

    

 







, 

A

    

,  

,  

+

      

,  

  



   

  

 

 ++   

B  +   .    / % 

  

+  B

+     

 



  "    

   +  ,



   

 ( 





";

      



'   .

"



@   .



 < 2> 

8 9 + 

     



,  

    

5

 



   

   < 7> 

8 9

1%

"+



  

     



   



 )66663  





  

- -   , ,

 9#"!* 9!:;0 A  .+3   J3$ A  ,   J3$