High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6069/2018dismissed

Gurleen Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2018-04-02Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

!" "#$%$&'

(

!" "#$%$&'

(

!" "#$%$&'

(

!" "#$%$&'

(

)*+""&, )* "!$!$&"* -% ! !" )&. / &0!1"*% "%2&0"&!% 3'4 53, 3'4 53, 3'4 53, 3'4 53,,3 ,3 ,3 ,3 *"%"&!' 3*6*$&0"*.$!$&71 &01)809# !"8

*!1"2"!$!$&"* ,,38:5;

,,38:5;

,,38:5; 1" 2"!$!$&"* 1 % 2* <"0 * !1" $%%) &#" =*$! $& !1" & !)*" #"*!$* *$ *>) %1$&7!1"*0"*0 !"0

?/<=1$#11"* *"%)+! !1"%"&$*%"#&0 *<"@ 6$& !$&

$%6 $&! $&"0 &0

($%# &#"++"0 &0 *!1"$%%) &#" =*$!$&!1"& !)*" 6 &0 6)%!0$*"#!*"%2&0"&!A!$%%)" "! $+3 *B *0:

3; "&$* "#&0 *< @ 6$& !$&% :66"*#" !*" 6; !1" "@ 6$& !$& 2 %%"0/<1"*$&!1"<" *

( *6*"%2&0"&!?=1$#1$%

$+$ !"0! *"%2&0"&!A & /*$"

8 !1" 2"!$!$&"* %)/6$!!"0 1"* "@ 6$& !$& *6 * 22" *$&7 $& %"&$* %"#&0 *< "@ 6$& !$& $& 3 *#1

( % *"7)+ * # &0$0 !" &! )/ $&71 *$ $&71 "&$* "#&0 *< #1+8 &02)*8 $%!*$#! *& * &1"% $0 *6= %%$7&"0/<!1"2"!$!$&"* &0= % !!"%!"0/<!1"*$&#$2 + !1"%#1+1"% $0 *6#&! $&"0!1" & 6" !1"2"!$!$&"*=$!11"* !1"*4%& 6" %5 9"&0"*$&7186!1"*4%

& 6" %3 &.$&0"*, )* &0*"7$%!* !$&

( &0= % /" *$&7 21!7* 21 %6" !1"* 7$*+ "$!1"* !1" 2"!$!$&"* &* !1" #1+ /*)71! !1" 6$%! B" ! !1" &!$#" !1" )&. / #1+ 0)# !$&

*0C *%1*!D!1" *04E/)!!1"% $06$%! B"= %/*)71!!!1"&!$#" *"%2&0"&!F#1+!=1$#1!1"

$#$ +% *"%2&0"&!F%#1+ %B"0 !1" 2"!$!$&"* ! 22" * $& !1" "@ 6$& !$& %%)*$&7 1"* !1 ! !1" 6$%! B"=)+0/"*"#!$ $"0+ !"*&&!1"/ %$% !1" 06$%%$& *68*++ &)6/"*= %$%%)"0!!1"2"!$!$&"* &0 !"*!1""@ 6$& !$&1"**"%)+!= % 0"#+ *"0 %2 %%"0=$!1 (6 *B%)! (G "%2&0"&!8!1"*"

!"* =*!" +"!!"*0 !"0GG

G!!1" *0 *!1"#1 &7" 2 *!$#)+ *% &0 21! !1"2"!$!$&"*=$!1)!6"&!$&$&7 &<*" %& *!1"% $0#1 &7"& !1$%*"7 *08!1" *0$%%)"0 *"7$%!"*"0+"!!"*A(

GGGAG0 !"0 ?G

G &0%)71!"@2+ & !$& *!1"*" %&% *!1"#1 &7"$&2 *!$#)+ *%

!"* 7 2 &"<" */)!!1"%#1+0$0&!*"2+<1"*" !"* *"6$&0"* = % %"&! /< !1" *0 ! !1" %#1+ 9$0" *"7$%!"*"0 +"!!"* G A?AA 0 !"0

G /)! 7 $& !1" %#1+ 0$0 &! *"2+< 1"

!1"* !1"2"!$!$&"* 22" *"0$& &7 ! *%1 & "2)!<1$"

3$&$%!*< )&. / &0%)/6$!!"0 & 22+$# !$& *#1 &7" 2 *!$#)+ *%=1$#1= % %"&! /< *"7$%!"*"0 +"!!"* (? A

G 0 !"0 A

G &0 = % *"#"$9"0 &

G $& !1" @ 6$& !$& * &#18 "#!$& ( 9$0" AAAFHA&!1"/ %$% !1"% $0+"!!"*+ %! &0 $& +*"6$&0"*= %%"&! /<!1" *0!!1"%#1+/<*"7$%!"*"02%!9$0"+"!!"*G A G(8 0 !"0

G ! =1$#1 !1" %#1+ %"&! & "@2+ & !$& 9$0" +"!!"* F

?0 !"0

G &0 !"*#&%$0"*$&7!1"% 6"8!1""#*"! *< !1"

*0 9$0" +"!!"* 0 !"0

G 0"#+$&"0 !1" #1 &7" 21!8 6!1"*4%

A & 6" &0 !1"*4% & 6" "!# 1" 2"!$!$&"* #1 ++"&7"0 !1" *0"* *"."#!$& /< = <

!$!+"0 % I)*+""& , )* -% ! !" )&. / &0!1"*%J=1$#1= % ++="08!1"*0"*0 !"0

G = %%"! %$0" &0 0$*"#!$&= %$%%)"0!*""@ 6$&"!1"2* <"*$&!1"+$71! !1"/%"*9 !$&%6 0"/<!1")*! 2*2%8!1"6 !!"*= %*""@ 6$&"0/)!$&!1"6" &!$6"8!1" 2"!$!$&"* 1 0 22" *"0 $& !1" % 6" "@ 6$& !$& %"#&0 !$6" =$!1 !1"

++=$&72 *!$#)+ *%' 6" ' )*+""&, )* ++)6/"* '

!1"*4% 6" ' )*$&0"*$&71 3!1"*4% 6" ' 3 &$&0"*2 +, )* "7$%!* !$&)6/"*'

A GAA 1"#+" *"0!1""@ 6$& !$&/<%#*$&7A

6 *B%=!1" 2%$!$&= %!1 !!1"2"!$!$&"*1 02 %%"0!1"%"&$*%"#&0 *<"@ 6$& !$& $&

(=$!1 (6 *B% &0!1"% 6""@ 6$& !$&$&

=$!1A

6 *B% ="9"*8!1" *0 )&0!1 !!1""@ 6$& !$&! B"&/<!1"2"!$!$&"*$&!1" <" *

(= %=$!1 ++!1"=*&72 *!$#)+ *%+$B"!1"& 6" 1"* !1"*= % 6"&!$&"0 %5 9"&0"*$&71$&%!" 0 )*$&0"*$&718& 6" 1"*6!1"* = %6"&!$&"0 %3 &.$&0"*, )*$&%!" 0 3 &$&0"*2 +, )*8*"7$%!* !$& &)6/"* = % 6"&!$&"0 %

( $&%!" 0 GAA &0!1"*"= % 0$

"*"&!21!7* 21&!1" *61" *0 )&0 !1 ! $& %2$!" *"2" !"0 *"6$&0"*%8 !1" %#1+ 0$0 &! #**"#! !1" ++"7"0 6$%! B"% &0 ++="0!1"2"!$!$&"*!! B"!1""@ 6$& !$&$&!1"<" *

(8 !1"*"

*"8!1" *0= % !1"9$"=!1 !!1"2"!$!$&"* %="++ %!1"%#1+

( 1 %2+ <"0 * )0/)!B""2$&7$&9$"=!1" #!!1 !!1"2 *!$#)+ *%7$9"&/< !1"2"!$!$&"*$&!1""@ 6$& !$&1"+0$&3 *#1

= %6 !#1$&7=$!11"* 0"! $+% !1""@ 6$& !$&1"+0$&!1%! &0 *0"@ 6$& !$&$&!1"<" * &0 !1 %! &0 *0 "@ 6$& !$& 1"+0 $& !1" <" *

8 1"* *"%)+!

!1 %! &0 *0 "@ 6$& !$& ! B"& $& !1" 6&!1 3 *#18

)&0"* ++

$&=1$#1%1"1 %7!A

6 *B%)! (G = %)21"+0/)! 1"**"%)+!

(= %# &#"++"0!= % +%1"+0!1 !!1" #!$&=)+0/" ! B"& 7 $&%!!1"%#1+)&0"*

$+$ !$&/<+ =% 5" *&"0 #)&%"+ * !1" 2"!$!$&"* 1 % %)/6$!!"0 !1 ! !1" 2"!$!$&"*$%&! ! )+!/"# )%"!1" *6= %%"&!/<!1"%#1+ &01 % +% %)/6$!!"0!1 !/<# &#"++$&7!1"*"%)+!

(8!1"2"!$!$&"*=)+0 %)

"* %%1"1 %%!)0$"0!1"*"

!"*&!1"/ %$% !1"% $0*"%)+! &!1"*"2+< $+"0/<!1"*"%2&0"&!%$&

8 $! $% %)/6$!!"0 !1 ! !1" 2"!$!$&"* 1"*%"+ 1 0 %$7&"0 1"* *6 $& !1" <" *

(=1$#1= % !!"%!"0/<!1"2*$&#$2 + !1"%#1+8!1"*"

*"8%1"# &&! 6 B" &"@#)%" 1"*$7&* &#" /)!!1"=*&72 *!$#)+ *%6"&!$&"0$& !1" *6$&=1$#1&!&+<!1"& 6" 1"*2 *"&!%= %=*&7+<*"#*0"0 /)!1"**"7$%!* !$&= % +%=*&7+< 6"&!$&"0 &0"9"&!1"21!7* 21 22"&0"0=$!1!1" *6= % %6"!1"*7$*+ 1 9" 1" *0 +" *&"0 #)&%"+ * !1" 2"!$!$&"* &0 !"* "@ 6$&$&7 !1" 9 $+ /+" *"#*08 6 !1" #&%$0"*"0 2$&$& !1 ! ++ !1" "***% # &&! /" $7&*"0 &0 !1"*"

*"8 !1" *0 1 % *$71!+< ! B"& 0"#$%$&!1 !!1""@ 6$& !$&! B"&/<!1"2"!$!$&"*$&!1"<" *

()&0"* 0$

"*"&! *"7$%!* !$& &)6/"*8 6"&!$&$&7 0$

"*"&! 2 *"&! 7" &0 +% /< 2)!!$&7 21!7* 21 0$

"*"&! 7$*+ # &&! /" ##"2!"0 &0 1 % * !1"*

G %1="0$!%6 7& &$6$!<$& ##"2!$&7!1"*"%)+!

$&=1$#1!1" 2"!$!$&"*1 0 7 $& 22" *"0=$!1!1"#**"#! 00*"%% &9$"= !1" /9"8!1"*"$%1 *0+< &<"***&!1"2 *! !1" *"%2&0"&!% *=1$#1 &<$&!"* "*"&#"$%*">)$*"0/<!1$%)*!"&#"8!1" 2*"%"&!2"!$!$&$%1"*"/<0$%6$%%"0=$!1)! &<*0"* %!#%!% :,,3;

:,,3;

(

1"!1"*%2" B$&7F*" %&"0 '

"%F 1"!1"*"2*! /+" '

"%F