M/S Winner Pharmaceuticals v. State Of Punjab And Others





   
 
 

  !"##$%&%'()*







 






    


 ()  +,  -
--
  +,  -
,,
 

  !"#  % &'()*)" '+),-"'(),."''((*&+(-.

&')/"*/-",)')"-()-/"-+)/'"-*+'-&+(-)



01"# $     "#   &-(2*"--.2"-+')"-+))"-/),&+(-) &),2"'+,/"/).*",((.".*(,"*,.)"*2.+"/')*&+(-) &/')2"/2('"2(,("-(+/+"))-."-*,+)&+(-)

1!"  # $  1
#  "# 

% 3
+)/',+(-. 3
-2,2,"-2(+",)..",))/"2,/+"22).".-++".-*+" .-.2"+/+.' +2/+++(-)

  !

"# $ 
  "#  % &*.*+"/)22"/).'",-+*&+(-)

#4"#  % &-)2,&+(-)

 5 6 $"#  % 3
.'/-+(-)

#

  "# $  0 "#   3
-)/-,"+2.)-"-/+,)"+.*(."+.*,)"+22*("+2)-2" +2..*"+2)('"+2../"+2)-)"+.(./"+2),("+.-,/"+2*/(" +2*+,"*,*.")-2'"+-2/-"+-)(+-+',/+(-)

$

 "#
#!"#  78 7% 3
*//2+(-)8


 $ "# $ 9
34  "#  78 % 3
//2*",+(-".),,"-)),/",'*-",/)(+(-)

#5 "#

 0 "#  % &-().2"),+2"-(2'/&+(-)



!

"#  % &-/+.,"-//2."-/,,/&+(-)

!9

 "#  % &+)/',&+(-."-2(+&+(-)





9



"# $  
3 40 "#  % &./)*&+(-)

 45

"#  % &-,+(,&+(-)
4  "#  % 3
+*.()+/'('+(-)

:;0 "#  % 3
*//2+(-)

  4 "# $ 9
# 1 1"# $ 
#  "#   3
+.+('+(-)

  "# $ 

 !

 "#  78 3
')2-**(-*+(-)

#4 5   "#   3
)).-+(-)

#1 
:

"# <4  "# $  3
+.*(.+(-. 
 =9 ":

1# $ 0  " > 1
40 "#

# $ 0  " 

  0 "    % 9
 $5 ?

"# 3
-'% &'+),-"''((*&+(-."

&/2('"-/,,/",+(-",'*-"2(,(",/)(",)')"-+)/'&+(-)" &,((."**-."-,+(,"*/**"/')2"/')*"*2.+"*,.)&+(-) &-(+/+"'+,/"./)*"-()-/".*(,"'++'-")'++&+(-) &-*,+)"-/+.,"-//2."-2,+-"-2,))"-)),/"+-('." +2/--"+/+.'"/*.*"+(,-/&+(-).

 
-'% 3
-2,2,+(-) 
-*% 3
+-2/-+-)(++(-)"


-'% 3
+-))+"+**.' +**/- +(-). 
-'% 3
+)./++(-)

 !  "    %  1
3"# ?@% &)22" /).'"')2-"*(-*"*,*."*.*+"//2*".'/-",-+*",)..",))/" 2,/+"22).".-++".-*+".-.2")-2'".),,"-(2'/"-()-/" -().2"-+',/"-+)/'"),+2"))-."-/+,)"-,(-2"-)/-," +2../"+.(./"+.*,)"+2)('"+2)-)"*//2"+-2/-"+-)(+" +*.()"+2*+,"+2*/("+2)-2"+2),("+2..*"+.-,/"+22*(" +2.)-"+/'('+.+('+(-)
  "#

#01"# 3
+ '% &'(),. '()*)&+(-.

= 

 "#  3
')/"*/-"**-."//2*",+(-",'*-  ,/)(+(-)
AAA --
/ B  

" 

 $       *

 0 1#2"#$3'45%#& 6","1
 '%'
'1%! 2&

--
   ,,
   6#78#2*/


 

  !

"  #$% "