Maninder Singh v. State Of Haryana


  

   
   

  !"#$%"&'('#)*

++  ,  +++  -., ,   +++ , 

*  /0 + ,  ,   








 



  1111  ,   2+

0








!"

#$


!%!&

' 



%( !%!
) *
+ ,-

.

+/
0

1 



234,%4!%! 
 .
 




.
 
5







6 !

7


 



 
 



 


2




.





 


.8
.




 



 
.
 
.
9
 



2

 



: 
 

 

.
!
.


 

 



5

5

*
 




; <
5
 


2
 

'

 

'
 
 
:3;









 


 
 

 


5














!

%, !%!

!%

!%!(




2
7.


 
 
 









 
 


!


 
2

3

 
 





 

 

.



;

 




 
6

.
 8

2



 

     

   

 & $

 =

1


/ 1
.






 


 

 
 + 





 
 



 
 


.

 














 



 

 
 




.
 


 
 







 

 


 


!


 
2

3






 






 






 
 .
 





.
1
#5
 


.++.
 .


 .

5



  











 

 :3;


 


 


.


 



 




6










.

2
3





.


 



.
 






2
9 



%& %& !%!
) *
+

=- (


2


 

 
 





5

 
 

 


 

 
 > 
.






6
 


6
6

.


 
 

 

 


 

6

 
.

 


.


 



*


3




6

 

.
 ,


0
#

 
8

2




 
!"

#$% %&    ''    
 

 
 


="!

 
2  


 
 
 


 

2


*





6

.
.

 
 





6

5
 
0
/ 6
.
 


"
 










 


 


 



 










 
 
!
 "





 



#

$



!
"  

 $  



%  
$
#
 &
$ &


"






&
 "
#







 &



 
 



%


!





#

 #




#
 

 
"

 


%  
'
  "
$


 

"




$ 

#
 
  &
&
"


 

 $


" 








 
  

 

 
$  


$
#















$
 (

"




 
  
)
  &

"

$


&


# 




" &




  &












 






  

$ 

%





 
*+ 

+ 
 
&

" 



+ 








 *



"


 
 

"
$

 



  ,
 
 

&

 


 


 





" 
!
%  




 



#
 

  &
 


 





 



#

 







 
!


#
 

#
%







# 




$ 



 
 
) 


 
 

"$

%




 $ 

$

#



  
  
%

&

 
 

"
#


!
 
#

#








 





 




%



"
$

%


!
 




 
 
#
%



+ 
 




- 


$ 

#








 

+ 

 

 
 
"



%

.

8.

In fact, a two Judge bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court was confronted with a similar factual matrix in %()

& ##   
        '

' '  *
 
 5

0
/
/ ?

2  
 




"
/!
 






0




#
#



1  


2
) 
3
,












 
#
$

"


4

 
5 
!
" 



&

$

"
 


 


  &

 





#"
&










 

 5

"

  



"
#
  


 
#



&



 
"
#

4

!


$



 
#
36

33


$

 


!

"


 
 


 


!




$



 


7!8
 







 
#

#


"







4

 
5 


#




"

9





 
$ 




#
0

  
$ 
#
0
"

#


#
 


$

$
%




 






 $
 

 




  

   

#$



#

$  






 




 







&

 
  

"  

" 











$  
#

 
$


#

 
 



  

$  

 
 


 5

  
#



$


  


 
$


#
 
" 


  





 
"
 


 




















5


$
%






#
$

"


4 &

&


# 


"






&




 





$

$




#
 


 "


4

 
5 





!
(



!


,


 


7!8

#
 
  



&
&

 
"&
 


 
"
$
$
"


4 &






:6&
 



#






 
 


 



 + 
 




$


"


9








$

"




 
$ 

 
#

$ 






$ 
' 



#



 &





+ 
"
#



!
"





$ 


7!8
,
 



"






$


%
#

 
 




 

"
#


"


4





 
5 /.

< : 

 
@

2

3




 
 




 
5
6



 

 +, 
 




 




.


 


.


0


 
8

2

    -   

   ' " 
  
 
 





 






 *6

 

"
#


$ 
# 
 $
 


  
 

0
$
"



" &


#


$

&
# 
 
#


 


 

 
 
 "
;
$ &
$

  
 $


#


 




$


#

 


$



  
 $
 


 

     

 . 

 !


%  $&








1


< 

!  /+## 012 31  4 

  = *7$


#

$ 

" 



# 
 $
 


 *



 



 


3
A



3
  
 



 


 
2


 

 
 
 


5.



6

.

 
 






.




.




.

 


6
 



6

 





 




 


2
 



*
 

 



 

2

 


5
.
*

 B






 
; <
5

 

2

 
  

:/;










3

 









2
 
 
 

 

 

 
 
 
 

 
  
B



 

.4
 

B



 

 

.

B

3 


 


6

 








 


B



 




 


2


 
'B

 .
 

 
 

2
.



 

 

!


 


 




* 

 

 
2



 





2





 

.




 

6
.
 


& 



)-

.

)-
 


 ,   456

2   
$ 
)-
>  
 54

?4$
)- >  
 
?4$