Indus Towers Ltd v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And ORS



  

  
  
 



         

 !"# !$%&%"'())*

 + +, )





-+


  
,
.
 


   + 



(/ ,

) +
.
 +)

 )
0000
 

 


 



 





.
 +)

 1 ) , !


 




"
 
# !

$%&'()&*'*)*

 
""
$%&'()&*'*)+
#

&,)-()&*

#.

$/ #
0 
1 #.

"
 &)23,-*'$

#
"
"







 

 !.




&-24&5


"
 &)2)))'$

#
"


"!
 !


&2(
  .
 
())-

0 







 $ ".


6
 
".

7 
 
 
 

8
 


!!




#

!





"$
1 


!

1 

1 
"" 
 
 !
 
"#
  

9
" 1

1





#  
8






 .!

#




: .
 


! 
1

 .
 "" 

8  "
; !.

&))&())+

#


#
    

 .
 
# !



 ;$ (&')&3)
1






"

8
#
"" 

!
/ !

.
< 
#
/
/=
: .
76

 
!"
1
;
 $ ".

#
.
"=!

."


#


#

1 

 !.
"
#.

 $ ".
"
"

"
8




"
!
1

!
#!

! .
#.

".


$   
1 

#!
1
"


>/>
4/ 5

;
"


 $ ".
1
 =


"

/ "#
()&,


 
-&2)

!

 
  
"

&&),)

" .





#


 $ ".

 




?
1


!

< #
()&,

-&2)
 

!

 
  
"

&)(&)


3+%)

;

"
  
#.

"

 




?
1
 

 
1


9  

 .
#.

 $ ".
1 

#
1 

#!

1 !.
#.


:
 
#"



 


;
"#


"


 


 $ ".

 
1



 .
"

"#
# 

# !


 
   " 


;
"# 

 
1


 !.
#"
#.






&))-()&*

"!





 


 .
.
;
#
?
#"
#.


1
" =
#.






  
@ 


"
.



  


%


@ 

.
1
 
#.
# =!





;
"#

#.$!




 
   " 


1

1



=1!


 $ ".
8

 



#
 



  
@ 
1

 
1

!
2+

:

!
(3

()&%

 

.



# 
"

0;
.


9  
 

$
  2) !& "3 %"'"#+45567%'$&!"# 43'  ! !3&)    45
A
0;
.
" 
   
  
    

 
  
  
   
   
 

  

 

 

 

  

  
    


  
     
 

         
 
  


    
    
    



   
  :


 



1 

"


# 


" B
"


 
#.

$/ #
0 

.


#
 
1

 
(%
 
#.
 !


"

1 

"


#

.


#
!
1
(%
 
#.
  
.


"


#
 !

 !
#


 

1 

  
.

#
 
 
 

@ 

!!

  
.
1


  ".
1

#


!
8

 




 !


"


? "


!

(%
 




*(
 

@ 
" =

 


A "

&,)-()&*
;
 





1
 =
!
#.





&,)-()&*
1
1 
 


;
"# 
1 
# =

1
;
1 
#.$
;
! 




$/ #
0 
 !

/<
4< 5


@ 





"
.







 
  .
8



.
!
#
 



#.





 



 
 !

2+
 :

!
(3

()&%

"


#
  .



  

 !.
;
?
"


#

"



&-2
4&5
  .
 
())-

1


=!
"!
 


 
 

#
8

 


1!


!



"

"!

"
#.

$/ #
0 

A8




#
! 
1 
 

 



8

 
 !


!


 

#
"
#.


#

.
!
#
 
#.

  
@ 

 "
 !

2+

:

!
(3

()&%
1 


1 
"

#.


 


C

!

! 
!

#

!




".
;

 


1 
"

9  

 
!

    " !
  



 

# $ %$!$ $% %$!&             '
 
  (   
 
  
 )  

  
          
 
      

      
( 
   *    



  
             )+
, 



   " 
  


  

  -)    
 ,)  "  + $.%$/% 
   
   - )   0  $% %# %$ 
 

      

 1     1  2  3 41  56   1
   
  (   )  
 1   

  
 
 




 

   
 

  ) 
 2 341 56  $!

%# %$       1    7   )  
8
    $% %# %$

 2  3 41  56 ,   

2+9,:-    


 2 +9,:- 
2 " 0-

-)   
&   ;  1&  
 

  

"9  7  

 

   2  + 9 ,:-8   

  2  3 41  56  

    

      
 

22 341 56  
 
  
   
   

 



 &   

         

   1         "  
 2  "  -< =< -< !% -< =  & -< =/  
; 0 9 " 9  

 &      



     2   

   
 

 3
)  


  < 

   " <
; 
 ;

          
  '
  
   






 
  


  1 
    
 

 



     

    
   
  / >>>  >>>  >>> $% 

   " $%  ;   

  

   1
 

      
    

   +
 = <   (6+9
" /)%$ ? 


  

    

 

       
  
                 


 1

 




 

      
 

 $$ 

   " $$  
  ;       

) -  " :$)%$ ) % $!

%# %$ 

  +

$%=/!# ).

    



 
 
       
   

 

   @) $#= 69 ,  


     
!

 



1
.


 ! 
,

+


1 
"
1 


 ! 

&)

&&
 



#



 

6 !

 

: 

"

#
9  
#5

 



  

#.

$/ #
0 

" 
!

 

 .
"

#  
"=!'  !

 


 

 !.
 

"
#
"
 # 
 
#.
  !


"!
 


" 

"
  "

 

 
1 
#



 

 !.
#!
 .
""


" .









" '"
# 
"!
" 
1

#!
=
8





# 

.
 


 # 
 








#
 6 




 

 !.
8

#
".
 !


" .
 

   
? 

#
1



 

 !.


#
1
;
!


 




 

 !.



#




#1

=
 9 
!
4< 5



"
"!


 


#

#.

/<
1


"


!




"
  

8


"

 


  

#.

 

 

#

 

#


$/ #
0 

"!

 

 

  
;
!




 

)2)*()&*
:1 

 
 
  

#


$/ #
0 

-)&&()&*


 .
1
! 



;


#
6 

 



"
!
 


   
 

#

 

#





 

;

"

"
.

1
;
"



.
()&*
 
"

#

6 

6 !



1
  

#



;
"



 !.
 

 

# 




D 
"

#.

$/ #
0 


#
 
1 


#
 .
 


#
 !
< #

/ "# 
()&,

#


 !
#


"

 
1
1

E/F
4 5

 
! !
 
"

#!

 !
#
1
1 
#"
#.


"

 
#.

/ #
0 
 !


 
8





"

&))-()&*
1







 
$/ #
0 


"
1
" =
#.
"
 =

@ 

 =!

 "
;

"
1
=
# =
#.

 


 $ ".

#"!

"








8

 
 


.
9  
 


 



  

@ 

&,)-()&*
.


&))-()&*
;

 
1
   
 1 
#.

@ 



A "

  
;

1

#.

  



1


0"


"
#9

1 


#
# =

.



#
 .
"
  
#.

"
#.
#.$ !
1
;
;
"
1
"
#.

#





@ 
;
 
1
1 
 
#.

".



"





$/ #
0 
<
 


  "

! 

  
.

@ 
"".







! 
"
1
 .
 





 .
 =

 "


 




"#

# !

 %+(*(2+
%+(*(,)
%+(*(2*

%+(*(23



# 
#9

0; ;
"

1
"#
;
#.$


#

8
1





 

 !.
;
 .
.
1
 
  
#.







 
!!
! .


 
 


"
1
!
#.

! 
"
 
;
 




! 

@ 
!
"
 

.

&))-()&*


 .







$/ #
0 



  "
1
 
#.
"
.

&,)-()&*
1

#
 
1
# !


 


 .

  

!

""

 

 !.
1 

8

 
 

#!




 

 !.

"

#
!.
C





 "





 .
.

#
 
#.

".


$/ #
0 

 "


!
 2+

:

!
(3

()&%

  

"
1




#
 =
#.

$ 





=!

  
.
#.
#.$!

"
 !

"
1 

#.

 $ ".


1









#
 
!
#.

$/ #
0 


1 
"

#

#.




 


".!
1
$,+),$ D$()&3

&2&)()&3






 
 
 


6!"


 


"




  !""

#$"%&

'  (&)*& !&+

&, -
 


  ./ *  
1 

 





1 
".






A!


 

 .
.
#.
  .
 !

 

!

" 


"

#

#

""!
 

 !.



  
1

 


6!"



"

1.

!""

*/&

 1& ,%A
 




 22

& & * 

2,* 3&"+ 455* 67


1 

1


 
 



&2-
  .
 
())-



.
6  

 
 .

 


#.


# 

 .

 



 
:


 

A8

#
! 
!

 
 

 "
 
#.


#
 =



#
!
#.




!
8

 

 






!
 !

 "

  
#



1

#
 
;
6!"


"





  15
1




 
 

! 

".


$ / #
0 
!
 


  
 
1 
 
1


:1 

#







 





 


 


  



1 
"

#.

$/ #
0 
" 



1
"
#.


?
!
 


  
.'  

 "


!

2+

:

!
(3

()&%

.
  
 
 
 

&))-()&*


"
  





 


 

&))-()&*


.

!


#
.


#.







 #"

 






"
#!
# 
8










 
1
 


@ 


 
"
.

&,)-()&*
1

#
".

" !
1


1 
 

 
D

@ 




  .




  "

#"

! 
"
1
 .
 
;.



 

! .


 
 
: 
 




"

1 

.

#
 



$$


"
"
#.


!!




?
  
1 


#
!

#.

 


6  

:1 


"
"


#



A8

#
! 
!








'
 

#


$/ #
0 






#  

 
; 



  "

! 



.
A8 '
.

!
#
"
#.



=!
"!




 

!

 "







"!
 !

#

#.
"

1!

 
1

.
! 
!

$/ #
0 

!
 


1


 "
 
! 
1
.







 .
.
1

#
 




 

"
 !
1
!




."

!
"
;






"

#
.

"
#.




1


"

1

 .


"


.

9 
!
4< 5

"

 "

"


"
   

8

# 




 !"




.
   


 "

  

"

#"
 





"
#.

 

"

1

#




#


"
7

 !"

 
 

"

!

"

 



;
"!
 

"



 !.


#
#


6  





;


  


#  

"
 .


$/ #
0 

9 

!
4 5
/=
: .
76
 
!"
1

-&)&()(%
1 

$/ #
0 $ "
 .

  
 


"

 .

  !
1 

 



  
1
1

 
! !

 .

 !


 

;
 "
  
! 
#.

 

 

(*)%()&*

 






6 



#.

"
 .







 !.


" 
 45

.

45

 

 !.
.
 +)





1*        
)



B 1
)  CD )" B CD )"