Satbir And ANR v. Satbir And ORS
!" ##$$ % &
'#! ( )&$* +"" ,!-
"##$$ #! ./$-0 ",!-
#! 111
##$" $!/+"2 2# & !" 2-,* ##$$ !2" ##$$ ,2 -"&$ !
3" ! 4$2 3 &$ )"$, " ! 5" 3 &$6 0 /+ & " 2"$0 & " !! "&* ,
78 ! 0 ##$0+ 2&$#$ 5 6, 9!"!#!0:,
78! 0* !+ &2
78& $ ! # !! !0 " !! ! ;,
78 " "& ! & $ &2,* !!$2# ,,
78
3"$0& 2 $ !&$ "##$$ ""$2"$0 & "!!*""*/ ,
78 0"$ !3 &$"$* !!"2&+"
-:2:-
"- /:,
78< !&$"#$! $&#" ! "4& !!
,
, $!=!>!>& 42#0<!- & +"!" , *"" " $ ! ! 4$2 3 &$, )& &/" , ! " 2"$0 & " !! "& * " :,
78>& 42#0," ,"$$+!"* !"+ &! "$2"! /&,!!&"&$! $ 2!* !# $9# "!!"&* 3" 2! #$ * ?! ! " * ! #! 0 " $ ! 43, )& &/" , " , * &#"$! 0 " 4& > " * !,$2"$0 & "!!"&* * 9! :
78 # ! *"" / #$
< !&$ "##$$!""!"
, " , "+" $, " 2"$0 $ & "!!* $ $ /:
78 < !&$ & " !!"2#&! -$ "!$## # ( , $ ! &$ #! 7>& 42#0"!!""$2"$0 &
78 * $0/ 0"$ !3 &$!"2!!* 0 , ! !!& * $ $ 2! & " $2"$0 &* !# $9# "!! "&* >"-" !"& 2 $ !&$ "#
-:3:-
!2!$0"!!*"&* ,*"!!"+ 0 2 -"&$ !
3" # &*"" "$2"$0 & "!! "&* / ,
78 :,
78 ! !$0 *"" !!& * ! # $ 9# " !! "&* 2! 3" 2 " $ !0 @& $0 !$ *" 0 4 ! A" & +"6 &# , *" ! !!"
," "&* ,"$ &* ! 2$0*/:,
78# 2"!"#$
!!& * ! # $ 9# " !! "&* * ?!'$-9 "! & +"6&# # !&!&! 8
A $0 !, " "
B& 2$-!!* & +-$$+A 2 0$ +C'8 ;
"-+ +! - 0'?-)&2 2$#!, !+2 + 20'!& D""0 "! 3/&
" #& 8)& &/" !, &/ + C'8 8 ;
;2 2"! E2&+ 2 "! "-+ ! - "!+$+2 ! &/ + " 2 0$ !& *"" "0 " $$ !* B& 2$-2&! "*"$ " &/!!! "#3"! - #! "$2# 2$0 + ? +", $! 2 " # &+ " ! 3" 3 &$ "$! "2 $ $ &+ "
-:4:-
! "!!*"&* ,"3 &$
9!" $2:
78# 2"*""2
78 # &2 " * 0 $! " 2 !, 2&$#$ * ##$! ! " $ $ 2*! ,
78& $9#" & ,
78 * $ * !! 3"&, $$ " 2#* !!* , ,
78
< ! &$ " ##$$ " +&! " - *"$+""2 /$$!* /
* ## 92$0
78"3 &$"* +$0!" 2 " !! :
78 # "2 " $2"! /!!&"! 2!
# $ 9# 3" +&2 $*! > < D!"*!" - A" !" # !
'4'4-$;
*" "!"!/#$ :
" CF $ &# 2 4& -$&! " & "& *
78# 2" 3" !"# /#$
0 >20 ! ! # + "& * F/$$! * / F $!!2#$?&" 2&$ & $ "22+ )#+-*"$#
0 * " ! " < D!"* ! " # ! ! 20 $& " "& * 2"+ 2 "2 /$$!* / *&$! & $ 2" & "!!"#
-:5:-
"+" +& "*"$> !&+ "@&&2 ;
, " , " !
, " ,>2 "-*""$2"$0 & " !!"&* * ! 2$0 /:,
78, ! !!& 2!* !# $9# "!!
3"##$$* * !!
78* !9# $ ! # !! !0 !##$$ 8"& ! *$+ !;,
78& $ &2C*- , # # + #" - "!$>& 42#0 <! - & ( 0 " ! " ,
; '4' 4-$
:, 2# ,
78,
78! ,
78 #-$0 * !! & $ , $ &2 ! & $ 9#( + #" - "!( 0 "6&# # !&!&! 8 - ' $ +& -$ "!, 2$0, $ ,$ &2! & $9#"&$! ,
78,
78 ! ,
78 #-$0 3" !2&"&$! "!" G - 0" 0 H : ! + " ! ! ! 0 " 4& A" ( 0 "6 &# , C6 $ " &# 2 4& & @&!+2B $>& 4<!-,&'2 $ 4"&" & '2, 4-$ ##$ :
, !!!
#2 ,
,""$!"I &2I2#!& 2*""
-:6:-
2# F#&$ &2F, F# $ &2F, ! F $$ &2FH!* !!
78" " ! "!! " & $ &2( + #" ; "! +2B $>& 4<!6&# # !&!&! 8
;4&A" "4& ( 0 "&# !$*""- &"!&! *""2# * !! !" " "! < 4 &2>$+$# $,I &2I2#!& 2 *"" 2# F#&$ &2F, F# $ &2F, ! F $$ &2F 3" +" &2 *&$! $&! " 2#0, , "$#, 2 , +&!, $ !
" !!, *"" $ "
2$0 D" # #&, *&$! $&! 9&$ $ *" " !! #& #&$ &2 + $$0 ! ! +" # + " $"# "& ! * *""$$*2#"& --+#& $ I2#0,0,# ,
,!! "" - 0?&+$ $I ( $ &2 + !""$!&#"# 2& !" # , $ I# $!,# ,
,0,!#$, +&! ! +I $$ &2 " +" " # 2#" !$!" "$!
-:7:-
!$!+"!" "$!&+ "/ ! +0 " # ! 2$0 " !! 3" + +0 # $" "$!!& +" $ 2 4"$! -$&! " $-,
, 2#"#!" $" 2$0&4 &2 #$# 2 $+"++ 2 &"&! * " &$ $"#! ?& !* $!- "- +J! " " -$& "$!F &2 9!"2-$& "2#* !! " "!" "$! ?& ! " # 2 # * !! 2#&! $ &2"!" "$! 3"2&* !!"# 2# $ "$-,
, !2#"# "!! "$!3" %"$ $$+$2! # -!+ $ "-2 " 2$, +& $2 > *" # " $ " 2 "$!, &2 ! !&+" ,"# $! * !! $ &2 &! " "! $$ 4 &2( $4 &2* !!"$! *" $" # 2 -"$!&! " *C+"4& "-* !!2#"& C*- ," *$ 0*" #"# #$ *"" 2# &$! * !! $ $$
-:8:-
4 &2 3" 2& 2# * !! &2 *$$ +- ! 0 " # #$ * !+ 2# &! F< 4 &2F $! !* ( 0 " &# > " # , * !2 ## # * !" " !" "!!, 2& '
" $ $$4 &2
!+$0, " ##$$ $! ,
78 & & $ 9#, ,
78 & $
78"& $ &2
> " &2, " 2# #0 $ " ##$$7$2* /&&! !
" # $%& ''!''!"()&*! +($%
# $%& ''!''!"()&*+' $ &
78 :
78
"$04 & * ! 2$0
&& ( # $ $
3$>2!
78 :
78 &$#$ ##$!
!&* ! # $9# "!! $ $ &$!#!0
K:,
78 :
K ;,
; & $9#
78 4$!!* !$ ,
78 & $9# ! #
< . $ ,
78
78
78 " "##$$ : < #&$7 # $ &2 #-$0 ';,
78"& ! ##$$ 3$ ,,
78
78
-:9:-
!+$0, + " 2# ,,
78 * !! 0 " 3 &$, " ##$$7$2 "$! $! * ! 2#
78 $+ *" L ; # &2* "! $+ "$2#$$! #02, $2& 0$ !0#!!$2,"##$$*&$! $! " * ! 2# # # " " ! 2! 0 " 3 &$ 2/+ #02
78 * !$ &2"##$$
!+$0,##$$$*!!* !!!
, 2! !"9! - ,-,,./,0 ?"//"& D"" #/+7 ! E7 D"" # $ E7