← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23189/2021allowed

Satya Parkash v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-02-15Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri18 pages



       

 

  

!"

# $%&%!'

( (

)  *) ((( %%!' + ,)) )    

)

((( &-!'# '& .

/0 .( ) ) )  

 





  



 ! "    $

&&&& ) ) 1 ( 2+ '

(  )  *  $$+,$$- .* / 0 *  )     ) *  1* *    '$ 2$ $2'3 45* '$6 $3 $2'3 45* '76 '+ $2'3 45* '%6 *       1* !      !  )  '3:

 *

$

( !    )0  7; 



 < 



/* ; 0*

  *!     7$ 

(

 = * "$ 0*

/  $2'-   " "* . * > > "  *   .* * 0* * * ?*  $8 $2'-  $72 

(      )  !    !* **   *! )  0* *

( )    5 *  *  0*   0

( "

   *)   $% $2'- $8 $2'-  *   0   )  !

( )  

$% $2'- $8 $2'-  *   )     0* * 

" ! *     

(    ; 0  

 =   $% $2'-  )  

( ) *  ;  @0* )   $% $2'- $8 $2'- *      * )

      >

  " %. A5* $8 $2'-  +''



  !*



 0

 =   !

  * ?*      0   0* * "$ 0* )

 = *

/ ** *     *            0* 

   )     " *! %  >

 )     !*    !    !*     5  )  !  0* *   0 )   ) )   )  *  !

 *            *

 !* )  

'$ 2B $2'-   *  5* '

  *   *  ; $8 $2'- !*  0      * * ?*  !  0           !*  0  0    

=  

'$ 2B $2'-    *  5* 7   . A5* ; 

 

   )0     !*    * 

(  !    /1* =   1* 

/ ! 1*      ) ;   * 5 .



 <  /* ; 4"6 > * 'B-+ 45* >7,'+6   *     * * ; 

( ;     5* '$ *      5* '7   *    !*  ) *    *  ) **    5* '% %. A5*   *    *  ) ** 

(  5* '$ 5* '7 5* '% *   )

  * *!  ) * * *  * *   " "* . * > > "   0* $8 $2'-  0

 =    ! *

* *!       45* '6 *   0   )  

$% $2'-



$8 $2'-    *    !

   * ? *    *  ) **   *

* *!    45* 76  

'$ 2B $2'-        

*!    *   !  

C  1*     )    0      $% $2'-  1*  45* +6  

* *! 1*  ) ) ! ; 

C'" 0

* *  A! ; C$"*0 "  "

 ! 5 ! /1* =

"  C'" 0

* *     !  * $8 $2'-   0    )   0      !*     0)   )      )        

* *!  " 0      *       )    

* *!   C$"*0 "  "



5

   5* + 4/1* >6 ) *!? 5    ; 0   0   0)  !*      * ! 0   !*       /* . 0*   * ! 0 

+

 ) ) 5  =      )     $8 $2'-  +''



 >

  "  ) 0 )   *  *) !   0*   !*  *  >

  " %. A5*  0    """

; 0 ) 1* 0    

(   5* +

-

 * * *!    /1* =      )        0     )   C$"*0 "      ; 0   0   *  0   !*   

6

!*    /* . 0*    /1* =   !*    !*  /1* =     !  * ;

*!    1*       *      !*    *   

'$ 2B $2'- ) *   *     !*  ! 0) ; )    *     45* 76   1*    45* '6

 * *!  * * . A5* ;   * !*  *    * * ;       !   ;  0  ;    ? *    *  ) **  *

* *!   ) ;   5* '$ 5* '7 * *  0      /1* = 



*      ;  ) ! ? *

* *! *  ) ;  0   ? * *    % ) . A5*     *  ! ;    *! $   ;        )    *

( *!  * * *!             

    

!   )

"       *! $2 )    % )  )    " $8 $2'- !  ;    

*  ) * !*  

*  

*!     )  

 "  >

    ! /1* =   ) *   

  )  ) )   ) )  

* *!      *! $'

 )

 

   !*  

%  . A5* *  *

* *! ) )   !  $ %    )   

     )  ! .*

)  $  ? )     . A5* )    * ) )   ! .*      . A5* )  )     )   

 

'2

 * *  )   

       ! 

* *! )   

  %  )   ! 

*   *! $2 $'

)    . A5* )   *! $2            *! $'     

 )     

* *!  )  )  ! .*  )   

    

 

   1*   ! !        



* *!  )    )    !* !

*       * ? *    *  ) **   *  *    * ! ! 1*

* *! )   7'

2'

$2$'

) *   5  *     *  5   )  1* !   * ! )

''

=  

 ! "   *  $ *! ? )   !  $ . A5*  



* )    

* *! *   $2'3  )   $2$'

       ) ! !  *  

*!    *  /1* =  ;  !  *    0 *  )        



 .*    0 ;    ) )

'$

/    * 

'7

(    !     0 

 =  

 <  /* ;  "$ 0* !*    *   " "* . * > > "   !

    *!   0* * !

  

(    $% $2'-  0     *    !

!* 0    

/  !    1*  45* +6   ) )  

) * * 5* + )* )  ) ) ;

(  ) 

C'" 0          !*    )       *  

(  ) 

C$"*0 "    5 ; 0   0 

(    0    

( ) "*0 "   5  * !



0   !*       /* . 0*  )  * ! 0 

" /1* = )*  *  )  )  *   

 * 1*  45* +6 )* )   *  

=    5  *     /1* =  

"           !  1*    !*          

( .* )    /1* =   !   1*  * 

'%

=  *   *     

% )    ) * >

  "  $8 $2'-  )   0* *   !* )    

"       *! $2 $'

 )

)   

(     *! $2 )



   ; * * 3 #%'7& # %'

- +

'98: +

!"

;

<+% - %%!'(

 -3= !'

8 +% !'

: ;

3"

!"

+ &-!'# '& !(

(

= <%' && & <%;; 3# -3 ' # <%' && & :+!97;

%'( (   $2  

D*  $ '2  "*!   

#  >

 >

  "

)     -3 ' # <%' && &" 0 4C'6 "*0 "  4C $6   

/  

"0 <  . A5*,>

  )    "

>

 )  !  $8 $2'-  +''



>

0 )      *

A * *  ! 

>

$!8-3 %'

'

$ #

&

9#7 ) ;     ?  

>

%   0 * =



>?

 ?  ;  $3 $2$'

)  >

%, 

"0 < 

>

  "  . A5*   ! /1* =

>

% *     $  ) )

 

)   

/ * !*   $ C ) ) ) ?     >

( >*   )      !   )    

'8

" )   

         

   ! 

>    !  ?*  

E! "* .* 



     

 !"#  7B ?*  * *      

  



  

      



  !

"

 #$%&

  $   '  



  



( 

 "

    )

 





"

 *

 + '



 

 ,



- (

 '    

  )



 "

  ) & . / -









 *

 +



 

 #

   ' 









( 



 

    '



, )  

 

 

    

 "

  

"

 *

 + 

(

  ) 

 

     

   *

 +









 ) 

 

   

0 



&

 





 *  12 

 *   3 )   *           

 "  

 "    3&*

 



      

  

   

4  

 "

 ) +     



 

    

 3&* '

 )     



     "

 *

 +

   



 

) ) 

 

    

    " )





   "  

)    

 *

 +



  "

 , )  



& . /-





 ' 



*

 +

)    "      

 

  

 5 

 " "



  

 

 *

 -

 

 

  

"



  





 

 ) "   6) & 5   

  

)  *

 - 

 " 



 ,      



 

  

4   '

    ) 



  "

*

 +  )   )



 

)

     

 



 

 *

 + '  



 ,  

 *

 +

)    "     

0 

&

      ' 

.  &



"



    

)  

   

.  . )!



 &  





 

 )   



3&* 5

 



 3&* 

 

  

 " 

   

)   



 3&*

 4

 "  

   "       

)

 

  



 3&* 7

5

'+

" $  %#&## '(  )*

+ +     , -" !

E! "* .* )      ! 

 '- ?*  * * - 5 

 

   

 



  )  

   "

    8

 "

 



"

   ) 





 

  

  



  "

 

"

 



          "



 



 

    

    

    

     )



  ) 



   5

   8



 

     

  

          

     ) 





 





  

 

     

   



  

 

  

 "

   

 

 





      "

"      

   7

'-

A )      *! $2 )     ) *    !*     

A 1*   *! $'

)     

*               ! .*

( .* )

6

    

  ! .*

'3

A    *    *     $8 $2'-        0*    )  0 

 = ;  * ? *  *   )  * 0 *  ! * * *  )     *   

  ! )       ;     ;  *! ! 

 

"

#!  !

*  ) *    * ?* !  8



'B

/ )  *    ) )

( *    '$ 2$ $2'3 45* '$6 $3 $2'3 45* '76 '+ $2'3 45* '%6 !

  1*

( ;  5      1* ! )       )  +:

 *

/    *  )      !  **   B:

 *



$2

"     

     ! .*    !    > 82222,  !     A51*

(   !  )     

2) ) 4 ( (

  ;

'

;

>9+ C 0 ,  F,# C !  F,#