Icici Lombard General Insurance Co Ltd v. Harjinder Kaur @ Rajinder Kaur & ORS









 


 



  





 

 



  

 





 

 



   !"#$% &'(&)*% %+!*))$  

 !" "##$$" ! 
 "

  #
 $%
&



'(

)
! 
*"



+ #
 $%
&



'
,

-

%+!*))$,' %  # "##"$ " & !  "'" "(" "

 )

#" !! +$",%& "$"'"  "$ - %& "$-( &*!,#" "&"(" ."/ 0"

" ,"$'

#" !" 1 #'

"' "&  *"(  

/  " ,  $" "!!  "  2

  "  "  '$'  '   !" 3 4354)6 &*7"  '

 %  %& "$ "  !,#"       7 82 94#"*"&$( " " :#" , ,

" #$$"$" %  $  &, ,"

 &* ! $ #'  "!!,#"* 

 '  !$ " %& "$

"$  ;",  "!#$!* <;76 '

##!  ( !$"$* "  "   #"$ "!!   !  #"' "!"#"$ , 7)$"= "#, ,#"  7 ) 94  1  "'

 (   ,!  "  (   , " !    !"!    "! !$"$* #$$      "! #$!* <;76  "! !,#"*  $"&$   , *  $* ; 7)$"= ,"'!,#" "$$& #&$*  9("   

 '  !$ +    !$","      " 

 ! "##$$"&*,"='( $  &,1 "& "'

" #$"("" "!!,#"*#$* # "$"&$* "!!,#"*$,  ; 7)$"= % !  &,,"

&*! $ "" #$!* > "# "!"#"!="'#$!* "!!,#"*$"&$   , *   (  '"   "   & $* / *  " '"   #"' (  "' "*      "    "! !,#"*   $"&$  #"* !,#"   $"&$*  $, "#"!

$";1 ## ! "#$"! $"! #/

', .-&$  #,+ 




!

"#
$%
"&'
())*
+,-

.//"$
$0$
102$'

0$
0 !03$




1
4
0
"$ '
566)+(-
+%-
5,5'
0
0 !03$




7 "00
0 0"$'
56(,
+(-

+%-
.85
  ! "&,"

" ?  3!

 /

',   "

" .'

 +  #
!0 0
03$
0 !03$





1$$07 "'
56(6
+(-

/58 /

',   ?$  .'

 +   "&
!"
0
0"$

0$
0 
0 !03$
&0#
$
0
0"$'
56((

(/(9 "  /

',   +

"'"  .'

 +  
: $0$
0 !03$




0 "
"!%
0
"$ '
56(/

5698 1 "  " ! #"#  #"#4&= !  3 "

'  &,,"

&*! #"#, "#$* # "! !,#"* "  $"&$*#"*!,#".(  #! !#$"("" "$"&$*#"*!,#"#! " #"'("$, 7)$"= 1 # "&$*  "$ <;76 #$!*( ("  "    "$ ,

 

  6 

 , '

  %  #$!* " & !&  " # "!"#"!="'#$!*!

$ #, ,(!$ ,(

","'"" $"&$*&"

" $$(4 +.?<@A<
7<1@17 ;0
2$
+-
:#
+-
3"!( ","'   A

  3 !6):

  %"$?!  3"!% "*$"&$* 2   %"$ 2   


@",  "')   

)   A'"$A"&$*" ? 

)   &%"$



  
;0
2$
$!
5'(,,66

:#
$!

('6(966

372$
$!
+<-    !%";1!$  <

!"+.'

<

!"+   %"$, ,"*"&$7 62   % !$"

BA, A"&$*C "!#$!*"

 " $$(4 DA11%
A131A1%E"@ !11F  #$!*G ?"  & $*/ * ", "!"*,  > , H !$! 8&@ !11F  #$!*4G?","'% "*#*72)   

 +   (4 ?    !  111 +1 7   H$ "* ?

!&$7  I 1!$ , "$'( $"&$*"#, , 72 94 ("#" &"! #"*$"&$* ( " *$"&$* ( "#, , #"$"!!  #"'   7 ) 94("#" & $"&$* "!!,#"*("$,  7)$"= + !$"," "" "* #$" " #, ,#"  #!">  "$#, , #"*"&$  " #"!="'9!,#   #$!* ! ' "   / * 

 #"' (  "* $," > " $"&$*  "! !,#"*  &" # "$  "! #$!* (   !"  (""#!"$!"!&( ( &*  "$$&$"&$#"*!,#"$* ; 7) $"= #"$"!!  " #"' +,'    /

', !  &* !   # 9!$","   /

',  

 =
3 $  #"

"$ (  " ! #$!* "  #"   ! 8)    H !$! 868 !  2 6 88% "$" ( " /

',$'"' $"(( '" $"&$* "! !,#"*  #"* !,#"  " '"   #"'   #$!*  > "!#$!*# $ #$"(" " $"&$#"*!,#" / * "  "'"   #"'"!" #$!*$*"!#$!* 11
4
0
"$
3 $ #"(" &*.C&$  #,+  " !" (""#$$ " "$'"   #"' " !  "   #"* "  !$"," !" !$",

) !,#" , "!!,#"*" #$!*("$*"! #$!*
 # # + $ # "$/

', #; +  $;
0 


!03$




 "
0'
566,+(-

+%-
8.( 1 0
0 !03$




7 "00
0 0"$
3 $  #" .C&$    #, +  " " " +,#  9"!="'#$!*( !  $"&$*  #"*, !,#" !!

#""!" !" $ "" D!$!*I" " 

 ' ,"D+,#  9"!="' $!*I.(  " !"("  &  +  "    "!="'9+,#   $!*    " #!"$ !"! &( "  ! ' = #"$"!!  " #"'( "$," "!!,#"*$$( &$"&$#"* !,#" '&* $, ;  #$!*1 /

',  !!11$"&$* #"( "

" $$(4 D!114A"&$*% "

 &/! $, $"&$"$" ( !

$   !,#"* ($$  , *          " "!!  !"

 &*"'     !$"'""$$ , (  "$$&!,$'"$$*$"&$#"*#! 4  " & $*/ *"*#!$

'!!

#"!"    !$#   !!

#""!" ("  & ;!# ""!"*, > ,  H !$ !   +,#"*  "$$  & $"&$ (   "   / *"   !  ,#$*,  #&* I   1 !""  !$"

 #$!*<;76 ! '   =  "   & $* / *  "* # !$

' !!

#" !"      !$ ;!# !!

#" !"  

(" &  "" !"*, !"*> ,   H !$ !  @    !!

,"!   !$"," !"

  "* "

""'    ! , ( " &  &* .C&$  #,+ 
 "00
0
"$
3 $ #" % &' +  ? 3!

/

', "

" .'

 +  
1$$07 "=
3 $  #" 1 #""   /

',  "$  ! "!#$!*> 1  !!$

' $   #""   " & " D1   $!* !

$( "*$, $"&$*( '"  #"* !!

#"I  1 #""   " &  " D&    ?$  .'

+    !   "! !,#"* !   #

! "* ,""$  " '$ #$!* (   " +,#   $!* #!"$ #, ,("!

"' !  = !!

#"9#"'I  !"

$ "

' "  ""$*   /

', &*  ? 3!

 "

".'

+ " "'$3!

 ?$  .'

+ ( ,"=   " !" +  "

"$ (  " "!="' $!*  '"  (  "

 #" #, ,   &"!   #"* $"&$* "    #"' !'$"&$* "!!,#"*   7)$"=  !"* !"" "#!"$!"!&( "   

$"!!#! # 9!$","  "  "! !,#"*  $"&$  #"*    !,#"" %& "$ ( !"! $"&$*7)$"= #"* &* "!!,#"* 1   /

', #"  &*   +

"'"  .'

 +   0 "
"!%
0
"$
3 $ #"!

$ #$!*("$ "

 "+"A"&$*$*#$!*&  ," !  #$!* ( "!="'$!*(  "!!,#"*!

"' 7 ) 94 ! = #"'( #! *'"*$, $"&$* 1 !!

,"!(" "$"&$*  "!!,#"*

$, % /

',#" +

"'" .'

+  !$*  ##! "##$$" "!"$"&$*> "" #"' "&$, &*"#!"$!"!&(  C$"&$*!"&"&$  J

 '"     & " ,"

 &* .C&$   #, +  (  '"   $"&$*  "! !,#"*   !"  " +,#  9"!="' $!* & "   !" " "

$*#" #, ,("  #"*#$!*9!#$!*"  #"'$,'$"&$* ; 7)$"= , "! " #$!* !& " "+""!="'$!* 

! $ "$"&$* "!!,#"* $, 1  (   ," 1   ,  !   "##$$"  "!!,#"*$"&$#"*!,#"$* ; 7) $"= "$'(  
 ''" "##"$#"$*"$$(  "

" ,1!$"  "!" "!!,#"* "#" !,#"    !$"," &*  $"&$*   7) $"=  "$' (       "##$$"  "$$ & $   !  ;! ",  ,   "   ,   !$","  + $*  !$"," "$$&$ ! !,#" ; 7) $"=  "$' (     ,  "! !,#"* "

,"' $"&$* (  &    "  (   

 ' !$ "!   
(6'
56(.












+  
1-
B?K $"C













 
J  #"='9"  *9 J  #"&$  *9