High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/892/2017dismissed

Anmol Singh Nayar v. Punjab And Haryana High Court Thru. Registrar At Chandigarh And ORS.

2018-02-26Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri19 pages

$ % &'()*+!"

,$ -.()( ,$ -.()( ,$ -.()( ,$ -.()( / $ $ / $ $ / $ $ / $ $

0(&1()( (-.'( 2.3 34 3

0(&1()( (-.'( 2.3 34 3 5% 5% 5% 5% 675 $ 675 $ 675 $ 675 $ 675 $ $ 675 $ $ 675 $ $ 675 $ $

$%55( .(7(+28(+ .4 5( '4(+28(+ 34 " ".. 43 8( 934(43 ,() & (923.0'2-, :$ & 2. 4 :$ ;.. . 0'2-, 3.'2 & 42 . 2-3:$< + + + + ).43 4 +.4 .(38.( -2 - 2', 2(2 "#!

!"* =

>' ?;@+ 33'2 &) 34 " ( 2 8,,'

8( 2(2 A"!"* =

>' ?A@+ &) 9.8. 34 3 ; "A+ ?38 8( 22(3 . 0'28()+ ()( ( $83 ='28( ( 8.@+ 9 (92 (44( 43 () . 9

>(, ( ()( ($'4'28($8( 29(92 4(84( .38 4833 288', .3(238,( 4(83 -28(3

(83

(83% . 4 3 3 - (3 '2- =$ 3 @?8',?22 (. '28(5(-3((.9( 9(3(44 2 B!"!!#( 29(3432 ()9C(

( 8.C'(9..0 2 #!"!!# 8,42.3 4&( 42 ( 2 9(3 8 ,2 9. 8 , !

!;!"" "*!#!"#+ 34 " 33'2 ( 8( - (448( 3 38 "! 433 ()( ($'4'28($8&)9() 288', BD+ , (, -3 . -& 28(3 .'-.

8,4 >(, ( '

2 ' *="@=8@ . ()( ( $'4'28($8 '3+!!#= 3.6. '36@. -&)9(3422&)8('3=&@ . 8( .(. 8( 22(3.'2.(& 2') 2(3( 28(( ,'3.(& 4(83 - (42 33.( #)(3(3 .(32( 3'&,33 (448( 3 34 3 ;"A( 0'28(389..(2(442 28 8', 4'3'( . 3(2 8( <(23, 2(2"*!#!"B.)9 ,,&3 .( . (3 2( 3'&,33 (448( 3 . ( (44 , 3 . 0'28() ( - , . )(3 !!* !"; .( +34 "33'2- 2',2(2 "#!

!"* '

2 9.8. 34 3 ; "A 9

8 322 -& 28 8', . ()( ( $'4'28($8 .-. .0'2-, .4> ' 44(#;B !"*26/0()E',(53.( ( 2( .3-.' '28('( ( (( 2.36+ 2822 !

!"* . (83 .3(20'2-, 9 )2 (3.8( 22(3 .3(20'2-, 9 . ,,&3 . ( ( . , 3'&,33 (448( 3( 2(., 4(84( - .9 3 ( 2 ).( .).(20 2.0'28(38 ( 34 3;"A9(92(44( .9

3.(9(3.2 ,"!!!"#"!!"# .,9,,&3 .((3 .(32( 3'&,33

(448( 3F (,)+;"!

!"B 34 3;"A 9+. + -& (44) .3(243( 8 3G' ) 8'2 .( & 8 322 8'2 & (924(84( .4833 38 34 3 ;"A+ .2 3 )+(0'

.4 ( 2 8(3.)(382( 2(44 2 .()( ( $'4'28($8+.)9&&'3)4(82(& .4 .3 )9.8.9'2( 8.,(23) .4 .(3+.'3+4'8.( -- 2',2(2 "#!

!"*+(3( 3(2 .3 ' .(2 33'2 8 ,

!*!!"# &) ,(C - ( 34(C - 2 ( 2 -3( = 8', @9(328242'8 ( 82

!#!!"#+ .3 ' 4(332 ( , 2 (9 -

34 3;"A(44(43 () .9

>(, ( .(9(338.2'2&.2 ,"!!!"# "!!"#3'&08.283 .43 94

( 2.(.3'. 3.(&C4 (3(28 34 " 29 3(, 9.8.9(3 (C 82 !

!;!"# .( + *!#!"#+

-3( = 8', @ 42'82 ( 4 8 ( - . 3' 34 3;"A.3' '

2.( 9(3G'( 2 .,( >(, ( >8434 3

( 2";9..(28(2.3(, 3G' )+.3' 2234 3;#+ "( 2"A ,.(() 34 3( 222 ',& - 34 3 ( ";(334 3;( 2A( 2. ,(2.3'3'&08 .'8, .43 4 34 " 2 3 9 3(, ( ( 8.(3& 4(82 .283 .4>'

.8(3 /0()E',(53.(=3'4(@ .443 .( 8 ;;=@ . 3' 2( ) 4.&3 . (44 , (43 (338'2-+ 3'8.43 3 ((2) .38 .

.$(&'23 4.&.8 32( .8( 22(' (43 9.3 38 .

.$(( 2.(3'8.(43

9'23.(( 4 + 382+0 .38 . $'4 '28( $8 8 ' . >3 - ,4), .&08 3.(.4 34,(' &8('3 (882 - . 4 .,3 + 382 (

(44 2+ 34 3;"A9'2&8,3 .,( 2+. +..(3 -(-.,( ( .4

& .3'.3+.'3+4() 23,33( .9 4 &)34 " -', 3 -', 3 -', 3 -', 3% 3'44 .94 +( 28'

3 . 4 ,(2. 9 -3'&,33 3%?

@ .283 .8(3 /0()E',(53.(=3'4(@&). 4> ' 2 '4 &) . ,, 33' - - 2', 2(2 "#!

!"*+ .(3 (448(

9.(3 (83 (3 9 (3 (9 ( 2+ . + . ( 8 .3(2283 .4>' 33' -. ,4'- 2- 2',3 -()88 @ 34 3 ; "A (2,2) ( 0'28( 38+ .).( -0 2.0'28(38 $'&2 ('28() ( - - ,.)(3!!*!"; .)9 . ,,&3 .((33.G', (882 -. (23, (39(3.'3 .(32( ,(C -(448( 3 @"!433(232&). '

0(&( 2()( (-.' ( ),( 28(34(83 - .( #)(3 482 -.2( (448( ( 2 .43 8( & (924(84( .4833 38 + 8'2 - 34 3;"A @.- 2', G'3 3 ( 'B+*="@=8@ ( 2"" . '3,(2 >83 498 2&)

8;;(29.438;!

. 3'

2(.,4'- 2(8 3(38 ()8;;

=@ . 3' 2(( 2 ,3 .0'2-,

.8(3 $()((( $ -.3-.' '28('( (.(&(2( 2.3+="

B@"$'4,'(33B+ ( 2..0'2-, .8(3 4(C--(9(3 E3.( E('3.C ( 2 .3+ 44( B*" !"; =(3 - ' $7 =@ "#A*; !"!+ 2822

"!"!";+ . 4 .(3 8('3 (8 . 4 (3,'8.(3.33 )9&(23)( 82 ( ) 34 3;"A3382(3&'3)( (44 , + 3'8. 43 9'2 & 4(82 (& . 4 +9.8.9'28('34((&33.4 .3388( @.283 3 .8(33 $()((( $ -.( 24(C --(9(=3'4(@+ (8+.((448( .43 8(3 (..( .283 .8(3 /0()E',(53.( =3'4(@+(3 . (83 .8(3 .8(3 /0()E',( 53.( =3'4(@+ . (448( 3 9 ((2) ,(2 &) 4 3?/0()E',(53.(( 2( .+& .8' 2(!B!!"B( 2 .,( ,.34 39 382( 2(44 2 .$'&2 ('28($8 .$( .( '-'3+!"*( 29.,,&3 .$'&2 ('28() . (8,( 3.(9. .) .(2 (442 .) 9 28(3+ .'-. '() 9 382 .$'4'28($8. +(882 -

.( 28'

3 .4 +. (839'2& 23 -'3.(& 7( 28'

3 .4 +.'3+3'&,2 .( . 4 3+ . + G'2 & (92 &) G'(3. -. 4833 38 ( 2.- 2', 2(2"#!

!"*

8 (+ ( 2 8'

3 34 "

4432.4 ( 23'&,2.(.4 23 .(-(-.438'.43 4 (3.22 (44) .43 G'3 ( ) .3-(-.9'2& ( 82.4 3+. +G'2&23,332

.3(24, ()&08 ,3+( 28'

3 34 "3'&,2.(.- 2', G'3

9(333'2,4, .(9.(9(328(2&).4> ' .8(3 /0()E',(53.(=3'4(@( 234 "9(32')&'

2,4, .3(20'2-, ,(2&) .4>'.0'2-, .4>' 8(,3 8 323 . 0'2-, 3 2 '4 &) . 8'

3 . 4 ( 2 .3 0'2-, 3 ( 23 -'3.(& + . +3'&,2.(.3 , .4 ( . 3(, 3 (& & 23,332 ( 2 ,() & 23,332 (882 -) 32(

32(

32( % .(.(2( 28'

3 .(4(3( -.( 2.(3 . 82 '3B+*="@=8@( 2""

. '3+(2.'3%?

HB B B B

8', .$83.(&,(2&)

8', .$83.(&,(2&) . +?

. +?

=@ =@ =@ =@&)4, ,(, -3.()( ( &)4, ,(, -3.()( ( &)4, ,(, -3.()( ( &)4, ,(, -3.()( ( $8='28(( 8.@ 8 3'( 9.

$8='28(( 8.@ 8 3'( 9.

.-.'F( .-.'F( .-.'F( .-.'F( =@ =@ =@ =@&)288', ,(, -3-& &)288', ,(, -3-& &)288', ,(, -3-& &)288', ,(, -3-& 28(3 . 8,, 2( 3 . 28(3 . 8,, 2( 3 . 28(3 . 8,, 2( 3 . 28(3 . 8,, 2( 3 . -.' .&(33 .9 ( -.' .&(33 .9 ( -.' .&(33 .9 ( -.' .&(33 .9 ( (8 (8 (8 (838 2'82&).-.'I 38 2'82&).-.'I 38 2'82&).-.'I 38 2'82&).-.'I H*="@ 8', . $8 3.( & *="@ 8', . $8 3.( & *="@ 8', . $8 3.( & *="@ 8', . $8 3.( & ,(2+?

,(2+?

>> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> =8@B48 .4333.(& 2 =8@B48 .4333.(& 2 =8@B48 .4333.(& 2 =8@B48 .4333.(& 2 &) 28 8', , (, -3 . &) 28 8', , (, -3 . &) 28 8', , (, -3 . &) 28 8', , (, -3 . -& 28(3 . &(33 . -& 28(3 . &(33 . -& 28(3 . &(33 . -& 28(3 . &(33 .

9 ( 2 9 ( 2 9 ( 2 9 ( 2 (8 (8 (8 (8 3+8 2'82&) 3+8 2'82&) 3+8 2'82&) 3+8 2'82&) .-.'I .-.'I .-.'I .-.'I H"" "" "" "" .G'( 8( 3 288'33.( .G'( 8( 3 288'33.( .G'( 8( 3 288'33.( .G'( 8( 3 288'33.( &(3 93% &(3 93% &(3 93% &(3 93% =(@ =(@ =(@ =(@ ,'3&(8J 2(F ,'3&(8J 2(F ,'3&(8J 2(F ,'3&(8J 2(F =&@ =&@ =&@ =&@ ,'3.

,'3.(& 2') 2(3(

28(( 2.(34(832 (42 28(( 2.(34(832 (42 28(( 2.(34(832 (42 28(( 2.(34(832 (42

33.( 3 )(3F

33.( 3 )(3F =8@ =8@ =8@ =8@ ,'3.((( 2.(- .) ,'3.((( 2.(- .) ,'3.((( 2.(- .) ,'3.((( 2.(- .) )(3( 2.( (( 2.(- )(3( 2.( (( 2.(- )(3( 2.( (( 2.(- )(3( 2.( (( 2.(- ) )(3 .32() ( '() ) )(3 .32() ( '() ) )(3 .32() ( '() ) )(3 .32() ( '() .)( 9.8..(448( 3 .)( 9.8..(448( 3 .)( 9.8..(448( 3 .)( 9.8..(448( 3 8', ( 2I 8', ( 2I 8', ( 2I 8', ( 2I . ( 4 , . (23, < 8( 2(2"*!#!"B(23.'3%?

$ %&

' '

()*+*), -

0 0 . 12

3-"

' (, ' 4, % 5

'6 . - 2', 2(2 "#!

!"* 3 42'82 &9% %7 89. 8: 9;51 ;< =; .

;<%7

> ? 3- 0

5 0 ' '

@ 0

*A*+*)B

C(,+ *)B @D'E >

5 @ @@ '@

0 5 0 ' 3- :

@ 0

' '

>? 3-

()*+*)B ;

A7$%#D):)B*C*),F )A**)B .

0 5 0 '

;

A 7$%#D): )B*C*), F )A**)B '

),*A*)B 4**

)B*C*), )A**)B '.

2 !## ' ;

)B*C*), )A**)B

/ >? 3-

0 50 ' B*+*)B +*+*)B

6 .4, ()&08 (32&).8'

3 34 "(&'.8'33( 2(&'.-(-. .4 ,( ( .43 4 9.(& 082'-.3 8.4 .(38()(2.(.3 3 )9'2&( 82 ( ) 34 3;"A9. ( 0'

., . 43 8(2 ( 382 ( (44 2 . 433 G'3 . 3 8'

3'&,33 &) 34 " . 3(2 (, . 4 .( .( .3 ) .4 9'2

& ( 82 . 4, () &08 3+ . + 082 (2 - .,4'- 2- 2',3.93.( 34 ".(32'4 .0'2-, .$'4, ' 2(2 !

!"* . 8(3 /0() E',( 53.( =3'4(@&)9.8.9(3.2.(6 3868( 22(38(

& 2&(2 , 4(84( - . 38 4833 $'4 '28( $8 >(, ( 3 ( (3 -&) 8(-(2 - 8,( 2 ',& 8(3338 8 2+

34 " '

2.(.3(,9(3 8.( -2& . 4> ' 3 .( (3 .( 34 "

32(8('3.(. 4833 38 3.(& (2(3H43 (I( 2.8( 22(39& -(92 (44((.9 3C( 234 3&) 3'&08. 42'8 4 .-&) (3483'

'3 3 .( 4 9 .( '. 4833 9(3 '

2(C &)34 " . -( G'3 .( (33 8 32( 3 9... 388( 22(3 .0'28() & -. ,,&3 .(8'2&(924(84( ()( ( $'4'28($8 .8(3 /0()E',(53.( =3'4(@+. (839.(28(3/0()E',(53.(( ( ..(2(442 34 323, " !"B 28 8', 348

(8( 83 (3

;"!;!"B.).(2(44(2 .4, ()>(, (

(3 9 (3 . ,( 3 >(, ( 4'3'( . 3(2 (23, . ,( ,+ . 4 3 &8(, G'( 2 . $'&2 ( '28( $8 . $( .( .(8.882 -)+.)0 238 '-'3+ !"B .( + !"!"*+ . 3' . 5( >(, ( .38'2- )7=8 ,(@ 9(34'&3.2(3.).(2G'( 2 .5( 3>(, (

,.(& (83+38(.(4 3?/0() E',(53.(( 2( .9 .,,&3 .((3 .) .(2 2 .$'&2 ('28($8 '-'3+

!"B3(38(.(.3' .38'2- ) 7=8 ,(@9(34'&3.2 !"!"*( (&'B, .3+ 9.8.2(.)9 .,,&3 .(.G'3 8 32( & .4>' 9(3 9.. .(32( (448( .)9. ,,&3 .( &'.G'3 & .4> ' .( 9(3 ( 392 ',() 9(3 9.. 38 8( 22(3 .0'28()8'2&(924(84( .4'43 38 .'-. .2( (448( +.) 9 .,,&3 .( .8(3 /0()E',( 53.( =3'4(@+. ( (-.'-( 2.,4,33

(44( . 9 .)3- 2,,2() ,. $'&2 ('28($89.8..).(20 2 '-'3+ !"B+&'3)+ .(3 .(.)9.,,&3 '28($8(3 .2( 9 348 38 '2- )7=8 ,(@>(, ( +!"B 9 .4'42&('

28;;=@ . 3' 2( .-.' ( (.2.(& .2( 9+.4 3.(20 2.0'28(38 ,3 8('3=@ 8;; . 3' +.'3+.)9 2&(2 ,4(84( - .4833 38 . 43 38'2- )7 3',(&).-.' '

2.(.)9 ,.,,&3 .( . &(33 (& (83+.4>'4822282. 44( .(8( ')- .'-..3(2283

.8(3 /0()E',(53.(=3'4(@9'2&(444( G'4((-(4.3*+#( 2 ,.3(20'2-, '.(282 2 .3(20'2-, .3(,(2+ .'3%?

HB (() < 5 7 ' 0

- 0

' ((

' 9 0

< 5 .

% / % / C % ' 3'

2 0

0 /

.- ((

' 9 0

2 0

)4)B

6 + .

- ((

< 5

' 9

0 %

' 9

' 9 0

' ' < 5

< 5 - ((

6 22 ((3 39- &).$'4,' ( 29'2&(444( '3G'.,.' 2%?

H( .

((

G G H6 I+ ((

G G

' 9 0 /

6 IA > E 0 7 %

G 6 ((

' 9 0

), )B

/ ((

6 I)) %'

I G G 6 ' 0! E 0 '

> F8 )AA(0(0

)+)?

G G ((

)B )C

G G

G G %

G G

6I 6 I

66 I) %

' 9 #0 %

' 2 ((

' )4)B

%6 38( ,.(3 3- &).4>' (&.(.(3& .2.(.,( - ('3=@ 8;; . 3' 3.(.-&) (43

0'28( 38 3 G'2 & 3 ( . , .3 (44 , 3'8.43( 2 4

. >3'&,33 ,(2&).( 28'

3 .4 .(.283 3 .8(33 $()(((

$ -.( 24(C--(9(=3'4(@9'2.(( (448(

(..( .0'2-, .8(3 /0()E',(53.( =3'4(@ 8(

& (8842 (3 &. . 283 3 9 8 322&).4>' .8(3 /0()E',(53.( =3'4(@( 2.(& 348 8()23 -'3.2. +. 3'&,33 .(.283 3 .8(33 $()((( $ -.

( 24(C--(9(=3'4(@9 22&);'2-3 . 4>'23 ,433'38(

2'( ). (3 '9 8 (23 8 .8(4 -

&).4>8' 4((?"9.8.(23.'3 ,4.(33% I) %

' 9 #0 %

' 2 ((

' )4)B

%6 . >G'3 (32&).( 28'

3 .4 3.( .8(3 /0()E',(53.(=3'4(@+ .4 3.(2(442 .43 38'2-=8 ,(@9. .)928(39. .43 8(3 34 3;"A9 28(3(3 .(32( - .(448( 3. C.3'&,33 3 (

4(+ . 8(3 /0() E',( 53.( =3'4(@ (3+ . 4 3. .(2((2) 2.$'&2 ('28( $8 '-'3+ !"B ( 2+ . + (3 . 2( 9.)9 28(3,,&3 .( ( )(+.(-G'3 2822&).4>'9'2

24 2'4 3'8.)4 (8(3.G'3 .(3&

2822 9. 8 . 4( 8('3 =@ 8;; . 3' .(,423 -'3.. 8(3 /0()E',(53.(=3'4(@ .4(.(.)9 28(3 .(32( -(448( 3 .43 38'2-=8 ,.(@+9.334 3; "A.(& .,,&3 0'28()3 ((8'3.(3

3 . 2( < 2( 9< 38 < (44 , .3(243+/0()E',(53.(( 2( . 9 28(3&'9.,,&3 .$'&2 ( '28()F&'3.4>'(92.,4(84(

. 9.(33- 8( 4((,'

3.3('3(3 .2( (44 , ( 2 .(32( (448( .(39.).C)92H(44 , I 8('3=@ 8 ;;.(3& 42 . 3,&).4>' .3'&,33 .(. '3G'2(& . ()( ($'4'28($89(2+(39.( &082 9 .(282 2(229 &).4> ' .33' G'3 .8(3 /0()E',(53.( =3'4(@ .3'+92 2( ), .43

4 8+9,(C. 9 -2%?

!"#323,332 = @ = @ = @ = @

&'()*+!"

= $@ = $@ = $@ = $@ E( - E( - E( - E( -