High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/872/2023allowed

Ram Parkash (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs. v. Land Acquisition Collector-Cum-District Revenue Officer, Jhajjar

2026-03-24Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

'> +%#'& +%#'& +%#'& +%#'& > > > >'& '&6 6 6 64 A A A A #1* *'$ #1* *'$ #1* *'$ #1* *'$ 5 5 5 5646 6 6 69

B22#33+$% 22#33+$% 22#33+$% 22#33+$%

7 7

2'$/#$% 2'$/#$% 2'$/#$% 2'$/#$%

"# #$% "

! ! ! ! *="+$''/+,/0'1+%# %(#+22#33+$% )(*$+ (+*$,,+"-+$ $+ "*%+8*$;(+*$*,/0'1+%#:

:*%( .")(* +$+,/0'1+%# "# 2'$/#$%'4? @@@@ , "+3 , "+3 , "+3 , "+3 ' ' ' '456 456 456 4567 '&64 '&64 '&64 '&64

"%(#"#+ '$ 8#$%*'$#/*$%(#+2 223*1+%*'$,%(# +8#* +33':#/ '967'& 64* /* 2'

#/'&+ :*%(/"+:

:$+$/%(#+22#33+$% +"#2#"8*% %%#/ %'&*3#&"# (+22 23*1+%*'$&'"1'$/'$+%*'$'&/#3+ +-*$"#&*33*$;+ :#33+ *$&*3*$; 2"# #$%+22#+3 '

45 45 45 457 A45 A45 A45 A457 '&64 '&64 '&64 '&64 - :+-'&2"# #$%+223*1+%*'$ ,2"

"+-#"(+ )##$8+/#&'"1'$/'$ $*$; %(#/#3+-'&5< /+- *$"#&*33*$;+$/45>/+- *$&*3*$;%(#2"# #$%+22#+3 $ 2."

.+$1# '& $'%*1# *$ %(# +223*1+%*'$ , "#23- '$ )#(+3& "# 2'$/#$%'4 4(+ )##$&*3#/(# +8#* %+=# #$'$"#1'"/ ( (+0# (#+"/ 3#+"$#/ 1'.$ #3 &'" %(# 2+"%*# +$/ ;'$# %("'.;( 1'$%#$% '&%(#+ +223*1+%*'$

'$ $1#/#/3-,%(#'%(#" *8*3+"3- *% %.+%#/3+$/':$#"

2#"%+*$*$;%'

+8# +1C.* *%*'

$ 2"'1##/*$;

(+0# +3"#+/- )# ##$ (#3/ #$%*%3#/ &'" %(# #$(+$ 1#/ +8'.$% '& 1'8 82#$ +%*'$ 2#"%+*$*$; %' %(# 3+ +$/ *%.+%#/ *$ "#0#$.# # %+%# *# 0*33+;#(#"*+

+.",#( *3+(+/.";+"(,* % %"*1%(+EE+"+3'$;:*%( '3+%*.8+ +$/ '%(#" %+%.%'"-) )#$#&*% ,*$0*#:'&E./;8#$%/ +%#/6<662+

#/)-%(#% %(* '."%*$

' ' ' '<96 <96 <96 <96'& '&64 64 64 64 A:*%( A:*%( A:*%( A:*%('%'%'%'% %(#"1'$$#1%#/1+

%(#"1'$$#1%#/1+

%(#"1'$$#1%#/1+ %*%3#/J $': +"-+$+ $': +"-+$+ $': +"-+$+ $': +"-+$+ %+%# %+%# %+%# %+%# $/.

%"*+3 A $&"+ %".1%."

$/.

%"*+3 A $&"+ %".1%."

$/.

%"*+3 A $&"+ %".1%."

$/.

%"*+3 A $&"+ %".1%."

"# #0#3'28#$% '"2'"+%*'$

%/ %("'.;( *% *0 %("'.;( *% *0 %("'.;( *% *0 %("'.;( *% *0 *0* *'$ ':$ 3+$$#", *0* *'$ ':$ 3+$$#", *0* *'$ ':$ 3+$$#", *0* *'$ ':$ 3+$$#", , , , , 74 4 4 475, #1%'" 9, +$1(=.

5, #1%'" 9, +$1(=.

=.3+, =.3+, =.3+, =.3+, +"-+$+

+% +"-+$+

+% +%%+$*$;(+$/'%(#"

D +%%+$*$;(+$/'%(#"

D +

#/%(#"#.2'$+$/+223-*$;%(#2 2"*$1*23#'&2+"*%-,)# */# ;"+$% %'& E.

%+$/&+*"1'8 82#$ +%*'$,%(#3+$/':$#" ?+2 223*1+$% )#*$; *8*3+"3- *%.+ +"# #$%*%3#/ &'" ;"+$% '& *8*3+" +8'.$% '& 1'8 82#$ +%*'$, (':#0#", :*%('.% + +$- 2+-8#$% '& *$%# #"# % &'" %(# 2#"*'/ '& /#3+- *$ $ &*3*$; %(# 2"# #$% +22#+3 $ % %(* "#;+"/"#3*+$1#1 1+$)#23+1#/.2'$%(#/#1* *'$ $'&'$D)3#.2"#8#'."%*$1 1+ # '&F*$;+22+( F*$;+22+( F*$;+22+( F*$;+22+( ('%+22+ ('%+22+ ('%+22+ ('%+22+$;+/*#+/%("'.;( $;+/*#+/%("'.;( $;+/*#+/%("'.;( $;+/*#+/%("'.;( (

(

2#1*+3 +$/1C.* *% 2#1*+3 +$/1C.* *% 2#1*+3 +$/1C.* *% 2#1*+3 +$/1C.* *% *%*'$ *%*'$ *%*'$ *%*'$ &&*1#"+$/$'

&&*1#"+$/$'

'%(#"G '%(#"G '%(#"G '%(#"G"#2'"%#/+ F66I 66I 66I 66I <II <II <II <IIG+$/%(#3+%# %#H2'

*%*'$ $'& 3+: 3+*/ /':$ *$ '(+" *$;( #+/ ("

'(+" *$;( #+/ ("

'(+" *$;( #+/ ("'.;

'.;

.;( "

A "

.;( "

A "

.;( "

A "

.;( "

A "

%+%# '&

%%+"

"+/# ( '33#1%

"+/# ( '33#1% %'" A "

%'" A "

"#2'"%#/ + F64 64 64 64 6IG 6IG 6IG 6IG :(#"#)-, /#3+- '& & -#+"

+$/ 4<4 /+- :+ 1'$/'$#/ %' +11'"/ / 2+"*%- )#%:##$ *8*3+"3- 23+ 1#/ 3+$/':$#"

+3)# #*%$'*$%#"# %:+ +:+"/#/&'"/ /#3+-#/2#"*'/(#"#3#0+$%2'"% %*'$ %(#"#'&* #H%"+1 1%#/(#"#.$/#" 7 F +0*$;(#+"/3#+"$#/#$*'" '.$ #3&'"%(#2+"%*# +$/'$2#".

+3 '& % %(# 8+%#"*+3 23+1#/ '$ "#1'"/, :# # +"# +%* &*#/ %(+% %(# +22#33+$% +"# #$%* %*%3#/%' ##=2+"*%-:*%(%(#*"1'70 0*33+;#"

*$%(#;"+$%'&1'82#$ +% +%*'$ %(#*" +1C.*"#/ 3+$/ (* '."% (+ 1'$ * %#$%3- (#3/ *$ + 1+%#$+ + '& /#1 1* *'$ %(+%%(#*$'"/*$+%#/#3+-*$& &*3*$;+22#+3*$1'82#$ +%'"-8+%% %#"

2#" "

#,8+-$'%)#&+%+3+ %(#"*;(% + +$/#C.*%*# )#%:##$%(#2+"%*# 1+$ $)# :#3 33 )+3+$1#/ )- /#$-*$; %(# %+%.%'

%'"- )#$#&*% .1( + *$%#"# % &'" /#3+ 3+-#/ 2#"*'/ K# +"# %(.

'& %(# 1'$ */#"#/ '2*$*'$ %(+% %(# /#3+- - *$ &*3*$ *$;%(#&*"

%+22#+3 1'.3/)#1'$/ /'$#/ .)E#1%%'%(#1'$/*%*'$%(+% % %(# +22 2#33+$% :'.3/ $'% )# #$%*%3#/ %' #$."# .$/.# )#$#&*% &'" %(# /#3+- +-#/ 2#"* "*'/ K# ;"+$% .1( *$/.3;#$1# *$ *$ %(# +22#33+$%!

&+0'." +3 ' &'" "#+

+ '$%(+%+)+%1('&&*"

%+22#+3 +% %(#*$ %+$1#'&'%(#"3+$/':$#"

%*33 332#$/*$;1'$ */#"+%*'$)#&'"#%(# #*;('."%33%(+%%(#*;('

'."% '.;

;(% %' (+0# #82(+%*1+33- /#$*#/ % %' %(# 3+%#71'8#"

:+ %(# )#$#&*% *% '& *$%# #"# % *$13./*$; '$ %(# '3+%*.8, .

.$/#" #1%*'$ 45 '& %(# 1% &'" 2#"* "*'/&"'8%(#/+%#'&2+

*$;'&%(# #+:+"/)-%(# #&#"#$1#'."%%*33 3 %(# &*3*$ *$;'&%(#&*"

%+22#+3 G $0 0*#:'&%(#/* 1.

*'$8+/#(#"

"#*$+)'0#+ :#33+ 1'$%#$% '& +223*1+%*'$ ,%(# # +8#+"#+33':#/+$//#3+-'& 5</+- *$"#7&*3*$;+$/45>/ /+- *$&*3*$;%(#2"#

#$%+22#+3* (#"#)-1'$/'$#/

'> > > >'& 6 6 6 64 A A A A LM - :+-'&2"# #$%+22#+3,1(+33#$;

;#(+ )##$3+*/%'%(#:+"//+ 6<6 2+

#/ )- %(# 3#+"$#/ //3 * % %"*1% ./;#, (+EE+"71.87 #&#"# $1# '."%:(#"#)-

#&#"#$1# #%*%*'$.$/#"#1%*'

'$>'&%(# +$/1C.* *%*'$ 1%, >I5 2"#&#""#/ +% %(# *$ %+$1# '& +22#33+$% ?3+$/':$#" :+ 2+"%3- +33':

:#/ :(*3# +:+"/*$;

%(#8 1'82#$ +%*'$ N

,< <6,666?7 2#" +1"# &'" %(# +1C.* *"#/ 3+$/+3'$;:*%( '%(#" %+%.%'"-)#$#&*% ?*$%#"# %* *$%(#*"&+0'." LM

#+ +"$#/ 1'.$ #3 &'" %(# 2+"%*# +"# +/ */#8 %(+% .$/#" *8 8*3+" 1*"1.8 %+$1# + +$/ 2#"%+*$*$; %' %(# 3+$/ &'"8 8*$; 2+"% '& %(# +8# +1C.* *% %*'$ :*%(*$ %(# "#0#$ $.# # %+%# '& 0*33+;# (#"* +

+.", #( *3 +(+/.";+"(, * % %"*1% (+EE+"%(#8+"= =#%0+3.# %+$/ *$1"#+ #/%'

5,5,9<?72#"+1"#+%.$*&'"8"

"+%# 0*/#E./;8#$%/ /+%#/6<662+

#/)-%(#% %(* '."%*$

'<96'&6

'<96'&6 64 64 64 64

A:*%('%( A:*%('%( A:*%('%( A:*%('%( (#"1'$$# (#"1'$$# (#"1'$$# (#"1'$$#1%#/1+

1%#/1+

1%#/1+ %*%3#/J $':+"-+$+%+%#$/.

%"*+ $':+"-+$+%+%#$/.

%"*+ +3A +3A +3A +3A $&"+ %".1%."# $&"+ %".1%."# $&"+ %".1%."# $&"+ %".1%."# #0#3'28#$%'"2'"+%*'$ %/% #0#3'28#$%'"2'"+%*'$ %/% #0#3'28#$%'"2'"+%*'$ %/% #0#3'28#$%'"2'"+%*'$ %/% %("'.;(*% *0* *'$':$ 3+$$ %("'.;(*% *0* *'$':$ 3+$$ %("'.;(*% *0* *'$':$ 3+$$ %("'.;(*% *0* *'$':$ 3+$$ $#", $#", $#", $#", , , , ,74 4 4 47 5,#1%'"9, +$1(=.3+,+"-+$+ 5,#1%'"9, +$1(=.3+,+"-+$+ 5,#1%'"9, +$1(=.3+,+"-+$+ 5,#1%'"9, +$1(=.3+,+"-+$+ $+

+%%+$*$;(+$/'%(#"

D $+

+%%+$*$;(+$/'%(#"

D $+

+%%+$*$;(+$/'%(#"

D $+

+%%+$*$;(+$/'%(#"

D L4M 11 1'"/*$;3-,%(#2"# #$%+22#+3* / /* 2'

#/'&*$%#"8 '&%(#/#1*

*'$ "#$/#"#/*$ +%

+% %%+$*$;(D

%%+$*$;(D

%%+$*$;(D 1+ # .2"++$/%( (#+22#33+$% +"#(#3/#$%*%3#/

*8*3+"+8'.$% '&1'82#$ +%*'$+ (+ )##$+ +:+"/#/%''%(#" *8*3+"3- *%.+ 3+$/':$#"

, +3'

'$; :*%( +33 %+%.%'"- )#$#&*%

+$/ *$%#"# % +0+*3+)3# .$/#" +8#$/#/ 2"'0*

*'$ '& +$/ 1C.* *%*'$ 1%, >I5 + +223*1+)3# %' %(# 2"#

#$% +1C.* *%*'$*$13.

./*$;%(#*$%#"# %'$ '3+%*.8 ':#0#",%(#+22#33+$% (+33 $'% )# #$%*%3#/ %' *$ $%#"# % '$ %(# #$(+$1#/ 1'82# #$ +%*'$ &'" %(# 2#"*'/ '& /#3+- - *$ "#7&*3*$;+ :#33 + &*3*$;%(#+22#+3 L5M

#$ $/*$;+223*1+%*'$ ,*&+$- (+33 +3 ' %+$//* 2'

#/'& +"1( +"1( +"1( +"1(5 5 5 5,6 ,6 ,6 ,69 %*= K( K( (#%(#" 2#+=*$;?"#+ '$#/ #

(#%(#""#2'"%+)3# #