High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1452/2023disposed of

Sube Singh (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs And ORS v. Land Acquisition Collector-Cum-District Revenue Officer, Jhajjar

2026-05-05Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

'< +%#'& +%#'& +%#'& +%#'& <=> <=> <=> <=>'& '& '& '&A A A A B #4* *'$ #4* *'$ #4* *'$ #4* *'$A> A> A> A>A>A A A A B B B B C33#..+$% 33#..+$% 33#..+$% 33#..+$%

, 3'$2#$% 3'$2#$% 3'$2#$% 3'$2#$%

"# #$%

! ! ! !

! *?"+$%''2+,2;'4+%# %(#+33#..+$% )(*$+ (+*$,,+"-+$ $+ @@@@ , "+. , "+. , "+. , "+. '

// // // //0 '&A '&A '&A '&A

"+ +-#"1+2#*$%(#+33.*4+%*'$* &'

'"2#.#%*$5%(#$+1#'&(+%*$ $2#"

6'( +$2(*" *$5(&"'1%(#1#1''&3+"%*#

'% %*4#*$%(#+33.*4+%*'$ #+ +"$#2 %+%# 4'7$ #. +44#3% $'%*4# '$ )#(+.& '& "# 3'$2#$% 6%+% %#+$2"+* #$'')8#4%*'$%'%(#3 3"+-#"1+2#*$%(#+33.*4+%*'$

'$ (#+"*$5 .#+"$#2 4'7$ #. &'

'" %(# 3+"%*# +$2 &'" %(# "#+

'$ 1#$%*'$#2*$%( (#+33.*4+%*'$,%(# +1#* +..'9 9#2+1#'&(+%*$2#" 6' (

+$2(*"*$5(*

'"2#"#2%')#2#.#%#2&"'1%(# 1#1''&3+"%*# '

//:

//:0 '&A '&A '&A '&A

"+ +-#" 1+2#*$%(#+33.*4+%*'$* &'"*13.#+2*$5%(#+33.*4+$% + .#5+."#3"# #$%+% %*;# '&2#4#+ #26+33#..+$%'

<,+$2/

" %(# "#+ '$ 1#$%*'$#2 *$ %(# +33.*4+%*'$, %(# +1# * +..'9 9#2,

7)8#4%%'+..87

%#D4#3%*'$ +$2%(#+33.*4+$%

+ 1#$%*'$#2*$3+"+5"+3('

, =+$2'&%(#+3 33.*4+%*'$+"#'"2#"#2%')#*13 3.#+2#2+ .#5+."#3"# #$%+%*;# '& 2#4#+ #26+33#..+ +$%'

<,+$2/"# 3#4%*;#.-*$ $'"2#"%'37"

7#%(#3"# #$%4+

# '

//> //> //> //>0 '&A '&A '&A '&A - 9+-'&3"# #$%+33.*4+%*'$,3"+ +-#"(+ )##$1+2#&'"4'$2'$ $*$5 %(#2#.+-'&: 2+- *$&*.*$5%(#3"# #$%+33# #+. $ 37"

7+$4# '& $'%*4# *$ %(# +3 33.*4+%*'$, $' "#3.- '$ )#(+.& & '& "# 3'$2#$% 6%+% %#(+ )##$&*.#2 ( (+;# (#+"2 .#+"$#2 4'7$ #. &'" %(# 3+"%*# +$2 5'$# %("'75( 4'$%#$% '&%(#+ +33.*4+%*'$ '$ $4#2#2.-,%(#'%(#" *1*.+".- %7+%#2.+$2'9$#"

3#"%+*$*$5%'

+1# +4E7* *%*'

$ 3"'4##2*$5 (+;# +."#+2- )# ##$ (#.2 #$%*%.#2 &'" %(# #$(+$ 4#2 +1'7$% '& 4'1 13#$ +%*'$ 3#"%+*$*$5 %' %(# .+ +$2 *%7+%#2 *$ "#;#$7# # %+%# *# ;*..+5#!(#"*+

+7",#( *.+(+27"5+"(,* %"*4%(+88+"+.'$59*%( '.+%*71+ +$2 '%(#" %+%7%'"-) )#$#&*% ,*$;*#9'&87251#$%2 +%#2A><AA<3+

#2)-%(#% %(* '7"%*$

' ' ' '>A >A >A >A'& '& '& '&A< A< A< A< B 9*%( 9*%( 9*%( 9*%('%'%'%'% %(#"4'$$#4%#24+

%(#"4'$$#4%#24+

%(#"4'$$#4%#24+ %*%.#2G $'9 +"-+$+ $'9 +"-+$+ $'9 +"-+$+ $'9 +"-+$+ %+%# $27 %"*+. B $&"+ %"74%7"

%+%# $27 %"*+. B $&"+ %"74%7"

"# #;#.'31#$% '"3'"+%*'$ "# #;#.'31#$% '"3'"+%*'$ "# #;#.'31#$% '"3'"+%*'$ "# #;#.'31#$% '"3'"+%*'$ %2 %2 %2 %2 %("'75( *% *;

%("'75( *% *;

*;* *'$ '9$ .+$$#", *;* *'$ '9$ .+$$#", *;* *'$ '9$ .+$$#", *;* *'$ '9$ .+$$#", , , , , 0< < < <0<=, #4%'" , +$4(?7 <=, #4%'" , +$4(?7 <=, #4%'" , +$4(?7 <=, #4%'" , +$4(?7 ?7.+, ?7.+, ?7.+, ?7.+, +"-+$+

+"-+$+

+"-+$+ +%%+$*$5(+$2'%(#"

F +%%+$*$5(+$2'%(#"

F +

#2%(#"#73'$+$2+33.-*$5%(#3 3"*$4*3.#'&3+"*%-,)# *2# 5"+$% %'& %+$2&+*"4'1 13#$ +%*'$,%(#.+$2'9$#" 6+3 33.*4+$% )#*$5 *1*.+".- *%7+ +%#2 +"# #$%*%.#2 &'" 5"+$% '& *1*.+" +1'7$% '& 4'1 13#$ +%*'$, ('9#;#", 9*%('7% + +$- 3+-1#$% '& *$%# #"# % &'" %(# 3#"*'2 '& 2#.+- *$ $ &*.*$5 %(# 3"# #$% +33#+. $ % %(*

"#5+"2"#.*+$4#4 4+$)#3.+4#273'$%(#2#4* *'$ $'&'$F).#73"#1#'7"%*$4 4+ # '&H*$5+33+( H*$5+33+( H*$5+33+( H*$5+33+( ('%+33+ ('%+33+ ('%+33+ ('%+33+$5+2*#+2%("'75( $5+2*#+2%("'75( $5+2*#+2%("'75( $5+2*#+2%("'75( (

(

3#4*+.+$24E7* 3#4*+.+$24E7* 3#4*+.+$24E7* 3#4*+.+$24E7* *%*'$ *%*'$ *%*'$ *%*'$ &&* &&* &&* &&*4#"+$2$'

4#"+$2$'

'%(#"I '%(#"I '%(#"I '%(#"I"#3'"%#2+ HAA</ AA</ AA</ AA</ >// >// >// >//I+$2%(#.+%# %#D3'

*%*'$ $'& .+9 .+*2 2'9$ *$ '(+" *$5( #+2 ("'75

'(+" *$5( #+2 ("'75

'(+" *$5( #+2 ("'75 75( "

B "

75( "

B "

75( "

B "

75( "

B "

%+%# '&

%%+"

"+2# ( '..#4%

"+2# ( '..#4% %'" B "

%'" B "

"#3'"%#2 + HA A A A <A</I <A</I <A</I <A</I 9(#"#)-, 2#.+- '& & < -#+"

+$2 > 2+- 9+ 4'$2'$#2 %' +44'"2 2 3+"*%- )#%9##$ *1*.+".- 3.+ 4#2 .+$2'9$#"

+.)# #*%$'*$%#"# %9+ +9+"2#2&'"2 2#.+-#23#"*'2(#"#.#;+$%3'"% %*'$ %(#"#'&* #D%"+4 4%#2(#"#7$2#"0 H< +;*$5(#+"2.#+"$#2#$*'" '7$ #.&'"%(#3+"%*# +$2'$3#"7 "7 +. '& % %(# 1+%#"*+. 3.+4#2 '$ "#4'"2, 9# # +"# +%* &*#2 %(+% %(# +33#..+$% +"# #$%* %*%.#2%' ##?3+"*%-9*%(%(#*"4'0;

;*..+5#"

*$%(#5"+$%'&4'13#$ +%*'$ %(#*" +4E7*"#2 .+$2 (* '7"% (+ 4'$ * %#$%.- (#.2 *$ + 4+%#$+ + '& 2#4 4* *'$ %(+%%(#*$'"2*$+%#2#.+-*$& &*.*$5+33#+.*$4'13#$ +%'"-1+%% %#"

, 3#" "

#,1+-$'%)#&+%+.+ %(#"*5(% + +$2#E7*%*# )#%9##$%(#3+"%*# 4+$ $)# 9#.

.. )+.+$4#2 )- 2#$-*$5 %(# %+%7%'

%'"- )#$#&*% , 74( + *$%#"# % &'" 2#.+ .+-#2 3#"*'2 J# +"# %(7 '& %(# 4'$ *2#"#2 '3*$*'$ %(+% %(# 2#.+- - *$ &*.*$ *$5%(#&*"

%+33#+. 4'7.2)#4'$2 2'$#2 7)8#4%%'%(#4'$2*%*'$%(+% % %(# +33 3#..+$% 9'7.2 $'% )# #$%*%.#2 %' #$7"# 7$27# )#$#&*% &'" %(# 2#.+- +-#2 3#"* "*'2 J# 5"+$% 74( *$27.5#$4# *$ *$ %(# +33#..+$% &+;'7" +.

' &'" "#+

+ '$%(+%+)+%4('&&*"

%+33#+.

+% %(#*$ %+$4#'&'%(#".+$2'9$#"

9 9+

%*..

..3#$2*$54'$ *2#"+%*'$)#&'"#%(# #*5('7"%..%(+%%(#*5('

'7"% '75 5(% %' (+;# #13(+%*4+..- 2#$*#2 % %' %(# .+%#04'1#"

9+ %(# )#$#&*% *% '& *$%# #"# % *$4.72*$5 '$ %(# '.+%*71, 7 7$2#" #4%*'$ = '& %(# 4% &'" 3#"* "*'2&"'1%(#2+%#'&3+

*$5'&%(# #+9+"2)-%(# #&#"#$4#'7"%%*.. . %(# &*.*$ *$5'&%(#&*"

%+33#+.

;*#9'&%(#2*

*'$1+2#(#"

"#*$+)';#+ 9#..+ 4'$%#$% '& +33.*4+%*'$,%(#

+1#* +..'9#2+$22#.+-'&:

:2+- *$&*.*$5%(#3"# #$%+33 3#+. * (#"#)-4'$2'$ $#2

'<=> <=> <=> <=>'

'&& '&&A A A A B K<L - 9+-'&3"# #$%+33#+.,4(+..#$5 5#(+ )##$.+*2%'%(#9+"22+ +%#2 <<A>A<< 3+

#2 )- %(# .#+"$#2 22. * %"*4% 725#, (+88+"04710 #&#"# $4# '7"%9(#"#)-

#&#"#$4# #%*%*'$7$2#"#4%*'

'$<M'&%(#+$24E7* *%*'$ 4%, <M/= 3"#&#""#2 +% %(# *$ %+$4# '& +33#..+$% 6.+$2'9$#" 9+ 3+"%.- +..'9 9#2 9(*.# +9+"2*$5 %(#1 4'13#$ +%*'$ N

<,> >A,AAA60 3#" +4"# &'" %(# +4E7* *"#2 .+$2+.'$59*%( '%(#" %+%7%'"-)#$#&*% 6*$%#"# %* *$%(#*"&+;'7" KL #+ +"$#2 4'7$ #. &'" %(# 3+"%*# +"# +2 *2#1 %(+% 7$2#" *1 1*.+" 4*"471 %+$4# + +$2 3#"%+*$*$5 %' %(# .+$2 &'"1 1*$5 3+"% '& %(# +1# +4E7* %*'$ 9*%(*$ %(# "#;#$ $7# # %+%# '& ;*..+5# !(#"* +

+7", #( *. +(+27"5+"(, * %"*4% (+88+"%(#1+"?

?#%;+.7# %+$2 *$4"#+ #2%'

< <=,<=,:>603#"+4"#+%7$*&'"1"

"+%# ;*2#87251#$%2 2+%#2A><AA<3+

#2)-%(#% %(* '7"%*$

'>A'&A

'>A'&A A< A< A< A< 9*%('%( 9*%('%( 9*%('%( 9*%('%( (#"4'$$#4%#24+

(#"4'$$#4%#24+

(#"4'$$#4%#24+ %*%.#2G $'9+"-+$+%+%#$27 %"*+ $'9+"-+$+%+%#$27 %"*+ $'9+"-+$+%+%#$27 %"*+ $'9+"-+$+%+%#$27 %"*+ +.B +.B +.B +.B $&"+ %"74%7"# $&"+ %"74%7"# $&"+ %"74%7"# $&"+ %"74%7"# #;#.'31#$%'"3'"+%*'$%2% #;#.'31#$%'"3'"+%*'$%2% #;#.'31#$%'"3'"+%*'$%2% #;#.'31#$%'"3'"+%*'$%2% %("'75(*% *;* *'$'9$ .+$$ %("'75(*% *;* *'$'9$ .+$$ %("'75(*% *;* *'$'9$ .+$$ %("'75(*% *;* *'$'9$ .+$$ $#", $#", $#", $#", , , , ,0< < < <0< <=,#4%'", +$4(?7.+,+"-+$+ <=,#4%'", +$4(?7.+,+"-+$+ <=,#4%'", +$4(?7.+,+"-+$+ <=,#4%'", +$4(?7.+,+"-+$+ $+ +%%+$*$5(+$2'%(#"

F $+ +%%+$*$5(+$2'%(#"

F KL 44 4'"2*$5.-,%(#3"# #$%+33#+.* 2 2* #2'&*$%#"1 '&%(#2#4*

*'$ "#$2#"#2*$

%%+$*$5(F

%%+$*$5(F 4+ # 73"++$2%( (#+33#..+$% +"#(#.2#$%*%.#2

*1*.+"+1'7$% '&4'13#$ +%*'$+ (+ )##$+ +9+"2#2%''%(#" *1*.+".- *%7+ +%#2 .+$2'9$#"

, +.'

'$5 9*%( +.. %+%7%'"- )#$#&*%

+$2 *$%#"# % +;+*.+).# 7$2#" +1#$2#2 3"';*

*'$ '& +$2 4E7* *%*'$ 4%, <M/= + +33.*4+).# %' %(# 3"#

#$% +4E7* *%*'$*$4.7 72*$5%(#*$%#"# %'$ '.+%*71 '9#;#",%(#+33#..+$% (+.. $'%

)# #$%*%.#2 %' *$ $%#"# % '$ %(# #$(+$4#2 4'13# #$ +%*'$ &'" %(# 3#"*'2 '& 2#.+- - *$ "#0&*.*$5+ 9#.. + &*.*$5%(#+33#+. K=L

#$ $2*$5+33.*4+%*'$ ,*&+$- (+.. +.

' %+$22* #2'&

+-A> A> A> A>,A ,A ,A ,A %*? ! ! ! ! J( J( (#%(#" 3#+?*$56"#+ '$#2 #

(#%(#""#3'"%+).# #