Punab State Power Corporation Limited v. M/S Bansal Generations Limited And Another










 

 

 



 !"

"#$%$&'
(")!"*+",


&-

.


/"
0&1 +
(! !"
2",
,), !$&
3$*$!"-.
!$ 4 ))"44 &!

5",%0%

6%
 &% 4
"&", !$&%
3$*$!"-.
/ &-$7 ,/

&!/",  "%)&-"&!%  



 !

!

"#

$%

,"%"&!'

, , 8""&
/ &-",
9 4.
-8# !".

,
!/"
))"44 &! :::::







































!

"#

 &'( 
;<=



,
!/"
," %&%
*"&!$&"-
$&
!/"
))4$# !$&.
2/$#/
$%
-049 %0)),!"-
+9
&
$- 8$!.
-"4 9

>
- 9%
$&
$4$&7
!/"
))" 4
$%
#&-&"- 
%! &-%
-$%)%"-





 ))"44 &!= 0&1 +
(! !"
2",
,), !$&
3$*$!"-.
!$ 4
$% 77,$"8"-

!/"
-$%*$%% 4

!/"
+1"#!$&%
$4"-
0&-",
("#!$&
<?

!/" ,+$!, !$&
&-
&#$4$ !$&
#!.
;;
,
%/,!
@;;
#!A
%""B$&7 %"!!$&7= %$-"

!/"
2 ,-
- !"-
;<
,"&-","-
$&
 80,

!/" ,"%)&-"&!=#&!, #!,

, , 8""&
/ &-",
9 4.
4" ,&"-
#0&%"4
,
!/"
))"44 &! %0+*$!%
!/ !
!/"
#&!, #!,
/ -
%0))4$"-
>
!, &%,*",%
!

42",
, !"
$& 070%!.
;
!
 &0 ,9.

&-
&2
# &&!
!0,&
,0&-
&-
% 9
!/ ! 0&-",! B$&7
2 %
0&-",
),!"%!

!/
!/"
,+$!, !,
&-
!/"
+1"#!$&7
0,!

/ 8"
 $4"-
!
&!$#"
!/"
$*),! &!
 #!
!/ !
!/"
0,&$%/$&7

0&-",! B$&7

! ##")!
!/"
42",
, !"%
2 %
* -"
+9
!/"
#&!, #!,.
* 9
+"
0&-",
),!"%!. 2/$#/
* 9
&!
% 8"
/$*
,*
2 ,-$&7
044
, !"
/"
2 ,-
$%
!! 449
+$ %"- &-
&&=%)" B$&7
&-
%0",%
,*
$44"7 4$!9
&-
)",8",%$!9.
*0#/
4"%% 7 $&%!
),8$%$&%

("#!$&
<

!/"
#!
&-.
!/0%.
0,7"%
!/$%
0,!
, %"!!$&7= %$-"
!/"
2 ,-
&-
!/"
$*)07&"-
,-",

/ 8"
/" ,-
!/"
4" ,&"-
#0&%"4
,
!/"
))"44 &!.
)), $%"-
!/" ) )",
+B
&-

!/"
8$"2
!/ !
&"$!/",
!/$%
0,!
&,
!/"
+1"#!$&7
0,! # &
,"= )),"#$ !"
&-
,"="C *$&"
!/"
"8$-"&#"
"8"&
$

-$","&!
)$&$&
$% !
+"
,*"-

/"
,"*"&!$&"-
8$"2

*$&"
$%
%0)),!"-
+9
!/"
, !$ -"#$-"&-$
#044"-
0!
+9
!/"
&D+4"
(0),"*"
0,!
$&
')*'+' ',,

-./&.'0-1/-.

.* 2,

  130-/,      4 
/"
,+$!, !,.
$&
"C!"&%$8".
/ %
-" 4!
2$!/
!/"
!",*%
&- #&-$!$&%

!/"
#&!, #!
&-
/"4-
!/ !
!/"
#!$&

!/"
))"44 &!
$&
* B$&7
#&-$!$& 4
",

##")!$&7
!/"
4-
, !"%
2$!/
!/"
)"& 4!9
,
&"2
, !"% 2/$#/%"8",
$%
42",
, !"
$%
&!
$&
,-",
%
!/","
2 %
&
),8$%$&%

),$#"  44
#4 0%"
$&
!/"
#&!, #!
7,""*"&!

/"
,+$!, !,
4%
&!$#"-
!/"
 #! !/ !
!/"
#4 $* &!
/ -
!
%0))49
?
&%

E5
!, &%,*",%
0)! <
%
)",
#&!, #!0 4
-"4$8",9
)",$-.
+0!
0)!
<;
/ - %0))4$"-
;
!, &%,*",%
2$!/
)"& 4!9

, !"%
F=<<
=?
/"

,+$!, !,
!",
! B$&7
$&!
#&%$-", !$&
!/"
"8$-"&#"
&-
!/"
!",*%
&- #&-$!$&%

!/"
#&!, #!
0&-
!/ !
&#"
!/","
2 %
&
),8$%$&
$&
!/" #&!, #!
7,""*"&!
&-
!/"
))"44 &!
/ -
-*$!!"-
!
=>.
3$&"
=?
!/ ! !/"
4-
, !"%
2$!/
)"& 4!9
,
&"2
, !"%
2","
","-
!

!/"
#4 $* &!.
2/$#/ 2 %
#&!, ,9
!
!/"
",
* -"
%
!/"
#4 $* &!
2 %
","-
4"%%",

!2 , !"%
/"
,"-0#!$&
$&
!/"
, !"%
2 %
&!
%
)",
!/"
!",*%
&-
#&-$!$&%

/"
,+$!, !,
4%
&!$#"-
!/"
 #!
!/ !
"C!"&%$&
$& #&!, #!0 4
-"4$8",9
)",$-
,
!/"
-"",,"-
)",$-
2 %
442"-
+9
!/" #*)"!"&!
0!/,$!9
2$!/0!
$& &#$ 4
4$ +$4$!9.
+0!
&
*&!/=2$%"
-"4$8",9 %#/"-04"
2 %
7$8"&
,
-"",*"&!
/"
#&!, #!,
2 %
$&,*"-
+0!
&" *&!/
-"4$8",9
)",$-
"C!"&%$&
&49
!/,07/
4"!!",
- !"-
;; 442$&7

!/"
"C!"&%$&

&"
*&!/
$&
-"4$8",9
)",$-
2$!/0!
&9 $& &#$ 4
4$ +$4$!9
$&
070%!.
;
2 %
&!
),)",
%
!/"
-"",*"&!
2 % 4$!"-
2 9
+ #B
$&
; &
*9
8$"2.
!/"
))"44 &!
/ %
&!
! B"&
# ,"

&9
!",*%
 )0,#/ %"
#&!, #!
/"
$&!$* !$&
7$8"&
!
!/"
#&!, #!,
!",
##")! &#"
 &"2
, !"%
2 %
0&-",
),!"%!
/$%
#4" ,49
$*)4$"%
!/ !
&"2
-"4$8",9
%#/"-04" 7$8"&
+9
!/"
))"44 &!
"C)$,"-
&
<;;
&-
,$7/!49
%.

!/"
#&!, #!, / %
+""&
/"4-
"&!

$!4"-
!
#*)"&% !$& &
*9
8$"2.
!/"
+1"#!$&%
2","
&!
 44$&7
2$!/
!/"
) , *"!",% 
("#!$&
<?

;;
#!
&-
!/"
2 ,-
# &&!
+"
% $-
!
+"
7 $&%!
!/" )0+4$#
)4$#9
,
%0",%
,*
) !"&!
$44"7 4$!9
%
&!$#"-
+9
!/"
&D+4" (0),"*"
0,!
$&
,,60'./ 70(*/&, 2, $/(80 $/)/(91/-.

7.8&0.+     :4

,
!/"
,"7$&7
," %&%.

-
&!
$&!"&-
!
-$",
2$!/
!/" $&-$&7%
,"&-","-
$&
!/"
2 ,-
2/$4"
%$!!$&7
&
!/"
,*
#/ $,

!/" ,+$!, !,

7,0&-
,
$&!",","&#"
$%
* -"
0! ))" 4
%! &-%
-$%*$%%"- /9./13/&

-*#

 !

"  &'1/,8

$%

"8/.8/& ,9/';0-<=&/',-/* >/,= "8/.8/& /9&.'3(/ >/,=