High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/629/2018disposed of

M/S Home Trail Estate Pvt. Ltd. v. The State Of Punjab & ANR.

2018-08-27The Taxing Officer,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma6 pages

"#$$%&'&()*

+',$-"&. '#"#$-&/"#$0&,&#$1 $#&#&($- 2$-'3' 4$5#"#$3(6"7"(1"(#4$- $'8(1$(#'

-$'$(#) -'49:3,"-;;"-<".=5$(&-1/%"#$<&#4 -3($$#;-"<".=1/%"#$"(1 '3-/&5&(4"=1/%"#$ -#4$8$#&#&($- -"(9"6 38#"=11. =3(6"7

4$8$#&#&($-4"'&.$1#4$8-$'$(#8$#&#&(&,83;(&(;#4$ "''$'',$(#-1$-1"#$1 * (($>3-$?!<4$-$7@#4$"''$''&(;

"3#4-&#@4"' .$/&$1 #"> ( #4$ 4$".#4 %"-$'$-/&%$' 8-/&1$1 7@#4$ 8$#&#&($-#&(1-8"#&$(#'&(#4$4'8&#". ('388-##4$"-;3,$(#'=-$.&"(%$4"'7$$(8."%$138(" &/&'&($(%4631;,$(##4&' 3-#&(

#&#.$1"'A

A&(<4&%4&1$(#&%".&''3$4"'7$$(1$%&1$1"(1#4&' 3-#4"'

8&($1#4"##4$,$1&%&($'&(#4$4$".#4%"-$'$-/&%$'8-/&1$1##4$ &(1-8"#&$(#'&'(##">"7.$"'#4$",3(#%4"-;$1%"((#7$7&3-%"#$1 #%3..3#",3(#'".$,$1&%&($'=$/$(&#4$",3(#&''$8"-"#$.@ %4"-;$1-84"-,"%@=."7-"#-@'$-/&%$'=&,8."(#''$-/&%$'8-/&1$17@ #4$1%#-'"'&#&'"%,8'&#$,$1&%".'$-/&%$8-/&1$1

(#4$#4$-4"(1=.$"-($1%3('$.-#4$5#"#$<4&.$(# 1&'83#&(;#4$631;,$(#-$$--$1##4&' 3-#&( #$% &''37,&##$1#4"##4$5#"#$4"'8-$$--$158$%&".0$"/$ $#&#&(";"&('##4$"-$'"&17$-$(A7.$#4$538-$,$ 3-#<4&%4&'

'#&..8$(1&(;"(1#4$-$"-$%(#-"-@/&$<'#"9$(7@#4$:$-"."&;4 3-# &(A () *+ $ ,*)$A

!BC 5 :$-!<$/$-=4$%3.1(#8&(#3##4"##4$-$&'"(@&(#$-&, '#"@;-"(#$17@(A7.$#4$538-$,$ 3-#-$;"-1&(;#4$8$-"#&(#4$ 631;,$(#1$.&/$-$17@#4&' 3-# #$-4$"-&(;.$"-($1%3('$.-#4$8"-#&$'"(1%('&1$-&(; #4$%(#$(#&('-"&'$1=&(3-/&$<=#4$8-$'$(#8$#&#&(1$'$-/$'#7$ "..<$1<4&.$'$##&(;"'&1$#4$-1$-"''$'',$(#1"#$1 *

(($>3-$?!"'#4$'",$&' 'D3"-$.@%/$-$17@#4$631;,$(# &/&'&($(%4#4&' 3-#8"''$1&( # $% &'4&.$1$%&1&(; # $ % &'=#4&' 3-#4"1..<$1#4$631;,$(#4"-94"(1&;4 3-# 8"''$1&(A, & , -(

! * 4-!=";"&('#<4&%458$%&".0$"/$$#&#&(<"'1&',&''$1$.$/"(# 8"-"'-,631;,$(##4&' 3-#&( # $% &'"-$$>#-"%#$17$.<./ 0$ 4"/$ %('&1$-$1 #4$ -$.$/"(# '#"#3#-@ 8-/&'&('#4$3(6"7"(1"-@"("5#"#3#$'=#4$ &4"- &("(%$ %#= #4$ ##"- -"1$'4 %#= #4$ 631;,$(# #4$ 4"-94"(1 "(1 .."4"7"1 &;4

3-#'=631;,$(#'#4$:$-"."&;4 3-# %&#$17@ #4$-$'8(1$(#'!"-$&(-$'8$%#3.";-$$,$(#<&#4#4$

?B?

8&(&(-$%-1$17@#4$4"-94"(1&;4 3-#"(1#4$ .."4"7"1&;4 3-#"(1&(1(-$"'(#-$%-1"

%(#-"-@ 8&(&( - # 4.1 #4"# #4$ '388.@ ,$1&%&($'= 1-3;'= '#$(#'= &,8."(#' $#% # " 8"#&$(# 13-&(;",$1&%".8-%$13-$&(4$-'"(@$.$,$(#'".$= ,3%4 .$'' '$#' 3# #4$&(;-$1&$(#' " A'".$A4$ 8<$-#&,8'$'".$'#">+2.<'-, (#-@C 0&'#5%4$1&.$2"(1-#&%.$B ?!#4$

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

('#&#3#&((1&"1$'(#$("7.$3'#-$%-1"( 8&(&(#4"#&#%/$-''$-/&%$'8-/&1$17@4'8&#".' $-$'3%4"#-"('"%#&(&'83###">=<4$#4$-3(1$- #4$"-@"("-3(6"72%#=&#<3.14"/$# '"#&'@#4$1,&("(#("#3-$#$'#7@-$$-$(%$##4$ '37'#"(%$ #4$ %(#-"%# %(#-"%# - ,$1&%". #-$"#,$(# ($%$''"-&.@&(/./$',$1&%&($'='388.@ '3-;&%".&#$,'='#$(#'=&,8."(#'=/"./$'=<&#43#<4&%4

",$1&%".8-%$13-$-,$1&%".#-$"#,$(#%"((#7$ %,8.$#$14$'388.@#4$'$"-#&%.$'"'4$.17@#4$ .."4"7"1"(1#4$4"-94"(1&;4 3-#'"-$&(#$;-".

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

?C?

-"4$"-#$#%4$(.@%4&%$"/"&."7.$##4$8"#&$(# &'#4$("#3-$#4$&,8."(#=(",$.@=&#'D3".&#@73# '3%4"8-%$13-$&'"1,&##$1.@=",$1&%".8-%$13-$ "(1"'$-/&%$#4"#%"((#7$%,8.$#$1<&#43#"( &,8."(#+1-3;'"(1,$1&%&($'"'"(&(#$;-".8"-##4$ 8-%$13-$8-&/"#$4'8&#".1$'(#8-/&1$,$1&%". '$-/&%$'--$$4$"%##4"#&#%4"-;$',($@=- 1-3;'= ,$1&%&($' $#% %"((# -"&'$ "( &($-$(%$ &(#$(##'$..;1'&(#4$'4"8$,$1&%&($'='#$(#'= &,8."(#'$#%$"-$=#4$-$-$=&(%,8.$#$";-$$,$(# <&#4 #4$ 8&(&( -$%-1$1 7@ #4$ 4"-94"(1 &;4

3-# &(

'38-"! "(1 #4$ .."4"7"1&;4 3-#&(

("-;3,$(##4"##4$1$&(&#&(F'".$G3(1$- #4$ &4"- "(1 #4$ ##"- -"1$'4 %#'= &' $(#&-$.@ 1&$-$(#=,3'#".'"&.8$-3'".#4$1$&(&#&( '".$&(#4$&4"-"(1#4$ ##"--"1$'45#"#3#$'-$/$".'

#4"# #4&' "-;3,$(# 4"' "88"-$(#.@ 7$$( -"&'$1 7@ 1&'-$;"-1&(;#4$1$&(&#&('".$&(#4$'$'#"#3#$' <4&%4"-$$''$(#&"..@&1$(#&%".##4$1$&(&#&('".$ #4$8-$'$(#'#"#3#$ $#4$-$-$=4"/$(4$'&#"#&(&(4.1&(;#4"# ,$1&%".8-%$13-$'+'$-/&%$'$-$17@#4$8$#&#&($-' "-$"'$-/&%$4$'388.@1-3;'=,$1&%&($'=&,8."(#= '#$(#'= /"./$' "(1 #4$- &,8."(#' "-$ &(#$;-". # " ,$1&%".'$-/&%$'+8-%$13-$'"(1%"((#7$'$/$-$1# &($-"'".$"'1$&($13(1$-#4$3(6"7-#4$"-@"(" %# "(1#4$-$-$="-$(# $>&;&7.$# /".3$"11$1 #">1 4$ %(#$(#&(' -"&'$1 7@ .$"-($1 %3('$. - #4$ 5#"#$ -$;"-1&(;631;,$(#:$-"."&;4 3-#&'##"..@,&'%(%$&/$1-#4$

-$"'(#4"#&( #$% &'2 &/&'&( $(%4 631;,$(##4&' 3-# 4"1 ".-$"1@7$$(%('&1$-$1 $/$(#4$ "-$'"&1631;,$(# (#4$<-&#8$#&#&(=(3,7$-#4$-.$;".&''3$'4"/$".' 7$$(-"&'$1'#4$%."&,,"1$7@#4$8$#&#&($-&''D3"-$.@%/$-$17@#4$ 631;,$(##4&' 3-#=<$($$1(##;&(##4$#4$-&''3$'4$'",$ "-$.$#8$(#7$%('&1$-$1&("(@"88-8-&"#$%"'$ 4$<-&#8$#&#&('#"(1'"..<$1

50!

4$#4$-'8$"9&(;+-$"'($1) $'+ 4$#4$--$8-#"7.$) $'+