High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/449/2013dismissed

Sohan Lal v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Patiala And ORS

2018-07-25Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!#!$%&!' ('!'!") *'((+!,!"-.$/012 34*"*$ 55($$*"' 6(&,., 4( &(,!7!"8 !+(&1*9.&.&'1 *'!*$* *"'4(& (,5"7("',

! "#$%&'() $ %$'!#) * ! "#$%&'() $ )( + ,,,

&(,("'- &*".:4*"7*&!17#+*'(1 &'4(*55($$*"' &:*";*$#!&3!"84:*"817#+*'(1 &&(,5"7("' <<<<<

)( + -% %&=>*"&(>*!"(7.",.++(,,.$9(&('4(*9.&.&'*"7 $(*&"(73!"8$(("+4*8*!",'4!,*$$(8(7'(&>!"*'!" %&=>*" *$$(8(7 '4*' 4( 4*7 ;&=(7 *, 3 ;!'4 '4( *7#!"7&* .9$!+ 3+4$1 *'!*$*? &(,5"7("' & ,!@ /(*&,1 ,!@ >"'4, *"7 ';($#( 7*/, !, ,(&#!+(, ;(&( *$$(8(7$/ '(&>!"*'(7 " 0 ;!'4.' 4$7!"8 *"/ !"A.!&/ & 5*/>("' &('&("+4>("' +>5(",*'!"*"7'4.,1&*!,(77(>*"7"'!+(7*'(7B)@%C 4(*9.&.&'1"'4(9*,!,'4((#!7("+(9&.84'"&(+&71&(D(+'(7 '4(&((&("+("'4(5&(>!,('4*''4("*>('4(*55($$*"'7!7"'!8.&(!"

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

4$*;1'4(&(&(1*"*7#(&,(!"(&("+(4*79((" 7&*;" 4( >*"*8(>("' ,4.$7 4*#( 9((" *,'("(7 ;!'4 '4( "., ' 5&7.+(,>(:*", *D1(>5$/(('4(,+4$1;4+.$7"'4*#( *55(*&(7 *, * ;!'"(,, !" *#.& '4( *55($$*"' 9(!"

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

7(&+4*$$("8(8&."

!"'(&(&("+(!,>*7(.' (,.$'*"'$/19/.54$7!"8'4(!>5.8"(7&7(&1'4( (''(&, *'("' 55(*$ !, 7!,>!,,(7 ",(A.("'$/1 '4( *55$!+*'!" & *77!'!"*$(#!7("+(!,*$,7!,>!,,(7 %$'!#) * )( + %&*.$ %&*.$ %/ 01-2 34 +44 56 78 9 :8 +44 ;