High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1427/2011dismissed

Birbrender Singh & ORS v. Parabhjit Kaur & ORS.

2015-10-08Mr. Justice Arun Monga23 pages

ARCHANA ARORA 2015.10.21 17:49 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document

!"# $

$ %&&'()( *'%+&,-# !(,+,& &,( ./

%/&, 00&11

%) 2&,)3) , +/4(%5 3,

%/&,) &)0 & %) /( &,4(%5 3,

%/&,) 00&11

%) 2&,)3) , +/4(%5 3,

%/&,) &)0 & %)

* 6!7 87

!"#$

#%!!

&' (

)

!*"#

#%!!

+

,

!# -

+

) )

.

* $ !.!*#* #-

'

)

!$ ##

////

0

12

1 #

4 3

5

.

0 1

3

9(% :

1# 4

1

,

!"#$

#%%!

!*"#

#%%!

6

,

2 ,

!" !

!#

$

!

!%

& ' !()

*

+ ,+

-&

&

!( &

!.

!" !) ' !(

+ & '

' !)' !.' !/

' !0

1

' !2

;

(, 7

81

) 7

1 !

1 ) #

1

) "

*

8

#

8

'

#*

:

2

1

#*

1

2

1

1

1 !9"9 ( - (

1,

2 !;.9.;

&

( (

4

'

4

1 1

( <

=

1 >?

'

1

&' (

)

,1

"99 @

1

"%7

1 1 ,

!!

!!

!;9- <1,?

<

*- 2 1 !$ 2?

8

1

2 1

A

1

2

1

2

1 1 BC .%

!*"#

#%%!

< C

!?

,2

2 , 1 !7.

1 ' !7!%$!%9 ;7!--!-$ ;!-;!$% !% ,

< 1 1 1?

6

1 1 ,

1

,

8

,1 1

1

,

2 1 ,

, < A?

1

4

1 -%% , !"

,

1 .#% A1

:

6

,11

1

8 2 !;*%*#

'

1 **- , - ,

1 -%% , !"

,

1

1

, ;7!% , 1 )1

4

1

1 !"!

, !- ,

( (

0

1,

2 !;*"**

8

,1

1

1 1 )

1 '

,

!"

<!?

8

!;*- <

= !;*-

>?

1 AA

(2

1 1

1 ,1

1 2

1 !% !;*-

D

1

BC E0.7!- #;

;

!;*$

1

C !-

,

, ) , ,1

!7"

:

) :

!7" #$-

8

,1

,

<

4 1

6

,1

1 #;

.

!;-!

,2

(

A A

8

,1

1 1 #;

.

!;-!

1 2 !;-%

!."

*

# .

.

- !;$# ,2

!7"

,1

1 0

;

- !;$# ,:

C

!7"

:

1 !7"

:

C

!7.

6

, ,1

2 .7!-

"% ( $ (

$

!% !# 2

E

!#"

*

4 C

$;! ## #.

-

4

,

2 , ,

6

1

&' (

1 &+=(

31 )

%/&,2)2 &+=(

&)/

&(& +=7)>

> # 1:

%( ./2 $ % ( ./ & += 7) >> ; (?(1 ># ,( @,()/

3%%,&0+=

.&, 2) /&):

,

%/&,) (?(1 >#+, /(9 1( )$/ , 92(,2)9% / ,(

1( )/

%(>-3 + #&4( &,( ./

%/&,2)531(0( ./

%/&,) > 7 #/( &, ( ./

%/&,)2)/

.

, ( ./

%/&, (?(1;-- 1 2 1

2

2

1

!"<!?

!;*-

+

,

1

-

1 #9 !;-%

G

-

8

0

;

- !;$# C

1

1

4

2

,

1

!"

<!?

!;*-

1 2 !;*-

1 #;

!;-%

B

# .

(, 81

!7"

:

8

,1 ,

"-;

#;

$ !;$.

BC E07!*

.

- !;$% ,

4

1 1 1

1

, # - !;;"

8

,1

7

1

2 !;*;

>

2 !;;*

6

,1 1 @

4(% ( ./ & %/,3./7)2)5( , %/

%/&, (?(1 8

,1 1

1 1

1 AA

6

,1 1 8H,

1 @

(93%/3/&?

,&'& )&+=7)2) 1 .

1

%/&,)

8

,1

-

1 1 1

6

, ,1

1

1 )1

1

:

1

4 ,

D #

# @@

.

- !;$#

4

1

1

8

,1

1

!% !% !;*-

6

1 ,1

1 -%%

, !"

,

-9"

, - ,

1

B 1

+

:

@

1 ;7!% , :

1

,2

, 1

1

6 1

!"<!?

!;*-

,1

2

( @

1 '

1

,

'1 1 1

C

!79

1

8

,1 )

1 !79

1

,

1 !7!- :

) $ ) ,

)

## "

!;$#

,

1 #*

8

,1

* !7-

2 !;-%

E $) #.

, !* ,

!.

!"

!% !# !"

E "

,

1

1

"!

4

!99#

8

,1

C

2 !;*;

,

,

1

6

,1

1

**"

( !* ,

&' (

@

)

,

,1

1 !.9 (

!"

<!?

8

!;*-

:

' AA

1

:

8

@ 1

) BC - 9

;

1 "% $ (

, '

8

,1

,

:

1 @

?

0

, 2

,

?

0

1

1

1

8

!;*- 1

7 !"

<!?

!;*-

2

1

!"

<!?

!;*-

?

0

,

7D #

# @@

?

0

1

-*

+1

,

1

?

0 7

2

,

7

+

,

,

# ,1

11

2

2

1

@ ,4(% ,&:

1

%/&,)2)$,2( 539 ,!

%,

%/&,) (?(1; 1

1

1

1

D "!

.!

@@

1

!"

<!?

!;*-

,1

, ,

;

1 ,1

4

@ ,

8

1

6 1

@

,'

4

1 :

@ G

'

1 ,1

1I G 7 I 6

!"<!?

<#?

8

!;*-

!"#$"%& '

(

&

)* +++, + ! !

( '

* +

+

& $-%.

+ $"%

(

!

4 8H,

1 @ &+=(

31 )

%/&,2)2 &+=(

&)/ &(& += 7)>

>

,

$"%'

/ '0 ' 1 2 /

,

&

+*

+*

$-%/ "#$"% )*

"345& +

$6%/ + $-%

"#

"#$"%

"#$"%

$#%/ + $-%

"#

* ,

"#$"% 7

+*

+

"#$"%

+$-%

"#$"%

<

$4%

* ! (

' !

!

!

! )* "#$"% +$-%

**

+$-% $5% ! ! 0 "#$"%

8

"345 &

"#$"%

, (

+ $9% ! !#$-% "#$"%

&' ( 1 27

"

1

1 **9 (

,1

1:

% ( ./#) '

)&)30,

,( @,()/

3%%,&0+=

.&,6) '

)&)30,

6 1 8H,

1 @

:

7

1

:

; < (

=<

">6

/ < .

">"?9+"?@ .

3>"55+"59

.

3>"53+"9? "? '

.

5>"?6+"?# .

3>"95+"99 3>"93+"@"

.

3>"@?

.

3>"@@ "3- .

3>"35 .

3>-"-+-?6 -?5

-?9 -?3 -"" -"6 -"# "93 -"9 -"3

/

7

/

<

/

<

/

A

,

A

<

-

$BC %

6 @

,1

,:

1

6

2

:

<?

1 1

1 **- , - ,

8

1 2 C ,

4 1

,

<?

8

:

.

- !;$#

#

.

<?

1 2

1 ,1 AA

,

1

> <?

4 1 1

1

1

6

1

4

!"<!?

!;*-

<?

4 1

1

1 :

!"<!?

4

&' ( :

1

'

1

!"<!?

1

,

2

,1

<?

1

12 '

C 12

2

1

8 2 AA

1

11 2 1

1 1 !% !;*-

<?

4 1 :

;7!% ,

4 1

<? 4 0

, 2 ,:

,:

!79 1

1

<C?

8

1

1

,

,

1 12

!7"

# .

,

1

H

,

' C

, ,

1

<C?

4

1 ,

,

1 1

1

,

2 '

2

,

4

1

C 12

,

# .

,2

1

1 # # !;;"

!;;*

C?

4 #;

!;-%

1

,

2

1 2

1 1

#;

!;-%

<C?

4

1

1

1

, 1

2

1

1 1

1

D , 1

"

&+=(

31 )

%/&,6) '

)& )30,

1

2

2 !;-%

2

<C?4

1

'

,'

1

12 1 #$- #;

;

!;*$ <BC E0.7!-?

1 ,2

!7"

:

) :

!7"

, ,

1 17 1

1

) 1&

9,%.

.&

<C?

4 ,

"-;

#;

$ !;$.

BC E07!*

.

- !;$#

#% $ !;$.

,

,

,

<C?

@

1,

2 !;9.9"

BC E - !;;.;"

BC E.#

#$- #;

;

!;*$

C

!79

<C?

1 !7-

2 !;-%

!7- BC E0$7

'

<C?

4

&' (

1 **- , - , ,

, ,

AA 7

' 1,

<CC?

E $)

1 !9 , , !"

* !!

!;9!

BC E0-7@

<CC?

E -1

1 "% , !9 , 1 1

#"

"

!;$#

1 1

;

BC E0*7B

4

,

;

,1

!"<!?

!;*-

<CC?

6

G1 ,I

2 , 2

1

1

2

,

,

1 ,' ,

2 !;;*

6 1

1 2

2

2

1 , 1

:

!"

<!?

!;*-

, ,

7

4

, ,

C 7

6

1 2 ,

:

1 ,

7

7

@:

2

1 1 1

87

$ '%+&,-#

,'/