High Court of Punjab and HaryanaSAO/48/2010allowed

Harbans Singh v. Mohinder Singh

2015-12-21Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal14 pages

!

"#$$% $$$$$$&& ''"

(!$

) $$$$$

!& "* "!

)#

! " #

$

%& '#

$

((((

! "#

$% &'%(!)*

# % )*

, &'%(!) '

%#%-).-( * /////

0

)

, +

-#

/ ## #

'-

# #

0/1

## 2## '- 3 #

###)

#

#

. +

#

#- %#

$

#

)

.

#

+#

50

/ 4

# .

!7

. & *

#

!

#

#6 7 0 &.

.##-

#

!1

#+

.

#

#

.

.##-

.+.

84 "#

%#

#

-#

.

$ 50

# 7 0

9

.

.

-

.##-

#

# +

.

6

7 0 /

& &

/

9

+!

-#

#

#

.

.

+

#

+!

-#

.#

+!

-#

-

.##-

#

.

" .

-#

# 0 .

-

. -

##

+!

-#

/

& "# #-

+ #-# :

.

4"

. #- #

.#

#

-

#

7)

#.

+

# -#

.

"#

#

.#-

+

%#

# ; .

#

&

.

+

.#

#

#

# & .

!7

.

#

< #

#-

50 # =

1/7

#- / 4

#

# #

#

$ .+

+

#

#

&.

4

! 0>

.

# !7>

"

#

.#

#

$ .+

0 =

.+

0

# -

#.

+#

.+

#

-#

.

:

4

# 2.

6

#

6

#-

4.

&

50

.

.

4"

50

"&

.#

# 4

#

6

#-

4.

#

.

.+

#

+#

&

50

-#

.

4

"

.#

.#

4"

-

# & #-

50

.#

"

4 +

#

=

#

50

#+

#

#

.

.

#

#.

+##-

.+

# "&

.#

# 84 #

? %

&

#.

#

+ # < #

#

"# #-

#

6 #

#.

#

# #-

.

"#- #

!"##

$

!"##

% !"#& '

% %

%

!"#&

(

!"#& )

% %

(

$

*+,! "#& % ,-

$ !"#&

!"#& .

*

$

%$

!"#& / )

?

#

#

4 #

.+

%# &

.

@6

#

= .+

= "&

# "&

.

5 0

#

.

#-

# #-

#

+

#

&

6#

.

#

#

0)

;

#- ##

#-

%#

>

A "

#

#-

&

#

4

.

#-

#

-#

7/

/0

#

!0>

.# .+

77/

#

.

%#

7/

%#

# +

#-

-

-

#

+

%#

.

#-

@

.

50 ,

0 ,

&>' 5

,

' 1

+#

%#

#.

#.

"

##- #

,

#.

+#

+ 9

, +

#

/ 4

$ ,

#.

&

#

-# ##.#

# %#

- #-

.

"

. $

- & ##.#

#

4"

+

#

#

#

.#

#

, +

# 4#-

+%

#

.

.##+ # #.

+

%#

.

&

4

+#

50

.

-#

#

/ #

# 1// +

#

#

.

7/

#

#

#

+ #.

#

#-

# #

.

#

7/

%# :

.

4"

+

#

%#

#

#

&

@6 5 , +

#.

#

# . %#

.##+ #

+.#

%#

#

.

+#

/0

9

7/

+%

#

# . %# , -# #

.

##-

.

, +

+#

50 #

, +

+.#

#

50

#

.

&.

!7

.

#

# #-

# 8"

#

%#

#-

+#

#

+#

#

+#-

4

#- .

%#

7/

+#

.#

&

#

%#

7/

.

/0

#

%#

#

"

%#

&

# :#

+ 4- #

"

0/1

#

. +

#

#- %#

#

/)

-

-##-

+

##-

#

#-

#

##-

# #

.

# #

##

.

! 7 7

0 2

+,- ." ( ,!+! ,/ ".0+&&1.+,*23

2 4 '3555

8"

4

#

#

.#- ## #

.

& - =1,, "6.(!$+"-7"* "*."8"*

,!923

::

+

#

&

-#

##-

#

.

#

8"

.

= , 8 !." 4!$ /$ ""* 523

2 4 '3%;

#

.#-

## #

.

.#

"#-

.

! 7

7 0 & %#

4

#

## # = $+,+!.

/

**0(!$)<!,&

'! = / * ; 23

2 4 '3 >;

,B+

#

#-

! 7 0

!

7 # &

#

#

#- #

##-

#.# #

##-

# ! 0

. #.#

.

#

# 8"

#

.4

.

##

# + #-

##

#

#

+#

# +

#

&

#

# #

.

-

.#-

8"

##-

# 1

+#

#

.

%#

. + 4 =

"

.

# .

#

&

8"

.

! 7 ! 0

# #

. .

##

= ?, ./ * 23 ., +6. = ! "* "

, 4 ,!+! ) .*$ ,

@ % 23

2 4 '3 >9

,B+

#

.

## #

#

#.# #

#-

#

-##- #

##

# !

. .4

# "#

#

##

#

#+

-

# 5

."

.

+

.

#.

#. &

."

4 ##

#

9#

#

4

#

.

.4

# "#

#

##

#

. $+,+!.

/4!$,&

'!A!

2+&,3

#

#

5)

= /$ .." 4 "* "

, 4!$ 6, 6/ ,8.&+, "* "

, 2

3 4 ' :5>

,B+

.#-

#

#- .

# #-

.#-

#

#

#

! 0

#

#

#

#

.

#.# # +

# .

=

.#-

## #

.

.

&

##

#

#

##

# @

"#

#

#

! 0

8"

#.-

8"

"

8"

#

##-

# $

& ## #

.

8"

. +

#

#

+ 9

#

#

#

8"

. #

9#

! 7

7

! 0 2

8"

4

#

#- #- #-

-

#-

. 8"

" #+

& #

#-

+

# .

,B+

#

)

=.

#-

%#

&

8"

&

"

#

" 1!+, (!$ 00/& ,+/' "* ,! % 23

4 '3 59$ = +/ 7 "* ,! (!$ ,! ""

/&"0 )"8"B, "* ,! > 23

%9: 2 3;

,B+

& "

.

.+

#

#

& #

&

&

# !

.

,B+ .

/! , !! 2"* 3= / *(!$"8+ '* ,!"*"4 ! ,!23=*$"*

,!; : 23=B ,'* *

6

8"

#

&

#&

#- %#

.

.

"# 8"

" + #- 4

##

# #

# #

. +

1)

#.-

8"

#

. +

8"

#

# #

#-

! 7 7 0

"

?

#

#

8"

1 /

" %#