← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5763/2016dismissed

Bharti Axa General Insurance Co. Ltd v. Naresh Kumar And ORS

2019-05-28Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

  

    



    !"#$%&'

'''$$

 (

) *#"

'''+



   !"#$%&'

'''$$

 (

)&   ,)"

'''+

-".-  "/ 0''

      2 / '+345678"  ."$$

  % "7 

 $"

".:" ''



. "4 .".$$

;

   !"#$%&'7: 8 "".

 # '

.

%  7  .   ".           "  '

   53% "6:) *#6"""

".

  "

     8

6  <  "    #"" %   46  6 " )"'<+ 5=>>: %:686# : 4"/

=// $'#' 8

6+!

":  ?"

  7    #"" %   46  6 "  )"'<+

1=

.." "..68 4684% ;+3  6 6#8% 6 $ #."#"$$"

 #"" % 46 84%  53%7": ) : $

"7 

".4674" # %53%) .

":"  "  

 # $  68"

 3 @    4" ". # 4 # " "

@## %. 7"54 7 ".8

6$  % 6?"

#."# "

".  53% .)&  "6:-$A "   $"@4"#"" % : %6@ ) *#53%:." " "

@4 "":

""B6"". ".353%@4"3:46 A  "  C  <"

$ 7  <   4  "    :%  "  "

$ 7  53%

 #4"3 7: ) *#: #C

<"

$ 7< @4"%".53%: A" <"

$ < @."#  +)"'  '

.""..   5 "  17 > 2!: 6" "" #".

)& :2"

 5":*6   +3 ' ? 6 $ 8 ".  53%# %) &   );.5#'+ ##"4"6 #

 $"46)"'>>".

>5 " ".""(

 6  ''+3 ;87#456;":    !"'&' "."..68 7

#6 "#$ """.+ '>   "6: '

 "6" # 7  53%: 64" %   $"

D  

:  "88

6 4%  6  +

=  $

   $  #"@      #"  ". + '>7

=: $" $""".4"%. 7     #" E ) *#7:" ..3  8% 

"4"6 #$"46)"'>>>".

> 5 "    ".    ""  (     6     4"8  7 #6 "#$ "".+

  "6: '

 "6"# "". 7: A"C   ".  5  7< :: "$$"4% " "@##."# '

"'

@ 6 $": ." 3%@

"

..$# 4 %"3 .. '

 "6"# #".+ 7

=: $" #

+ '

=: #" A %"4 '

5 4":" #$" "

"". #  7"

:"64%""  !

# ?4 :'

F$"" 7

 $$'+

)"'

 . 3": #:  $")"'. 

>

$: #' 3": #. "4 .".

)"'

 7%""A 8 6 "43 " :6"

#4 %". #$"@ "

  ". ""

 # ".  #@ #$"464.""3"   # 3"  ".   

%  $ @    #  46  6 %  ".

$$

"".# .   '# 7 :6

# 

"  #$"' "6"#7  4   "

%" 6 686" $".  53%4)& .".  53% #6"6.

 +6 6   "

" :$"

    .# %##4 :4 %  #' "6"   7  .?4

 "% "

"8 "#7"6"#7 8

"" 4 % 4. $"#" "#$ "

$%4 4%#4  #"" % G ":  : $")"' : "

68 86    #".$ %6#"" %  4 %7.%7"4 .".

 :6  "4#.4% $")"''  7   $%." #

 ". #$"'

: #. "4 .". $")"';

   "#$%7

"A8"

6 "43 " "#

"6 8"

#  "" ".   $"

 % #  "."# :6 4" @#""85 " > ".""(

 7 %".":"."# 4" 

 4. "" "8. $"8

6  A$  7

" :6 $" " 4 "

$% "#$ "   8"

#  ""

".  $"

 %4%

":6#"" % "484% $ "7:": ""

6%8 .. 886   @ : ""

6%8 .. 886       7.%: .A."6@ +: "6 4  % 

". 4" ."6 '+.6 #6

6"  #$"7   $"$%."  #

 ". #$"'

    $ 6  ".    $ 7  ."

":6  

 : .#/

' E        6    ".  53%  *#  "  ".

5')& 3%") *# "".5'F%56 A$  " '

" 6 686".

#"" % 6 ")"'<+ 1=

4% $""'

7



6H22'

.

"'

 $"87: #)& ". #$" "'>>

>7  ." "#$ "7. "7": #"."#:"#H22'

'

.

)"'

 $"87: #) *#".

#  $"  )"'>>>7   

>       ." "#$ "7. "7":#"."#:"#H22'

>' E $""'

: ""

68 .. 8 86   #". 7. " .. H2+'

 ' + .' "$ 8  $$"". $ 8

# ?"$"8  $")"'

 #$" )"'>>".

># %5')& 6" # "

2E $" #$")"'>>>".

># %5')  *#6" # " 2E>'?$" 8 .I#5'54  2E 5'2:*# 2E'

"7 6" #  " +E 4  6" # ''86   

A+ 7 "$%".+! A+ 7 "$%".  $"

 % JI'+

=JI'+ 7 "$%".$4  ."#" A+ "$%"."  ''

>".<6!" A+>'

.66# 7?4  

)"'

 .8"".$" 6  7

)"'  .8"".$"  6  7

)"'> 6  $"  )"'      .8"  ".  $" '  +

 %7    # $"  :  

":  $ %  4%  ""     !

#  ?4 : "#$ "".+ '>7 7

= "6:  ".1K$#."#".$"

  $%#G

 : :" # ". #$")"'>>".

>7 :  "#$ "".+ '7

= "6: ".1K $#."#".$"

  $%#: :"

$"". #$")"'>>>".

>'+ )"'

" :# 4 "#A$%#3" % 8

%'

 6

 .::$

4%?4 $")"';    "#$% .  $$$

4."  !"'

)"   ".    $$

 :  

  "     +  $$"6 " 7:"4  ."#!" "'

8  " ."$$

4  6"6 "6 "' ?  .     ."#"

   6#  8   4%   " ."$$

;   "#$%: "..6 8 : "8"

8 : $ @ ".   '

7 +: "6"I% .".  53%"6#"A"8# "..68 : 8"

8 :"6 %3 "6 "#$ "'

"". 6#"4:"%". $ '

5 " ".""(   $ ".: .

6

"' :  "$"8$"#$ "#$ ""$ " :" 

  3%  "  ":  ".  $"$% #6  " " 6

$ 8 ".$ "7:"6"A

"  '<%$    $$"  ""4"$: 3 6  %$".

$" '??4     "48"

%" "7: 

# 6".3  '

#"7 + " 8$ ".8   " %$$"

 "  # # %#""'  " %

0 68 6".6 "". +8 66 6 %$"4#." ":% "6B4 "..   

"

6  ' ??4  " 68  4%$

4."      6 ".  .    6  $"

"   "#  "   "

" : "". 4%     6 6  86'  ?  $"    I#  )   *# 3 %:

" " # 2E>'<86 .. 3    #$:

 $   $" "4"4'<86 83 # $:"

8 4  $ ""   $8"

8 )"'

 8"."..68    '5')& 2E

"". + ""4"8 "684%2E>;)  *#'2E 54 

"$"8%:

 "".  '?"6 $$6:

4"I$ 4 #" "

 ".  4A$68: .    #   ".   6)& 6" 6 ."#  +:6" G " )"'

   . 6        !"  7    8 "    $  4%    $": " $4 '?."7  "" 3 '

?  "$ A$4%  " ."$$

 :   :   "." "

 "7:   ".

"4"%6 6   # .: . 7."7

#       "  6    "#$ "  $"$"" %  .  6#" " 6$$ %4%  

1  ' <":87 "". $ "4:"%". $ '

? : # . 4%#.

 % 8"

8#"."..68  '?%" A$%$ 66 "4"%6 6 ' ? : :

       .   "

  4 .   $     $"8   % 8  4%"$ 6  ":"$$": 

:'

? +46 6  ."  6 4%  6 686'<:  

 . 6 4."!"".6 '?" 8  4%  #  :  $" 4 ." 4%

     6 6  86    ."  "  4  "6    "8 6' ?."7       %  4  "  A         ".  "4"% 6 6 '

&  "  ."    $$

  .  "   " ''   

 



7 

  

 

  

  !"7 # $% ! 

  %   

&&  !'(7 ) % ! 

   * !

  *  

 "&

(       

 (&   !&"4"

"".$$  ""$   "

..  .      #        "I    :     "4 8" 4#'



 ?.6  "4%?4 :

 " "4 "44%"""

 "%"8  8 4 " "'?."7 "6""  :' 6"#$$

7 #  #

  "6 %'

0''

 3  

!"#$ %&"'

!()$*   "&#

'# !+,

  "&#