Major Singh v. Amar Singh And ORS







  

     

     

     

                   











      







 !"#$!%&'&"()  !"#$!%&'&"()  !"#$!%&'&"()  !"#$!%&'&"()** ** ** **

+",&(-. ***//!00(  1!,'2' 3,&(-.($" .!,'  *** !'/"($!( '

 )

 )

 )

 )  45  45  45  45 *    6

7

*    6

7

*    6

7

*    6

7 ,!'!( )

,* +(('08$9"% !8 #", .!//!00( *   6

78* ,0

  6

78* ,0

  6

78* ,0

  6

78* ,0
* ,!'!(  !-20, !%"($ //!0 .' :!!( #&0!$ :; .! //!00( /0&( &##8 &3/2-(&(- .! +2$-3!(  ($ $!%,!! $ !$
<*=*
8 /''!$ :; .! &' ,&%  2$-!8 ,(08 >.!,!:; .! '2&  #&0!$:; .!/0&( &##.':!!($&'3&''!$:;2/."0$&(- .!+2$-3!( ($ $!%,!!$ !$
**
8/''!$:; .! &9&02$-!8!(&",&9&'&"(8 ,(0* * .!,! ,! %"(%2,,!(  #&($&(-' -&('  .! //!00(  ,!%",$!$:; .! ,&0 "2, '>!00' .!&,' //!00 ! "2, * <* ' /!, .! :,&!# #% ' "( ,!%",$8 .! //!00( ?/0&( &##

+",&(-.0"(->& .("(//!00( ?/0&( &## 2@($&(-.#&0!$

&9&02& 8'!!@&(-,!0&!#"#+"&( /"''!''&"("( .!:'&'"#&(.!,& (%! A2 !'  ! "# 2@. &, &(-. '"( "# 6@@, &(-.8 >." !B/&,!$ "( *<**.!/0&( &##''! 2/7&00$ !$
**
=00!-!$ " .9! :!!( !B!%2 !$ :; 2@. &, &(-. &( #9"2, "# .&' C :," .!,'8 (3!0;8 2@($&(-.83,&(-.8 !.,($ +",&(-.'"('"# 6@@, &(-.8 :!A2! .&(- .&' !( &,! !'  !8 &( !A20 '.,!'*  .!

/0&( &##'#2, .!,00!-!$ . ,('#!,!!$$ !$
D*
*=8>.&%. &'00!-!$ ".9!:!!(!B!%2 !$:; 2@. &,&(-.&(#9"2,"#3, &(-.$!#!($( "*
,!'/"($!( &'#:,&% !$$"%23!( ($>& ."2  %"('&$!, &"(* >'%"( !($!$ .  2@. &,&(-.>'&(%/:0!"# !B!%2 &(- .!'&$,('#!,!!$E.!>'("0$/!,'"(($!B/&,!$ #!>3"( .' .!,!# !,* <*


/"((" &%!8 .!'2& >'%"( !' $"(:!.0#"#$!#!($(  "'*
88
8
($C* <* ( .! >,& !( '  !3!( 8 &  >' $3& !$ .  2@. &, &(-. .$ !B!%2 !$  7&00 "( 
**
= &( #9"2, "# .&' :," .!,'8 .">!9!,8& >'00!-!$ . # !, .!$! ."#.&'>&#!8 2@. &,&(-. ' , !$ 0&9&(- 0"(- >& . .&' :," .!,3, &(-.$!#!($(  "*
 ' >&#!"# 2@. &,&(-.($>&#!"#3,&(-.>!,!,!0'&' !,'*  >' 00!-!$ :; .! %"( !' &(- $!#!($( ' .  2@. &, &(-. ,('#!,,!$ .&' '.,! "# 0($ &( A2!' &"( &( #9"2, "# 3, &(-. $!#!($( "*
9&$!,!-&' !,!$,('#!,!!$$ !$
D*
*=* ( .!:'&'"#'&$$!!$832  &"("*
<
>''(% &"("(
*
*=* <*< .! ,&0 "2,  #,3!$ &''2!' ($ /, &!' 0!$ .!&, ,!'/!% &9!!9&$!(%!* <*C # !,.!,&(- .!%"2('!

0#", .!/, &!'($%"('&$!,&(- .!!9&$!(%!"(,!%",$8 .! ,&0 "2, $&'3&''!$ .!'2& #&0!$:; .! /0&( &##''!!@&(-,!0&!#"#+"&( /"''!''&"(($/!,3(!( &(+2(% &"(* <* .! &,'  //!00 ! "2,  9&$! .! &3/2-(!$ +2$-3!(  ($ $!%,!! $ !$
<*=*
8 0'" $&'3&''!$ .! //!08 >.&0! ":'!,9&(- .  .!00!-!$,('#!,!!$8B*
8&'.9&(-,!%& 0 .

2@. &, &(-. &' ,!'&$&(- >& . .&' :," .!,3, &(-.8 >." &'

/,"9&$&(-#""$($%0" .&(- ".&3*.!,!&'#2, .!,,!%& 0 .  .! !B!%2 ( &'0&9&(-.//&0;8($.!&'.//;>& . .!'!,9&%!',!($!,!$ :; .! :!(!#&%&,; "# .! $!!$8 ' '2%.8 .! >( ' " %"3/!(' ! .&' :," .!,3, &(-. $2,&(- .&' 0&#! &3! #", .&' '!,9&%!' ,!($!,!$ :; ,('#!,,&(-.&''.,!&( .!/,"/!, ;*.!&,' //!00 ! "2, >.&0! %"('&$!,&(- .!/,"9&'&"('"#!% &"(C"# .!,('#!,"#,"/!, ;% 
==#",'.", 8 .!F% 4 8>.&%.$!#&(!'F'0!48":'!,9!$ . /,&%! &( !,3'"#%2,,!(%;&'(" '&(!A2("( "%"3/0!  .!'0!*2, .!,8 >.&0!%"('&$!,&(- .!/,"9&'&"('"#!% &"("# .!($&( "( ,%  % 8
= #", '.", 8 F .! "( ,%  % 4  8 .! &,'  //!00 ! "2,  ":'!,9!$ . &(%'!%"( ,% .':!!(!B!%2 !$"(%%"2( "#( 2,0 0"9!($##!% &"(:! >!!

( .!/, &!'8>.",!&(%0"'!,!0 &"(8'2%. %"( ,% >"20$(" :!9"&$#",>( "#%"('&$!, &"(&(9&!>"# 02'!' 
   "# !% &"(  &:&$ *  .! &,'  //!00 ! "2,  #2, .!, ":'!,9!$ .  ."2-. .!/0&( &##'.9!%.00!(-!$ .!3!( 0%/%& ; "# 2@. &, &(-. " !B!%2 ! .! '&$ ,('#!, !!$8 :2  .! '&$ %"( !( &"(' ,! ("  ,2! '&(%! .! !B!%2 (  //!,!$ :!#",! .!

!-&' !,&(-2 .",& ;($%!, &#&% !"# .!2 .",& ;"( .!'&$!!$ %0,&#&!' .  .!$!!$>'!B!%2 !$:; .!!B!%2 ( &(.&'#200'!('!'* 9!( .!,!# !,8 .!32  &"(.':!!('(% &"(!$"( .!:'&'"#'&$ $!!$*.!&,' //!00 ! "2, ":'!,9!$ .  .!/0&( &##'.$#&0!$ "/,"$2%!(;%"-!( !9&$!(%! .  .!!B!%2 (  2@. &,&(-.>' (" &('"2($$&'/"'&(-3&($  .! &3!"#!B!%2 &"("# .!,('#!, !!$8B*
* C* --,&!9!$ -&('  .! $&'3&''0 "# .! &,'  //!08 .! //!00( .'#&0!$ .!/,!'!( !%"($//!0*

* 5!,(!$%"2('!0#", .!//!00( '2:3& ' .  .!00!-!$ ,('#!,$!!$>'>& ."2 (;%"('&$!, &"(($&'.& :; .!/,"9&'&"(' "#!% &"("# .!($&( "( ,% % '>!00' .!/,"9&'&"('"# !% &"( C "# .!  % *    &' #2, .!, %"( !($!$ .  .! 00!-!$ ,('#!,$!!$&(#9"2,"#$!#!($( 3,&(-.&'$ !$
D*
*= ($ .!!B!%2 ( $&!$3"( .' .!,!# !,8>.&%.& '!0#&''2'/&%&"2' %&,%23' (%! '2,,"2($&(- .! ,('#!, $!!$*  (" .!, %"( !( &"( .' :!!(,&'!$ . /,&", " .!!B!%2 &"("# .!00!-!$ ,('#!,$!!$8 .! !B!%2 (  2@. &,&(-..$0,!$;!B!%2 !$,!-&' !,!$7&00$ !$ 
**
=($!B/,!''!$.&'$!'&,! . .&'/,"/!, ;'.00:!&(.!,& !$ :;00.&':," .!,*.!!B!%2 ( >'&''2!0!''8''2%.8.!.$0"9! ($##!% &"(#",.&':," .!,*('2%.%&,%23' (%!'8& :!%"3!'.&-.0; $"2: #20 . .!.$!B!%2 !$ .!00!-!$ ,('#!,$!!$"2 "#.&''>!!  >&00*  00 .!'! #% ' .9! ("  :!!( /,"/!,0; %"('&$!,!$ :; .! ,&0

"2, '>!00' .!&,' //!00 ! "2, >.&0!$&'3&''&(- .!'2& * D* .9!%"('&$!,!$ .!#",!'&$'2:3&''&"('($/!,2'!$ .!//!,:""@* *  &'(" $&'/2 !$ .  .!!B!%2 ( ($ .!:!(!#&%&,;"# .! 00!-!$ ,('#!, !!$8 B*
8 ,! ,!0 :," .!,'*  .! //!00(  %"20$(" 0!$(;%"-!( !9&$!(%! "/,"9! . ,!%& 0'&( .!$!!$,! #% 200;&(%",,!% *.!!B!%2 ( .$-&9!(,!'"(' "3@! .!'&$ ,('#!, $2,&(- .&' 0&#! &3!8 &*!* .! >' :!&(- 0""@!$ # !, :; .&' :," .!,3,&(-.* &'/0!$!$&( .!>,& !('  !3!(  .  .!>&#! "# .!!B!%2 ( $&!$8 .!,!# !,8.!' , !$0&9&(->& . .!:!(!#&%&,;8 '&(%! .&' >&#! >' ,!0 '&' !, "# .! >&#! "# .! :!(!#&%&,;*  .! !B!%2 ( >'$3& !$0;:"9!=;!,'"#-!*6!!/&(-&(9&!> .!

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
* (9&!>"##",!'&$,!'"('8("&( !,#!,!(%!&'%00!$#", &( .!&3/2-(!$+2$-3!( ($$!%,!!

* .!/,!'!( //!0&'$!9"&$"#(;3!,& ($ .!'3!&' .!,!:;$&'3&''!$*
* !($&(-3&'%!00(!"2'//0&% &"('

'.00' ($$&'/"'!$ "#* * * * ** * * *  G  6

7H G  6

7H G  6

7H G  6

7H  20'! .&             7.! .!,'/!@&(-?,!'"(!$) !' " 7.! .!, !/", :0!) !'

"