Nanak & ANR v. Union Of India

  

        

!"#$#%&'&()
* !(!+!($!(",#- ..#//!("'

0#-'1'

(&(($&!

 #'.($#("

)  23  4 5 34  -#'#(")6 '41(&"!!78&!-9$:%!"#9-9 -!/+!-4&(;,9$:%!"#9-",#!..#//!("' ' ,#"(! !9$:%!"#9--#'.($#("  <,#",#-",# #.-"#-'/%!/(#='.!.#-7!>8#!//=#$" '##",#?1$;7#("@
 8#-##--#$"",# #.-"#--("  <,#",#-",#?1$;7#("',1/$8#-#.-"#$&(",#$&;#'"@ 66 66 34 

3 ,#  .-#'#("  !..#!/  &'  $&-#%"#$  !;!&('"  ",#  ?1$;7#("  $!"#$
A
9.!''#$8>",# !&/=!> /!&7'-&81(!/9 ,!($&;!-,#(%,9

,!($&;!-,9:&$#=,&%,",#%/!&7!../&%!"&(",#.-#'#("!..#//!("'=!' $&'7&''#$ ,#%!'#",#!..#//!("'&'",!"0&($'(",#!..#//!("' 8!-$#$!/%!/"-!&(-7!-&$!8!$(B
"$#/&:#-/1(%," !../&%!(""&''"!"#$",!"$1#",#!:>-1',!($?#-+",#"-!&(9",# '(",#!..#//!("'#//$=(-7",#-1((&(;"-!&(!"+7AA
*(#!- #==(9!-&$!8!$ !&/=!>4"!"&( #=!',!:&(;!:!/&$7(",/> '#!'(!/"&%+#"-7!(%,!-&"!-&$!8!$-7
B*
"
*B
 ,#   !&/=!>  %("#'"#$  ",#  %/!&7 (  ",#  ;-1($  ",!"  ",# $#%#!'#$$&#$!'!-#'1/"&(?1-&#''1#-#$8>,&7,!:&(;8##(,&"8> C64.#%&!/"-!&((#!-$=('"!-"#-'&;(!/,#8$>=!'1($/>&(;&(

6
6 ",#7&$$/#",&-$/&(#"=!''"!"#$",!"",#$#%#!'#$=!'("!.!''#(;#- ",#"-!&(!($9",#-#-#9",#!../&%!("'!-#("#("&"/#$"%7.#('!"&( -7",#./#!$&(;'9//=&(;&''1#'=#-#-!7#$)6  <,#",#-",#$#%#!'#$=!'!8(!&$#.!''#(;#-"-!&(!"",# "&7#&(%&$#("@
 <,#",#-",#&(%&$#("&'%:#-#$=&",&(!78&"4#%"&(
 %

-#!$=&",4#%"&(
6",# !&/=!>'%"@  <,#",#-  ",#  !../&%!("

'  &'

!-#  ",#  '/#  $#.#($#("'    ",# $#%#!'#$@



#/&# ,# !&/=!> /!&7'-&81(!/,!'-#"1-(#$",#&($&(;",!"",# $#%#!'#$=!'("!8(!&$#.!''#(;#-",#"-!&(!($",!"",#.'&"&( ",#$#!$8$>-#:#!/#$",!",#%77&""#$'1&%&$#8>%7&(;&(-("",# ;$'"-!&(,#-#-#9",#!../&%!("'!-#("#("&"/#$"%7.#('!"&( ,!:#,#!-$",#/#!-(#$%1('#/'-",#.!-"&#'!($,!:#!/' %!-#1//>;(#",-1;,",#&/# #-#",# !&/=!> /!&7'-&81(!/95&',!( 4&(;, ##(!9 3%&/"!..#!-#$!' <!($'"!"#$",!",#=!'($1">( !(;!.1-

&"> "  1;!/+!8!$  (  ;!  4.#%&!/  $'  "-!&(  (  
B
   ( B
9  !"  !81"  )AA  ,1-'  =,#(  ",#  "-!&(  =!'  .!''&(;  ",-1;, !-&$!8!$#==( !&/=!>4"!"&(9'1$$#(/>!8>%!7#&(-("",# "-!&(&(8#"=##(",#-!&/=!>/&(#'(#!-'"!-"#-'&;(!/!"+7AA
* # 8/#=,-(981"",#8>$&$("7:#!($=!'-1(:#-8>",#"-!&(,# =&"(#''=!'%-''#D!7&(#$!"/#(;",#%/!-&&#$",!"",#8>=!',&$$#( 8>",#'&$#",#.&//!-'":#-8-&$;#''(!'",#"-!&(%-''#$ ",#":#-8-&$;#9",#8>%!7#&(-("",#"-!&(!($'"$&(8#"=##(

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

34     
* '?+' <,#",#-'.#!+&(; -#!'(#$ ) #'

<,#",#- #.-"!8/# ) #'